{ "$schema": "urn:kingdom:schema:civilisation-flow-nuance-atlas:0.1", "protocol": "kingdom.civilisation-flow-nuance-atlas/0.1", "atlas_id": "civilisation-flow-nuance-atlas-2026-08-26", "version": "0.1.0", "title": "Civilisation Flow Nuance Atlas", "compiled_on": "2026-08-26", "evidence_through": "2026-08-21", "state": "reviewed-static-flow-nuance-atlas", "scope": { "question": "What must remain visible when tracing a possible path from word or expression through shared story, institutions, decisions, authority, capability, action, aftermath, feedback, and repair?", "intended_use": [ "Inspect where a proposed civilisation-to-reality path can branch, stall, leak, reverse, recur, or never begin.", "Keep carriers, material conditions, emotional and power questions, affected parties, delays, uncertainty, counterflows, and repair requirements visible at every analytical stage and transition.", "Make influence claims harder by exposing missing mediators, rival paths, inadequate observation coverage, and non-implications." ], "excluded_use": [ "A runnable pipeline, diffusion simulator, intervention recipe, effect-size estimator, deterministic predictor, threshold optimizer, persuasion or targeting system, propaganda or counterpropaganda guide, or coercive strategy.", "A person, group, religion, class, emotion, power, legitimacy, influence, civilisation, or net-good score.", "A historical finding, causal effect, metaphysical verdict, authority grant, consent or lawful-basis record, capability grant, action, publication trigger, or deployment trigger." ], "unit_of_analysis": "One analytical stage, transition, or crosswalk overlay whose possible carriers, conditions, gaps, alternatives, affected parties, and non-effects are explicitly typed.", "analytical_shape": "temporal-multilayer-directed-seam-and-overlay-design-lens", "shared_story_definition": "A bounded narrative artifact, performance, or interpretive frame available to more than one participant; shared does not mean believed, understood, agreed, consensual, legitimate, or uniformly received.", "flow_definition": "A question about separately evidenced states, events, transitions, interruptions, branches, counterflows, aftermaths, and repairs; flow is not a conserved social substance or an automatic funnel.", "new_vocabulary_register": "DESIGN_COMMITMENT", "external_empirical_sources_added": false, "evidence_horizon_scope": "predecessor-claims-only", "data_classification": "public-static-design-atlas-no-person-data" }, "predecessor_bindings": [ { "id": "word-story-religion-civilisation", "protocol": "kingdom.word-story-religion-civilisation-map/0.1", "map_id": "word-story-religion-civilisation-2026-08-20", "locator": "repo:data/language/word-story-religion-civilisation-map.v0.1.json", "raw_digest": "sha256:a4a87b7b23dbdf7e7e6689b5083f76a746c7f41bc56f2124281dfda609a62479", "semantic_digest": "sha256:0c791b2491ebdcd85cf58e26e41e8b35b883781fd26bccc19dfd3f7853c7855a", "relation": "historical-language-story-and-institution-concept-predecessor", "mutated": false, "republished": false, "authority_imported": false }, { "id": "reality-influence-claim-graph", "protocol": "kingdom.reality-influence-claim-graph/0.1", "map_id": "reality-influence-claim-graph-2026-08-21", "locator": "repo:data/reality/reality-influence-map.v0.1.json", "raw_digest": "sha256:4d68be39226c8d5451c8d9166fa74ba54bb793b7655f119d8765090cbbcf890e", "semantic_digest": "sha256:45d4323d1a6190b3c333f02f2c744858e8da27944fbcb2042fbae492ca6e31ac", "relation": "typed-claim-stage-gate-aftermath-and-repair-predecessor", "mutated": false, "republished": false, "authority_imported": false }, { "id": "civilisation-reality-projection", "protocol": "kingdom.civilisation-reality-projection/0.1", "map_id": "civilisation-reality-projection-2026-08-25", "locator": "repo:data/reality/civilisation-reality-projection.v0.1.json", "raw_digest": "sha256:acc5d16b0981266fe9908714af4791fe2266d063a363f89e43f7a208b0b4b48e", "semantic_digest": "sha256:03c20d3976a7b449c009cac7736ab73aa9f17fa619951d3753ecbb69bcc1496b", "relation": "six-crosswalk-and-open-domain-design-predecessor", "mutated": false, "republished": false, "authority_imported": false } ], "flow_rules": { "source_claims_remain_in_predecessors": true, "predecessors_remain_immutable": true, "shared_story_is_not_shared_belief": true, "stages_are_not_an_automatic_sequence": true, "transitions_are_not_transitive": true, "claim_graph_direction_is_not_time_direction": true, "flow_does_not_erase_structure": true, "structure_does_not_imply_stasis": true, "form_stock_and_institution_are_memory_and_constraint_lenses_not_ontological_verdicts": true, "boundary_choice_can_hide_displaced_effects": true, "authority_dependency_is_not_causal_influence": true, "decision_is_not_authority": true, "authority_is_not_capability": true, "capability_is_not_permission": true, "attempt_is_not_execution": true, "execution_is_not_success": true, "sequence_is_not_causation": true, "outcome_is_not_causal_effect": true, "causal_effect_is_not_legitimacy_goodness_or_justice": true, "emotion_is_not_inferred_from_expression_or_participation": true, "power_position_is_not_motive_worth_legitimacy_or_authority": true, "dynamics_are_qualitative_lenses_not_effect_sizes_or_predictions": true, "topology_representation_is_not_occurrence": true, "material_context_is_not_deterministic_cause": true, "absence_requires_adequate_observation_coverage": true, "absence_is_not_zero_nonexistence_disbelief_or_consent": true, "influence_aftermath_and_uncertainty_are_non_summable": true, "repair_is_not_erasure_absolution_restored_consent_or_completed_justice": true, "non_action_has_no_adverse_inference": true, "unsupported_domains_remain_open": true }, "nuance_dimensions": [ { "id": "carriers", "meaning": "Media, bodies, roles, organizations, infrastructures, resources, and records that can hold or convey a bounded form.", "aggregate_weight": null, "rank": null }, { "id": "transformations", "meaning": "Changes in wording, genre, access, selection, status, procedure, capability, material state, or interpretation.", "aggregate_weight": null, "rank": null }, { "id": "gates", "meaning": "Independent checks or conditions that may permit, constrain, refuse, or redirect a stage without being caused by a prior stage.", "aggregate_weight": null, "rank": null }, { "id": "temporal-profile", "meaning": "Onset, duration, latency, overlap, decay, recurrence, censoring, and resolution kept qualitative and separately visible.", "aggregate_weight": null, "rank": null }, { "id": "accumulation-profile", "meaning": "A scoped stock/flow question with units or explicit non-additivity, inflows, outflows, decay, and reset.", "aggregate_weight": null, "rank": null }, { "id": "observables", "meaning": "Traces that could be witnessed without converting observation into cause, meaning, value, consent, or completion.", "aggregate_weight": null, "rank": null }, { "id": "affected-parties", "meaning": "Direct, indirect, non-user, future, and ecological parties whose benefits, burdens, options, and disagreement stay plural.", "aggregate_weight": null, "rank": null }, { "id": "distribution", "meaning": "Who receives benefits, burdens, risks, voice, options, and repair access across time without a net score.", "aggregate_weight": null, "rank": null }, { "id": "emotion", "meaning": "Typed observation and contextual affect questions that never infer private or collective mental state from public traces.", "aggregate_weight": null, "rank": null }, { "id": "social-position", "meaning": "Separately typed economic, status, office, network, agenda, coercive, and discursive positions.", "aggregate_weight": null, "rank": null }, { "id": "power-asymmetry", "meaning": "Unequal ability to name, distribute, select, decide, coerce, resource, measure, wait, exit, or secure repair.", "aggregate_weight": null, "rank": null }, { "id": "material-conditions", "meaning": "Body, care, labor, time, geography, resources, ecology, property, infrastructure, logistics, data, and technology contexts.", "aggregate_weight": null, "rank": null }, { "id": "flow-dynamics", "meaning": "Qualitative questions about continuity, thresholds, latency, accumulation, path dependence, branches, displacement, coupling, and feedback.", "aggregate_weight": null, "rank": null }, { "id": "topology", "meaning": "Representable forks, joins, parallel paths, bottlenecks, leakage, substitution, interruptions, reversals, recurrence, and loops.", "aggregate_weight": null, "rank": null }, { "id": "negative-or-missing-flow", "meaning": "Typed non-observation, no opportunity, blocking, censorship, loss, inaccessibility, refusal, exclusion, measurement failure, or unknown.", "aggregate_weight": null, "rank": null }, { "id": "distortions", "meaning": "Selection, translation, measurement, incentive, censorship, compression, propaganda, or feedback risks treated as audit questions.", "aggregate_weight": null, "rank": null }, { "id": "counterflows", "meaning": "Counterstory, challenge, veto, refusal, withdrawal, privacy, voice, exit, alternate path, correction, and repair.", "aggregate_weight": null, "rank": null }, { "id": "failure-modes", "meaning": "Ways a stage or transition may fail, be misread, shift burden, launder authority, or conceal residual harm.", "aggregate_weight": null, "rank": null }, { "id": "repair", "meaning": "Fresh-gated stopping, preservation, correction, restitution, compensation, rehabilitation, satisfaction, non-repetition, residual, and recurrence review.", "aggregate_weight": null, "rank": null }, { "id": "evidence", "meaning": "Provenance, scope, method, negative cases, counterevidence, falsifiers, expected traces, and transport limits.", "aggregate_weight": null, "rank": null }, { "id": "uncertainty", "meaning": "Source, measurement, missingness, temporal, identification, transport, affected-party, normative, and authority uncertainty kept as a vector.", "aggregate_weight": null, "rank": null }, { "id": "alternatives", "meaning": "Rival pathways, mediators, explanations, institutions, responses, non-actions, and futures.", "aggregate_weight": null, "rank": null }, { "id": "stop-and-stall", "meaning": "Deliberate stop conditions remain distinct from blocking, no opportunity, censorship, incapacity, delay, and measurement failure.", "aggregate_weight": null, "rank": null }, { "id": "reversibility-and-nonimplication", "meaning": "Recoverable elements, irreversible residuals, prerequisites, and claims that do not follow from the representation.", "aggregate_weight": null, "rank": null } ], "affected_party_vocabulary": [ { "id": "expression-originators", "meaning": "People or collectives attributed as originating an expression or story.", "omission_risk": "Their authorship, refusal, safety, context, or intended audience may be overwritten." }, { "id": "translators-curators-and-stewards", "meaning": "People or institutions that translate, select, preserve, describe, or distribute artifacts.", "omission_risk": "Their interpretive and access power may disappear behind a neutral-medium story." }, { "id": "source-communities-and-traditions", "meaning": "Communities connected to a source practice, language, story, archive, or sacred claim.", "omission_risk": "Publication may extract, flatten, expose, or falsely represent community voice." }, { "id": "audiences-and-non-audiences", "meaning": "People reached, not reached, avoiding exposure, or outside the intended public.", "omission_risk": "Availability may be mistaken for universal exposure or reception." }, { "id": "institutional-participants", "meaning": "Staff, members, reviewers, representatives, dissenters, and people excluded from an institution.", "omission_risk": "A formal decision may hide agenda control, labor, non-decisions, and exclusion." }, { "id": "decision-subjects", "meaning": "People whose rights, opportunities, resources, status, or environment may be shaped