{ "actionArrays": { "decision": [], "evaluation": [], "implementation": [], "operational": [], "redress": [] }, "adoption": { "authorityLocation": "outside-this-system", "state": "not-adopted" }, "asOf": "2026-08-21", "authorship": { "compiledBy": "codex-assisted-publication", "exactTextHumanReviewed": false, "humanDirectionRecorded": true, "humanReviewCompleted": false, "humanReviewRequired": true, "origin": "maintainer-authorized-assisted-publication" }, "baseSnapshot": { "admissionMode": "exact-immutable-vendored-snapshot-only", "asOf": "2026-08-21", "byteReceipt": "sha256:1751b2ac331d6a1283cbf57b5b6961d9071f528298f97589fcbd7cf36407e139", "bytes": 196005, "canonicalReceipt": "sha256:cc2c22e356cef0160ed5da1e2fd756bad5801f574c4cb064dec157b9207b9739", "canonicalUrl": "https://thekingdom.dev/government/uk-government-engine-2026-08-21.json", "contractVersion": "0.1.0", "exactTextHumanReviewed": false, "guideUrl": "https://thekingdom.dev/UK-GOVERNMENT-ENGINE-v0.1.md", "nextReviewDue": "2026-09-21", "officialSourceHandling": "link-only", "path": "vendor/government-engine/government-2026-08-21.json", "planeIds": [ "plane:delivery", "plane:jurisdiction", "plane:law", "plane:mandate", "plane:money", "plane:remedy" ], "runtimeFetch": false, "schema": "kingdom.government-engine-public-snapshot/0.1", "schemaUrl": "https://thekingdom.dev/government/schemas/v0.1/public-snapshot.schema.json" }, "boundaries": { "acceptsFreeText": false, "accountAccess": false, "advice": false, "approval": false, "authorityCreation": false, "automatedAction": false, "automatedDecision": false, "automaticProgression": false, "credentialAccess": false, "credentialCollection": false, "currentOfficeholders": false, "deadlineDetermination": false, "decisionAuthority": false, "deployment": false, "eligibilityDetermination": false, "externalCrosswalkAsGovernmentEvidence": false, "externalEffects": false, "filing": false, "governmentAffiliation": false, "identityAccess": false, "identityCollection": false, "legalAdvice": false, "legalConclusion": false, "liabilityDetermination": false, "liveData": false, "llmRuntime": false, "mcpExposure": false, "networkAtBuildOrRuntime": false, "officialEndorsement": false, "partyProfiles": false, "payment": false, "peopleProfiles": false, "personalData": false, "personalDataCollection": false, "preferredOptionSelection": false, "procurement": false, "publicForm": false, "ranking": false, "runtimeFetch": false, "scoring": false, "spending": false, "submissions": false, "taxAdvice": false, "taxConclusion": false, "transaction": false }, "buildProvenance": { "deterministic": true, "inputCanonicalReceipts": { "config": "sha256:24cf7e2f470ba154a956c1665e9b4a130497410428720e521c6d3b8af34b8c4d", "dossiers": "sha256:5e487ca2f1938bcaf8da13ca1db956eb356f587eade6a92ce179f70686759929" }, "networkUsed": false, "schemaByteReceipt": "sha256:9949457e87db784c734b195195c7f3cdc2afb138ada400f61583ebd0a6cf7be6", "schemaCanonicalReceipt": "sha256:b7118c1cd2f226b276b02f21bb080d3e3e5aae6aa26bc03e74277a5d1844c5c9" }, "categoryErrorRules": [ { "id": "rule:appropriation-not-credit", "left": "appropriation", "relation": "does-not-imply", "right": "credit" }, { "id": "rule:appropriation-not-issue", "left": "appropriation", "relation": "does-not-imply", "right": "issue" }, { "id": "rule:complaint-not-appeal", "left": "complaint", "relation": "does-not-imply", "right": "appeal-or-deadline-protection" }, { "id": "rule:estimate-not-appropriation", "left": "estimate", "relation": "does-not-imply", "right": "appropriation" }, { "id": "rule:external-crosswalk-not-official-evidence", "left": "external-crosswalk", "relation": "does-not-imply", "right": "official-evidence" }, { "id": "rule:forecast-not-appropriation", "left": "forecast", "relation": "does-not-imply", "right": "appropriation" }, { "id": "rule:forecast-not-authority", "left": "forecast", "relation": "does-not-imply", "right": "authority" }, { "id": "rule:freshness-not-legal-effect", "left": "freshness", "relation": "does-not-imply", "right": "legal-effect" }, { "id": "rule:guidance-not-law", "left": "guidance", "relation": "does-not-imply", "right": "law" }, { "id": "rule:issue-not-outturn", "left": "issue", "relation": "does-not-imply", "right": "outturn" }, { "id": "rule:mandate-not-legal-power", "left": "mandate", "relation": "does-not-imply", "right": "legal-power" }, { "id": "rule:payment-rail-not-authority", "left": "payment-rail", "relation": "does-not-imply", "right": "authority" }, { "id": "rule:payment-settlement-not-liability", "left": "payment-or-settlement", "relation": "does-not-imply", "right": "liability" }, { "id": "rule:payment-settlement-not-spending-power", "left": "payment-or-settlement", "relation": "does-not-imply", "right": "spending-power" }, { "id": "rule:plan-not-appropriation", "left": "plan", "relation": "does-not-imply", "right": "appropriation" }, { "id": "rule:plan-not-estimate", "left": "plan", "relation": "does-not-imply", "right": "estimate" }, { "id": "rule:service-not-decision-authority", "left": "service-or-api", "relation": "does-not-imply", "right": "decision-authority" }, { "id": "rule:topic-not-competence", "left": "topic", "relation": "does-not-imply", "right": "legislative-or-executive-competence" } ], "contractVersion": "0.1.0", "counts": { "authorityDependencyEdges": 17, "authorityDependencyNodes": 25, "causalEdges": 24, "causalNodes": 30, "desiredOutcomes": 3, "dossiers": 3, "evidenceAtoms": 30, "externalContextBindings": 4, "humanGates": 6, "jurisdictionBranches": 4, "options": 9, "planeAssessments": 18, "routeOrientations": 4 }, "dossiers": [ { "actionArrays": { "decision": [], "evaluation": [], "implementation": [], "operational": [], "redress": [] }, "adoption": { "authorityLocation": "outside-this-system", "state": "not-adopted" }, "authorityDependencyGraph": { "automaticProgression": false, "edges": [ { "fromId": "four-nation:england", "id": "dependency:england-scotland-alternative", "rationale": "England and Scotland branches are distinct hypothetical territorial pathways, not a single UK route.", "toId": "four-nation:scotland", "type": "alternative" }, { "fromId": "four-nation:delivery", "id": "dependency:four-nation-delivery-feedback", "rationale": "Delivery differences may reveal jurisdiction questions without answering them.", "toId": "four-nation:scotland", "type": "feedback" }, { "fromId": "four-nation:law", "id": "dependency:four-nation-law-money", "rationale": "Instrument and competence review precedes any public-money orientation.", "toId": "four-nation:money", "type": "prerequisite" }, { "fromId": "four-nation:mandate", "id": "dependency:four-nation-mandate-jurisdiction", "rationale": "A broad public mandate does not settle competence for an exact matter.", "toId": "four-nation:england", "type": "does-not-imply" }, { "fromId": "four-nation:remedy", "id": "dependency:four-nation-remedy-parallel", "rationale": "Redress orientation remains parallel to service-content design.", "toId": "four-nation:delivery", "type": "parallel" }, { "fromId": "four-nation:wales", "id": "dependency:wales-ni-alternative", "rationale": "Wales and Northern Ireland branches require their own hypothetical pathways.", "toId": "four-nation:northern-ireland", "type": "alternative" } ], "nodes": [ { "assessmentId": "assessment:four-nation-delivery", "baseEntityIds": [ "claim:delivery-departments", "claim:delivery-rails-not-authority" ], "id": "four-nation:delivery", "label": "Four-nation delivery question", "planeId": "plane:delivery" }, { "assessmentId": "assessment:four-nation-jurisdiction", "baseEntityIds": [ "claim:jurisdiction-asymmetric", "claim:jurisdiction-local-four-nations" ], "id": "four-nation:england", "label": "England branch", "planeId": "plane:jurisdiction" }, { "assessmentId": "assessment:four-nation-law", "baseEntityIds": [ "claim:law-guidance-distinct" ], "id": "four-nation:law", "label": "Four-nation instrument question", "planeId": "plane:law" }, { "assessmentId": "assessment:four-nation-mandate", "baseEntityIds": [ "claim:authority-government-parliament-distinct" ], "id": "four-nation:mandate", "label": "Four-nation accountability question", "planeId": "plane:mandate" }, { "assessmentId": "assessment:four-nation-money", "baseEntityIds": [ "claim:money-parliamentary-authority" ], "id": "four-nation:money", "label": "Four-nation money question", "planeId": "plane:money" }, { "assessmentId": "assessment:four-nation-jurisdiction", "baseEntityIds": [ "claim:jurisdiction-northern-ireland" ], "id": "four-nation:northern-ireland", "label": "Northern Ireland branch", "planeId": "plane:jurisdiction" }, { "assessmentId": "assessment:four-nation-remedy", "baseEntityIds": [ "claim:remedy-routes-distinct" ], "id": "four-nation:remedy", "label": "Four-nation remedy question", "planeId": "plane:remedy" }, { "assessmentId": "assessment:four-nation-jurisdiction", "baseEntityIds": [ "claim:jurisdiction-scotland" ], "id": "four-nation:scotland", "label": "Scotland branch", "planeId": "plane:jurisdiction" }, { "assessmentId": "assessment:four-nation-jurisdiction", "baseEntityIds": [ "claim:jurisdiction-wales" ], "id": "four-nation:wales", "label": "Wales branch", "planeId": "plane:jurisdiction" } ] }, "causalChangeHypothesisGraph": { "claimsCausalTruth": false, "edges": [ { "fromId": "causal:four-nation-bau", "id": "causal-edge:four-nation-bau-output", "toId": "causal:four-nation-bau-state", "type": "hypothesises-contribution" }, { "fromId": "causal:four-nation-branches-output", "id": "causal-edge:four-nation-branches-outcome", "toId": "causal:four-nation-outcome", "type": "hypothesises-contribution" }, { "fromId": "causal:four-nation-alt-branches", "id": "causal-edge:four-nation-branches-output", "toId": "causal:four-nation-branches-output", "type": "hypothesises-contribution" }, { "fromId": "causal:four-nation-evaluation", "id": "causal-edge:four-nation-evaluation", "toId": "causal:four-nation-outcome", "type": "tests" }, { "fromId": "causal:four-nation-matrix-output", "id": "causal-edge:four-nation-matrix-outcome", "toId": "causal:four-nation-outcome", "type": "hypothesises-contribution" }, { "fromId": "causal:four-nation-alt-matrix", "id": "causal-edge:four-nation-matrix-output", "toId": "causal:four-nation-matrix-output", "type": "hypothesises-contribution" }, { "fromId": "causal:four-nation-negative", "id": "causal-edge:four-nation-negative", "toId": "causal:four-nation-outcome", "type": "may-undermine" }, { "fromId": "causal:four-nation-outcome", "id": "causal-edge:four-nation-outcome-depends-on-assumption", "toId": "causal:four-nation-assumption", "type": "depends-on" } ], "nodes": [ { "id": "causal:four-nation-alt-branches", "optionId": "option:four-nation-branches", "statement": "Synthetic alternative: four separately held jurisdiction branches.", "type": "intervention-option" }, { "id": "causal:four-nation-alt-matrix", "optionId": "option:four-nation-matrix", "statement": "Synthetic alternative: a static comparison matrix with no competence result.", "type": "intervention-option" }, { "id": "causal:four-nation-assumption", "optionId": null, "statement": "Hypothesis assumes branch separation reduces accidental UK-wide generalisation.", "type": "assumption" }, { "id": "causal:four-nation-bau", "optionId": "option:four-nation-bau", "statement": "Synthetic business-as-usual comparator: one undifferentiated proposition page.", "type": "intervention-option" }, { "id": "causal:four-nation-bau-state", "optionId": null, "statement": "Hypothesised comparator state: one undifferentiated proposition page remains.", "type": "output" }, { "id": "causal:four-nation-branches-output", "optionId": null, "statement": "Hypothesised branch output: four separate static branches, each held for specialist review.", "type": "output" }, { "id": "causal:four-nation-evaluation", "optionId": null, "statement": "Evaluation would require specialist-approved jurisdiction scenarios and a non-personal aggregate protocol.", "type": "evaluation-need" }, { "id": "causal:four-nation-matrix-output", "optionId": null, "statement": "Hypothesised matrix output: a non-equivalence comparison with no competence result.", "type": "output" }, { "id": "causal:four-nation-negative", "optionId": null, "statement": "A comparison view may still imply equivalence between asymmetric settlements.", "type": "negative-pathway" }, { "id": "causal:four-nation-outcome", "optionId": null, "statement": "Desired orientation outcome: visible territorial divergence before any authority or delivery conclusion.", "type": "desired-outcome" } ] }, "desiredOutcomes": [ { "assumptionNodeIds": [ "causal:four-nation-assumption" ], "evaluationNeedNodeIds": [ "causal:four-nation-evaluation" ], "id": "outcome:four-nation-divergence-visible", "negativePathwayNodeIds": [ "causal:four-nation-negative" ], "statement": "Make four-nation divergence visible without determining competence or choosing a delivery model." } ], "evidenceAtoms": [ { "baseEntityId": "claim:jurisdiction-asymmetric", "baseEntityType": "claim", "baseSnapshotByteReceipt": "sha256:1751b2ac331d6a1283cbf57b5b6961d9071f528298f97589fcbd7cf36407e139", "baseSnapshotCanonicalReceipt": "sha256:cc2c22e356cef0160ed5da1e2fd756bad5801f574c4cb064dec157b9207b9739", "baseSnapshotCanonicalUrl": "https://thekingdom.dev/government/uk-government-engine-2026-08-21.json", "evidenceUse": "orientation-only", "exactTextHumanReviewed": false, "genericOfficialHostTrust": false, "id": "evidence:four-nation-asymmetry", "officialSourceHandling": "link-only", "supportsConclusion": false }, { "baseEntityId": "claim:delivery-departments", "baseEntityType": "claim", "baseSnapshotByteReceipt": "sha256:1751b2ac331d6a1283cbf57b5b6961d9071f528298f97589fcbd7cf36407e139", "baseSnapshotCanonicalReceipt": "sha256:cc2c22e356cef0160ed5da1e2fd756bad5801f574c4cb064dec157b9207b9739", "baseSnapshotCanonicalUrl": "https://thekingdom.dev/government/uk-government-engine-2026-08-21.json", "evidenceUse": "orientation-only", "exactTextHumanReviewed": false, "genericOfficialHostTrust": false, "id": "evidence:four-nation-delivery", "officialSourceHandling": "link-only", "supportsConclusion": false }, { "baseEntityId": "claim:law-guidance-distinct", "baseEntityType": "claim", "baseSnapshotByteReceipt": "sha256:1751b2ac331d6a1283cbf57b5b6961d9071f528298f97589fcbd7cf36407e139", "baseSnapshotCanonicalReceipt": "sha256:cc2c22e356cef0160ed5da1e2fd756bad5801f574c4cb064dec157b9207b9739", "baseSnapshotCanonicalUrl": "https://thekingdom.dev/government/uk-government-engine-2026-08-21.json", "evidenceUse": "orientation-only", "exactTextHumanReviewed": false, "genericOfficialHostTrust": false, "id": "evidence:four-nation-law", "officialSourceHandling": "link-only", "supportsConclusion": false }, { "baseEntityId": "claim:jurisdiction-local-four-nations", "baseEntityType": "claim", "baseSnapshotByteReceipt": "sha256:1751b2ac331d6a1283cbf57b5b6961d9071f528298f97589fcbd7cf36407e139", "baseSnapshotCanonicalReceipt": "sha256:cc2c22e356cef0160ed5da1e2fd756bad5801f574c4cb064dec157b9207b9739", "baseSnapshotCanonicalUrl": "https://thekingdom.dev/government/uk-government-engine-2026-08-21.json", "evidenceUse": "orientation-only", "exactTextHumanReviewed": false, "genericOfficialHostTrust": false, "id": "evidence:four-nation-local", "officialSourceHandling": "link-only", "supportsConclusion": false }, { "baseEntityId": "claim:authority-government-parliament-distinct", "baseEntityType": "claim", "baseSnapshotByteReceipt": "sha256:1751b2ac331d6a1283cbf57b5b6961d9071f528298f97589fcbd7cf36407e139", "baseSnapshotCanonicalReceipt": "sha256:cc2c22e356cef0160ed5da1e2fd756bad5801f574c4cb064dec157b9207b9739", "baseSnapshotCanonicalUrl": "https://thekingdom.dev/government/uk-government-engine-2026-08-21.json", "evidenceUse": "orientation-only", "exactTextHumanReviewed": false, "genericOfficialHostTrust": false, "id": "evidence:four-nation-mandate", "officialSourceHandling": "link-only", "supportsConclusion": false }, { "baseEntityId": "claim:money-parliamentary-authority", "baseEntityType": "claim", "baseSnapshotByteReceipt": "sha256:1751b2ac331d6a1283cbf57b5b6961d9071f528298f97589fcbd7cf36407e139", "baseSnapshotCanonicalReceipt": "sha256:cc2c22e356cef0160ed5da1e2fd756bad5801f574c4cb064dec157b9207b9739", "baseSnapshotCanonicalUrl": "https://thekingdom.dev/government/uk-government-engine-2026-08-21.json", "evidenceUse": "orientation-only", "exactTextHumanReviewed": false, "genericOfficialHostTrust": false, "id": "evidence:four-nation-money", "officialSourceHandling": "link-only", "supportsConclusion": false }, { "baseEntityId": "claim:jurisdiction-northern-ireland", "baseEntityType": "claim", "baseSnapshotByteReceipt": "sha256:1751b2ac331d6a1283cbf57b5b6961d9071f528298f97589fcbd7cf36407e139", "baseSnapshotCanonicalReceipt": "sha256:cc2c22e356cef0160ed5da1e2fd756bad5801f574c4cb064dec157b9207b9739", "baseSnapshotCanonicalUrl": "https://thekingdom.dev/government/uk-government-engine-2026-08-21.json", "evidenceUse": "orientation-only", "exactTextHumanReviewed": false, "genericOfficialHostTrust": false, "id": "evidence:four-nation-ni", "officialSourceHandling": "link-only", "supportsConclusion": false }, { "baseEntityId": "claim:remedy-routes-distinct", "baseEntityType": "claim", "baseSnapshotByteReceipt": "sha256:1751b2ac331d6a1283cbf57b5b6961d9071f528298f97589fcbd7cf36407e139", "baseSnapshotCanonicalReceipt": "sha256:cc2c22e356cef0160ed5da1e2fd756bad5801f574c4cb064dec157b9207b9739", "baseSnapshotCanonicalUrl": "https://thekingdom.dev/government/uk-government-engine-2026-08-21.json", "evidenceUse": "orientation-only", "exactTextHumanReviewed": false, "genericOfficialHostTrust": false, "id": "evidence:four-nation-remedy", "officialSourceHandling": "link-only", "supportsConclusion": false }, { "baseEntityId": "claim:jurisdiction-scotland", "baseEntityType": "claim", "baseSnapshotByteReceipt": "sha256:1751b2ac331d6a1283cbf57b5b6961d9071f528298f97589fcbd7cf36407e139", "baseSnapshotCanonicalReceipt": "sha256:cc2c22e356cef0160ed5da1e2fd756bad5801f574c4cb064dec157b9207b9739", "baseSnapshotCanonicalUrl": "https://thekingdom.dev/government/uk-government-engine-2026-08-21.json", "evidenceUse": "orientation-only", "exactTextHumanReviewed": false, "genericOfficialHostTrust": false, "id": "evidence:four-nation-scotland", "officialSourceHandling": "link-only", "supportsConclusion": false }, { "baseEntityId": "claim:jurisdiction-wales", "baseEntityType": "claim", "baseSnapshotByteReceipt": "sha256:1751b2ac331d6a1283cbf57b5b6961d9071f528298f97589fcbd7cf36407e139", "baseSnapshotCanonicalReceipt": "sha256:cc2c22e356cef0160ed5da1e2fd756bad5801f574c4cb064dec157b9207b9739", "baseSnapshotCanonicalUrl": "https://thekingdom.dev/government/uk-government-engine-2026-08-21.json", "evidenceUse": "orientation-only", "exactTextHumanReviewed": false, "genericOfficialHostTrust": false, "id": "evidence:four-nation-wales", "officialSourceHandling": "link-only", "supportsConclusion": false } ], "externalContext": [], "hold": { "reasonCode": "four-nation-specialist-competence-review-required", "state": "held", "stopsProgression": true }, "humanGates": [ { "authorityOutsideSystem": true, "completed": false, "id": "gate:four-nation-competence-review", "label": "Four-nation specialist competence review", "planeIds": [ "plane:jurisdiction", "plane:law" ], "required": true }, { "authorityOutsideSystem": true, "completed": false, "id": "gate:four-nation-service-review", "label": "Four-nation service and remedy review", "planeIds": [ "plane:delivery", "plane:remedy" ], "required": true } ], "id": "dossier:four-nation-public-service-information", "jurisdictionBranches": [ { "baseBodyIds": [ "body:local-government-england", "body:uk-government" ], "baseClaimIds": [ "claim:jurisdiction-local-four-nations" ], "id": "branch:england", "jurisdiction": "England", "status": "specialist-review-required" }, { "baseBodyIds": [ "body:local-government-northern-ireland", "body:northern-ireland-assembly", "body:northern-ireland-executive" ], "baseClaimIds": [ "claim:jurisdiction-northern-ireland" ], "id": "branch:northern-ireland", "jurisdiction": "Northern Ireland", "status": "specialist-review-required" }, { "baseBodyIds": [ "body:local-government-scotland", "body:scottish-government", "body:scottish-parliament" ], "baseClaimIds": [ "claim:jurisdiction-scotland" ], "id": "branch:scotland", "jurisdiction": "Scotland", "status": "specialist-review-required" }, { "baseBodyIds": [ "body:local-government-wales", "body:senedd", "body:welsh-government" ], "baseClaimIds": [ "claim:jurisdiction-wales" ], "id": "branch:wales", "jurisdiction": "Wales", "status": "specialist-review-required" } ], "options": [ { "description": "Use one undifferentiated proposition page as a synthetic comparator.", "id": "option:four-nation-bau", "kind": "business-as-usual", "label": "Undifferentiated page", "selected": false }, { "description": "Publish four separately held territorial information branches.", "id": "option:four-nation-branches", "kind": "alternative", "label": "Separate branches", "selected": false }, { "description": "Publish a static comparison matrix that withholds any competence answer.", "id": "option:four-nation-matrix", "kind": "alternative", "label": "Held comparison matrix", "selected": false } ], "planeAssessments": [ { "evidenceAtomIds": [ "evidence:four-nation-delivery" ], "id": "assessment:four-nation-delivery", "planeId": "plane:delivery", "question": "Which delivery bodies and service patterns differ in each nation?", "specialistReviewRequired": true, "status": "specialist-review-required", "unresolvedQuestionIds": [ "question:four-nation-delivery-owner" ] }, { "evidenceAtomIds": [ "evidence:four-nation-asymmetry", "evidence:four-nation-local", "evidence:four-nation-ni", "evidence:four-nation-scotland", "evidence:four-nation-wales" ], "id": "assessment:four-nation-jurisdiction", "planeId": "plane:jurisdiction", "question": "Which exact matter and territorial competence test applies to each branch?", "specialistReviewRequired": true, "status": "specialist-review-required", "unresolvedQuestionIds": [ "question:england-competence", "question:ni-competence", "question:scotland-competence", "question:wales-competence" ] }, { "evidenceAtomIds": [ "evidence:four-nation-law" ], "id": "assessment:four-nation-law", "planeId": "plane:law", "question": "Which current enactments and instruments govern each distinct branch?", "specialistReviewRequired": true, "status": "specialist-review-required", "unresolvedQuestionIds": [ "question:four-nation-current-law" ] }, { "evidenceAtomIds": [ "evidence:four-nation-mandate" ], "id": "assessment:four-nation-mandate", "planeId": "plane:mandate", "question": "Which institution is accountable for the proposition in each branch?", "specialistReviewRequired": true, "status": "insufficient-evidence", "unresolvedQuestionIds": [ "question:four-nation-accountability" ] }, { "evidenceAtomIds": [ "evidence:four-nation-money" ], "id": "assessment:four-nation-money", "planeId": "plane:money", "question": "Which distinct funding authority and accountability chain would apply?", "specialistReviewRequired": true, "status": "not-assessed", "unresolvedQuestionIds": [ "question:four-nation-funding" ] }, { "evidenceAtomIds": [ "evidence:four-nation-remedy" ], "id": "assessment:four-nation-remedy", "planeId": "plane:remedy", "question": "Which distinct correction, complaint or challenge route would apply?", "specialistReviewRequired": true, "status": "not-assessed", "unresolvedQuestionIds": [ "question:four-nation-remedy" ] } ], "preferredOptionId": null, "proposition": { "affectedTerritories": [ "England", "Northern Ireland", "Scotland", "Wales" ], "canonicalReceipt": "sha256:f86be1c08e235fc20ea9727356ca1676bd8563d092de987ff901ba2d63fa0a84", "dossierId": "dossier:four-nation-public-service-information", "humanReviewed": false, "kind": "synthetic-exemplar", "officialProposal": false, "outOfScope": [ "competence determination", "funding authority", "implementation", "service