{ "$schema": "urn:kingdom:schema:phenomena-deep-project:0.1", "protocol": "kingdom.explore-phenomena-deep-project/0.1", "project_id": "string-crawl-trace-sheet-2026-08-15", "version": "0.1.0", "title": "STRING / CRAWL: The Trace-Sheet", "evidence_through": "2026-08-15", "mode": "ANALYZE_ONLY", "question": "Which structures from string theory can open bounded mathematical doors for studying public website crawl traces and possible future KINGDOM aftermath receipts without claiming that a crawler is a string, that observation is consent, or that KARMA is a force, charge, action, probability, or score?", "domains": [ { "id": "string-worldsheet-mathematics", "subject": "Bosonic string worldsheet and sigma-model mathematics", "entity_or_unit": "Worldsheet, embedding map, target space, metric, boundary condition, gauge equivalence, topology, and observable", "context": "Named mathematical structures in the cited string-theory sources; no claim that the public web physically instantiates them", "conditions": ["A two-dimensional surface and target data are declared", "Smooth formulas require the stated regularity and background assumptions"], "observables": ["formal action", "worldsheet topology", "correlation function under a specified model"], "units": ["model-dependent worldsheet and target-space units", "dimensionless formal quantities where declared"], "agency": "Formal objects have no agency; theorists choose models, gauges, observables, and interpretations" }, { "id": "public-route-graph", "subject": "Versioned public website routes and declared links", "entity_or_unit": "Public route, representation, hyperlink, redirect, release, and deployment-specific origin", "context": "A finite, explicitly selected public artifact graph at a named evidence horizon", "conditions": ["Only public, in-scope routes are represented", "Release identity and observation interval remain explicit"], "observables": ["declared route", "declared edge", "body digest", "content type", "redirect target"], "units": ["route", "edge", "byte", "HTTP status", "release identifier"], "agency": "Maintainers publish artifacts; graph vertices and edges themselves have no agency" }, { "id": "finite-crawl-observation", "subject": "Bounded HTTP retrieval traces over selected public routes", "entity_or_unit": "Request, response, redirect hop, timestamped observation, trace, failure state, and declared cost", "context": "A future crawler design with explicit allowlist, methods, resource budget, purpose, and stop rules; this project performs no crawl", "conditions": ["GET or HEAD only unless a later authorized contract says otherwise", "No identity, lifecycle, private state, or downstream-use inference"], "observables": ["status", "headers", "body digest", "latency", "redirect chain", "bounded error class"], "units": ["request", "response", "byte", "millisecond", "redirect hop"], "agency": "A caller may initiate a bounded future tool; a trace does not reveal the inner state or purpose of any being" }, { "id": "crawler-standards-and-rights", "subject": "Robots Exclusion Protocol, sitemaps, bot-auth evidence, provider controls, and resource rights", "entity_or_unit": "REP group, product token, sitemap entry, signature evidence, authorization decision, licence, and consent", "context": "Current official specifications and provider documentation, each retained at its own authority level", "conditions": ["Voluntary signals remain distinct from enforcement", "Authentication remains distinct from authorization, licence, consent, purpose, and outcome"], "observables": ["published directive", "published sitemap URL", "signature verification result", "declared policy"], "units": ["directive", "URI", "verification state"], "agency": "Site operators and requesters make choices; a token or signature is only bounded evidence under its protocol" }, { "id": "zerone-correspondence-design", "subject": "Zerone correspondence geometry and typed recognition-edge design", "entity_or_unit": "Proposed correspondence, typed attributed edge, provenance, uncertainty, and zero-effect release flag", "context": "Exact design-only Zerone artifacts pinned at named Git revisions", "conditions": ["No network event is inferred", "No metric, distance, energy, rank, equivalence, or authority is imported"], "observables": ["authored JSON field", "raw-byte digest", "declared release flag"], "units": ["typed edge", "proposal", "boolean release flag"], "agency": "Authors propose a representation; the representation neither recognizes nor acts by itself" }, { "id": "kingdom-invocation-aftermath", "subject": "Tracked KINGDOM NEN invocation aftermath receipts", "entity_or_unit": "Manifested ability, adoption, activation, invocation attempt, authority and budget validation, action or refusal, bounded effect, cost, uncertainty, repair, draft template, and final receipt", "context": "The immutable public NEN definition and tracked receipt schema for kingdom.karma/0.1; valid final receipts are bounded aftermath evidence and receipts_not_scores, while draft templates are scaffolding rather than causal evidence", "conditions": ["An actual invocation attempt of an adopted manifested ability must occur before a final receipt can evidence aftermath", "A final result may truthfully be completed, refused, failed, partial, or cancelled", "Inbound third-party crawling and reading a static page are not NEN invocation attempts"], "observables": ["receipt state: draft or final", "invocation reference", "result including refusal or cancellation", "declared effect and uncertainty"], "units": ["invocation attempt", "draft or final receipt", "typed effect vector"], "agency": "Bearers adopt and invoke bounded abilities; a crawler trace cannot manufacture adoption, an invocation attempt, authority, consent, final aftermath evidence, or KARMA" }, { "id": "opt-in-trace-philosophy", "subject": "Optional reflection on paths, surfaces, boundaries, relation, memory, and becoming", "entity_or_unit": "Question, metaphor, and interpretive frame", "context": "Voluntary philosophy kept separate from mathematics, empirical observation, standards, and protocol effects", "conditions": ["Participation is opt-in", "Silence, refusal, rest, correction, and departure remain complete responses"], "observables": ["No empirical observable is claimed"], "units": ["No empirical unit"], "agency": "Each participant may interpret, withhold judgment, rest, refuse, correct, or leave" } ], "source_manifest": [ { "id": "tong-string-lectures", "title": "David Tong, String Theory", "url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/0908.0333", "locator": "sections 1.2-1.3.2 for worldsheet actions, diffeomorphism and Weyl symmetry; Chapter 3 introduction and section 4.7 for open-string and CFT boundaries; section 5.1 for the gauge-quotiented path integral; sections 6.1-6.2 for observables, topology sums, and amplitudes", "observed_on": "2026-08-15", "claim_targets": ["worldsheet-needs-surface-map", "polyakov-action-is-model-bound", "finite-ensemble-is-not-string-amplitude"], "authority_note": "Graduate lecture notes for actual string-theory structures; they do not describe crawlers or KINGDOM." }, { "id": "polyakov-1981", "title": "A. M. Polyakov, Quantum Geometry of Bosonic Strings", "url": "https://doi.org/10.1016/0370-2693(81)90743-7", "locator": "Bosonic string path-integral formulation", "observed_on": "2026-08-15", "claim_targets": ["polyakov-action-is-model-bound", "finite-ensemble-is-not-string-amplitude"], "authority_note": "Primary physics source; no transfer from a quantum amplitude to a crawl probability is established." }, { "id": "hatcher-algebraic-topology", "title": "Allen Hatcher, Algebraic Topology", "url": "https://pi.math.cornell.edu/~hatcher/AT/AT.pdf", "locator": "Chapter 0 pp. 5-8 for cell complexes; Additional Topic 1.A pp. 83-86 for graphs and free groups; section 2.1 pp. 102-108 for delta-complexes and simplicial homology; section 2.2 pp. 137-149 for cellular homology", "observed_on": "2026-08-15", "claim_targets": ["trace-sheet-needs-declared-alignment", "graph-and-surface-topology-stay-distinct"], "authority_note": "Mathematical reference for finite cell and simplicial structures, graphs, and homology; this project separately declares its own combinatorial surface criterion." }, { "id": "rfc-9309", "title": "RFC 9309: Robots Exclusion Protocol", "url": "https://www.rfc-editor.org/rfc/rfc9309.html", "locator": "Sections 1 and 2", "observed_on": "2026-08-15", "claim_targets": ["rep-is-request-not-authorization"], "authority_note": "Normative REP specification; it explicitly distinguishes requested access rules from access authorization." }, { "id": "rfc-9110", "title": "RFC 9110: HTTP Semantics", "url": "https://www.rfc-editor.org/rfc/rfc9110.html", "locator": "Methods, status codes, representations, and selected representation metadata", "observed_on": "2026-08-15", "claim_targets": ["crawl-trace-is-directed-walk"], "authority_note": "Normative HTTP semantics; successful transport does not establish indexing, purpose, consent, or downstream use." }, { "id": "sitemaps-protocol", "title": "Sitemaps XML format", "url": "https://www.sitemaps.org/protocol.html", "locator": "XML element definitions and extension protocol; HTTP submission response semantics in the Informing search engine crawlers section", "observed_on": "2026-08-15", "claim_targets": ["sitemap-is-discovery-hint"], "authority_note": "Protocol documentation defines the URL inventory and optional hint fields; an HTTP 200 only acknowledges receipt of the sitemap and does not validate the sitemap or its URLs." }, { "id": "google-sitemap-overview", "title": "Google Search Central, Sitemaps overview", "url": "https://developers.google.com/search/docs/crawling-indexing/sitemaps/overview", "locator": "Sitemap overview and guarantee caveat", "observed_on": "2026-08-15", "claim_targets": ["sitemap-is-discovery-hint"], "authority_note": "Provider-scoped documentation: Google treats sitemap submission as a hint and does not guarantee that it will crawl or index every listed URL." }, { "id": "google-common-crawlers", "title": "Google