by a proposal or decision.", "omission_risk": "Decision makers may be counted while subjects and non-users disappear." }, { "id": "operators-and-labor", "meaning": "People who implement, maintain, moderate, care for, repair, or refuse an action.", "omission_risk": "Capability may be described as technical while labor, safety, time, and discretion vanish." }, { "id": "resource-providers", "meaning": "People and institutions supplying funds, credit, data, energy, land, equipment, access, or infrastructure.", "omission_risk": "Dependence and agenda power may be hidden as neutral capacity." }, { "id": "directly-affected-parties", "meaning": "People or systems directly touched by an attempted or executed action.", "omission_risk": "The actor's outcome can replace the affected party's benefit, burden, refusal, and residual." }, { "id": "indirect-non-user-and-bystander-parties", "meaning": "People affected through spillovers, supply chains, institutions, markets, media, or shared environments.", "omission_risk": "A narrow system boundary can displace effects outside the measured population." }, { "id": "future-parties", "meaning": "People and communities exposed to path dependence, option loss, maintenance, debt, or delayed aftermath.", "omission_risk": "Short horizons can count immediate benefits while hiding later burdens and irreversibility." }, { "id": "ecological-systems", "meaning": "Land, water, climate, species, habitats, and material cycles affected by resource and infrastructure choices.", "omission_risk": "Human-only accounting can externalize extraction, waste, damage, and repair limits." } ], "flow_dynamics_vocabulary": [ { "id": "continuous-or-episodic", "label": "Continuous or episodic", "question": "Is the trace sustained, intermittent, event-bounded, reconstructed, or unknown at the chosen resolution?", "observables": [ "Timestamped records and declared observation windows." ], "does_not_establish": [ "Continuity, stable intensity, or effect between observations." ], "aggregate_weight": null, "rank": null, "effect_size": null, "prediction": false, "optimization_target": false }, { "id": "threshold-or-tipping", "label": "Threshold or tipping", "question": "Is a transition conditional on a declared heterogeneous trigger, opportunity set, reset rule, and evidence horizon?", "observables": [ "Scoped trigger definitions, distributions, negative cases, and hysteresis checks." ], "does_not_establish": [ "A universal threshold, person susceptibility, future tipping point, or targeting parameter." ], "aggregate_weight": null, "rank": null, "effect_size": null, "prediction": false, "optimization_target": false }, { "id": "delay-or-latency", "label": "Delay or latency", "question": "What separates exposure, decision, action, effect, observation, and record time?", "observables": [ "Declared onset, latency window, overlap, censoring, and temporal resolution." ], "does_not_establish": [ "Instantaneous effect, chosen lag validity, or cause from temporal order." ], "aggregate_weight": null, "rank": null, "effect_size": null, "prediction": false, "optimization_target": false }, { "id": "accumulation-or-memory", "label": "Accumulation or memory", "question": "What carrier retains what quantity or form, under what unit, inflow, outflow, reconstruction, decay, and reset rule?", "observables": [ "Versioned archives, resources, practices, infrastructures, and scoped counts where additivity is valid." ], "does_not_establish": [ "A collective mind, faithful preservation, or summability of meaning, attention, legitimacy, emotion, or status." ], "aggregate_weight": null, "rank": null, "effect_size": null, "prediction": false, "optimization_target": false }, { "id": "path-dependence-or-hysteresis", "label": "Path dependence or hysteresis", "question": "Which switching costs, sunk resources, standards, learning, networks, commitments, or lost options preserve history in later choices?", "observables": [ "Named reinforcement, exit cost, alternative timing, and reset or reversal evidence." ], "does_not_establish": [ "Path dependence from persistence alone or inevitability from an early event." ], "aggregate_weight": null, "rank": null, "effect_size": null, "prediction": false, "optimization_target": false }, { "id": "branching-or-convergence", "label": "Branching or convergence", "question": "Which different paths can leave a state, rejoin, remain parallel, or produce similar observations?", "observables": [ "Alternative path records, forks, joins, negative cases, and convergence limits." ], "does_not_establish": [ "That represented branches occurred or that similar endpoints share one cause." ], "aggregate_weight": null, "rank": null, "effect_size": null, "prediction": false, "optimization_target": false }, { "id": "leakage-substitution-or-displacement", "label": "Leakage, substitution, or displacement", "question": "Did burden, attention, resource use, behavior, or harm move beyond the chosen boundary or into an alternate channel?", "observables": [ "Cross-boundary traces, substitute channels, non-user effects, and lifecycle records." ], "does_not_establish": [ "Net benefit, disappearance of harm, or completeness of the system boundary." ], "aggregate_weight": null, "rank": null, "effect_size": null, "prediction": false, "optimization_target": false }, { "id": "coupling-or-decoupling", "label": "Coupling or decoupling", "question": "Which stages vary together, detach, or are linked only by a shared cause, rule, infrastructure, or measurement process?", "observables": [ "Scoped co-variation, interruption, mediator, and rival-path evidence." ], "does_not_establish": [ "Causal linkage, structural identity, or stable coupling outside the observed scope." ], "aggregate_weight": null, "rank": null, "effect_size": null, "prediction": false, "optimization_target": false }, { "id": "reinforcing-feedback", "label": "Reinforcing feedback", "question": "Can a separately evidenced return path amplify later availability, selection, resources, or observations?", "observables": [ "Distinct loop transitions, policy exposure, changed incentives, and later measurements." ], "does_not_establish": [ "Runaway growth, causal cycle, desirability, or automatic amplification." ], "aggregate_weight": null, "rank": null, "effect_size": null, "prediction": false, "optimization_target": false }, { "id": "balancing-feedback", "label": "Balancing feedback", "question": "Can challenge, saturation, constraint, refusal, exit, correction, or repair reduce or redirect a separately evidenced path?", "observables": [ "Veto, counterflow, capacity constraint, correction, retirement, and recurrence records." ], "does_not_establish": [ "Equilibrium, successful correction, equal counterpower, or restored prior conditions." ], "aggregate_weight": null, "rank": null, "effect_size": null, "prediction": false, "optimization_target": false } ], "topology_vocabulary": [ { "id": "fork", "label": "Fork", "question": "Can one observed state have multiple separately evidenced successors?", "observables": [ "Distinct outgoing transition records." ], "does_not_establish": [ "That every represented branch occurred." ], "aggregate_weight": null, "rank": null, "effect_size": null, "prediction": false, "optimization_target": false }, { "id": "join", "label": "Join", "question": "Can multiple prior paths contribute to one later state without becoming one cause?", "observables": [ "Multiple provenance and mediator records." ], "does_not_establish": [ "Commensurability, equal contribution, or causal sufficiency." ], "aggregate_weight": null, "rank": null, "effect_size": null, "prediction": false, "optimization_target": false }, { "id": "parallel-path", "label": "Parallel path", "question": "Can alternative channels coexist without joining?", "observables": [ "Separately scoped channel and audience traces." ], "does_not_establish": [ "Independence or equivalent reach." ], "aggregate_weight": null, "rank": null, "effect_size": null, "prediction": false, "optimization_target": false }, { "id": "bottleneck", "label": "Bottleneck", "question": "Which scarce access, review, resource, capability, or authority condition constrains a path?", "observables": [ "Queues, capacity, exclusion, delay, and gate records." ], "does_not_establish": [ "Legitimate scarcity, optimal allocation, or a single limiting cause." ], "aggregate_weight": null, "rank": null, "effect_size": null, "prediction": false, "optimization_target": false }, { "id": "leakage", "label": "Leakage", "question": "What crosses the declared system or affected-party boundary?", "observables": [ "Externality, spillover, supply-chain, and displaced trace records." ], "does_not_establish": [ "Boundary completeness or net effect." ], "aggregate_weight": null, "rank": null, "effect_size": null, "prediction": false, "optimization_target": false }, { "id": "substitution", "label": "Substitution", "question": "What alternative artifact, channel, institution, resource, or behavior replaces a blocked path?", "observables": [ "Before/after channel and opportunity records." ], "does_not_establish": [ "Equivalent meaning, burden, effect, or consent." ], "aggregate_weight": null, "rank": null, "effect_size": null, "prediction": false, "optimization_target": false }, { "id": "interruption", "label": "Interruption", "question": "Where does a path pause or break through refusal, failure, expiry, censorship, loss, or unknown?", "observables": [ "Last witnessed state, expected next trace, and coverage record." ], "does_not_establish": [ "Nonexistence, lack of belief, or permanent cessation." ], "aggregate_weight": null, "rank": null, "effect_size": null, "prediction": false, "optimization_target": false }, { "id": "reversal", "label": "Reversal", "question": "Which status, decision, capability, artifact, or material change can be undone and what residual remains?", "observables": [ "Withdrawal, rollback, restoration attempt, and residual record." ], "does_not_establish": [ "Return to the prior world, erased history, or restored consent." ], "aggregate_weight": null, "rank": null, "effect_size": null, "prediction": false, "optimization_target": false }, { "id": "recurrence", "label": "Recurrence", "question": "Can a pattern reappear after delay, repair, or apparent cessation?", "observables": [ "Repeated scoped events and non-repetition checks." ], "does_not_establish": [ "One stable mechanism or inevitable repetition." ], "aggregate_weight": null, "rank": null, "effect_size": null, "prediction": false, "optimization_target": false }, { "id": "reinforcing-loop", "label": "Reinforcing loop", "question": "Do separately evidenced transitions return in an amplifying direction?", "observables": [ "Closed path with evidence for every transition and changed later state." ], "does_not_establish": [ "A causal loop from repeated labels or correlation." ], "aggregate_weight": null, "rank": null, "effect_size": null, "prediction": false, "optimization_target": false }, { "id": "balancing-loop", "label": "Balancing loop", "question": "Do separately evidenced counterflows constrain or redirect a return path?", "observables": [ "Constraint, refusal, correction, repair, and later-state records." ], "does_not_establish": [ "Equilibrium, fairness, successful repair, or equal power." ], "aggregate_weight": null, "rank": null, "effect_size": null, "prediction": false, "optimization_target": false } ], "negative_flow_vocabulary": [ { "id": "not-observed", "meaning": "No qualifying trace was observed inside a declared window and method.", "adequate_coverage_required": true, "does_not_establish": [ "Nonoccurrence, zero effect, disbelief, consent, or permanent absence." ] }, { "id": "detection-bounded-absence", "meaning": "Expected traces were not detected under an explicitly adequate bounded observation design.", "adequate_coverage_required": true, "does_not_establish": [ "Absolute