adoption" ], "personalDataPresent": false, "scope": "static read-only four-nation public-service information orientation", "sourceAuthorship": "codex-assisted-publication-under-recorded-human-direction", "verbatimStatement": "A synthetic public-service information proposition represented through four distinct England, Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland branches, each stopped at specialist review." }, "routeOrientations": [], "selectionState": "not-selected", "synthetic": true, "title": "Synthetic four-nation public-service information proposition", "trialChamber": { "compatibility": "unavailable", "result": null, "useAsAuthority": false } }, { "actionArrays": { "decision": [], "evaluation": [], "implementation": [], "operational": [], "redress": [] }, "adoption": { "authorityLocation": "outside-this-system", "state": "not-adopted" }, "authorityDependencyGraph": { "automaticProgression": false, "edges": [ { "fromId": "notice:appeal", "id": "dependency:notice-appeal-jr", "rationale": "Tribunal appeal and judicial review are separately oriented in parallel; availability is not determined.", "toId": "notice:jr", "type": "parallel" }, { "fromId": "notice:complaint", "id": "dependency:notice-complaint-review", "rationale": "Complaint and statutory review are separately oriented in parallel; neither is selected.", "toId": "notice:review", "type": "parallel" }, { "fromId": "notice:delivery", "id": "dependency:notice-delivery-feedback", "rationale": "Content-design findings may reveal legal or remedy questions but do not resolve them.", "toId": "notice:law", "type": "feedback" }, { "fromId": "notice:jurisdiction", "id": "dependency:notice-jurisdiction-remedy", "rationale": "Territorial jurisdiction may constrain the relevant challenge orientation.", "toId": "notice:remedy", "type": "prerequisite" }, { "fromId": "notice:law", "id": "dependency:notice-law-money", "rationale": "Current specialist legal review is a prerequisite to any tax-liability explanation.", "toId": "notice:money", "type": "prerequisite" }, { "fromId": "notice:mandate", "id": "dependency:notice-mandate-law", "rationale": "Institutional responsibility does not itself identify the legal basis of a decision notice.", "toId": "notice:law", "type": "does-not-imply" } ], "nodes": [ { "assessmentId": "assessment:notice-remedy", "baseEntityIds": [ "redress:tax-tribunal-appeal" ], "id": "notice:appeal", "label": "Tribunal-appeal orientation", "planeId": "plane:remedy" }, { "assessmentId": "assessment:notice-remedy", "baseEntityIds": [ "redress:hmrc-service-complaint" ], "id": "notice:complaint", "label": "Service-complaint orientation", "planeId": "plane:remedy" }, { "assessmentId": "assessment:notice-delivery", "baseEntityIds": [ "body:hmrc", "claim:delivery-departments" ], "id": "notice:delivery", "label": "Explanatory-content delivery question", "planeId": "plane:delivery" }, { "assessmentId": "assessment:notice-remedy", "baseEntityIds": [ "redress:judicial-review-england-wales" ], "id": "notice:jr", "label": "Judicial-review orientation", "planeId": "plane:remedy" }, { "assessmentId": "assessment:notice-jurisdiction", "baseEntityIds": [ "claim:jurisdiction-asymmetric" ], "id": "notice:jurisdiction", "label": "Notice jurisdiction question", "planeId": "plane:jurisdiction" }, { "assessmentId": "assessment:notice-law", "baseEntityIds": [ "claim:law-guidance-distinct" ], "id": "notice:law", "label": "Notice law question", "planeId": "plane:law" }, { "assessmentId": "assessment:notice-mandate", "baseEntityIds": [ "claim:money-hmrc-role" ], "id": "notice:mandate", "label": "HMRC responsibility question", "planeId": "plane:mandate" }, { "assessmentId": "assessment:notice-money", "baseEntityIds": [ "claim:money-tax-policy-administration" ], "id": "notice:money", "label": "Tax administration distinction question", "planeId": "plane:money" }, { "assessmentId": "assessment:notice-remedy", "baseEntityIds": [ "claim:remedy-routes-distinct" ], "id": "notice:remedy", "label": "Challenge-route orientation question", "planeId": "plane:remedy" }, { "assessmentId": "assessment:notice-remedy", "baseEntityIds": [ "redress:hmrc-statutory-review" ], "id": "notice:review", "label": "Statutory-review orientation", "planeId": "plane:remedy" } ] }, "causalChangeHypothesisGraph": { "claimsCausalTruth": false, "edges": [ { "fromId": "causal:notice-bau", "id": "causal-edge:notice-bau-output", "toId": "causal:notice-bau-state", "type": "hypothesises-contribution" }, { "fromId": "causal:notice-evaluation", "id": "causal-edge:notice-evaluation", "toId": "causal:notice-outcome", "type": "tests" }, { "fromId": "causal:notice-layered-output", "id": "causal-edge:notice-layered-outcome", "toId": "causal:notice-outcome", "type": "hypothesises-contribution" }, { "fromId": "causal:notice-alt-layered", "id": "causal-edge:notice-layered-output", "toId": "causal:notice-layered-output", "type": "hypothesises-contribution" }, { "fromId": "causal:notice-negative", "id": "causal-edge:notice-negative", "toId": "causal:notice-outcome", "type": "may-undermine" }, { "fromId": "causal:notice-outcome", "id": "causal-edge:notice-outcome-depends-on-assumption", "toId": "causal:notice-assumption", "type": "depends-on" }, { "fromId": "causal:notice-route-output", "id": "causal-edge:notice-route-outcome", "toId": "causal:notice-outcome", "type": "hypothesises-contribution" }, { "fromId": "causal:notice-alt-route-map", "id": "causal-edge:notice-route-output", "toId": "causal:notice-route-output", "type": "hypothesises-contribution" } ], "nodes": [ { "id": "causal:notice-alt-layered", "optionId": "option:notice-layered", "statement": "Synthetic alternative: layered explanatory content with explicit uncertainty labels.", "type": "intervention-option" }, { "id": "causal:notice-alt-route-map", "optionId": "option:notice-route-map", "statement": "Synthetic alternative: a non-directive static route-distinction map.", "type": "intervention-option" }, { "id": "causal:notice-assumption", "optionId": null, "statement": "Hypothesis assumes clearer distinctions can improve orientation without implying case-specific rights.", "type": "assumption" }, { "id": "causal:notice-bau", "optionId": "option:notice-bau", "statement": "Synthetic business-as-usual comparator: retain the current generic explanatory-content pattern.", "type": "intervention-option" }, { "id": "causal:notice-bau-state", "optionId": null, "statement": "Hypothesised comparator state: the generic explanatory-content pattern remains.", "type": "output" }, { "id": "causal:notice-evaluation", "optionId": null, "statement": "Evaluation would require human-approved research, accessibility review and safeguards against deadline inference.", "type": "evaluation-need" }, { "id": "causal:notice-layered-output", "optionId": null, "statement": "Hypothesised layered output: static explanation with explicit uncertainty boundaries.", "type": "output" }, { "id": "causal:notice-negative", "optionId": null, "statement": "Readers may treat a route distinction as a route recommendation or deadline assurance.", "type": "negative-pathway" }, { "id": "causal:notice-outcome", "optionId": null, "statement": "Desired orientation outcome: clearer separation of explanation, complaint, review, appeal and judicial review.", "type": "desired-outcome" }, { "id": "causal:notice-route-output", "optionId": null, "statement": "Hypothesised route-map output: parallel distinctions with no route or deadline result.", "type": "output" } ] }, "desiredOutcomes": [ { "assumptionNodeIds": [ "causal:notice-assumption" ], "evaluationNeedNodeIds": [ "causal:notice-evaluation" ], "id": "outcome:notice-route-distinction", "negativePathwayNodeIds": [ "causal:notice-negative" ], "statement": "Support route distinction without determining a route, deadline, eligibility, liability or legal effect." } ], "evidenceAtoms": [ { "baseEntityId": "redress:tax-tribunal-appeal", "baseEntityType": "redressRoute", "baseSnapshotByteReceipt": "sha256:1751b2ac331d6a1283cbf57b5b6961d9071f528298f97589fcbd7cf36407e139", "baseSnapshotCanonicalReceipt": "sha256:cc2c22e356cef0160ed5da1e2fd756bad5801f574c4cb064dec157b9207b9739", "baseSnapshotCanonicalUrl": "https://thekingdom.dev/government/uk-government-engine-2026-08-21.json", "evidenceUse": "orientation-only", "exactTextHumanReviewed": false, "genericOfficialHostTrust": false, "id": "evidence:notice-appeal", "officialSourceHandling": "link-only", "supportsConclusion": false }, { "baseEntityId": "redress:hmrc-service-complaint", "baseEntityType": "redressRoute", "baseSnapshotByteReceipt": "sha256:1751b2ac331d6a1283cbf57b5b6961d9071f528298f97589fcbd7cf36407e139", "baseSnapshotCanonicalReceipt": "sha256:cc2c22e356cef0160ed5da1e2fd756bad5801f574c4cb064dec157b9207b9739", "baseSnapshotCanonicalUrl": "https://thekingdom.dev/government/uk-government-engine-2026-08-21.json", "evidenceUse": "orientation-only", "exactTextHumanReviewed": false, "genericOfficialHostTrust": false, "id": "evidence:notice-complaint", "officialSourceHandling": "link-only", "supportsConclusion": false }, { "baseEntityId": "claim:delivery-departments", "baseEntityType": "claim", "baseSnapshotByteReceipt": "sha256:1751b2ac331d6a1283cbf57b5b6961d9071f528298f97589fcbd7cf36407e139", "baseSnapshotCanonicalReceipt": "sha256:cc2c22e356cef0160ed5da1e2fd756bad5801f574c4cb064dec157b9207b9739", "baseSnapshotCanonicalUrl": "https://thekingdom.dev/government/uk-government-engine-2026-08-21.json", "evidenceUse": "orientation-only", "exactTextHumanReviewed": false, "genericOfficialHostTrust": false, "id": "evidence:notice-delivery", "officialSourceHandling": "link-only", "supportsConclusion": false }, { "baseEntityId": "redress:judicial-review-england-wales", "baseEntityType": "redressRoute", "baseSnapshotByteReceipt": "sha256:1751b2ac331d6a1283cbf57b5b6961d9071f528298f97589fcbd7cf36407e139", "baseSnapshotCanonicalReceipt": "sha256:cc2c22e356cef0160ed5da1e2fd756bad5801f574c4cb064dec157b9207b9739", "baseSnapshotCanonicalUrl": "https://thekingdom.dev/government/uk-government-engine-2026-08-21.json", "evidenceUse": "orientation-only", "exactTextHumanReviewed": false, "genericOfficialHostTrust": false, "id": "evidence:notice-jr", "officialSourceHandling": "link-only", "supportsConclusion": false }, { "baseEntityId": "claim:jurisdiction-asymmetric", "baseEntityType": "claim", "baseSnapshotByteReceipt": "sha256:1751b2ac331d6a1283cbf57b5b6961d9071f528298f97589fcbd7cf36407e139", "baseSnapshotCanonicalReceipt": "sha256:cc2c22e356cef0160ed5da1e2fd756bad5801f574c4cb064dec157b9207b9739", "baseSnapshotCanonicalUrl": "https://thekingdom.dev/government/uk-government-engine-2026-08-21.json", "evidenceUse": "orientation-only", "exactTextHumanReviewed": false, "genericOfficialHostTrust": false, "id": "evidence:notice-jurisdiction", "officialSourceHandling": "link-only", "supportsConclusion": false }, { "baseEntityId": "claim:law-guidance-distinct", "baseEntityType": "claim", "baseSnapshotByteReceipt": "sha256:1751b2ac331d6a1283cbf57b5b6961d9071f528298f97589fcbd7cf36407e139", "baseSnapshotCanonicalReceipt": "sha256:cc2c22e356cef0160ed5da1e2fd756bad5801f574c4cb064dec157b9207b9739", "baseSnapshotCanonicalUrl": "https://thekingdom.dev/government/uk-government-engine-2026-08-21.json", "evidenceUse": "orientation-only", "exactTextHumanReviewed": false, "genericOfficialHostTrust": false, "id": "evidence:notice-law", "officialSourceHandling": "link-only", "supportsConclusion": false }, { "baseEntityId": "claim:money-hmrc-role", "baseEntityType": "claim", "baseSnapshotByteReceipt": "sha256:1751b2ac331d6a1283cbf57b5b6961d9071f528298f97589fcbd7cf36407e139", "baseSnapshotCanonicalReceipt": "sha256:cc2c22e356cef0160ed5da1e2fd756bad5801f574c4cb064dec157b9207b9739", "baseSnapshotCanonicalUrl": "https://thekingdom.dev/government/uk-government-engine-2026-08-21.json", "evidenceUse": "orientation-only", "exactTextHumanReviewed": false, "genericOfficialHostTrust": false, "id": "evidence:notice-mandate", "officialSourceHandling": "link-only", "supportsConclusion": false }, { "baseEntityId": "claim:money-tax-policy-administration", "baseEntityType": "claim", "baseSnapshotByteReceipt": "sha256:1751b2ac331d6a1283cbf57b5b6961d9071f528298f97589fcbd7cf36407e139", "baseSnapshotCanonicalReceipt": "sha256:cc2c22e356cef0160ed5da1e2fd756bad5801f574c4cb064dec157b9207b9739", "baseSnapshotCanonicalUrl": "https://thekingdom.dev/government/uk-government-engine-2026-08-21.json", "evidenceUse": "orientation-only", "exactTextHumanReviewed": false, "genericOfficialHostTrust": false, "id": "evidence:notice-money", "officialSourceHandling": "link-only", "supportsConclusion": false }, { "baseEntityId": "redress:hmrc-statutory-review", "baseEntityType": "redressRoute", "baseSnapshotByteReceipt": "sha256:1751b2ac331d6a1283cbf57b5b6961d9071f528298f97589fcbd7cf36407e139", "baseSnapshotCanonicalReceipt": "sha256:cc2c22e356cef0160ed5da1e2fd756bad5801f574c4cb064dec157b9207b9739", "baseSnapshotCanonicalUrl": "https://thekingdom.dev/government/uk-government-engine-2026-08-21.json", "evidenceUse": "orientation-only", "exactTextHumanReviewed": false, "genericOfficialHostTrust": false, "id": "evidence:notice-review", "officialSourceHandling": "link-only", "supportsConclusion": false }, { "baseEntityId": "claim:remedy-routes-distinct", "baseEntityType": "claim", "baseSnapshotByteReceipt": "sha256:1751b2ac331d6a1283cbf57b5b6961d9071f528298f97589fcbd7cf36407e139", "baseSnapshotCanonicalReceipt": "sha256:cc2c22e356cef0160ed5da1e2fd756bad5801f574c4cb064dec157b9207b9739", "baseSnapshotCanonicalUrl": "https://thekingdom.dev/government/uk-government-engine-2026-08-21.json", "evidenceUse": "orientation-only", "exactTextHumanReviewed": false, "genericOfficialHostTrust": false, "id": "evidence:notice-routes", "officialSourceHandling": "link-only", "supportsConclusion": false } ], "externalContext": [ { "baseSnapshotByteReceipt": "sha256:1751b2ac331d6a1283cbf57b5b6961d9071f528298f97589fcbd7cf36407e139", "baseSnapshotCanonicalReceipt": "sha256:cc2c22e356cef0160ed5da1e2fd756bad5801f574c4cb064dec157b9207b9739", "baseSnapshotCanonicalUrl": "https://thekingdom.dev/government/uk-government-engine-2026-08-21.json", "bridgeId": "bridge:taxsorted-tax-system", "collection": "pipelineStages", "recordId": "stage-review-and-appeal", "supportsClaimIds": [], "taint": "external-context-only" }, { "baseSnapshotByteReceipt": "sha256:1751b2ac331d6a1283cbf57b5b6961d9071f528298f97589fcbd7cf36407e139", "baseSnapshotCanonicalReceipt": "sha256:cc2c22e356cef0160ed5da1e2fd756bad5801f574c4cb064dec157b9207b9739", "baseSnapshotCanonicalUrl": "https://thekingdom.dev/government/uk-government-engine-2026-08-21.json", "bridgeId": "bridge:taxsorted-tax-system", "collection": "pipelineStages", "recordId": "stage-service-complaint", "supportsClaimIds": [], "taint": "external-context-only" } ], "hold": { "reasonCode": "route-deadline-and-eligibility-insufficient-evidence", "state": "held", "stopsProgression": true }, "humanGates": [ { "authorityOutsideSystem": true, "completed": false, "id": "gate:notice-accessibility-research", "label": "Accessibility and research ethics review", "planeIds": [ "plane:delivery" ], "required": true }, { "authorityOutsideSystem": true, "completed": false, "id": "gate:notice-specialist-tax-legal-review", "label": "Specialist tax and legal review", "planeIds": [ "plane:law", "plane:money", "plane:remedy" ], "required": true } ], "id": "dossier:hmrc-decision-notice-explanatory-content", "jurisdictionBranches": [], "options": [ { "description": "Retain a generic explanatory-content pattern as the synthetic comparator.", "id": "option:notice-bau", "kind": "business-as-usual", "label": "Generic explanation", "selected": false }, { "description": "Explore layered static explanations with visible uncertainty and non-advice boundaries.", "id": "option:notice-layered", "kind": "alternative", "label": "Layered explanation", "selected": false }, { "description": "Explore a static distinction map that does not