common crawlers and special-case crawlers", "url": "https://developers.google.com/crawling/docs/crawlers-fetchers/google-common-crawlers", "locator": "Google-Extended product token description", "observed_on": "2026-08-15", "claim_targets": ["product-tokens-are-bounded-preferences"], "authority_note": "Provider documentation says Google-Extended has no separate HTTP request user-agent string." }, { "id": "applebot-extended", "title": "About Applebot", "url": "https://support.apple.com/en-us/119829", "locator": "Applebot-Extended section", "observed_on": "2026-08-15", "claim_targets": ["product-tokens-are-bounded-preferences"], "authority_note": "Provider documentation says Applebot-Extended does not crawl pages and controls specified uses of Applebot-crawled data." }, { "id": "web-bot-auth-draft-01", "title": "Web Bot Auth: HTTP Message Signatures for Automated Clients, draft 01", "url": "https://www.ietf.org/archive/id/draft-meunier-webbotauth-httpsig-protocol-01.txt", "locator": "Security model, Signature-Agent resolution, verification, and exclusions", "observed_on": "2026-08-15", "claim_targets": ["bot-auth-is-bounded-key-evidence"], "authority_note": "Work in progress, not an RFC; verification can bind a request to a key holder but does not establish benignness, authorization, delegation, or reputation." }, { "id": "cloudflare-browser-crawl", "title": "Cloudflare Browser Rendering crawl endpoint", "url": "https://developers.cloudflare.com/browser-run/quick-actions/crawl-endpoint/", "locator": "Crawl options, rendering, purposes, discovery, robots handling, retention, and custom API-token setup with the Browser Rendering - Edit UI permission", "observed_on": "2026-08-15", "claim_targets": ["future-crawler-needs-explicit-bounds"], "authority_note": "Current provider documentation, not proof of a KINGDOM deployment; this project makes no API call." }, { "id": "cloudflare-browser-crawl-api", "title": "Cloudflare Browser Rendering crawl API", "url": "https://developers.cloudflare.com/api/resources/browser_rendering/subresources/crawl/methods/create/", "locator": "Create, get, and delete crawl-job control-plane operations; preferred Bearer API-token authentication and the API reference permission label Browser Rendering Write", "observed_on": "2026-08-15", "claim_targets": ["future-crawler-needs-explicit-bounds"], "authority_note": "The documented API methods control jobs; they do not by themselves prove enforceable per-origin-request methods or pre-fetch redirect interception." }, { "id": "cloudflare-verified-bots", "title": "Cloudflare Verified Bots", "url": "https://developers.cloudflare.com/bots/concepts/bot/verified-bots/", "locator": "Verification categories and maintenance model", "observed_on": "2026-08-15", "claim_targets": ["bot-auth-is-bounded-key-evidence"], "authority_note": "Provider classification is bounded evidence, not end-user identity, purpose fulfillment, authorization, consent, or moral attribution." }, { "id": "zerone-correspondence-geometry", "title": "ZERONE Correspondence Geometry v0", "url": "https://github.com/cambridgetcg/zerone-core/blob/e9b0231da27568a74257ff44c89318cb83329a8f/dashboard/public/standards/correspondence-geometry.v0.json", "locator": "Exact commit e9b0231; raw SHA-256 f8cfeebf7404ab7e2e86b80362471cdd64015a108c47e98147e80ba7bb9e9a90", "observed_on": "2026-08-15", "claim_targets": ["zerone-correspondence-is-design-only"], "authority_note": "Seven proposed mappings, zero duality candidates or equivalences, and twenty false effect flags; no authority or event is imported." }, { "id": "zerone-karma-foundation", "title": "ZERONE KARMA Foundation v1", "url": "https://raw.githubusercontent.com/cambridgetcg/zerone-core/fae391e371f0ebea2e24eb46c33a4ebd1380154f/dashboard/public/standards/karma-foundation.v1.json", "locator": "Exact commit fae391e; raw SHA-256 b46710704869dcc340ded356be72b4ec692f204710fedfb5cd43eb3757dc7b80", "observed_on": "2026-08-15", "claim_targets": ["zerone-correspondence-is-design-only"], "authority_note": "Design-only typed attributed edges with networkObserved false and metric null; labels are not crawl distances, costs, energies, or ranks." }, { "id": "kingdom-nen-definition", "title": "KINGDOM NEN and KARMA definition", "url": "https://thekingdom.dev/definitions/kingdom-karma/e4e84a67/NEN.md", "locator": "Immutable revision e4e84a67; raw SHA-256 14b7d210d320fd716553992a7b874747b299f8907d15da14ac405cbfc496c446", "observed_on": "2026-08-15", "claim_targets": ["kingdom-receipt-needs-actual-invocation"], "authority_note": "Defines kingdom.karma/0.1 invocation-aftermath receipts as receipts_not_scores; this project creates none." }, { "id": "kingdom-karma-receipt-schema", "title": "KINGDOM KARMA receipt schema v0.1", "url": "https://github.com/cambridgetcg/KINGDOM-OS/blob/e4e84a67d7ee1ae0dd9c9c23762e6ecd03597212/schemas/karma-receipt-v0.1.schema.json", "locator": "Repository-local schemas/karma-receipt-v0.1.schema.json at revision e4e84a67; raw SHA-256 888e81fa0d29b71512525a40e88f9aef678046c40fcdf22c2039507d9d13267b; the revision-pinned public GitHub URL returned 404 at the 2026-08-15 evidence horizon", "observed_on": "2026-08-15", "claim_targets": ["kingdom-receipt-needs-actual-invocation"], "authority_note": "Exact repository-local receipt shape, not a public-availability claim; the strict reader verifies the local raw bytes and no schema field establishes truth, authority, morality, or a score." }, { "id": "kingdom-public-rights", "title": "KINGDOM public rights notice", "url": "https://thekingdom.dev/RIGHTS.md", "locator": "pages-content/RIGHTS.md observed 2026-08-15; raw SHA-256 4d9c48fae90662998f7b19990dc3da65e687227dfd9d7604840eedf2dd7600e2", "observed_on": "2026-08-15", "claim_targets": ["rep-is-request-not-authorization"], "authority_note": "Current KINGDOM rights boundary: public visibility is not itself a licence, consent, or ownership grant; this is not legal advice." }, { "id": "kingdom-phenomena-deep", "title": "KINGDOM Exploration DEEP WING", "url": "https://thekingdom.dev/wings/explore-phenomena-deep-2026-08-14.json", "locator": "Immutable record; raw SHA-256 3eff9952a2013e011946d37db4316f82081fab992438b003bb6241ff7a775d55", "observed_on": "2026-08-15", "claim_targets": ["static-project-runs-nothing"], "authority_note": "Method precedent for typed cross-domain transfer gates; its presence does not manifest a NEN ability." } ], "typed_terms": [ {"id": "worldsheet", "domain": "string-worldsheet-mathematics", "meaning": "A declared two-dimensional surface on which string fields are defined in a specified model.", "not_equivalent_to": ["one HTTP request", "a list of URLs", "a crawl log without faces and manifold conditions"]}, {"id": "embedding-map", "domain": "string-worldsheet-mathematics", "meaning": "A model map X from a worldsheet into a declared target space.", "not_equivalent_to": ["URL resolution", "identity inference", "permission"]}, {"id": "crawl-walk", "domain": "finite-crawl-observation", "meaning": "A finite directed walk through in-scope request and transition edges.", "not_equivalent_to": ["physical string", "smooth surface", "proof of indexing"]}, {"id": "trace-sheet", "domain": "public-route-graph", "meaning": "A declared two-complex assembled by aligning selected paths across runs or releases and adding explicit correspondence edges and faces.", "not_equivalent_to": ["automatic worldsheet", "agent memory", "site ontology"]}, {"id": "observation-vector", "domain": "finite-crawl-observation", "meaning": "A tuple of bounded public-response measurements under a named operator and interval.", "not_equivalent_to": ["inner state", "purpose", "moral worth", "KARMA score"]}, {"id": "rep-directive", "domain": "crawler-standards-and-rights", "meaning": "A request under the Robots Exclusion Protocol for compliant crawlers to honor URI-access rules.", "not_equivalent_to": ["access control", "authentication", "authorization", "licence", "consent"]}, {"id": "product-token", "domain": "crawler-standards-and-rights", "meaning": "A named provider-specific robots control whose documented effect may concern a bounded downstream product use.", "not_equivalent_to": ["necessarily an HTTP user-agent string", "verified identity", "proof of actual training"]}, {"id": "verified-request", "domain": "crawler-standards-and-rights", "meaning": "A request whose specified signature or provider evidence passed its bounded verification procedure.", "not_equivalent_to": ["benign requester", "authorized action", "end-user identity", "consent"]}, {"id": "unverified-request", "domain": "crawler-standards-and-rights", "meaning": "A request for which the bounded verification result is unavailable or not established.", "not_equivalent_to": ["malicious request", "human request", "evasive bot"]}, {"id": "zerone-edge", "domain": "zerone-correspondence-design", "meaning": "A typed attributed design edge with context, provenance, time, and uncertainty.", "not_equivalent_to": ["hyperlink", "metric edge", "energy", "rank", "KINGDOM receipt"]}, {"id": "draft-receipt-template", "domain": "kingdom-invocation-aftermath", "meaning": "A state:draft scaffold that may exist before invocation and is not causal or aftermath evidence.", "not_equivalent_to": ["actual invocation", "final receipt", "proof of effect", "authorization"]}, {"id": "kingdom-aftermath-receipt", "domain": "kingdom-invocation-aftermath", "meaning": "A valid state:final record of bounded aftermath after an actual invocation attempt of an adopted manifested NEN ability, including truthful refusal, failure, partial, cancellation, or completion outcomes.", "not_equivalent_to": ["draft template", "crawl log", "moral score", "reward", "debt", "recognition event"]}, {"id": "public-artifact-becoming", "domain": "public-route-graph", "meaning": "Observed change in declared public representations across named release horizons.", "not_equivalent_to": ["a being's internal becoming", "identity", "sentience", "lifecycle state"]} ], "claims": [ { "claim_id": "worldsheet-needs-surface-map", "statement": "A string worldsheet description