nonexistence, impossibility, motive, or zero effect outside the bound." ] }, { "id": "no-opportunity", "meaning": "The relevant exposure, choice, gate, resource, or occasion was unavailable.", "adequate_coverage_required": true, "does_not_establish": [ "Refusal, incapacity, disagreement, or lack of demand." ] }, { "id": "blocked", "meaning": "A named gate, constraint, veto, dependency, or failure prevented a candidate transition.", "adequate_coverage_required": true, "does_not_establish": [ "Permanent prevention, legitimacy of the block, or absence of alternate paths." ] }, { "id": "censored", "meaning": "A record, expression, distribution, response, or outcome may be suppressed by a named actor or rule.", "adequate_coverage_required": true, "does_not_establish": [ "The hidden content, its truth, its reception, or the censor's motive." ] }, { "id": "destroyed-or-lost", "meaning": "A carrier or record is unavailable because destruction, decay, loss, or failed preservation is evidenced or plausible.", "adequate_coverage_required": true, "does_not_establish": [ "What the missing record contained or whether an event occurred." ] }, { "id": "inaccessible", "meaning": "A trace may exist but access is restricted by rights, privacy, law, cost, language, location, or infrastructure.", "adequate_coverage_required": true, "does_not_establish": [ "Absence, secrecy motive, permission to bypass controls, or public status." ] }, { "id": "private-or-refused", "meaning": "A participant keeps information private or refuses expression, participation, inspection, or continuation.", "adequate_coverage_required": true, "does_not_establish": [ "Consent, hostility, incapacity, guilt, debt, or permission to retry." ] }, { "id": "excluded", "meaning": "A person, community, artifact, option, or issue is outside a selected agenda, institution, channel, or sample.", "adequate_coverage_required": true, "does_not_establish": [ "Irrelevance, low value, consensus, or legitimate exclusion." ] }, { "id": "measurement-failure", "meaning": "The instrument, construct, sampling, archive, attribution, or data pipeline cannot support the intended observation.", "adequate_coverage_required": true, "does_not_establish": [ "A zero value, absence of the construct, or license to substitute a proxy silently." ] }, { "id": "unknown", "meaning": "The current record cannot distinguish occurrence, absence, blocking, refusal, loss, inaccessibility, or measurement failure.", "adequate_coverage_required": true, "does_not_establish": [ "Any preferred explanation, action permission, or adverse inference." ] } ], "material_condition_vocabulary": [ { "id": "body-and-care", "label": "Body and care", "question": "Which bodily access, health, disability, safety, care, rest, and dependency conditions shape participation or aftermath?", "observables": [ "Accessible, consented, context-specific condition and care records." ], "does_not_establish": [ "Diagnosis, capacity, worth, consent, or deterministic response." ], "aggregate_weight": null, "rank": null, "effect_size": null, "prediction": false, "optimization_target": false }, { "id": "labor-and-time", "label": "Labor and time", "question": "Whose work, maintenance, attention, delay, waiting, care, or unpaid time carries the stage?", "observables": [ "Role, schedule, workload, compensation, queue, and maintenance records." ], "does_not_establish": [ "Fairness, willingness, productivity, or consent from continued labor." ], "aggregate_weight": null, "rank": null, "effect_size": null, "prediction": false, "optimization_target": false }, { "id": "land-and-geography", "label": "Land and geography", "question": "How do place, distance, borders, jurisdiction, land access, settlement, and spatial concentration shape opportunity and burden?", "observables": [ "Scoped geographic, access, jurisdiction, and displacement records." ], "does_not_establish": [ "Natural boundaries, territorial authority, identity, or geographic determinism." ], "aggregate_weight": null, "rank": null, "effect_size": null, "prediction": false, "optimization_target": false }, { "id": "energy-and-resources", "label": "Energy and resources", "question": "Which energy, materials, food, water, equipment, and extractive dependencies enable or burden the stage?", "observables": [ "Bounded resource, supply, use, waste, and scarcity records." ], "does_not_establish": [ "Sustainability, entitlement, efficient use, or causal sufficiency." ], "aggregate_weight": null, "rank": null, "effect_size": null, "prediction": false, "optimization_target": false }, { "id": "climate-and-ecology", "label": "Climate and ecology", "question": "Which climate, habitat, species, pollution, waste, and ecological feedback conditions lie inside or outside the boundary?", "observables": [ "Scoped environmental baselines, lifecycle traces, and affected ecosystem records." ], "does_not_establish": [ "Complete ecological accounting, net benefit, or reversible harm." ], "aggregate_weight": null, "rank": null, "effect_size": null, "prediction": false, "optimization_target": false }, { "id": "money-credit-and-property", "label": "Money, credit, and property", "question": "Which ownership, income, debt, tax, credit, price, patronage, and property relations shape options and control?", "observables": [ "Scoped ownership, funding, compensation, obligation, price, and incidence records." ], "does_not_establish": [ "A universal class identity, deservedness, motive, authority, or fair distribution." ], "aggregate_weight": null, "rank": null, "effect_size": null, "prediction": false, "optimization_target": false }, { "id": "infrastructure-and-logistics", "label": "Infrastructure and logistics", "question": "Which transport, storage, communications, housing, institutions, supply chains, and maintenance systems carry or constrain the path?", "observables": [ "Dependency, capacity, outage, queue, maintenance, and access records." ], "does_not_establish": [ "Neutrality, reliability, equal access, or inevitable path dependence." ], "aggregate_weight": null, "rank": null, "effect_size": null, "prediction": false, "optimization_target": false }, { "id": "data-and-technology", "label": "Data and technology", "question": "Which formats, models, platforms, sensors, identifiers, code, compute, networks, and permissions mediate observation or action?", "observables": [ "Version, provenance, access, capability, error, drift, and system-boundary records." ], "does_not_establish": [ "Truth, objectivity, safety, consent, authority, understanding, or external effect." ], "aggregate_weight": null, "rank": null, "effect_size": null, "prediction": false, "optimization_target": false } ], "emotion_observation_vocabulary": [ { "id": "self-report", "meaning": "A participant reports an experience in their own terms for a declared context and horizon.", "required_context": [ "Attribution, scope, privacy, method, language, and withdrawal limits." ], "does_not_establish": [ "Diagnosis, permanence, population state, causation, consent to another use, or a targeting signal." ] }, { "id": "attributed-expression", "meaning": "A public or private expression is attributed as using emotion language or form.", "required_context": [ "Exact artifact, genre, audience, attribution, and interpretive alternatives." ], "does_not_establish": [ "Private experience, sincerity, intent, hostility, belief, or collective emotion." ] }, { "id": "behavioral-observation", "meaning": "A bounded behavior is observed without treating it as a transparent mental-state proxy.", "required_context": [ "Opportunity set, observation method, alternatives, missingness, and situational constraints." ], "does_not_establish": [ "Emotion, motive, susceptibility, diagnosis, or consent." ] }, { "id": "physiology", "meaning": "A consented physiological measure is recorded under a declared method and context.", "required_context": [ "Consent, device, calibration, population, uncertainty, privacy, and clinical limits." ], "does_not_establish": [ "A unique emotion, diagnosis, intent, moral state, or permission to target." ] }, { "id": "cultural-vocabulary", "meaning": "A language, tradition, genre, or community has terms and practices for describing affect.", "required_context": [ "Source language, community, period, genre, interpreter, translation, and counterreadings." ], "does_not_establish": [ "Universal categories, doctrinal identity, individual experience, or group emotion." ] }, { "id": "institutional-framing", "meaning": "An institution labels, invites, rewards, disciplines, or suppresses particular emotional expression.", "required_context": [ "Rule, authority claim, setting, affected parties, enforcement, alternatives, and challenge routes." ], "does_not_establish": [ "Actual experience, legitimacy, effectiveness, motive, or consent." ] } ], "affect_context_vocabulary": [ { "id": "fear-or-threat", "label": "Fear or threat", "question": "Could threat appraisal, vigilance, avoidance, protection, or urgency be relevant under separately typed evidence?", "observables": [ "Self-report or attributed expression kept distinct from behavior and institutional framing." ], "does_not_establish": [ "Private fear, group fear, danger, hostility, susceptibility, or predictable compliance." ], "aggregate_weight": null, "rank": null, "effect_size": null, "prediction": false, "optimization_target": false }, { "id": "anger-or-outrage", "label": "Anger or outrage", "question": "Could perceived wrong, blame, protest, confrontation, or demand for change be relevant under separately typed evidence?", "observables": [ "Attributed expression, self-report, or bounded behavior with alternatives." ], "does_not_establish": [ "Private anger, violence, irrationality, motive, or group disposition." ], "aggregate_weight": null, "rank": null, "effect_size": null, "prediction": false, "optimization_target": false }, { "id": "humiliation-or-status-injury", "label": "Humiliation or status injury", "question": "Could public degradation, exclusion, stigma, defeat, or denied recognition be relevant in a scoped context?", "observables": [ "Attributed accounts, status rules, exclusion records, and counterinterpretations." ], "does_not_establish": [ "A private experience, revenge motive, collective state, or inevitable escalation." ], "aggregate_weight": null, "rank": null, "effect_size": null, "prediction": false, "optimization_target": false }, { "id": "grief-or-loss", "label": "Grief or loss", "question": "Could bereavement, dispossession, cultural loss, option loss, or mourning shape expression, memory, or repair needs?", "observables": [ "Self-report, ritual or public expression, material loss, and community interpretation." ], "does_not_establish": [ "Uniform grief, closure, incapacity, consent, or a required response." ], "aggregate_weight": null, "rank": null, "effect_size": null, "prediction": false, "optimization_target": false }, { "id": "hope-or-efficacy", "label": "Hope or efficacy", "question": "Could perceived possibility, collective efficacy, trust, experimentation, or future orientation be relevant?", "observables": [ "Self-report, proposal, participation, or institutionally framed invitation kept distinct." ], "does_not_establish": [ "Agreement, confidence, success probability, consent, or future action." ], "aggregate_weight": null, "rank": null, "effect_size": null, "prediction": false, "optimization_target": false }, { "id": "love-care-or-solidarity", "label": "Love, care, or solidarity", "question": "Could attachment, care work, mutual aid, loyalty, compassion, or solidarity support or constrain a path?", "observables": [ "Declared relationship, care practice, material support, and self-description." ], "does_not_establish": [ "Pure motive, universal benefit, absence of domination, obligation, consent, or permanence." ], "aggregate_weight": null, "rank": null, "effect_size": null, "prediction": false, "optimization_target": false }, { "id": "hate-or-moral-exclusion", "label": "Hate or moral exclusion", "question": "Could dehumanizing expression, exclusion, stigma, threat framing, or unequal protection be relevant under specific evidence?", "observables": [ "Exact expression, rule, distribution, affected-party record, and counterevidence." ], "does_not_establish": [ "Private hate, group essence, future violence, guilt, motive, or permission to censor or target." ], "aggregate_weight": null, "rank": null, "effect_size": null, "prediction": false, "optimization_target": false }, { "id": "belonging-or-identity-security", "label": "Belonging or identity security", "question": "Could recognition, membership, continuity, exclusion, assimilation pressure, or plural accommodation matter?", "observables": [ "Self-description, membership rule, access practice, expression, and dissent." ], "does_not_establish": [ "Identity, uniform attachment, loyalty, consent, or authority over another community." ], "aggregate_weight": null, "rank": null, "effect_size": null, "prediction": false, "optimization_target": false }, { "id": "shame-or-guilt", "label": "Shame or guilt", "question": "Could self-evaluation, attributed blame, accountability, stigma, apology, or repair language be relevant?", "observables": [ "Self-report, attributed expression, institutional sanction, and public record kept separate." ], "does_not_establish": [ "Private shame or guilt, culpability, confession, restored trust, or completed repair." ], "aggregate_weight": null, "rank": null, "effect_size": null, "prediction": false, "optimization_target": false } ], "social_position_vocabulary": [ { "id": "economic-resources-ownership-labor-and-debt", "label": "Economic resources, ownership, labor, and debt", "question": "What ownership, work, income, wealth, tax, debt, patronage, and essential-resource relations shape options?", "observables": [ "Scoped, contestable economic and material records." ], "does_not_establish": [ "A universal class taxonomy, worth, motive, interest, or elite identity." ], "aggregate_weight": null, "rank": null, "effect_size": null, "prediction": false, "optimization_target": false }, { "id": "status", "label": "Status", "question": "What prestige, rank, stigma, recognition, or inherited position is institutionally or socially recorded?", "observables": [ "Named status rules, practices, recognition, and contestation." ], "does_not_establish": [ "Worth, competence, motive, class, office, or authority." ], "aggregate_weight": null, "rank": null, "effect_size": null, "prediction": false, "optimization_target": false }, { "id": "office", "label": "Office", "question": "What formal role, mandate, responsibility, procedure, scope, expiry, and revocation are declared?", "observables": [ "Institutional role and authority-claim records." ], "does_not_establish": [ "Authentic authority, capability, legitimacy, motive, or actual control." ], "aggregate_weight": null, "rank": null, "effect_size": null, "prediction": false, "optimization_target": false }, { "id": "network-position", "label": "Network position", "question": "What dependencies, brokerage, isolation, centrality, or channel access appear in a bounded relation graph?", "observables": [ "Declared nodes, edges, boundary, missingness, and time window." ], "does_not_establish": [ "Influence, causation, power total, identity, motive, or stable position." ], "aggregate_weight": null, "rank": null, "effect_size": null, "prediction": false, "optimization_target": false }, { "id": "agenda-control", "label": "Agenda control", "question": "Who can introduce, exclude, delay, reframe, bundle, or retire issues before visible decision?", "observables": [ "Submission, selection, queue, non-decision, exclusion, and procedural records." ], "does_not_establish": [ "A hidden motive, complete agenda, legitimate exclusion, or causal effect." ], "aggregate_weight": null, "rank": null, "effect_size": null, "prediction": false, "optimization_target": false }, { "id": "coercive-capacity", "label": "Coercive capacity", "question": "Which sanction, policing, military, surveillance, incarceration, exclusion, or resource-denial capacities are separately evidenced?", "observables": [ "Law, command, capability, use, refusal, affected-party, and aftermath records." ], "does_not_establish": [ "Permission, necessity, proportionality, legitimacy, motive, or effectiveness." ], "aggregate_weight": null, "rank": null, "effect_size": null, "prediction": false, "optimization_target": false }, { "id": "discursive-power", "label": "Discursive power", "question": "Whose categories, languages, stories, credentials, and standards become legible, credible, publishable, or authoritative?", "observables": [ "Naming, translation, canon, moderation, citation, curriculum, and challenge records." ], "does_not_establish": [ "Truth, belief, understanding, total domination, motive, or authority to represent a community." ], "aggregate_weight": null, "rank": null, "effect_size": null, "prediction": false, "optimization_target": false } ], "power_asymmetry_vocabulary": [ { "id": "naming-and-interpretive", "label": "Naming and interpretive asymmetry", "question": "Who can name, classify, translate, define genre, or set the accepted interpretation?", "observables": [ "Attribution, editorial, translation, credential, and counterreading records." ], "does_not_establish": [ "Truth, motive, understanding, or legitimate representation." ], "aggregate_weight": null, "rank": null, "effect_size": null, "prediction": false, "optimization_target": false }, { "id": "attention-and-distribution", "label": "Attention and distribution asymmetry", "question": "Who controls channels, reach, ranking, repetition, access, or visibility?", "observables": [ "Ownership, distribution, exposure, moderation, and selection records." ], "does_not_establish": [ "Attention, belief, persuasion, consent, or causal effect." ], "aggregate_weight": null, "rank": null, "effect_size": null, "prediction": false, "optimization_target": false }, { "id": "canon-and-curriculum", "label": "Canon and curriculum asymmetry", "question": "Who selects, preserves, teaches, excludes, or retires material and alternatives?", "observables": [ "Selection criteria, archives, curricula, omissions, and challenges." ], "does_not_establish": [ "Truth, merit, consensus, or legitimate exclusion." ], "aggregate_weight": null, "rank": null, "effect_size": null, "prediction": false, "optimization_target": false }, { "id": "agenda-and-procedure", "label": "Agenda and procedure asymmetry", "question": "Who can propose, delay, frame, bundle, veto, decide, appeal, or keep an issue off the agenda?", "observables": [ "Procedure, queue, proposal, non-decision, decision, veto, and appeal records." ], "does_not_establish": [ "Authority, legitimacy, motive, consent, or procedural justice." ], "aggregate_weight": null, "rank": null, "effect_size": null, "prediction": false, "optimization_target": false }, { "id": "legal-jurisdiction-and-coercion", "label": "Legal, jurisdiction, and coercion asymmetry", "question": "Who claims rule-making scope, sanction, enforcement, exemption, protection, or coercive capacity?", "observables": [ "Authority claims, jurisdiction, rights, capability, enforcement, and affected-party records." ], "does_not_establish": [ "Authentic authority, lawful basis, proportionality, legitimacy, or effectiveness." ], "aggregate_weight": null, "rank": null, "effect_size": null, "prediction": false, "optimization_target": false }, { "id": "resources-and-class", "label": "Resources and class asymmetry", "question": "Who owns or controls funds, credit, labor, property, essentials, patronage, and repair resources?", "observables": [ "Ownership, funding, labor, debt, incidence, access, and dependency records." ], "does_not_establish": [ "Universal class identity, motive, worth, or a net power score." ], "aggregate_weight": null, "rank": null, "effect_size": null, "prediction": false, "optimization_target": false }, { "id": "status-and-hierarchy", "label": "Status and hierarchy asymmetry", "question": "Who receives rank, prestige, stigma, deference, access, immunity, or burden?", "observables": [ "Status rules, practices, mobility, challenge, and distribution records." ], "does_not_establish": [ "Worth, competence, motive, class, office, or legitimate hierarchy." ], "aggregate_weight": null, "rank": null, "effect_size": null, "prediction": false, "optimization_target": false }, { "id": "technical-and-infrastructure", "label": "Technical and infrastructure asymmetry", "question": "Who owns systems, sets standards, holds credentials, supplies compute, or can stop, inspect, or repair them?", "observables": [ "Version, ownership, access, capability, dependency, outage, and maintenance records." ], "does_not_establish": [ "Authority, neutrality, safety, objectivity, or permission." ], "aggregate_weight": null, "rank": null, "effect_size": null, "prediction": false, "optimization_target": false }, { "id": "epistemic-and-measurement", "label": "Epistemic and measurement asymmetry", "question": "Who defines constructs, sources, samples, metrics, uncertainty, publication, and accepted evidence?", "observables": [ "Method, selection, instrumentation, missingness, review, and counterevidence records." ], "does_not_establish": [ "Truth, objectivity, completeness, causal identification, or authority." ], "aggregate_weight": null, "rank": null, "effect_size": null, "prediction": false, "optimization_target": false }, { "id": "temporal-path-and-exit", "label": "Temporal, path, and exit asymmetry", "question": "Who can wait, delay, commit, revoke, switch, exit, recover sunk costs, or impose future maintenance and option loss?", "observables": [ "Delay, expiry, switching cost, debt, lock-in, exit, retaliation, and repair records." ], "does_not_establish": [ "Voluntary continuation, feasible exit, consent, inevitability, or reversible harm." ], "aggregate_weight": null, "rank": null, "effect_size": null, "prediction": false, "optimization_target": false } ], "evidence_uncertainty_vocabulary": [ { "id": "source", "meaning": "Uncertainty about provenance, authenticity, completeness, interpretation, access, or source position.", "aggregation_weight": null }, { "id": "measurement", "meaning": "Uncertainty about construct, instrument, error, attribution, resolution, drift, and proxy validity.", "aggregation_weight": null }, { "id": "selection-and-missingness", "meaning": "Uncertainty from sampling, archival survival, censorship, exclusion, privacy, nonresponse, and unknown opportunity sets.", "aggregation_weight": null }, { "id": "temporal", "meaning": "Uncertainty about event, exposure, onset, latency, overlap, duration, decay, recurrence, censoring, and record time.", "aggregation_weight": null }, { "id": "identification-and-model", "meaning": "Uncertainty about mediators, rival mechanisms, confounding, feedback, estimand, comparator, assumptions, and sensitivity.", "aggregation_weight": null }, { "id": "transport", "meaning": "Uncertainty about whether a relation or finding travels across population, place, period, institution, technology, or material condition.", "aggregation_weight": null }, { "id": "affected-party-incompleteness", "meaning": "Uncertainty about omitted direct, indirect, non-user, future, supply-chain, and ecological parties or residuals.", "aggregation_weight": null }, { "id": "normative-disagreement", "meaning": "Uncertainty or irreducible disagreement about rights, values, legitimacy, justice, benefit, burden, repair, and acceptable risk.", "aggregation_weight": null }, { "id": "authority-and-jurisdiction", "meaning": "Uncertainty about principal, issuer, scope, jurisdiction, authenticity, expiry, revocation, representation, consent, and lawful basis.", "aggregation_weight": null } ], "action_gate_vocabulary": [ { "id": "attribution-and-provenance", "meaning": "The relevant expression, artifact, transformation, source, and limits are attributable and versioned.", "external_verification_required": true, "atlas_satisfies": false }, { "id": "publication-and-access", "meaning": "Rights, privacy, community access, audience, distribution, retention, and withdrawal conditions are separately reviewed.", "external_verification_required": true, "atlas_satisfies": false }, { "id": "reviewed-proposal", "meaning": "A bounded proposal states purpose, scope, alternatives, affected parties, resources, risks, stop conditions, and repair readiness.", "external_verification_required": true, "atlas_satisfies": false }, { "id": "decision-procedure", "meaning": "A declared procedure, decision maker, agenda, dissent, reasons, appeal, expiry, and review record exists.", "external_verification_required": true, "atlas_satisfies": false }, { "id": "current-authority-and-jurisdiction", "meaning": "Current principal, issuer, scope, jurisdiction, authenticity, expiry, conflicts, and revocation are externally verified.", "external_verification_required": true, "atlas_satisfies": false }, { "id": "affected-party-register", "meaning": "Direct, indirect, non-user, future, and ecological parties, omissions, representatives, disagreement, and retaliation risks are reviewed.", "external_verification_required": true, "atlas_satisfies": false }, { "id": "rights-assessment", "meaning": "Rights, duties, exclusions, remedies, accessibility, privacy, and non-discrimination are assessed under named frameworks.", "external_verification_required": true, "atlas_satisfies": false }, { "id": "consent-or-lawful-basis", "meaning": "Each required consent or separately named non-consent lawful basis is valid for the exact purpose, act, party, and horizon.", "external_verification_required": true, "atlas_satisfies": false }, { "id": "capability-and-resources", "meaning": "Technical, human, financial, material, informational, maintenance, and repair capability is evidenced without importing permission.", "external_verification_required": true, "atlas_satisfies": false }, { "id": "budget-and-horizon", "meaning": "Cost, resource, attention, time, maintenance, lifecycle, exit, and future obligation bounds are explicit.", "external_verification_required": true, "atlas_satisfies": false }, { "id": "safety-and-stop-route", "meaning": "Preflight, monitoring accountability, refusal, withdrawal, cancellation, containment, appeal, and emergency stop routes are current.", "external_verification_required": true, "atlas_satisfies": false }, { "id": "repair-readiness", "meaning": "Evidence preservation, fresh authority, affected-party review, correction, restitution, compensation, rehabilitation, satisfaction, residual, recurrence, and non-repetition routes are resourced.", "external_verification_required": true, "atlas_satisfies": false } ], "policy_templates": [ { "id": "evidence-counterevidence", "family": "promotion-evidence", "question": "What source-bound record would show the represented carrier, gate, stage, relation, or interpretation was absent, differently typed, independent, or outside the boundary?", "does_not_establish": "Listing counterevidence requirements does not decide the claim." }, { "id": "evidence-falsifier", "family": "promotion-evidence", "question": "What authenticated incompatible record, failed expected trace under adequate coverage, or absent required gate would defeat a later occurrence claim?", "does_not_establish": "A proposed falsifier is not an observed falsification." }, { "id": "evidence-transport-bound", "family": "promotion-evidence", "question": "What expression, artifact, institution, population, jurisdiction, material context, technology, place, period, and horizon bound transport?", "does_not_establish": "A declared bound does not justify transport within or beyond it." }, { "id": "promotion-requires-source-bound-successor", "family": "promotion-evidence", "question": "Has a new source-bound successor pinned evidence, method, negative cases, counterevidence, falsifiers, and transport limits before promotion?", "does_not_establish": "This atlas cannot promote a mechanism, historical finding, causal claim, authority, or action." }, { "id": "negative-expected-trace", "family": "negative-flow", "question": "What stage-specific trace would be expected if the represented event or transition were observable?", "does_not_establish": "An expected trace is not an observed event or effect." }, { "id": "negative-opportunity-set", "family": "negative-flow", "question": "Who or what had a real, safe, accessible opportunity to produce, receive, refuse, or report the trace?", "does_not_establish": "A nominal opportunity is not access, participation, exposure, or consent." }, { "id": "negative-observation-horizon", "family": "negative-flow", "question": "What event, detection, reporting, retention, and review horizons bound observation?", "does_not_establish": "A window does not establish adequate temporal coverage." }, { "id": "negative-observation-method", "family": "negative-flow", "question": "What source-bound method includes negative cases, counterevidence, construct validity, and missingness?", "does_not_establish": "A proposed method is not a measurement or result." }, { "id": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "family": "negative-flow", "question": "Are opportunity, population, channel, detector, sensitivity, and false-negative coverage adequate for a bounded absence statement?", "does_not_establish": "Unknown or inadequate coverage cannot support absence, zero, or nonexistence." }, { "id": "negative-access-limits", "family": "negative-flow", "question": "What privacy, refusal, censorship, destruction, exclusion, language, infrastructure, and jurisdiction limits constrain access?", "does_not_establish": "An access limit does not identify why a trace is missing." }, { "id": "negative-rival-statuses", "family": "negative-flow", "question": "Could no opportunity, blocking, censoring, loss, inaccessibility, refusal, exclusion, measurement failure, or unknown explain the missing trace?", "does_not_establish": "A candidate status is not asserted to have occurred." }, { "id": "party-benefit-question", "family": "party-aftermath", "question": "What separately evidenced benefit, access, protection, resource, recognition, or restored option arises for this affected party?", "does_not_establish": "A possible benefit is not observed benefit, consent, or a reason to net burdens away." }, { "id": "party-burden-question", "family": "party-aftermath", "question": "What labor, cost, exposure, delay, extraction, compliance, care, or opportunity burden falls on this affected party?", "does_not_establish": "A possible burden is not measured incidence or a complete harm account." }, { "id": "party-risk-question", "family": "party-aftermath", "question": "What rights, safety, privacy, exclusion, displacement, retaliation, dependency, or irreversible risk faces this affected party?", "does_not_establish": "A risk question is not a probability, diagnosis, prediction, or effect." }, { "id": "party-option-voice-exit-question", "family": "party-aftermath", "question": "What voice, refusal, correction, appeal, alternative, safe exit, and remedy options remain usable for this affected party?", "does_not_establish": "A formal option is not accessible exercise, agreement, or consent." }, { "id": "party-horizon-question", "family": "party-aftermath", "question": "Which immediate, delayed, cumulative, recurrence, recovery, lifecycle, future, and ecological horizons matter for this party?", "does_not_establish": "A named horizon is not adequate observation or completed aftermath." }, { "id": "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown", "family": "party-aftermath", "question": "What party-indexed evidence is missing, private, unsafe, inaccessible, excluded, delayed, or unknown?", "does_not_establish": "No report is not no benefit, burden, risk, residual, dissent, or affected party." }, { "id": "party-residual-question", "family": "party-aftermath", "question": "What harm, burden, lost option, disagreement, displaced effect, or recurrence could remain after correction or repair for this party?", "does_not_establish": "A residual question is not an observed residual or completed repair." }, { "id": "party-selected-question-reason", "family": "party-aftermath", "question": "Which party-specific aftermath dimensions are relevant because this card explicitly selects the affected party?", "does_not_establish": "Selection opens only the listed questions; it does not assert equal salience, an effect, or complete party coverage." }, { "id": "repair-attempt-question", "family": "repair", "question": "What uniquely identified repair attempt, actor, target, parameters, preflight, stop route, and failure status would be recorded?", "does_not_establish": "A repair proposal or attempt is not execution, outcome, or repair." }, { "id": "repair-outcome-question", "family": "repair", "question": "What separately witnessed repair execution and party-indexed outcome would be observed without calling the attempt effective?", "does_not_establish": "An outcome observation is not a repair effect, restoration, or justice." }, { "id": "repair-residual-evidence-unknown", "family": "repair", "question": "What party-indexed residual evidence or unknown remains after the proposed repair path?", "does_not_establish": "No report is not absence of a residual, recurrence, dissent, or harm." }, { "id": "repair-dissent-question", "family": "repair", "question": "What refusal, disagreement, representation limit, alternative repair, appeal, and non-action must remain visible?", "does_not_establish": "Participation, silence, withdrawal, settlement, or closure is not restored consent or absolution." }, { "id": "repair-recurrence-question", "family": "repair", "question": "What original failure mode, displaced harm, degraded safeguard, unmet obligation, or fresh incident must be checked for recurrence?", "does_not_establish": "No detected recurrence is not non-repetition without adequate longitudinal coverage." }, { "id": "repair-review-or-retirement-question", "family": "repair", "question": "Do residuals, recurrence, changed gates, new parties, or failed outcomes require correction, supersession, withdrawal, reopening, or retirement?", "does_not_establish": "Review status does not complete repair or authorize a new action." }, { "id": "dimension-evidence-boundary", "family": "dimension-boundary", "question": "What source-bound evidence and explicit disposition supports each selected qualitative dimension?", "does_not_establish": "A selected lens is not salience, occurrence, effect size, score, rank, or prediction." }, { "id": "dimension-emotion-observation", "family": "dimension-boundary", "question": "Which typed emotion-observation methods are relevant to this card?", "does_not_establish": "Expression, behavior, physiology, self-report, vocabulary, or institutional framing does not reveal a private or collective state." }, { "id": "dimension-affect-context", "family": "dimension-boundary", "question": "Which named affect contexts require source-bound inquiry?", "does_not_establish": "Affect vocabulary is not measured intensity, inferred emotion, motive, identity, susceptibility, or effect." }, { "id": "dimension-social-position", "family": "dimension-boundary", "question": "Which separately typed social-position axes could shape opportunity, burden, voice, and access?", "does_not_establish": "A position is not motive, worth, identity, authority, legitimacy, or a total power score." }, { "id": "dimension-power-asymmetry", "family": "dimension-boundary", "question": "Which unequal abilities to name, allocate, decide, coerce, measure, wait, exit, or obtain repair require inquiry?", "does_not_establish": "A power relation is not