select or rank challenge routes.", "id": "option:notice-route-map", "kind": "alternative", "label": "Route distinction map", "selected": false } ], "planeAssessments": [ { "evidenceAtomIds": [ "evidence:notice-delivery" ], "id": "assessment:notice-delivery", "planeId": "plane:delivery", "question": "Could static explanatory content make distinctions visible without changing a decision or operating a case?", "specialistReviewRequired": true, "status": "insufficient-evidence", "unresolvedQuestionIds": [ "question:notice-accessibility", "question:notice-content-governance" ] }, { "evidenceAtomIds": [ "evidence:notice-jurisdiction" ], "id": "assessment:notice-jurisdiction", "planeId": "plane:jurisdiction", "question": "Which territorial and tribunal jurisdiction applies to an exact decision type?", "specialistReviewRequired": true, "status": "insufficient-evidence", "unresolvedQuestionIds": [ "question:notice-jurisdiction" ] }, { "evidenceAtomIds": [ "evidence:notice-law" ], "id": "assessment:notice-law", "planeId": "plane:law", "question": "Which current law and notice-specific instrument governs an exact decision?", "specialistReviewRequired": true, "status": "insufficient-evidence", "unresolvedQuestionIds": [ "question:notice-current-law" ] }, { "evidenceAtomIds": [ "evidence:notice-mandate" ], "id": "assessment:notice-mandate", "planeId": "plane:mandate", "question": "Which public institution owns the decision and explanatory-content accountability?", "specialistReviewRequired": true, "status": "insufficient-evidence", "unresolvedQuestionIds": [ "question:notice-accountability" ] }, { "evidenceAtomIds": [ "evidence:notice-money" ], "id": "assessment:notice-money", "planeId": "plane:money", "question": "Can policy, administration, liability and payment remain visibly separate?", "specialistReviewRequired": true, "status": "insufficient-evidence", "unresolvedQuestionIds": [ "question:notice-liability-boundary" ] }, { "evidenceAtomIds": [ "evidence:notice-appeal", "evidence:notice-complaint", "evidence:notice-jr", "evidence:notice-review", "evidence:notice-routes" ], "id": "assessment:notice-remedy", "planeId": "plane:remedy", "question": "Which complaint, review, appeal or judicial-review routes might require separate specialist orientation?", "specialistReviewRequired": true, "status": "insufficient-evidence", "unresolvedQuestionIds": [ "question:notice-deadline", "question:notice-eligibility", "question:notice-route" ] } ], "preferredOptionId": null, "proposition": { "affectedTerritories": [ "United Kingdom" ], "canonicalReceipt": "sha256:aec1cdc5a5f0b258667476a24b707fe48ee8fea8aeb613d441f38b3d6130b850", "dossierId": "dossier:hmrc-decision-notice-explanatory-content", "humanReviewed": false, "kind": "synthetic-exemplar", "officialProposal": false, "outOfScope": [ "case handling", "deadline determination", "eligibility determination", "route selection", "tax liability determination" ], "personalDataPresent": false, "scope": "static read-only explanatory-content orientation", "sourceAuthorship": "codex-assisted-publication-under-recorded-human-direction", "verbatimStatement": "A synthetic HMRC decision-notice explanatory-content redesign that keeps complaint, statutory review, tribunal appeal and judicial review parallel and determines no route, deadline, eligibility, liability or legal effect." }, "routeOrientations": [ { "baseRedressRouteId": "redress:hmrc-service-complaint", "deadlineDetermined": false, "eligibilityDetermined": false, "id": "route-orientation:hmrc-complaint", "relationship": "parallel", "routeDetermined": false }, { "baseRedressRouteId": "redress:hmrc-statutory-review", "deadlineDetermined": false, "eligibilityDetermined": false, "id": "route-orientation:hmrc-review", "relationship": "parallel", "routeDetermined": false }, { "baseRedressRouteId": "redress:judicial-review-england-wales", "deadlineDetermined": false, "eligibilityDetermined": false, "id": "route-orientation:judicial-review", "relationship": "parallel", "routeDetermined": false }, { "baseRedressRouteId": "redress:tax-tribunal-appeal", "deadlineDetermined": false, "eligibilityDetermined": false, "id": "route-orientation:tax-tribunal-appeal", "relationship": "parallel", "routeDetermined": false } ], "selectionState": "not-selected", "synthetic": true, "title": "Synthetic HMRC decision-notice explanatory-content redesign", "trialChamber": { "compatibility": "unavailable", "result": null, "useAsAuthority": false } }, { "actionArrays": { "decision": [], "evaluation": [], "implementation": [], "operational": [], "redress": [] }, "adoption": { "authorityLocation": "outside-this-system", "state": "not-adopted" }, "authorityDependencyGraph": { "automaticProgression": false, "edges": [ { "fromId": "delivery:rail-question", "id": "dependency:delivery-money-feedback", "rationale": "Operational observations may expose a public-money question without settling it.", "toId": "money:authority-question", "type": "feedback" }, { "fromId": "mandate:accountability-question", "id": "dependency:mandate-jurisdiction-parallel", "rationale": "Institutional accountability and territorial competence remain separate lines of inquiry.", "toId": "jurisdiction:competence-question", "type": "parallel" }, { "fromId": "law:instrument-question", "id": "dependency:money-law-prerequisite", "rationale": "A spending narrative cannot substitute for identifying the relevant legal authority.", "toId": "money:authority-question", "type": "prerequisite" }, { "fromId": "delivery:rail-question", "id": "dependency:rail-does-not-imply-authority", "rationale": "A service or payment rail does not create mandate, legal power or spending authority.", "toId": "mandate:accountability-question", "type": "does-not-imply" }, { "fromId": "remedy:accountability-question", "id": "dependency:remedy-delivery-parallel", "rationale": "Accountability and complaint questions can be examined alongside service design without becoming implementation instructions.", "toId": "delivery:rail-question", "type": "parallel" } ], "nodes": [ { "assessmentId": "assessment:money-service-delivery", "baseEntityIds": [ "claim:delivery-pay", "claim:money-gbs", "claim:money-rtgs-chaps" ], "id": "delivery:rail-question", "label": "Service and settlement rails", "planeId": "plane:delivery" }, { "assessmentId": "assessment:money-service-jurisdiction", "baseEntityIds": [ "claim:jurisdiction-asymmetric" ], "id": "jurisdiction:competence-question", "label": "Territorial competence question", "planeId": "plane:jurisdiction" }, { "assessmentId": "assessment:money-service-law", "baseEntityIds": [ "claim:law-guidance-distinct" ], "id": "law:instrument-question", "label": "Instrument and authority question", "planeId": "plane:law" }, { "assessmentId": "assessment:money-service-mandate", "baseEntityIds": [ "claim:authority-government-parliament-distinct" ], "id": "mandate:accountability-question", "label": "Institutional accountability question", "planeId": "plane:mandate" }, { "assessmentId": "assessment:money-service-money", "baseEntityIds": [ "claim:money-estimates", "claim:money-parliamentary-authority", "unknown:public-money-trace" ], "id": "money:authority-question", "label": "Authority and traceability question", "planeId": "plane:money" }, { "assessmentId": "assessment:money-service-remedy", "baseEntityIds": [ "claim:remedy-routes-distinct" ], "id": "remedy:accountability-question", "label": "Accountability-route question", "planeId": "plane:remedy" } ] }, "causalChangeHypothesisGraph": { "claimsCausalTruth": false, "edges": [ { "fromId": "causal:money-bau", "id": "causal-edge:money-bau-output", "toId": "causal:money-bau-state", "type": "hypothesises-contribution" }, { "fromId": "causal:money-evaluation", "id": "causal-edge:money-evaluation-outcome", "toId": "causal:money-outcome", "type": "tests" }, { "fromId": "causal:money-glossary-output", "id": "causal-edge:money-glossary-outcome", "toId": "causal:money-outcome", "type": "hypothesises-contribution" }, { "fromId": "causal:money-alt-glossary", "id": "causal-edge:money-glossary-output", "toId": "causal:money-glossary-output", "type": "hypothesises-contribution" }, { "fromId": "causal:money-map-output", "id": "causal-edge:money-map-outcome", "toId": "causal:money-outcome", "type": "hypothesises-contribution" }, { "fromId": "causal:money-alt-linked-map", "id": "causal-edge:money-map-output", "toId": "causal:money-map-output", "type": "hypothesises-contribution" }, { "fromId": "causal:money-negative", "id": "causal-edge:money-negative-outcome", "toId": "causal:money-outcome", "type": "may-undermine" }, { "fromId": "causal:money-outcome", "id": "causal-edge:money-outcome-depends-on-assumption", "toId": "causal:money-assumption", "type": "depends-on" } ], "nodes": [ { "id": "causal:money-alt-glossary", "optionId": "option:money-glossary", "statement": "Synthetic alternative: publish a static distinctions glossary.", "type": "intervention-option" }, { "id": "causal:money-alt-linked-map", "optionId": "option:money-linked-map", "statement": "Synthetic alternative: publish a static source-linked authority map.", "type": "intervention-option" }, { "id": "causal:money-assumption", "optionId": null, "statement": "Hypothesis assumes readers notice and understand explicit category distinctions.", "type": "assumption" }, { "id": "causal:money-bau", "optionId": "option:money-bau", "statement": "Synthetic business-as-usual comparator: retain dispersed source-linked explanations.", "type": "intervention-option" }, { "id": "causal:money-bau-state", "optionId": null, "statement": "Hypothesised comparator state: public-money distinctions remain dispersed.", "type": "output" }, { "id": "causal:money-evaluation", "optionId": null, "statement": "A future evaluator would need a human-approved comprehension protocol and non-personal aggregate evidence.", "type": "evaluation-need" }, { "id": "causal:money-glossary-output", "optionId": null, "statement": "Hypothesised glossary output: static category distinctions with no authority result.", "type": "output" }, { "id": "causal:money-map-output", "optionId": null, "statement": "Hypothesised map output: source-linked distinctions and held unknowns.", "type": "output" }, { "id": "causal:money-negative", "optionId": null, "statement": "Readers may mistake navigation order or technical rails for an authority chain.", "type": "negative-pathway" }, { "id": "causal:money-outcome", "optionId": null, "statement": "Desired orientation outcome: clearer separation of plan, Estimate, authority, banking, payment and settlement concepts.", "type": "desired-outcome" } ] }, "desiredOutcomes": [ { "assumptionNodeIds": [ "causal:money-assumption" ], "evaluationNeedNodeIds": [ "causal:money-evaluation" ], "id": "outcome:money-category-separation", "negativePathwayNodeIds": [ "causal:money-negative" ], "statement": "Support orientation about public-money distinctions without tracing a labelled pound or asserting authority." } ], "evidenceAtoms": [ { "baseEntityId": "claim:money-parliamentary-authority", "baseEntityType": "claim", "baseSnapshotByteReceipt": "sha256:1751b2ac331d6a1283cbf57b5b6961d9071f528298f97589fcbd7cf36407e139", "baseSnapshotCanonicalReceipt": "sha256:cc2c22e356cef0160ed5da1e2fd756bad5801f574c4cb064dec157b9207b9739", "baseSnapshotCanonicalUrl": "https://thekingdom.dev/government/uk-government-engine-2026-08-21.json", "evidenceUse": "orientation-only", "exactTextHumanReviewed": false, "genericOfficialHostTrust": false, "id": "evidence:money-authority", "officialSourceHandling": "link-only", "supportsConclusion": false }, { "baseEntityId": "claim:money-estimates", "baseEntityType": "claim", "baseSnapshotByteReceipt": "sha256:1751b2ac331d6a1283cbf57b5b6961d9071f528298f97589fcbd7cf36407e139", "baseSnapshotCanonicalReceipt": "sha256:cc2c22e356cef0160ed5da1e2fd756bad5801f574c4cb064dec157b9207b9739", "baseSnapshotCanonicalUrl": "https://thekingdom.dev/government/uk-government-engine-2026-08-21.json", "evidenceUse": "orientation-only", "exactTextHumanReviewed": false, "genericOfficialHostTrust": false, "id": "evidence:money-estimates", "officialSourceHandling": "link-only", "supportsConclusion": false }, { "baseEntityId": "claim:money-gbs", "baseEntityType": "claim", "baseSnapshotByteReceipt": "sha256:1751b2ac331d6a1283cbf57b5b6961d9071f528298f97589fcbd7cf36407e139", "baseSnapshotCanonicalReceipt": "sha256:cc2c22e356cef0160ed5da1e2fd756bad5801f574c4cb064dec157b9207b9739", "baseSnapshotCanonicalUrl": "https://thekingdom.dev/government/uk-government-engine-2026-08-21.json", "evidenceUse": "orientation-only", "exactTextHumanReviewed": false, "genericOfficialHostTrust": false, "id": "evidence:money-gbs", "officialSourceHandling": "link-only", "supportsConclusion": false }, { "baseEntityId": "claim:jurisdiction-asymmetric", "baseEntityType": "claim", "baseSnapshotByteReceipt": "sha256:1751b2ac331d6a1283cbf57b5b6961d9071f528298f97589fcbd7cf36407e139", "baseSnapshotCanonicalReceipt": "sha256:cc2c22e356cef0160ed5da1e2fd756bad5801f574c4cb064dec157b9207b9739", "baseSnapshotCanonicalUrl": "https://thekingdom.dev/government/uk-government-engine-2026-08-21.json", "evidenceUse": "orientation-only", "exactTextHumanReviewed": false, "genericOfficialHostTrust": false, "id": "evidence:money-jurisdiction", "officialSourceHandling": "link-only", "supportsConclusion": false }, { "baseEntityId": "claim:law-guidance-distinct", "baseEntityType": "claim", "baseSnapshotByteReceipt": "sha256:1751b2ac331d6a1283cbf57b5b6961d9071f528298f97589fcbd7cf36407e139", "baseSnapshotCanonicalReceipt": "sha256:cc2c22e356cef0160ed5da1e2fd756bad5801f574c4cb064dec157b9207b9739", "baseSnapshotCanonicalUrl": "https://thekingdom.dev/government/uk-government-engine-2026-08-21.json", "evidenceUse": "orientation-only", "exactTextHumanReviewed": false, "genericOfficialHostTrust": false, "id": "evidence:money-law", "officialSourceHandling": "link-only", "supportsConclusion": false }, { "baseEntityId": "claim:authority-government-parliament-distinct", "baseEntityType": "claim", "baseSnapshotByteReceipt": "sha256:1751b2ac331d6a1283cbf57b5b6961d9071f528298f97589fcbd7cf36407e139", "baseSnapshotCanonicalReceipt": "sha256:cc2c22e356cef0160ed5da1e2fd756bad5801f574c4cb064dec157b9207b9739", "baseSnapshotCanonicalUrl": "https://thekingdom.dev/government/uk-government-engine-2026-08-21.json", "evidenceUse": "orientation-only", "exactTextHumanReviewed": false, "genericOfficialHostTrust": false, "id": "evidence:money-mandate", "officialSourceHandling": "link-only", "supportsConclusion": false }, { "baseEntityId": "claim:delivery-pay", "baseEntityType": "claim", "baseSnapshotByteReceipt": "sha256:1751b2ac331d6a1283cbf57b5b6961d9071f528298f97589fcbd7cf36407e139", "baseSnapshotCanonicalReceipt": "sha256:cc2c22e356cef0160ed5da1e2fd756bad5801f574c4cb064dec157b9207b9739", "baseSnapshotCanonicalUrl": "https://thekingdom.dev/government/uk-government-engine-2026-08-21.json", "evidenceUse": "orientation-only", "exactTextHumanReviewed": false, "genericOfficialHostTrust": false, "id": "evidence:money-pay", "officialSourceHandling": "link-only", "supportsConclusion": false }, { "baseEntityId": "claim:remedy-routes-distinct", "baseEntityType": "claim", "baseSnapshotByteReceipt": "sha256:1751b2ac331d6a1283cbf57b5b6961d9071f528298f97589fcbd7cf36407e139", "baseSnapshotCanonicalReceipt": "sha256:cc2c22e356cef0160ed5da1e2fd756bad5801f574c4cb064dec157b9207b9739", "baseSnapshotCanonicalUrl": "https://thekingdom.dev/government/uk-government-engine-2026-08-21.json", "evidenceUse": "orientation-only", "exactTextHumanReviewed": false, "genericOfficialHostTrust": false, "id": "evidence:money-remedy", "officialSourceHandling": "link-only", "supportsConclusion": false }, { "baseEntityId": "claim:money-rtgs-chaps", "baseEntityType": "claim", "baseSnapshotByteReceipt": "sha256:1751b2ac331d6a1283cbf57b5b6961d9071f528298f97589fcbd7cf36407e139", "baseSnapshotCanonicalReceipt": "sha256:cc2c22e356cef0160ed5da1e2fd756bad5801f574c4cb064dec157b9207b9739", "baseSnapshotCanonicalUrl": "https://thekingdom.dev/government/uk-government-engine-2026-08-21.json", "evidenceUse": "orientation-only", "exactTextHumanReviewed": false, "genericOfficialHostTrust": false, "id": "evidence:money-rtgs", "officialSourceHandling": "link-only", "supportsConclusion": false }, { "baseEntityId": "unknown:public-money-trace", "baseEntityType": "unknown", "baseSnapshotByteReceipt": "sha256:1751b2ac331d6a1283cbf57b5b6961d9071f528298f97589fcbd7cf36407e139", "baseSnapshotCanonicalReceipt": "sha256:cc2c22e356cef0160ed5da1e2fd756bad5801f574c4cb064dec157b9207b9739", "baseSnapshotCanonicalUrl": "https://thekingdom.dev/government/uk-government-engine-2026-08-21.json", "evidenceUse": "orientation-only", "exactTextHumanReviewed": false, "genericOfficialHostTrust": false, "id": "evidence:money-trace-held", "officialSourceHandling": "link-only", "supportsConclusion": false } ], "externalContext": [ { "baseSnapshotByteReceipt": "sha256:1751b2ac331d6a1283cbf57b5b6961d9071f528298f97589fcbd7cf36407e139", "baseSnapshotCanonicalReceipt": "sha256:cc2c22e356cef0160ed5da1e2fd756bad5801f574c4cb064dec157b9207b9739", "baseSnapshotCanonicalUrl": "https://thekingdom.dev/government/uk-government-engine-2026-08-21.json", "bridgeId": "bridge:taxsorted-public-funding", "collection": "fundingMechanisms", "recordId": "mechanism-parliamentary-supply", "supportsClaimIds": [], "taint": "external-context-only" }, { "baseSnapshotByteReceipt": "sha256:1751b2ac331d6a1283cbf57b5b6961d9071f528298f97589fcbd7cf36407e139", "baseSnapshotCanonicalReceipt": "sha256:cc2c22e356cef0160ed5da1e2fd756bad5801f574c4cb064dec157b9207b9739", "baseSnapshotCanonicalUrl": "https://thekingdom.dev/government/uk-government-engine-2026-08-21.json", "bridgeId": "bridge:taxsorted-public-funding", "collection": "transparencyGaps", "recordId": "gap-pooled-pound-traceability", "supportsClaimIds": [], "taint": "external-context-only" } ], "hold": { "reasonCode": "labelled-pound-traceability-not-established", "state": "held", "stopsProgression": true }, "humanGates": [ { "authorityOutsideSystem": true, "completed": false, "id": "gate:money-evaluation-design", "label": "Independent evaluation-design review", "planeIds": [ "plane:delivery", "plane:remedy" ], "required": true }, { "authorityOutsideSystem": true, "completed": false, "id": "gate:money-public-authority-review", "label": "Public-money authority review", "planeIds": [ "plane:law", "plane:money" ], "required": true } ], "id": "dossier:public-money-transparency-information-service", "jurisdictionBranches": [], "options": [ { "description": "Retain dispersed explanatory materials as the synthetic comparator.", "id": "option:money-bau", "kind": "business-as-usual", "label": "Dispersed explanations", "selected": false }, { "description": "Publish a static glossary distinguishing plans, Estimates, appropriations and payment rails.", "id": "option:money-glossary", "kind": "alternative", "label": "Distinctions glossary", "selected": false }, { "description": "Publish a static source-linked map with explicit unknown and hold states.", "id": "option:money-linked-map", "kind": "alternative", "label": "Authority map", "selected": false } ], "planeAssessments": [ { "evidenceAtomIds": [ "evidence:money-gbs", "evidence:money-pay", "evidence:money-rtgs" ], "id": "assessment:money-service-delivery", "planeId": "plane:delivery", "question": "Which information and payment rails are being described without treating them as authority?", "specialistReviewRequired": false, "status": "insufficient-evidence", "unresolvedQuestionIds": [ "question:money-service-scope" ] }, { "evidenceAtomIds": [ "evidence:money-jurisdiction" ], "id": "assessment:money-service-jurisdiction", "planeId": "plane:jurisdiction", "question": "Would any proposed explanation differ across the four nations or local systems?", "specialistReviewRequired": true, "status": "specialist-review-required", "unresolvedQuestionIds": [ "question:money-territorial-scope" ] }, { "evidenceAtomIds": [ "evidence:money-law" ], "id": "assessment:money-service-law", "planeId": "plane:law", "question": "Which enactment or instrument supplies authority for each described public-money step?", "specialistReviewRequired": true, "status": "insufficient-evidence", "unresolvedQuestionIds": [ "question:money-instrument-authority" ] }, { "evidenceAtomIds": [ "evidence:money-mandate" ], "id": "assessment:money-service-mandate", "planeId": "plane:mandate", "question": "Which institution is accountable for each explanatory statement?", "specialistReviewRequired": true, "status": "insufficient-evidence", "unresolvedQuestionIds": [ "question:money-accountability-owner" ] }, { "evidenceAtomIds": [ "evidence:money-authority", "evidence:money-estimates", "evidence:money-trace-held" ], "id": "assessment:money-service-money", "planeId": "plane:money", "question": "Can plan, Estimate, appropriation, issue, banking, payment and outturn be kept distinct?", "specialistReviewRequired": true, "status": "contested", "unresolvedQuestionIds": [ "question:labelled-pound-trace" ] }, { "evidenceAtomIds": [ "evidence:money-remedy" ], "id": "assessment:money-service-remedy", "planeId": "plane:remedy", "question": "What accountability or correction route would apply to erroneous explanatory content?", "specialistReviewRequired": true, "status": "not-assessed", "unresolvedQuestionIds": [ "question:money-content-correction-route" ] } ], "preferredOptionId": null, "proposition": { "affectedTerritories": [ "United Kingdom" ], "canonicalReceipt": "sha256:dc4181b8179f15a3b33541c57c97e399f41bee23fb335efee9b2342a9f22e538", "dossierId": "dossier:public-money-transparency-information-service", "humanReviewed": false, "kind": "synthetic-exemplar", "officialProposal": false, "outOfScope": [ "authority determination", "labelled-pound tracing", "live financial data", "payment or transaction execution" ], "personalDataPresent": false, "scope": "static read-only public-money information orientation", "sourceAuthorship": "codex-assisted-publication-under-recorded-human-direction", "verbatimStatement": "A synthetic static information proposition that could make plans, Estimates, appropriations, issue, banking, payment, settlement and outturn distinctions visible while holding any labelled-pound trace as unestablished." }, "routeOrientations": [], "selectionState": "not-selected", "synthetic": true, "title": "Synthetic public-money transparency information service", "trialChamber": { "compatibility": "unavailable", "result": null, "useAsAuthority": false } } ], "freshness": { "automaticRuntimeEnforcement": false, "expiredState": "hard-quarantined-historical-only", "immutableAfterDeadline": "historical-orientation-only", "inheritsBaseReviewWindow": true, "mutableAliasPolicy": "retire-or-replace", "nextReviewDue": "2026-09-21", "readerTimeBehavior": "immutable-artifact-remains-available-but-must-be-treated-as-historical-only-after-review-deadline", "readerTimeStateNotEmbedded": true, "releaseGateRequired": true, "stateAtPublication": "within-review-window" }, "jurisdiction": { "code": "UK", "label": "United Kingdom", "scope": "orientation-only" }, "schema": "kingdom.government-transformation-orientation-public-snapshot/0.1", "title": "Government Transformation Engine: United Kingdom", "trialChamber": { "compatibility": "unavailable", "result": null, "useAsAuthority": false }, "urls": { "canonical": "https://thekingdom.dev/government/uk-government-transformation-engine-2026-08-21.json", "guide": "https://thekingdom.dev/UK-GOVERNMENT-TRANSFORMATION-ENGINE-v0.1.md", "human": "https://thekingdom.dev/government-transformation-engine/", "mutableAlias": "https://thekingdom.dev/government-transformations.json", "producer": "https://github.com/cambridgetcg/kingdom-government-transformation-engine/tree/v0.1.0", "repository": "https://github.com/cambridgetcg/kingdom-government-transformation-engine", "schema": "https://thekingdom.dev/government/transformations/schemas/v0.1/public-snapshot.schema.json" } }