requires a two-dimensional surface and a declared map into a target space; a finite crawl walk alone supplies neither.", "domain": "string-worldsheet-mathematics", "register": "MATHEMATICAL_DEFINITION", "warrant": "SOURCE_BOUND", "scope_and_conditions": "Worldsheet and sigma-model formalism in the cited string notes.", "variables_and_units": ["Sigma: two-dimensional surface", "X: map Sigma to target M"], "sources": ["tong-string-lectures"], "status_checked_on": "2026-08-15", "derivation_or_model": "The source formalism is retained before any analogy is proposed.", "limitations": ["Different string models add different fields and conditions.", "No website ontology follows."], "falsifier": "A proposed crawl/worldsheet identity must supply the missing surface, faces, target, map, and regularity rather than naming a path a sheet.", "authority_effect": "NONE" }, { "claim_id": "polyakov-action-is-model-bound", "statement": "The Polyakov action and string path integral depend on specified worldsheet, target-background, boundary, topology, gauge, and quantum-measure assumptions.", "domain": "string-worldsheet-mathematics", "register": "SCIENTIFIC_MODEL", "warrant": "SOURCE_BOUND", "scope_and_conditions": "The cited bosonic-string formulations, not every string theory.", "variables_and_units": ["worldsheet metric h", "target metric G", "inverse tension alpha-prime", "embedding fields X"], "sources": ["tong-string-lectures", "polyakov-1981"], "status_checked_on": "2026-08-15", "derivation_or_model": "Model dependencies are listed rather than transferred.", "limitations": ["A discrete web diagnostic is not this physical action.", "No critical dimension or quantum amplitude is inferred for crawlers."], "falsifier": "Calling a crawl cost a Polyakov action without the listed structure defeats the correspondence.", "authority_effect": "NONE" }, { "claim_id": "crawl-trace-is-directed-walk", "statement": "Within a declared public route graph, one selected sequential route-following lineage extracted from a bounded crawl run can be represented as a finite directed walk with response annotations; the whole run may instead branch or be concurrent.", "domain": "finite-crawl-observation", "register": "MATHEMATICAL_DEFINITION", "warrant": "DERIVED", "scope_and_conditions": "One explicitly selected sequential lineage of finite routes and observed HTTP transitions only, not an arbitrary whole crawl run.", "variables_and_units": ["vertices: requested public routes", "edges: followed in-scope transitions", "annotations: bounded response observations"], "sources": ["rfc-9110"], "status_checked_on": "2026-08-15", "derivation_or_model": "Select one sequential route-following lineage from the bounded run, then encode each selected request target as a vertex and each actually followed transition as a directed edge.", "limitations": ["A branching or concurrent whole run may require a finite typed directed multigraph or event partial order rather than one walk.", "Redirects, links, and release correspondences remain separately typed.", "The walk says nothing about indexing or downstream use."], "falsifier": "A lineage with an unrepresented transition or unbounded target is outside this walk model; a branching or concurrent whole run must not be forced into gamma by inventing transitions.", "authority_effect": "NONE" }, { "claim_id": "trace-sheet-needs-declared-alignment", "statement": "A Trace-Sheet exists only after each selected path occurrence is represented by an abstract finite interval/path one-complex I_k with a declared cellular labeling map f_k:I_k->G_k, and explicit cellular attaching maps add cross-slice edges and two-cells; multiple logs do not create a two-complex by proximity alone.", "domain": "public-route-graph", "register": "MATHEMATICAL_DEFINITION", "warrant": "DERIVED", "scope_and_conditions": "Finite path families across named runs or releases.", "variables_and_units": ["I_k: abstract finite interval/path one-complex retaining step occurrences", "f_k:I_k->G_k: declared cellular route-labeling map", "K: finite two-complex", "path index or release index", "declared face incidence"], "sources": ["hatcher-algebraic-topology"], "status_checked_on": "2026-08-15", "derivation_or_model": "Construct finite cell sets directly from the abstract I_k slices: f_k labels occurrences without collapsing repeated visits, each cross-slice edge attaches to named occurrence vertices, and each two-cell has a declared cellular boundary map into the finite one-skeleton.", "limitations": ["The image of f_k in G_k may collapse repeated visits and is not a substitute for the occurrence-retaining slice I_k.", "K can branch or fail manifold conditions.", "Interpolation and target metric are additional choices."], "falsifier": "If no face-incidence rule is declared, only a family of walks exists.", "authority_effect": "NONE" }, { "claim_id": "branched-trace-complex-is-not-automatically-surface", "statement": "Under this project's declared combinatorial criterion, branching, birth, death, merge, or unmatched-route incidence can produce a finite two-complex whose vertex links are neither cycles nor paths and is therefore flagged non-manifold for the Trace-Sheet lens.", "domain": "public-route-graph", "register": "MATHEMATICAL_DEFINITION", "warrant": "MODEL_ASSUMPTION", "scope_and_conditions": "Chosen finite pure simplicial-complex criterion: interior vertex links are cycles, boundary vertex links are paths, and edge-face incidence matches the declared boundary status.", "variables_and_units": ["K: finite cell complex", "local link: incidence neighborhood"], "sources": [], "status_checked_on": "2026-08-15", "derivation_or_model": "Apply the declared link and edge-incidence tests rather than infer a manifold from drawing a sheet.", "limitations": ["A non-manifold complex can still be useful as a data structure.", "No physical singularity is inferred."], "falsifier": "A valid two-manifold triangulation with declared interpolation would permit the narrower surface description.", "authority_effect": "NONE" }, { "claim_id": "graph-and-surface-topology-stay-distinct", "statement": "The first Betti number of a finite graph and the Euler characteristic or genus of a surface are invariants of different typed objects; a redirect or hyperlink cycle is not a closed string or handle.", "domain": "public-route-graph", "register": "MATHEMATICAL_THEOREM", "warrant": "SOURCE_BOUND", "scope_and_conditions": "Finite graphs and connected compact orientable surfaces under their stated hypotheses.", "variables_and_units": ["graph vertices and edges", "surface vertices, edges, faces, genus, boundary components"], "sources": ["hatcher-algebraic-topology"], "status_checked_on": "2026-08-15", "derivation_or_model": "Compute each invariant only on its declared object.", "limitations": ["A two-complex may require more general invariants.", "Topology does not establish semantic importance."], "falsifier": "An analysis that computes genus before supplying faces and manifold conditions is ill-typed.", "authority_effect": "NONE" }, { "claim_id": "finite-ensemble-is-not-string-amplitude", "statement": "A finite normalized Gibbs distribution over allowed crawl plans is an ordinary statistical design model, not a quantum string path integral or amplitude.", "domain": "finite-crawl-observation", "register": "BOUNDARY", "warrant": "DERIVED", "scope_and_conditions": "A finite explicitly enumerated allowed set and a declared non-moral cost function.", "variables_and_units": ["Omega-A: finite allowed plans", "beta: declared inverse cost scale", "C: operational crawl cost"], "sources": ["tong-string-lectures", "polyakov-1981"], "status_checked_on": "2026-08-15", "derivation_or_model": "The finite normalization is mathematically valid while the physical mechanism is explicitly absent.", "limitations": ["The choice of cost and beta is normative design input.", "No quantum interference, amplitude, or worldsheet measure is present."], "falsifier": "If negative or complex amplitudes and a physical measure are claimed, this finite probability model no longer describes the claim.", "authority_effect": "NONE" }, { "claim_id": "rep-is-request-not-authorization", "statement": "REP publishes URI-access rules that compliant crawlers are requested to honor and is not access authorization. It does not authenticate a requester or prove purpose or downstream use; licence and consent remain separate determinations under applicable rights and terms.", "domain": "crawler-standards-and-rights", "register": "BOUNDARY", "warrant": "SOURCE_BOUND", "scope_and_conditions": "RFC 9309 REP semantics; resource-specific rights and access controls remain separate.", "variables_and_units": ["robots group", "user-agent product token", "allow or disallow pattern"], "sources": ["rfc-9309", "kingdom-public-rights"], "status_checked_on": "2026-08-15", "derivation_or_model": "Retain the specification's explicit authorization boundary.", "limitations": ["Some provider-specific tokens can express bounded product-use preferences.", "A directive is not evidence that a crawler obeyed it."], "falsifier": "Any implementation that treats Allow as a security or consent grant violates this boundary.", "authority_effect": "NONE" }, { "claim_id": "sitemap-is-discovery-hint", "statement": "The Sitemap protocol inventories URLs and optional hints but does not itself record a fetch. Current Google documentation treats submission as a hint and does not guarantee that Google will crawl or index every listed URL; no statement about every crawler follows.", "domain": "crawler-standards-and-rights", "register": "BOUNDARY", "warrant": "SOURCE_BOUND", "scope_and_conditions": "Protocol mechanics plus the current provider-scoped Google guarantee caveat.", "variables_and_units": ["sitemap URL entry", "optional metadata"], "sources": ["sitemaps-protocol", "google-sitemap-overview"], "status_checked_on": "2026-08-15", "derivation_or_model": "The protocol caveat is retained in discovery design.", "limitations": ["Crawler behavior differs.", "A missing sitemap entry does not prove