motive, worth, truth, legitimate authority, or a scalar power total." }, { "id": "dimension-material-conditions", "family": "dimension-boundary", "question": "Which body, care, labor, land, resource, ecology, property, infrastructure, or technology conditions matter?", "does_not_establish": "A material condition is not deterministic cause, permission, value, effect, or prediction." }, { "id": "dimension-flow-dynamics", "family": "dimension-boundary", "question": "Which qualitative timing, memory, branch, displacement, coupling, or feedback dynamics require inquiry?", "does_not_establish": "A dynamic lens is not occurrence, effect size, threshold estimate, causal effect, or prediction." }, { "id": "dimension-topology", "family": "dimension-boundary", "question": "Which possible fork, join, parallel path, bottleneck, leak, substitution, interruption, reversal, recurrence, or loop requires inquiry?", "does_not_establish": "A represented topology is not claimed to have occurred." }, { "id": "dimension-negative-flow", "family": "dimension-boundary", "question": "Which rival missing-flow status requires opportunity, expected-trace, method, coverage, access, and horizon review?", "does_not_establish": "Missing observation is not zero, nonexistence, disbelief, satisfaction, or consent." }, { "id": "dimension-evidence-uncertainty", "family": "dimension-boundary", "question": "Which uncertainty vector components require separate evidence and disposition?", "does_not_establish": "Uncertainty cannot be averaged into permission, confidence, prediction, or adverse inference." }, { "id": "translation-preserved-question", "family": "translation-threshold-path", "question": "Which form, provenance, distinction, ambiguity, rhythm, relation, or access condition is preserved?", "does_not_establish": "Preservation of one feature is not fidelity or equivalence." }, { "id": "translation-changed-question", "family": "translation-threshold-path", "question": "Which wording, genre, category, emphasis, audience, or institutional status changes?", "does_not_establish": "A documented change is not distortion, improvement, motive, or effect." }, { "id": "translation-introduced-question", "family": "translation-threshold-path", "question": "Which interpretation, category, example, authority cue, or access assumption is introduced?", "does_not_establish": "An introduction is not intent, deception, or legitimate representation." }, { "id": "translation-omitted-question", "family": "translation-threshold-path", "question": "Which term, context, dissent, ambiguity, party, or access condition is omitted?", "does_not_establish": "An omission is not intent, falsity, or causal effect." }, { "id": "translation-untranslatable-question", "family": "translation-threshold-path", "question": "Which claimed remainder or non-equivalence must remain visible rather than be forced into equivalence?", "does_not_establish": "A claimed remainder is not metaphysical incommensurability." }, { "id": "translation-counterreadings-question", "family": "translation-threshold-path", "question": "Which source-community, translator, audience, dissenting, and alternate-translation readings must remain separate?", "does_not_establish": "Plural readings do not establish equal support, consensus, or truth." }, { "id": "translation-rights-and-access-question", "family": "translation-threshold-path", "question": "What attribution, rights, sacred or private access, audience, withdrawal, and representational-authority constraints apply?", "does_not_establish": "Translation, patronage, possession, or publication grants no representational authority." }, { "id": "translation-inactive-boundary", "family": "translation-threshold-path", "question": "Is translation unassessed or not applicable for this card?", "does_not_establish": "The card assumes no translation event, fidelity, equivalence, patron position, audience uptake, or representational authority." }, { "id": "threshold-trigger-question", "family": "translation-threshold-path", "question": "What exactly would count as the bounded trigger, and what rival trigger definitions exist?", "does_not_establish": "A trigger definition is not an observed or universal threshold." }, { "id": "threshold-unit-question", "family": "translation-threshold-path", "question": "What physical, event, administrative, or declared instrument unit is valid without summing social meaning?", "does_not_establish": "A valid unit is not an effect size or person susceptibility measure." }, { "id": "threshold-population-question", "family": "translation-threshold-path", "question": "Which bounded heterogeneous population or system is at issue?", "does_not_establish": "A population boundary is not a homogeneous response assumption." }, { "id": "threshold-opportunity-question", "family": "translation-threshold-path", "question": "Who or what had a real opportunity to encounter the proposed trigger under declared conditions?", "does_not_establish": "Opportunity is not exposure, response, or consent." }, { "id": "threshold-heterogeneity-question", "family": "translation-threshold-path", "question": "How could trigger conditions vary across parties, places, institutions, and material contexts without person estimates?", "does_not_establish": "A heterogeneity question is not a group or person susceptibility estimate." }, { "id": "threshold-horizon-question", "family": "translation-threshold-path", "question": "What onset, latency, duration, censoring, and follow-up window would permit observation?", "does_not_establish": "A horizon is not a prediction or proof of temporal identification." }, { "id": "threshold-reset-question", "family": "translation-threshold-path", "question": "What reset, persistence, switching-cost, and reversal evidence would distinguish a threshold from ordinary variation?", "does_not_establish": "Reset or hysteresis language is not evidence that either occurred." }, { "id": "threshold-evidence-requirement", "family": "translation-threshold-path", "question": "What observations, negative cases, counterevidence, falsifiers, and identification assumptions would support a threshold question?", "does_not_establish": "This atlas estimates no threshold, effect size, or future tipping point." }, { "id": "threshold-inactive-boundary", "family": "translation-threshold-path", "question": "Is threshold analysis unassessed or not applicable for this card?", "does_not_establish": "The card assumes no threshold, tipping point, heterogeneous trigger, person estimate, effect size, or prediction." }, { "id": "path-reinforcement-question", "family": "translation-threshold-path", "question": "Which exact standard, learning process, network, expectation, rule, resource, or feedback could reproduce the state?", "does_not_establish": "Persistence alone is not a reinforcement mechanism." }, { "id": "path-switching-cost-question", "family": "translation-threshold-path", "question": "What party-indexed financial, labor, status, rights, time, technical, ecological, or relational switching cost is evidenced?", "does_not_establish": "A possible cost is not observed incidence or inevitability." }, { "id": "path-sunk-resource-question", "family": "translation-threshold-path", "question": "What resource, infrastructure, training, commitment, archive, or obligation cannot be costlessly recovered?", "does_not_establish": "A sunk resource is not sufficient evidence of path dependence." }, { "id": "path-option-loss-question", "family": "translation-threshold-path", "question": "Which alternatives become unavailable, unsafe, inaccessible, delayed, or more burdensome, for whom and when?", "does_not_establish": "A possible option loss is not observed foreclosure or consent to continue." }, { "id": "path-alternative-timing-question", "family": "translation-threshold-path", "question": "What earlier or later choice point, sequence, or external event could have produced a different path?", "does_not_establish": "An alternative sequence is not a counterfactual causal estimate." }, { "id": "path-reversal-evidence-question", "family": "translation-threshold-path", "question": "What reversal, reset, failed reinforcement, substitution, or negative case would challenge path dependence?", "does_not_establish": "A proposed reversal test is not observed reversal." }, { "id": "path-evidence-requirement", "family": "translation-threshold-path", "question": "What mechanism, timing, comparison, negative-case, and reversal evidence would support path dependence?", "does_not_establish": "This atlas establishes no path dependence or hysteresis." }, { "id": "path-inactive-boundary", "family": "translation-threshold-path", "question": "Is path-dependence analysis unassessed or not applicable for this card?", "does_not_establish": "The card assumes no path dependence, hysteresis, reinforcement, lock-in, inevitability, or stasis." } ], "nuance_templates": { "transition-default": { "temporal_profile": { "onset": "Source state, transition opportunity, first trace, and target state may have different or unknown onsets.", "duration": "Opportunity, gate validity, transformation, observation, and record durations remain separate.", "latency": "Human, institutional, material, network, reporting, and detection latency may intervene.", "overlap": "Rival paths, external events, counterflows, prior states, and later feedback may overlap.", "decay": "Carrier, gate, capability, trace, and contextual validity may decay differently.", "recurrence": "Opportunity, interruption, retry, reversal, and recurrence require separate records.", "censoring": "Privacy, refusal, exclusion, destruction, inaccessibility, unsafe reporting, and measurement failure may censor traces.", "resolution": "Resolve source, opportunity, gate, transformation, target, observation, and record times separately.", "timing_claim_status": "qualitative-audit-lens-only", "prediction": false }, "accumulation_profile": { "quantity_kind": "Transition-specific carriers, declared resource units, events, and records", "unit": "non-additive", "additivity": "not-established", "inflows": [ "New source-bound carrier, gate, opportunity, transformation, target, and counterflow records." ], "outflows": [ "Expiry, withdrawal, revocation, loss, correction, supersession, retirement, or invalidation." ], "decay_or_reset": [ "Material change, fresh gate, version change, reversal, recurrence, or declared review reset." ], "scope": "One bounded transition question under declared parties, place, institution, jurisdiction, material context, and horizon.", "stock_flow_status": "analytical-lens-only", "summable_social_constructs": [], "effect_size_claimed": false }, "distribution": { "benefits": [ "Keep possible benefits party- and horizon-indexed without netting." ], "burdens": [ "Keep labor, cost, exposure, delay, extraction, compliance, and opportunity burdens separately indexed." ], "risks": [ "Keep rights, safety, privacy, exclusion, displacement, dependency, and irreversible risks separately indexed." ], "voice_and_options": [ "Keep voice, refusal, correction, appeal, alternative, exit, and remedy options separately observable." ], "horizons": [ "Keep onset, latency, duration, recurrence, recovery, lifecycle, future, and ecological horizons distinct." ], "aggregate_score": null }, "distortions": [ "A narrative bridge, temporal order, selective record, proxy, formal procedure, or narrow boundary can make an unsupported transition look complete." ], "counterflows": [ "Refusal, withdrawal, correction, counterstory, alternative route, veto, appeal, interruption, reversal, privacy, and non-action remain possible." ], "failure_modes": [ "Source and target labels are collapsed into one event, a missing gate is silently filled, or sequence is promoted to authority, execution, success, or cause." ], "repair_routes": [ "Preserve history, stop unsafe use, correct the typed record, reopen affected-party