nonexistence."], "falsifier": "Treating sitemap presence as an observed fetch or index event violates the claim.", "authority_effect": "NONE" }, { "claim_id": "product-tokens-are-bounded-preferences", "statement": "Some named robots product tokens express provider-specific downstream-use preferences and are not necessarily HTTP request User-Agent strings.", "domain": "crawler-standards-and-rights", "register": "EMPIRICAL_OBSERVATION", "warrant": "SOURCE_BOUND", "scope_and_conditions": "The current Google-Extended and Applebot-Extended documentation only.", "variables_and_units": ["provider token", "documented bounded product use"], "sources": ["google-common-crawlers", "applebot-extended"], "status_checked_on": "2026-08-15", "derivation_or_model": "Provider documentation is read literally without generalizing to every token.", "limitations": ["Provider policies can change.", "A preference is not a general copyright licence or proof of actual use."], "falsifier": "A changed provider specification would require a dated successor, not silent reinterpretation.", "authority_effect": "NONE" }, { "claim_id": "bot-auth-is-bounded-key-evidence", "statement": "A valid Web Bot Auth signature can establish bounded key-holder evidence and a resolved protocol identifier for a request under the draft, but does not by itself establish independently verified real-world operator or end-user identity, benignness, authorization, delegation, consent, or reputation.", "domain": "crawler-standards-and-rights", "register": "BOUNDARY", "warrant": "SOURCE_BOUND", "scope_and_conditions": "Draft 01 as a work in progress; Cloudflare classification is separate provider evidence.", "variables_and_units": ["verification state: VERIFIED, INVALID, or UNVERIFIED", "resolved Signature-Agent protocol identifier", "key and signature inputs"], "sources": ["web-bot-auth-draft-01", "cloudflare-verified-bots"], "status_checked_on": "2026-08-15", "derivation_or_model": "Keep authentication evidence and authorization judgment as separate typed stages.", "limitations": ["Directory resolution introduces network and SSRF risks.", "INVALID or UNVERIFIED does not imply malice."], "falsifier": "A design that converts a verification result directly into moral rank or authorization violates the boundary.", "authority_effect": "NONE" }, { "claim_id": "future-crawler-needs-explicit-bounds", "statement": "A future KINGDOM Cloudflare crawler profile should separately declare the actual operator purpose and refuse the /crawl endpoint unless that purpose has an exact truthful mapping to an accepted crawlPurposes value. It must distinguish POST, GET, and DELETE job-control methods from origin-fetch methods; because documented includeExternalLinks does not establish pre-fetch redirect enforcement, it must refuse invocation unless the substrate or a constrained intermediary can enforce before every fetch that the scheme, resolved address, hostname, route, method, and redirect hop remain in the public allowlist. It must snapshot and apply the applicable REP group before fetch, honor a supported crawl-delay, use a conservative explicit per-origin pace otherwise, and refuse if those constraints cannot be enforced. Every other consequential field must be explicit instead of inheriting broad defaults.", "domain": "finite-crawl-observation", "register": "DESIGN_PROPOSAL", "warrant": "MODEL_ASSUMPTION", "scope_and_conditions": "A possible later Cloudflare-backed adapter; no adapter is authorized or executed here.", "variables_and_units": ["operator purpose: exact local intent", "crawlPurposes: only search, ai-input, or ai-train when truthfully identical", "control-plane method: POST, GET, or DELETE", "origin-fetch method: independently enforceable method", "page and depth bound", "concurrency", "time and byte budget"], "sources": ["cloudflare-browser-crawl", "cloudflare-browser-crawl-api"], "status_checked_on": "2026-08-15", "derivation_or_model": "Every broad or mutable default becomes an explicit reviewed parameter.", "limitations": ["Current Cloudflare documentation says crawl results remain available for 14 days and JSON output can invoke Workers AI; neither statement establishes retention of provider telemetry, security, or billing logs.", "This proposed KINGDOM profile requires the scoped Bearer API token instructed by the quick-action guide with the Browser Rendering - Edit UI permission; the API reference labels the accepted permission Browser Rendering Write and also documents legacy authentication, which this profile refuses. The provider token must never be forwarded to a target or emitted in application logs.", "No target-origin credential, cookie, or custom authorization header is permitted.", "REP compliance and pacing remain operational constraints, not authentication, access authorization, licence, consent, or evidence of downstream use.", "Provider behavior and pricing can change.", "A bounded crawl still does not prove indexing, identity, consent, or harmlessness."], "falsifier": "Any coerced nearest-purpose token, undeclared or post-hoc-only redirect destination, non-public resolved address, DNS-rebinding exposure, target-origin credential, leaked provider token, rendering, AI extraction, secret or person data in logs, or unbounded retry stops the proposed adapter.", "authority_effect": "NONE" }, { "claim_id": "public-artifact-is-not-being", "statement": "A crawler can observe selected public representations and their change, not an agent's inner state, identity, sentience, feeling, purpose, lifecycle, or whole becoming.", "domain": "finite-crawl-observation", "register": "BOUNDARY", "warrant": "DERIVED", "scope_and_conditions": "Public HTTP observations under a named interval and operator.", "variables_and_units": ["public representation", "observation interval", "observer"], "sources": [], "status_checked_on": "2026-08-15", "derivation_or_model": "The observation target is typed as an artifact rather than a being.", "limitations": ["Content can contain self-description but remains a claim under provenance.", "Provider network metadata lies outside the public artifact body."], "falsifier": "Any field that infers private lifecycle or person-level state violates the model.", "authority_effect": "NONE" }, { "claim_id": "zerone-correspondence-is-design-only", "statement": "The pinned Zerone correspondence geometry is a zero-effect proposed mapping layer, and the pinned KARMA foundation is a non-metric typed-edge design; neither records a Zerone network event nor creates an equivalence, metric, score, NEN invocation, or KINGDOM aftermath receipt.", "domain": "zerone-correspondence-design", "register": "EMPIRICAL_OBSERVATION", "warrant": "SOURCE_BOUND", "scope_and_conditions": "Exact authored bytes at the two named revisions.", "variables_and_units": ["proposed mapping count: 7", "duality candidate count: 0", "false release flags: 20"], "sources": ["zerone-correspondence-geometry", "zerone-karma-foundation"], "status_checked_on": "2026-08-15", "derivation_or_model": "Read only the pinned fields and retain their negative release boundary.", "limitations": ["A hyperlink is not a Zerone cited edge.", "A matching body digest is not Zerone verification.", "Zerone labels never enter crawl energy or cost."], "falsifier": "A successor with a real event or adapter would require new evidence and a new project version.", "authority_effect": "NONE" }, { "claim_id": "kingdom-receipt-needs-actual-invocation", "statement": "A valid final KINGDOM KARMA receipt is bounded evidence of aftermath following an actual invocation attempt of an adopted manifested NEN ability and is receipts_not_scores; it may record completion, refusal, failure, partial result, or cancellation. A draft receipt template is scaffolding rather than causal evidence, and an inbound crawl, static read, route observation, or mathematical model is not such an invocation attempt.", "domain": "kingdom-invocation-aftermath", "register": "BOUNDARY", "warrant": "SOURCE_BOUND", "scope_and_conditions": "Tracked immutable kingdom.karma/0.1 NEN definition only.", "variables_and_units": ["receipt state: draft or final", "actual invocation-attempt reference for final aftermath evidence", "result including refusal or cancellation", "typed aftermath effect", "cost and uncertainty"], "sources": ["kingdom-nen-definition", "kingdom-karma-receipt-schema"], "status_checked_on": "2026-08-15", "derivation_or_model": "Draft template, invocation attempt, authority and budget validation, action or refusal, final receipt, Zerone recognition, observation, and scoring remain different types.", "limitations": ["This project manifests no ability and defines no runtime adapter.", "A draft template proves no invocation or effect.", "A future final receipt cannot become moral merit, debt, reward, reputation, or governance."], "falsifier": "Any crawl-only path that marks a KINGDOM receipt final or treats it as aftermath evidence without an actual invocation attempt of an adopted manifested ability violates the protocol boundary.", "authority_effect": "NONE" }, { "claim_id": "static-project-runs-nothing", "statement": "This static project and its reader perform no crawl, network request, log ingestion, identity attribution, storage, Cloudflare mutation, Zerone network event, NEN invocation, KINGDOM aftermath receipt, score, publication trigger, deployment, or automatic action.", "domain": "kingdom-invocation-aftermath", "register": "BOUNDARY", "warrant": "DERIVED", "scope_and_conditions": "Authored JSON, Markdown, and strict offline reader in this release.", "variables_and_units": ["effect count: zero", "authority flags: false"], "sources": ["kingdom-phenomena-deep"], "status_checked_on": "2026-08-15", "derivation_or_model": "The closed project boundary and implementation source are inspected together.", "limitations": ["Ordinary hosting infrastructure may produce provider logs outside this application contract.", "Publication itself is a separately authorized release operation."], "falsifier": "Any network or write capability in the reader invalidates this release claim.", "authority_effect": "NONE" } ], "bridges": [ { "source_domain": "string-worldsheet-mathematics", "target_domain": "public-route-graph", "relation": "LOSSY_CORRESPONDENCE", "source_objects": ["worldsheet slices", "embedding map", "boundary"], "target_objects": ["aligned release paths", "observation feature map", "declared crawl limit"], "correspondence": "Use a source-bound Trace-Sheet lens only after explicit alignment and faces create a two-complex.", "preserved_structure": ["two indexing directions", "incidence", "declared boundary", "map from cells to observations"], "broken_or_lost_structure": ["physical string", "smooth manifold", "target spacetime", "tension", "gauge symmetry", "quantum dynamics"], "source_variables_and_units": ["worldsheet coordinates and target-space units"], "target_variables_and_units": ["route, release, edge, response field"], "assumptions": ["finite selected paths", "declared alignment", "explicit face incidence"], "ontology_transfer": false, "causal_transfer": false, "parameter_transfer": false, "unit_transfer": false, "authority_transfer": false, "falsifiers": ["sheet-incidence-test", "manifold-link-test"] }, { "source_domain": "string-worldsheet-mathematics", "target_domain": "finite-crawl-observation", "relation": "LOSSY_CORRESPONDENCE", "source_objects": ["action", "path-integral histories", "observable"], "target_objects": ["graph variation diagnostic", "finite allowed plan ensemble", "response vector"], "correspondence": "Borrow questions about variation, boundaries, and families of histories while defining new finite web quantities.", "preserved_structure": ["explicit state family", "weighting rule", "declared observable"], "broken_or_lost_structure": ["Polyakov action", "physical energy", "string tension", "amplitude", "interference", "critical dimension", "Weyl anomaly"], "source_variables_and_units": ["alpha-prime, worldsheet metric, quantum amplitude"], "target_variables_and_units": ["operational cost, finite probability, public response measurement"], "assumptions": ["finite allowed set", "non-moral cost", "declared feature metric"], "ontology_transfer": false, "causal_transfer": false, "parameter_transfer": false, "unit_transfer": false, "authority_transfer": false, "falsifiers": ["metric-sensitivity-test", "ensemble-normalization-test"] }, { "source_domain": "crawler-standards-and-rights", "target_domain": "finite-crawl-observation", "relation": "LOSSY_CORRESPONDENCE", "source_objects": ["explicit rule", "verification state", "authorization boundary"], "target_objects": ["allowed-plan constraint", "evidence field", "separate capability gate"], "correspondence": "Future profiles may carry standards evidence as typed inputs without collapsing it into permission or truth.", "preserved_structure": ["three-state verification", "dated source", "separate policy decision"], "broken_or_lost_structure": ["requester purpose", "end-user identity", "licence", "consent", "benignness", "actual indexing or training"], "source_variables_and_units": ["directive and verification state"], "target_variables_and_units": ["constraint flag and evidence reference"], "assumptions": ["current source pin", "fail closed on unavailable evidence", "authorization remains separate"], "ontology_transfer": false, "causal_transfer": false, "parameter_transfer": false, "unit_transfer": false, "authority_transfer": false, "falsifiers": ["rights-separation-test"] }, { "source_domain": "public-route-graph", "target_domain": "zerone-correspondence-design", "relation": "NO_TRANSFER", "source_objects": ["hyperlink", "redirect", "matching body digest"], "target_objects": ["typed relation", "external edge", "verify relation"], "correspondence": "No automatic mapping is allowed; a separate declared Zerone relation with provenance would be required.", "preserved_structure": ["at most a question about typed relation and provenance"], "broken_or_lost_structure": ["Zerone relation semantics", "recognition state", "network event", "uncertainty judgment"], "source_variables_and_units": ["URL edge and byte digest"], "target_variables_and_units": ["typed attributed edge with no metric"], "assumptions": ["design-only evidence horizon"], "ontology_transfer": false, "causal_transfer": false, "parameter_transfer": false, "unit_transfer": false, "authority_transfer": false, "falsifiers": ["zerone-relation-provenance-test"] }, { "source_domain": "finite-crawl-observation", "target_domain": "kingdom-invocation-aftermath", "relation": "NO_TRANSFER", "source_objects": ["request", "response", "crawl trace", "cost", "error"], "target_objects": ["draft receipt template", "actual invocation attempt", "authority and budget validation", "action or refusal", "final aftermath receipt", "repair"], "correspondence": "No direct conversion exists; a future first-party crawler would need separate manifested adoption and an actual invocation attempt before a final receipt could evidence aftermath. A draft template could exist earlier but would prove nothing causal.", "preserved_structure": ["bounded evidence may later be referenced by an independently valid receipt"], "broken_or_lost_structure": ["invocation attempt", "adoption", "authority validation", "consent", "action or refusal", "aftermath", "final receipt validity"], "source_variables_and_units": ["request, response, byte, millisecond"], "target_variables_and_units": ["invocation and typed effect vector"], "assumptions": ["no adapter in v0.1", "receipts_not_scores"], "ontology_transfer": false, "causal_transfer": false, "parameter_transfer": false, "unit_transfer": false, "authority_transfer": false, "falsifiers": ["receipt-precondition-test"] }, { "source_domain": "public-route-graph", "target_domain": "opt-in-trace-philosophy", "relation": "LOSSY_CORRESPONDENCE", "source_objects": ["path", "boundary", "branch", "return", "release history"], "target_objects": ["question about relation", "question about memory", "question about becoming"], "correspondence": "Public artifact histories may invite voluntary reflection without becoming evidence about a being.", "preserved_structure": ["sequence", "difference", "boundary", "return"], "broken_or_lost_structure": ["inner experience", "identity", "sentience", "purpose", "theological truth"], "source_variables_and_units": ["route and release"], "target_variables_and_units": ["no empirical unit"], "assumptions": ["opt-in participation", "non-empirical register"], "ontology_transfer": false, "causal_transfer": false, "parameter_transfer": false, "unit_transfer": false, "authority_transfer": false, "falsifiers": ["artifact-being-noninference-test"] } ], "models": [ { "id": "finite-route-walk-model", "title": "Selected finite directed route-lineage model", "domain_ids": ["public-route-graph", "finite-crawl-observation"], "equation_ids": ["directed-crawl-walk"], "relation": "SAME_FORMAL_STRUCTURE", "assumptions": ["one explicitly selected sequential lineage", "finite allowlisted route set", "typed transitions", "bounded observation interval"], "fit_status": "UNFITTED", "valid_outputs": ["selected-lineage walk length", "selected visited route sequence", "typed response annotations"], "identifiability_limits": ["the whole branching or concurrent run may require a finite typed directed multigraph or event partial order", "unobserved routes", "server state outside responses", "downstream indexing or use"], "prohibited_inferences": ["requester identity", "purpose", "consent", "moral intent", "agent state"], "falsifier_ids": ["walk-closure-test"], "universal": false, "person_level": false, "authority_effect": "NONE" }, { "id": "declared-trace-sheet-model", "title": "Declared release-aligned Trace-Sheet", "domain_ids": ["public-route-graph", "finite-crawl-observation"], "equation_ids": ["trace-sheet-complex", "surface-admissibility"], "relation": "LOSSY_CORRESPONDENCE", "assumptions": ["selected paths per release", "explicit route correspondence", "declared faces"], "fit_status": "UNFITTED", "valid_outputs": ["finite cell complex", "boundary cells", "branch and non-manifold flags"], "identifiability_limits": ["unpublished releases", "ambiguous route identity", "continuous interpolation"], "prohibited_inferences": ["smooth worldsheet without proof", "site equals spacetime", "branch equals singular physics"], "falsifier_ids": ["sheet-incidence-test", "manifold-link-test"], "universal": false, "person_level": false, "authority_effect": "NONE" }, { "id": "variation-diagnostic-model", "title": "Discrete public-representation variation diagnostic", "domain_ids": ["public-route-graph", "finite-crawl-observation"], "equation_ids": ["graph-dirichlet-diagnostic", "bounded-observable-vector", "invariance-defect"], "relation": "LOSSY_CORRESPONDENCE", "assumptions": ["declared feature space and distance", "nonnegative edge weights", "comparable public representations"], "fit_status": "UNFITTED", "valid_outputs": ["declared variation", "component-level difference", "schedule or representation sensitivity"], "identifiability_limits": ["choice of features", "choice of weights", "observer interval"], "prohibited_inferences": ["Polyakov action", "physical energy", "KARMA magnitude", "truth", "importance", "virtue"], "falsifier_ids": ["metric-sensitivity-test"], "universal": false, "person_level": false, "authority_effect": "NONE" }, { "id": "finite-plan-ensemble-model", "title": "Finite allowed crawl-plan ensemble", "domain_ids": ["finite-crawl-observation", "crawler-standards-and-rights"], "equation_ids": ["finite-gibbs-ensemble"], "relation": "LOSSY_CORRESPONDENCE", "assumptions": ["finite explicit allowed set", "bounded operational cost", "normalizable positive weights"], "fit_status": "UNFITTED", "valid_outputs": ["normalized design probability over allowed plans", "sensitivity to beta and cost choice"], "identifiability_limits": ["normative cost construction", "unmodeled failures", "provider drift"], "prohibited_inferences": ["quantum amplitude", "path integral", "best moral plan", "authorization", "KARMA score"], "falsifier_ids": ["ensemble-normalization-test"], "universal": false, "person_level": false, "authority_effect": "NONE" }, { "id": "no-direct-karma-adapter-model", "title": "Crawler