and gate review, assess residuals, and consider supersession, withdrawal, or retirement." ], "repair_residuals": [ "Prior exposure, exclusion, delay, sunk cost, action, harm, lost option, distrust, and displaced effects may remain." ], "repair_recurrence_checks": [ "Check whether the same missing gate, false bridge, exclusion, unsafe route, proxy error, or displaced effect recurs." ], "repair_fresh_gate_required": true, "evidence_requirements": [ "Separate source and target witnesses, opportunity set, gates, transformation traces, negative cases, counterevidence, timing, affected parties, and transport limits." ], "uncertainty_aggregation": null, "stop_conditions": [ "Stop promotion or effectful use when source, target, opportunity, gates, rights, authority, safety, affected parties, evidence coverage, or transport remain unresolved." ], "stall_or_block_conditions": [ "No opportunity, refusal, veto, censorship, access loss, unsafe participation, missing capability, resource constraint, outage, jurisdiction conflict, or measurement failure." ], "reversibility": { "status": "irreversible-elements-present", "recoverable_elements": [ "Current records, access, routing, gate review, proposal state, and future transition attempts may be corrected or stopped." ], "residual_or_irreversible_elements": [ "Prior exposure, lost time, disclosure, coercion, injury, ecological change, sunk resources, distrust, and foreclosed options may persist." ], "prerequisites": [ "Preserved history, safe stop, affected-party participation, fresh authority, independent review, and resourced repair." ] }, "explicit_non_implications": [ "A represented transition is not occurrence, automatic advance, transitive influence, authority, permission, execution, success, causal effect, prediction, optimization, or action." ] }, "overlay-default": { "temporal_profile": { "onset": "Each selected stage, possible transition, challenge, and review has a separate or unknown onset.", "duration": "Artifact, institution, gate, action, aftermath, feedback, and repair horizons remain separate.", "latency": "Circulation, selection, institutional response, material change, observation, challenge, and repair may be delayed.", "overlap": "Rival stories, institutions, jurisdictions, actions, shocks, counterflows, and reviews may overlap.", "decay": "Carrier, access, context, capacity, authority, observation quality, and institutional memory may decay differently.", "recurrence": "Expression, circulation, selection, challenge, correction, repair, and retirement may recur without stable meaning or effect.", "censoring": "Privacy, refusal, exclusion, suppression, destruction, inaccessibility, unsafe reporting, and missing parties may censor traces.", "resolution": "Resolve every stage, transition opportunity, gate, event, observation, party, and record time separately.", "timing_claim_status": "qualitative-audit-lens-only", "prediction": false }, "accumulation_profile": { "quantity_kind": "Overlay-specific carriers, records, declared units, institutional memory, obligations, residuals, and recurrence questions", "unit": "non-additive", "additivity": "not-established", "inflows": [ "New source-bound expressions, artifacts, stage records, challenges, counterevidence, affected-party accounts, and reviews." ], "outflows": [ "Withdrawal, expiry, revocation, correction, supersession, loss, invalidation, or retirement." ], "decay_or_reset": [ "Version change, fresh gate, changed institution or material context, reversal, recurrence, or declared review reset." ], "scope": "One bounded projection crosswalk under declared carriers, parties, institutions, jurisdictions, places, material contexts, and horizons.", "stock_flow_status": "analytical-lens-only", "summable_social_constructs": [], "effect_size_claimed": false }, "distribution": { "benefits": [ "Keep possible benefits separated by affected party, mechanism question, and horizon." ], "burdens": [ "Keep labor, exposure, exclusion, extraction, delay, maintenance, and remedy burdens separately indexed." ], "risks": [ "Keep rights, safety, privacy, status, coercion, displacement, lock-in, and irreversible risks separate." ], "voice_and_options": [ "Keep refusal, dissent, correction, counterreading, appeal, alternative, exit, remedy, and non-action visible." ], "horizons": [ "Keep formation, circulation, institution, decision, action, aftermath, recurrence, future, and ecological horizons distinct." ], "aggregate_score": null }, "distortions": [ "Crosswalk labels, narrative continuity, selective records, formal institutions, proxy measures, and narrow boundaries can conceal missing mechanisms and displaced effects." ], "counterflows": [ "Counterstory, correction, refusal, withdrawal, dissent, appeal, alternate institution, safe exit, privacy, repair demand, retirement, and non-action remain possible." ], "failure_modes": [ "A design crosswalk is promoted to history, mechanism, authority, inevitability, population belief, causal effect, targeting input, or action path." ], "repair_routes": [ "Preserve source and projection history, stop unsafe use, correct typing and provenance, restore affected-party voice, reopen fresh gates, assess residuals, and review retirement." ], "repair_residuals": [ "Prior circulation, exclusion, exposure, institutional commitment, status injury, material harm, lost options, distrust, and displaced effects may remain." ], "repair_recurrence_checks": [ "Check whether the same false bridge, omitted party, authority laundering, inference error, suppression, narrow boundary, or failed repair recurs." ], "repair_fresh_gate_required": true, "evidence_requirements": [ "Pin source claims and target types, then separately evidence carriers, stages, opportunities, transitions, gates, affected parties, negative cases, counterevidence, falsifiers, and transport limits." ], "uncertainty_aggregation": null, "stop_conditions": [ "Stop promotion or effectful use when source qualification, stage typing, opportunity, transition, authority, rights, safety, affected parties, evidence coverage, or transport is unresolved." ], "stall_or_block_conditions": [ "Missing source claim, no opportunity, refusal, exclusion, censorship, unsafe participation, absent authority or capability, resource constraint, jurisdiction conflict, or measurement failure." ], "reversibility": { "status": "irreversible-elements-present", "recoverable_elements": [ "Current crosswalk metadata, publication, selection, routing, gate review, proposal state, and future use may be corrected or stopped." ], "residual_or_irreversible_elements": [ "Prior exposure, extraction, lost time, disclosure, coercion, injury, ecological change, status effects, distrust, and foreclosed options may persist." ], "prerequisites": [ "Preserved history, safe stop, affected-party participation, fresh authority, independent review, correction channels, and resourced repair." ] }, "explicit_non_implications": [ "A projection overlay is not a new source claim, historical finding, mechanism, causal effect, authority, persuasion model, prediction, optimization, or action." ] } }, "contract_templates": { "transition-authority": { "required_for": [ "Any external use that would instantiate, test, publish as fact, authorize, resource, invoke, execute, or repair a represented transition." ], "non_implications": [ "A predecessor relation, source state, target state, decision, capability, feedback item, or atlas record grants no authority to traverse a transition." ] }, "transition-causal": { "candidate_mediators": [ "Which separately observed carrier, gate, transformation, material condition, institution, affected-party response, or feedback could mediate the exact transition?" ], "alternative_causes": [ "Which common cause, prior state, rival path, selection process, external event, measurement change, or independent action could explain the target trace?" ], "non_implications": [ "Source and target observations, compatible relation types, or temporal sequence establish no causal transition or effect." ] }, "overlay-authority": { "required_for": [ "Any external publication as fact, institutional adoption, allocation, gate decision, invocation, action, or repair based on a projection overlay." ], "non_implications": [ "Pinned predecessors, compatible target types, a complete overlay, public visibility, or affected-party interest grants no authority, jurisdiction, consent, or lawful basis." ] }, "overlay-causal": { "candidate_mediators": [ "Which separately observed carrier, interpretation, selection process, institution, gate, resource, action, material condition, affected-party response, or feedback could instantiate a claimed path?" ], "alternative_causes": [ "Which prior state, rival story, common cause, institution, shock, selection process, measurement change, independent action, or counterflow could explain the target trace?" ], "non_implications": [ "A crosswalk, stage alignment, temporal order, recurrence, association, or narrative coherence establishes no mechanism or causal effect." ] } }, "flow": { "stage_ids": [ "word-or-expression", "shared-story-artifact", "circulation-exposure-response", "institutional-selection-context", "action-proposal", "decision-record", "authorization-rights-and-affected-party-gate", "capability-and-resources", "attempt", "execution-or-action", "outcome-observation", "aftermath-causal-and-normative-assessment", "feedback-challenge-and-counterflow", "repair-review-and-retirement" ], "transition_ids": [ "expression-to-shared-story", "story-to-circulation", "circulation-to-institutional-context", "institution-to-proposal", "proposal-to-decision", "decision-to-authorization-gate", "authorization-gate-to-capability", "capability-to-attempt", "attempt-to-execution", "execution-to-outcome", "outcome-to-aftermath-assessment", "assessment-to-feedback", "feedback-to-repair-review" ], "status": "analytical-order-not-deterministic-path", "may_branch": true, "may_join": true, "may_skip": true, "may_stall": true, "may_stop": true, "may_reverse": true, "may_recur": true, "may_never_start": true, "complete_path_claimed": false, "automatic_runtime": false }, "stages": [ { "id": "word-or-expression", "label": "Word or expression", "definition": "A bounded utterance, inscription, gesture, image, invocation, name, or other expression is attributable in context before any story, distribution, reception, belief, authority, or effect is claimed.", "analytical_status": "typed-predecessor-stage-design-lens", "predecessor_domain_ids": [ "semantic-symbolic", "informational-record" ], "predecessor_dimension_ids": [ "semantic-legibility", "provenance-traceability" ], "predecessor_node_type_ids": [ "EXPRESSION", "CLAIM_ASSESSMENT" ], "predecessor_ladder_ids": [ "expression-recorded" ], "nuance": { "carriers": [ "Voice, body, page, image, interface, ritual performance, transcript, or attributed source reference." ], "transformations": [ "Naming, transcription, editing, translation, quotation, extraction, genre assignment, and contextualization may change what is available for interpretation." ], "gates": [ "Attribution, provenance, privacy, source-community context, and publication access must be separately reviewed." ], "temporal_profile": { "onset": "Expression time and recording time may differ or be unknown.", "duration": "An utterance may be momentary while a record persists.", "latency": "Latency from expression to recording, discovery, or interpretation is unknown unless witnessed.", "overlap": "Multiple versions, languages, speakers, and contexts may overlap.", "decay": "Memory, media, context, and attribution may degrade differently.", "recurrence": "Quotation, ritual, replay, and re-inscription may recur without stable meaning.", "censoring": "Private, destroyed, suppressed, or unrecorded expressions may be absent from the accessible record.", "resolution": "Use the finest