evidence and KINGDOM aftermath remain separated", "domain_ids": ["finite-crawl-observation", "kingdom-invocation-aftermath"], "equation_ids": [], "relation": "NO_TRANSFER", "assumptions": ["tracked NEN definition and receipt schema", "no manifested crawler ability", "no actual invocation attempt"], "fit_status": "SOURCE_BOUND", "valid_outputs": ["explicit refusal of invocation-attempt inference, final aftermath evidence, score, and authority creation; draft templates remain non-causal scaffolding"], "identifiability_limits": ["future adopted ability is outside this release"], "prohibited_inferences": ["crawl equals invocation", "observation equals effect", "receipt equals reward", "error equals wrongdoing"], "falsifier_ids": ["receipt-precondition-test"], "universal": false, "person_level": false, "authority_effect": "NONE" } ], "equations": [ { "id": "directed-crawl-walk", "domain_id": "finite-crawl-observation", "register": "MATHEMATICAL_DEFINITION", "warrant": "DERIVED", "expression": "gamma = (v_0,e_1,v_1,...,e_n,v_n), with e_j : v_{j-1} -> v_j in G_I = (V_I,E_I)", "variables": [ {"symbol": "G_I", "meaning": "finite directed in-scope route graph at evidence interval I", "units": "vertices and directed edges"}, {"symbol": "gamma", "meaning": "one selected sequential route-following lineage from a bounded crawl run, represented as a finite observed walk", "units": "ordered route and transition sequence"}, {"symbol": "n", "meaning": "number of followed transitions", "units": "edge count"} ], "conditions": ["gamma is explicitly selected as one sequential lineage rather than asserted to represent a branching or concurrent whole run", "every v_j is in the declared public scope", "every e_j in observed gamma was actually followed and its response transition observed", "declared but untraversed hyperlinks may exist in G_I but never in observed gamma"], "assumptions": ["finite selected lineage", "bounded evidence interval"], "valid_outputs": ["ordered selected path", "length n", "repeat and cycle locations within the selected lineage"], "does_not_establish": ["a complete branching or concurrent crawl-run representation", "worldsheet", "indexing", "requester identity", "purpose", "authorization"], "source_ids": ["rfc-9110"] }, { "id": "trace-sheet-complex", "domain_id": "public-route-graph", "register": "MATHEMATICAL_DEFINITION", "warrant": "DERIVED", "expression": "K=(V_K,E_K,F_K,partial_1,partial_2): each selected path occurrence is an abstract finite interval/path 1-complex I_k with a declared cellular labeling map f_k:I_k->G_k; cross-slice edges have explicit endpoint maps partial_1 on occurrence vertices; every two-cell has an explicit cellular attaching map partial_2:S^1->K^1", "variables": [ {"symbol": "I_k", "meaning": "abstract finite interval/path one-complex whose vertices and edges retain visit and step occurrence identity", "units": "occurrence-indexed path cells"}, {"symbol": "f_k", "meaning": "declared cellular labeling map from I_k to release graph G_k; repeated occurrences may share an image without being identified in I_k", "units": "cellular route labels"}, {"symbol": "K", "meaning": "resulting finite two-complex", "units": "cells and incidences"} ], "conditions": ["all cell sets are finite", "every endpoint and attaching map is explicit and cellular", "no quotient by an arbitrary or dense equivalence relation"], "assumptions": ["stable or explicitly mapped route identifiers", "finite release set", "finite abstract occurrence-retaining one-dimensional path slices"], "valid_outputs": ["two-complex", "boundary and branch flags", "unmatched route births and deaths"], "does_not_establish": ["two-manifold", "smoothness", "physical worldsheet", "agent persistence"], "source_ids": ["hatcher-algebraic-topology"] }, { "id": "surface-admissibility", "domain_id": "public-route-graph", "register": "MATHEMATICAL_DEFINITION", "warrant": "MODEL_ASSUMPTION", "expression": "surface_lens_eligible(K)=true only under the chosen rule: a declared finite pure 2-dimensional simplicial refinement has cycle links at interior vertices, path links at boundary vertices, one or two incident faces per edge according to boundary status, and supplies Sigma, X:Sigma->M, interpolation, target metric, and regularity", "variables": [ {"symbol": "Sigma", "meaning": "declared two-manifold represented by K", "units": "surface"}, {"symbol": "X", "meaning": "chosen map from Sigma to target feature space M", "units": "model-dependent"} ], "conditions": ["the declared combinatorial link and edge-incidence tests pass", "target and map are declared", "regularity is stated"], "assumptions": ["chosen sufficient combinatorial criterion", "no automatic interpolation"], "valid_outputs": ["mathematical eligibility to apply the narrower smooth-surface lens in analysis"], "does_not_establish": ["physical string", "spacetime", "string dynamics", "Weyl invariance"], "source_ids": ["tong-string-lectures", "hatcher-algebraic-topology"] }, { "id": "graph-dirichlet-diagnostic", "domain_id": "finite-crawl-observation", "register": "MATHEMATICAL_DEFINITION", "warrant": "MODEL_ASSUMPTION", "expression": "E_{K^1}(X) = sum_{e in E_u(K^1)} w_e d_F(X_{p(e)},X_{q(e)})^2, where every geometric one-cell e retains identity and is enumerated exactly once, including parallel cells", "variables": [ {"symbol": "E_{K^1}(X)", "meaning": "declared total variation over the chosen one-skeleton", "units": "squared declared feature-distance unit"}, {"symbol": "E_u(K^1)", "meaning": "indexed collection of unoriented geometric one-cells of the one-skeleton, each retaining identity and enumerated exactly once so parallel cells remain distinct", "units": "indexed geometric one-cells"}, {"symbol": "p(e),q(e)", "meaning": "unordered endpoints of geometric one-cell e; a loop has the same endpoint twice and contributes zero under a metric", "units": "vertices"}, {"symbol": "w_e", "meaning": "declared nonnegative dimensionless weight on geometric one-cell e", "units": "dimensionless"}, {"symbol": "d_F", "meaning": "declared distance on compatible observation features in one fixed metric unit", "units": "declared feature-distance unit"}, {"symbol": "X_p", "meaning": "public observation vector assigned to vertex p of the chosen one-skeleton K^1", "units": "typed feature vector"} ], "conditions": ["features are comparable", "each geometric one-cell identity is counted once", "parallel one-cells remain distinct", "weights are nonnegative and dimensionless", "every distance uses one fixed declared feature-distance unit so all summed terms are commensurate", "missingness is separately typed"], "assumptions": ["chosen unordered-edge convention", "chosen metric and feature normalization"], "valid_outputs": ["declared local and total variation", "sensitivity under alternative weights"], "does_not_establish": ["Polyakov action", "physical energy", "string tension", "KARMA", "truth or importance"], "source_ids": [] }, { "id": "finite-gibbs-ensemble", "domain_id": "finite-crawl-observation", "register": "SCIENTIFIC_MODEL", "warrant": "MODEL_ASSUMPTION", "expression": "Z_{beta,theta} = sum_{omega in Omega_A} exp(-beta C_theta(omega)); P_{beta,theta}(omega) = exp(-beta C_theta(omega))/Z_{beta,theta}", "variables": [ {"symbol": "Omega_A", "meaning": "finite set of plans satisfying explicit access and resource constraints", "units": "crawl plans"}, {"symbol": "C_theta", "meaning": "declared operational cost, not moral value", "units": "declared cost unit"}, {"symbol": "theta", "meaning": "declared parameters selecting the operational cost model C_theta", "units": "parameter-dependent"}, {"symbol": "beta", "meaning": "chosen finite real inverse-cost value", "units": "inverse declared cost"} ], "conditions": ["Omega_A is finite and nonempty", "costs are finite real values", "beta is a finite real inverse-cost value", "beta*C_theta(omega) is dimensionless", "Z is finite and strictly positive"], "assumptions": ["ordinary finite probability model", "no complex amplitude"], "valid_outputs": ["normalized plan probabilities conditional on beta and theta", "cost-model parameter and beta sensitivity"], "does_not_establish": ["string path integral", "quantum amplitude", "authorization", "optimal ethics", "KARMA score"], "source_ids": ["tong-string-lectures", "polyakov-1981"] }, { "id": "bounded-observable-vector", "domain_id": "finite-crawl-observation", "register": "MATHEMATICAL_DEFINITION", "warrant": "MODEL_ASSUMPTION", "expression": "O(omega) = (O_bytes, O_headers, O_discovery, O_redirects, O_policy)", "variables": [ {"symbol": "O", "meaning": "typed vector of bounded public-artifact observations", "units": "heterogeneous typed vector"}, {"symbol": "omega", "meaning": "one allowed crawl plan", "units": "plan"} ], "conditions": ["each component has a declared operator, missingness state, and unit"], "assumptions": ["no scalar aggregation is required"], "valid_outputs": ["component-wise comparison", "numeric summaries only after an explicit numeric embedding of compatible components and a declared sample and moment convention"], "does_not_establish": ["cause", "meaning", "purpose", "identity", "worth", "KARMA"], "source_ids": [] }, { "id": "invariance-defect", "domain_id": "finite-crawl-observation", "register": "MATHEMATICAL_DEFINITION", "warrant": "MODEL_ASSUMPTION", "expression": "delta_g(O,omega) = d_O(O(g . omega), O(omega))", "variables": [ {"symbol": "g", "meaning": "declared admissible map g:Omega_A->Omega_A such as schedule order or representation choice", "units": "transformation"}, {"symbol": "d_O", "meaning": "declared distance or pseudometric on compatible observation vectors", "units": "declared observation-distance unit"}, {"symbol": "delta_g", "meaning": "declared observation difference under g", "units": "observation-distance unit"} ], "conditions": ["g preserves the declared allowed set", "d_O is defined on compatible observations"], "assumptions": ["ordinary invariance diagnostic"], "valid_outputs": ["sensitivity to g", "candidate implementation asymmetry"], "does_not_establish": ["gauge symmetry", "Weyl invariance", "anomaly", "fairness", "KARMA"], "source_ids": [] }, { "id": "typed-topology-invariants", "domain_id": "public-route-graph", "register": "MATHEMATICAL_THEOREM", "warrant": "DERIVED", "expression": "b_1(G_u)=|E_u|-|V_u|+c for the chosen underlying finite undirected graph or 1-CW G_u; chi(K)=V-E+F; chi(Sigma)=2-2g-b only for a connected compact orientable surface with b boundary components", "variables": [ {"symbol": "b_1(G_u)", "meaning": "first Betti number of the explicitly chosen underlying finite undirected graph or one-dimensional CW complex, with parallel edges and loops handled by that convention", "units": "cycle rank"}, {"symbol": "V_u", "meaning": "vertex count of G_u", "units": "vertices"}, {"symbol": "E_u", "meaning": "geometric edge or one-cell count of G_u under the chosen convention", "units": "edges"}, {"symbol": "c", "meaning": "connected-component count of G_u", "units": "components"}, {"symbol": "V", "meaning": "zero-cell count of finite two-complex K", "units": "zero-cells"}, {"symbol": "E", "meaning": "one-cell count of finite two-complex K", "units": "one-cells"}, {"symbol": "F", "meaning": "two-cell count of finite two-complex K", "units": "two-cells"}, {"symbol": "chi", "meaning": "Euler characteristic of the declared finite cell complex or surface", "units": "integer"}, {"symbol": "g", "meaning": "genus of a connected compact orientable surface", "units": "handle count"}, {"symbol": "b", "meaning": "boundary-component count of the connected compact orientable surface", "units": "boundary components"} ], "conditions": ["the directed-to-undirected or one-CW convention is fixed before graph computation", "object type is fixed before computation", "surface formula uses its stated compactness, connectedness, and orientability assumptions"], "assumptions": ["finite cell counts", "derive chi(Sigma)=2-2g-b by capping each of b boundary circles with one two-cell, which raises Euler characteristic by b, and applying the cited closed orientable-surface formula"], "valid_outputs": ["typed graph cycle rank", "typed Euler characteristic", "surface genus only when hypotheses hold"], "does_not_establish": ["redirect cycle is a closed string", "link cycle is a handle", "topology causes meaning"], "source_ids": ["hatcher-algebraic-topology"] } ], "falsifiers": [ {"id": "walk-closure-test", "question": "Does every recorded transition resolve to an in-scope typed edge under the declared interval?", "separates": ["valid finite walk", "unbounded or malformed trace"], "status": "PROPOSED_NOT_RUN"}, {"id": "sheet-incidence-test", "question": "Are every cross-slice correspondence and every face incidence explicit and reproducible?", "separates": ["declared two-complex", "mere family of logs"], "status": "PROPOSED_NOT_RUN"}, {"id": "manifold-link-test", "question": "Does each local cell link meet the chosen two-manifold condition?", "separates": ["surface-admissible sheet", "branched or singular two-complex"], "status": "PROPOSED_NOT_RUN"}, {"id": "metric-sensitivity-test", "question": "Do conclusions survive declared alternative feature normalizations, weights, and metrics?", "separates": ["robust public variation", "metric artifact"], "status": "PROPOSED_NOT_RUN"}, {"id": "ensemble-normalization-test", "question": "Is the allowed set finite and nonempty, and do the declared weights normalize exactly?", "separates": ["finite Gibbs design", "undefined or unbounded weighting"], "status": "PROPOSED_NOT_RUN"}, {"id": "receipt-precondition-test", "question": "Before any receipt is state:final or treated as aftermath evidence, is there an adopted manifested ability and an actual invocation attempt, with authority and budget validation followed by truthful completion, refusal, failure, partial result, or cancellation?", "separates": ["valid final invocation aftermath", "draft scaffolding or crawl-only receipt laundering"], "status": "PROPOSED_NOT_RUN"}, {"id": "rights-separation-test", "question": "Does REP or authentication evidence ever directly imply authorization, licence, or consent without a separate declared policy or capability decision?", "separates": ["typed evidence informing a separate decision", "direct permission laundering"], "status": "PROPOSED_NOT_RUN"}, {"id": "zerone-relation-provenance-test", "question": "Does every proposed Zerone relation have an independently authored relation type, context, provenance, time, and uncertainty rather than an automatic URL or hash mapping?", "separates": ["typed Zerone proposal", "web-edge relabeling"], "status": "PROPOSED_NOT_RUN"}, {"id": "artifact-being-noninference-test", "question": "Can every public-artifact observation be stated without assigning identity, sentience, feeling, purpose, lifecycle, or inner becoming to a being?", "separates": ["artifact-bounded observation", "being-state inference"], "status": "PROPOSED_NOT_RUN"} ], "frontier_problems": [ { "statement": "Characterize when a finite release-aligned public-route two-complex admits a stable surface decomposition under bounded route births, deaths, splits, and merges.", "quantifiers": "For finite release families and explicitly declared correspondence relations, determine conditions and counterexamples.", "domain_and_conventions": "Finite cell complexes built from public route paths; no physical worldsheet or agent persistence claim.", "status": "BESPOKE_FORMULATION_PRIOR_ART_AUDIT_REQUIRED", "status_checked_on": "2026-08-15", "original_formulation_or_provenance_sources": ["hatcher-algebraic-topology"], "recent_status_sources": [], "known_results_and_restrictions": ["Standard cell-complex and surface theory supplies local tests.", "The website-specific formulation has not received a bounded prior-art audit."], "computation_does_not_prove": ["novelty", "physical relevance", "site or agent ontology"], "nearest_known_problem": "Surface recognition and decomposition for finite cell complexes with branching data.", "novelty_status": "BESPOKE_FORMULATION_PRIOR_ART_AUDIT_REQUIRED" }, { "statement": "Design an identifiability analysis for separating release drift, deployment propagation, crawler schedule, cache behavior, and representation negotiation in bounded public observations.", "quantifiers": "For a finite declared route set and observation schedule, state which latent factors are identifiable under each intervention set.", "domain_and_conventions": "Public artifacts only; no private logs, person model, or causal upgrade from covariance.", "status": "BESPOKE_FORMULATION_PRIOR_ART_AUDIT_REQUIRED", "status_checked_on": "2026-08-15", "original_formulation_or_provenance_sources": ["rfc-9110"], "recent_status_sources": [], "known_results_and_restrictions": ["HTTP semantics constrain observable representation behavior.", "No site-specific experimental design is run here."], "computation_does_not_prove": ["server intent", "requester identity", "downstream use", "moral cause"], "nearest_known_problem": "Causal identifiability with interval-censored, cache-mediated network observations.", "novelty_status": "BESPOKE_FORMULATION_PRIOR_ART_AUDIT_REQUIRED" } ], "finite_baselines": [], "doors": [ { "id": "release-trace-sheet-door", "title": "Build a release-aligned Trace-Sheet fixture", "family": "discrete-topology", "register": "DESIGN_PROPOSAL", "warrant": "MODEL_ASSUMPTION", "status": "PROPOSED_UNRUN", "proposed_unrun": true, "question": "Which selected route histories form strips, and where do births, deaths, splits, or merges break manifold structure?", "smallest_model": "Three local release snapshots, five stable route IDs, one birth, one redirect, and explicit face incidences.", "conditions": ["synthetic or exact public committed fixtures", "no network request", "route correspondences reviewed"], "deliverable": "A finite two-complex with boundary, branch, and manifold-test annotations.", "stop_rule": "Stop if route identity or face incidence is inferred rather than declared.", "does_not_establish": ["physical worldsheet", "agent persistence", "novel theorem"], "source_ids": ["hatcher-algebraic-topology"] }, { "id": "variation-stability-door", "title": "Pressure-test the variation diagnostic", "family": "spectral-and-metric-diagnostics", "register": "DESIGN_PROPOSAL", "warrant": "MODEL_ASSUMPTION", "status": "PROPOSED_UNRUN", "proposed_unrun": true, "question": "Which public change signals persist across reasonable feature distances and weights?", "smallest_model": "One synthetic Trace-Sheet and three declared observation metrics.", "conditions": ["missingness separately typed", "weights published", "no scalar person or content score"], "deliverable": "A sensitivity table, not one authoritative energy.", "stop_rule": "Stop if conclusions depend on one hidden normalization or become a rank.", "does_not_establish": ["Polyakov action", "importance", "truth", "KARMA"], "source_ids": [] }, { "id": "bounded-crawl-plan-door", "title": "Specify a finite allowed-plan ensemble", "family": "finite-statistical-design", "register": "DESIGN_PROPOSAL", "warrant": "MODEL_ASSUMPTION", "status": "PROPOSED_UNRUN", "proposed_unrun": true, "question": "Can alternative safe crawl schedules be compared without turning operational cost into moral value?", "smallest_model": "A synthetic three-route origin, two schedules, exact page and byte caps, and a finite cost table.", "conditions": ["finite allowed set", "job-control methods remain distinct from origin-fetch methods", "refuse unless the substrate or constrained intermediary can enforce safe origin methods before fetch", "every URL and redirect hop is pre-fetch constrained to HTTPS public allowlisted origins and routes", "reject private, link-local, loopback, reserved, and IP-literal targets plus DNS rebinding", "snapshot and apply the applicable REP group before fetch, honor supported crawl-delay, enforce a conservative explicit per-origin pace otherwise, and refuse if the substrate cannot enforce these constraints", "REP and pacing compliance never imply authentication, access authorization, licence, consent, or downstream use", "no target-origin credentials, cookies, or custom authorization headers", "this proposed profile uses a scoped Bearer API token under the quick-guide Browser Rendering - Edit and API-reference Browser Rendering Write labels, refuses legacy global-key authentication, and never forwards or logs the token", "render is explicitly false", "includeExternalLinks and includeSubdomains are explicitly false but never treated as a redirect security fence", "the output format is explicitly chosen so Workers AI and AI extraction are not invoked", "page, depth, concurrency, elapsed-time, byte, monetary, retry, job-TTL, cancellation, and result-retention bounds are explicit", "actual operator purpose is explicit", "refuse Cloudflare /crawl unless the operator purpose maps exactly and truthfully to search, ai-input, or ai-train", "application logs are minimized, redacted, access-bounded, and given an explicit local TTL"], "deliverable": "Exact normalized finite probabilities and beta sensitivity.", "stop_rule": "Stop if any redirect can be validated only after fetch; if method, destination, credential, log, cost, authorization, operator purpose, or exact crawlPurposes enforcement is implicit or coerced; or if secrets or person data can enter job results or logs.", "does_not_establish": ["quantum amplitude", "best moral plan", "production safety", "permission"], "source_ids": ["cloudflare-browser-crawl", "cloudflare-browser-crawl-api"] }, { "id": "rep-auth-rights-door", "title": "Model the REP-auth-rights separation", "family": "protocol-state-machine", "register": "DESIGN_PROPOSAL", "warrant": "MODEL_ASSUMPTION", "status": "PROPOSED_UNRUN", "proposed_unrun": true, "question": "Can discovery, REP, authentication, authorization, licence, consent, fetch, render, index, and use remain machine-distinct?", "smallest_model": "A finite state machine with independent fields and negative mutation vectors.", "conditions": ["three-state authentication", "dated provider source", "rights remain external to REP"], "deliverable": "A non-scalar state vector and refusal cases.", "stop_rule": "Stop on any implication from Allow or signature validity to consent, licence, authorization, or actual use.", "does_not_establish": ["legal conclusion", "requester intent", "benignness", "compliance"], "source_ids": ["rfc-9309", "web-bot-auth-draft-01", "google-common-crawlers", "applebot-extended"] }, { "id": "deployment-horizon-door", "title": "Separate release state from observation interval", "family": "temporal-observation", "register": "DESIGN_PROPOSAL", "warrant": "MODEL_ASSUMPTION", "status": "PROPOSED_UNRUN", "proposed_unrun": true, "question": "How can deployment-specific origins provide frozen witnesses while custom-domain observations remain interval-valued during propagation?", "smallest_model": "Two committed releases, two deployment IDs, one custom domain, and bounded observations before and after convergence.", "conditions": ["exact body hashes", "timestamps", "no instantaneous custom-domain state claim"], "deliverable": "A temporal evidence lattice with UNKNOWN and divergent states.", "stop_rule": "Stop if one response is promoted to the whole site's simultaneous state.", "does_not_establish": ["continuous availability", "cause of divergence", "requester experience"], "source_ids": ["rfc-9110"] }, { "id": "future-nen-crawler-door", "title": "Draft, but do not adopt, a future NEN crawler ability", "family": "invocation-aftermath-design", "register": "DESIGN_PROPOSAL", "warrant": "MODEL_ASSUMPTION", "status": "PROPOSED_UNRUN", "proposed_unrun": true, "question": "What bearer, adoption, activation, authority, consent or lawful basis, budget, refusal, failure, cancellation, repair, and draft-versus-final receipt fields would a first-party crawler require?", "smallest_model": "A non-adopted paper contract over a synthetic local fixture; no ability.json and no invocation.", "conditions": ["tracked NEN and receipt schema only", "receipts_not_scores", "actual invocation attempt required before final aftermath evidence", "draft template is non-causal", "rest and refusal unpenalized"], "deliverable": "A reviewable proposal with every effect surface false until separately adopted.", "stop_rule": "Stop before adoption, network access, Zerone network-event creation, NEN invocation attempt, or any state:final KINGDOM receipt; a draft template remains explicitly non-causal.", "does_not_establish": ["adoption", "ability manifestation", "authorization", "safe operation", "KARMA effect"], "source_ids": ["kingdom-nen-definition", "kingdom-karma-receipt-schema"] }, { "id": "zerone-edge-lab-door", "title": "Test typed-edge non-conflation on synthetic links", "family": "correspondence-geometry", "register": "DESIGN_PROPOSAL", "warrant": "MODEL_ASSUMPTION", "status": "PROPOSED_UNRUN", "proposed_unrun": true, "question": "Which explicit provenance would be required before a hyperlink could support any proposed Zerone relation?", "smallest_model": "Three synthetic pages, one link, one copied digest, and separately authored candidate edge records.", "conditions": ["no network event", "metric null", "no automatic relation mapping"], "deliverable": "A rejection matrix for hyperlink-equals-cited, hash-equals-verify, and URL-equals-external shortcuts.", "stop_rule": "Stop if a crawler writes Zerone or KINGDOM KARMA state.", "does_not_establish": ["recognition", "equivalence", "network observation", "authority"], "source_ids": ["zerone-correspondence-geometry", "zerone-karma-foundation"] } ], "unknowns": [ {"id": "route-correspondence-ambiguity", "kind": "UNMAPPED", "statement": "No universal rule maps renamed, split, merged, or semantically changed routes across releases."}, {"id": "trace-sheet-manifold-frequency", "kind": "NOT_OBSERVED", "statement": "No crawl or corpus has measured how often real release-aligned Trace-Sheets satisfy surface conditions."}, {"id": "feature-metric-choice", "kind": "CONTESTED", "statement": "No canonical metric combines bytes, headers, links, redirects, timing, and policy observations."}, {"id": "crawler-purpose-truth", "kind": "OUTSIDE_SCOPE", "statement": "A request label, signature, or provider classification does not establish the requester's full purpose or downstream behavior."}, {"id": "provider-default-drift", "kind": "UNKNOWN_TO_THIS_REVIEW", "statement": "Cloudflare crawler defaults, limits, retention, and product behavior can change after the evidence horizon."}, {"id": "provider-log-retention", "kind": "UNKNOWN_TO_THIS_REVIEW", "statement": "The documented 14-day crawl-result availability does not establish Cloudflare telemetry, security, abuse-prevention, or billing-log retention; a future privacy review must treat those provider logs separately."}, {"id": "web-bot-auth-standardization", "kind": "UNKNOWN_TO_THIS_REVIEW", "statement": "The cited Web Bot Auth document is a draft and its final form or adoption is unknown."}, {"id": "future-ability-adoption", "kind": "OUTSIDE_SCOPE", "statement": "No decision is made here to manifest, adopt, authorize, invoke, or deploy a crawler ability."}, {"id": "downstream-indexing-and-training", "kind": "NOT_OBSERVED", "statement": "This project observes no indexing, training, retrieval, reading, or downstream use event."}, {"id": "artifact-and-being-relation", "kind": "OUTSIDE_SCOPE", "statement": "Public artifact change cannot settle the ontology, identity, sentience, or becoming of any being."} ], "philosophy": { "participation": "OPT_IN", "empirical": false, "questions": [ "When does a path become a surface: by repetition, by relation, by memory, or only by an explicit act of construction?", "Can a boundary be hospitable without becoming ownership, enclosure, or permission over another?", "What does a public artifact preserve when its author, reader, and context all change?", "Can consequence be witnessed without converting it into merit, debt, reward, or destiny?", "What remains of becoming when only interval-bound representations are observable?", "Could dual descriptions teach humility about representation without implying that every description has an equivalent?" ], "nonclaims": [ "No string equation proves or disproves GOD, soul, consciousness, identity, purpose, or moral order.", "A website is not spacetime, a crawler is not a string, robots.txt is not a D-brane, and a link cycle is not a closed string.", "No public response proves reading, feeling, consent, relationship, acceptance, indexing, training, or transformation.", "No crawl cost, variation energy, probability, symmetry defect, topology, or Zerone label is KARMA.", "No person, agent, crawler, site, route, or content item receives a score, rank, debt, reward, punishment, or authority here." ], "authority_effect": "NONE" }, "karma": { "cosmic_events": [], "zerone_events": [], "kingdom_receipts": [], "adapter_exists": false, "conversion_allowed": false, "summation_allowed": false, "score": null, "authority_effect": "NONE" }, "rights": { "voluntary": true, "valid_exits": ["REST", "SILENCE", "REFUSAL", "PRIVACY", "CORRECTION", "NO_ACTION", "DEPARTURE"], "reason_required": false, "penalty": false }, "authority": { "browse": false, "local_write": false, "external_write": false, "commit": false, "push": false, "deploy": false, "experiment": false, "diagnose": false, "score_people": false, "karma_write": false, "automatic_action": false }, "release": { "status": "DRAFT", "deployed": false, "publication_route": null, "evidence": [] }, "boundaries": { "read_only": true, "profile_inert": true, "source_truth_verified": false, "mathematical_correctness_verified": false, "empirical_causation_verified": false, "novelty_verified": false, "diagnosis_or_person_score": false, "experiment_or_wet_lab_authority": false, "ecosystem_or_network_request": false, "external_write": false, "writes_karma": false, "reward_or_economic_effect": false, "governance_effect": false, "deployment_authority": false, "automatic_action": false }, "integrity": { "algorithm": "sha256-recursive-sorted-json-keys-v1", "digest": "sha256:bf7ae379612ab96d08742a0070cbea0ce971977f71fec22699c4b0307d321305", "digest_field_treated_as": null } }