source-supported event and version resolution; otherwise mark unknown.", "timing_claim_status": "qualitative-audit-lens-only", "prediction": false }, "accumulation_profile": { "quantity_kind": "Expression form and provenance context", "unit": "non-additive", "additivity": "non-additive", "inflows": [ "New attributed expressions, variants, translations, and contextual records." ], "outflows": [ "Withdrawal, loss, destruction, access restriction, or supersession of a version." ], "decay_or_reset": [ "Context loss, media degradation, archival correction, or explicit version reset." ], "scope": "One bounded expression lineage under a declared archive and access surface.", "stock_flow_status": "analytical-lens-only", "summable_social_constructs": [], "effect_size_claimed": false }, "observables": [ "Expression bytes or recording, attribution, date or interval, medium, context, version, access limits, and documented challenges." ], "affected_party_ids": [ "expression-originators", "source-communities-and-traditions", "translators-curators-and-stewards", "audiences-and-non-audiences" ], "distribution": { "benefits": [ "Attribution, legibility, continuity, or access may benefit differently situated parties." ], "burdens": [ "Exposure, extraction, mistranslation, moderation, and preservation labor may be unequally borne." ], "risks": [ "Misattribution, decontextualization, retaliation, privacy loss, and false representation." ], "voice_and_options": [ "Record consent or lawful basis, correction, contextual reply, anonymity, access limits, and withdrawal separately." ], "horizons": [ "Immediate expression, later reuse, archival survival, and future reinterpretation require distinct review." ], "aggregate_score": null }, "affected_party_aftermath": [ { "affected_party_id": "expression-originators", "status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [ "party-benefit-question" ], "burdens": [], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false, "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason" }, { "affected_party_id": "source-communities-and-traditions", "status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [ "party-benefit-question" ], "burdens": [], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false, "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason" }, { "affected_party_id": "translators-curators-and-stewards", "status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [], "burdens": [ "party-burden-question" ], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false, "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason" }, { "affected_party_id": "audiences-and-non-audiences", "status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [ "party-benefit-question" ], "burdens": [], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false, "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason" } ], "emotion_observation": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "self-report", "attributed-expression", "cultural-vocabulary" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-emotion-observation", "boundary_ref": "dimension-emotion-observation", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "affect_context": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "fear-or-threat", "love-care-or-solidarity", "belonging-or-identity-security" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-affect-context", "boundary_ref": "dimension-affect-context", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "social_position": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "status", "discursive-power" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-social-position", "boundary_ref": "dimension-social-position", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "power_asymmetry": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "naming-and-interpretive", "epistemic-and-measurement" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-power-asymmetry", "boundary_ref": "dimension-power-asymmetry", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "material_conditions": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "body-and-care", "labor-and-time", "data-and-technology" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-material-conditions", "boundary_ref": "dimension-material-conditions", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "flow_dynamics": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "continuous-or-episodic", "accumulation-or-memory", "path-dependence-or-hysteresis" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-flow-dynamics", "boundary_ref": "dimension-flow-dynamics", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "topology": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "fork", "recurrence", "interruption" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-topology", "boundary_ref": "dimension-topology", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "negative_flow": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "not-observed", "destroyed-or-lost", "private-or-refused", "unknown" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-negative-flow", "boundary_ref": "dimension-negative-flow", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "negative_flow_profiles": [ { "status_ref": "not-observed", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "adverse_inference": false, "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses" }, { "status_ref": "destroyed-or-lost", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "adverse_inference": false, "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses" }, { "status_ref": "private-or-refused", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "adverse_inference": false, "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses" }, { "status_ref": "unknown", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "unknown", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "adverse_inference": false, "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses" } ], "translation_profile": { "status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "source_language": "Declared source language or sign system; unknown until source-bound evidence is added.", "target_language": "Declared target language or sign system; unknown until source-bound evidence is added.", "source_register": "Declared source register and institutional setting; unknown until evidenced.", "target_register": "Declared target register and institutional setting; unknown until evidenced.", "source_genre": "Declared source genre; unknown until evidenced.", "target_genre": "Declared target genre; unknown until evidenced.", "source_version": "Stable source version or witnessed performance reference; none is added by this atlas.", "translator_position_refs": [ "discursive-power" ], "patron_position_refs": [ "agenda-control" ], "audience_party_refs": [ "audiences-and-non-audiences" ], "preserved": [ "translation-preserved-question" ], "changed": [ "translation-changed-question" ], "introduced": [ "translation-introduced-question" ], "omitted": [ "translation-omitted-question" ], "untranslatable": [ "translation-untranslatable-question" ], "counterreadings": [ "translation-counterreadings-question" ], "rights_and_access": [ "translation-rights-and-access-question" ], "fidelity_claimed": false, "representational_authority_granted": false, "reason_ref": "translation-rights-and-access-question" }, "threshold_profile": { "status": "unassessed", "reason_ref": "threshold-inactive-boundary", "boundary_ref": "threshold-inactive-boundary" }, "path_dependence_profile": { "status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-established", "reinforcement_mechanism": [ "path-reinforcement-question" ], "switching_cost": [ "path-switching-cost-question" ], "sunk_resource": [ "path-sunk-resource-question" ], "option_loss": [ "path-option-loss-question" ], "alternative_timing": [ "path-alternative-timing-question" ], "reversal_evidence": [ "path-reversal-evidence-question" ], "evidence": [ "path-evidence-requirement" ], "path_dependence_established": false, "reason_ref": "path-evidence-requirement" }, "distortions": [ "Transcription, translation, quotation, metadata, search, and archival selection can change what later observers encounter." ], "counterflows": [ "Correction, countertranslation, contextual annotation, refusal, withdrawal, access restriction, and parallel expression." ], "failure_modes": [ "A fragment is treated as a complete view, an attributed speaker as a community, or a public expression as private belief." ], "repair_routes": [ "Preserve the challenged version, add provenance and countercontext, correct attribution, restrict access where justified, and open fresh review." ], "repair_residuals": [ "Prior circulation, stigma, extraction, and context loss may remain after correction." ], "repair_recurrence_checks": [ "Check whether the old fragment, attribution, or translation continues to circulate or reappears downstream." ], "repair_fresh_gate_required": true, "repair_profile": { "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "repair-review-or-retirement-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-run", "proposal_source": "card-repair-routes", "fresh_gate_refs": [ "attribution-and-provenance", "publication-and-access" ], "attempt": [ "repair-attempt-question" ], "execution_or_outcome_observation": [ "repair-outcome-question" ], "party_indexed_residuals": [ { "affected_party_id": "expression-originators", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "source-communities-and-traditions", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "translators-curators-and-stewards", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "audiences-and-non-audiences", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] } ], "dissent": [ "repair-dissent-question" ], "recurrence": [ "repair-recurrence-question" ], "review_or_retirement": [ "repair-review-or-retirement-question" ], "repair_completed": false, "causal_effect_claimed": false, "erasure_or_absolution_claimed": false, "restored_consent_claimed": false }, "evidence_requirements": [ "Stable expression or source reference, attribution basis, version, medium, context, dates, access conditions, and counterevidence." ], "evidence_uncertainty": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "source", "measurement", "selection-and-missingness", "temporal", "affected-party-incompleteness" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-evidence-uncertainty", "boundary_ref": "dimension-evidence-uncertainty", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "uncertainty_aggregation": null, "alternative_paths": [ "The expression may remain private, be independently rediscovered, enter several stories, be rejected, or leave no trace." ], "stop_conditions": [ "Stop publication or reuse when provenance, rights, privacy, community safety, or attribution cannot be responsibly bounded." ], "stall_or_block_conditions": [ "Loss, censorship, inaccessible language, missing context, unsafe attribution, or inadequate recording coverage." ], "reversibility": { "status": "partially-reversible", "recoverable_elements": [ "Metadata, access, attribution, translation, and later presentation may be corrected." ], "residual_or_irreversible_elements": [ "Prior exposure, copying, memory, retaliation, and cultural loss may persist." ], "prerequisites": [ "Version preservation, affected-party consultation, fresh authority, and a viable correction channel." ] }, "explicit_non_implications": [ "An expression is not a shared story, belief, consent, authority, cause, instruction, or effect." ] }, "authority_dependency": { "status": "no-authority-created-by-static-description", "required_for": [ "Recording, publishing, translating, or effectfully reusing protected or sensitive expression." ], "gate_input_ids": [ "attribution-and-provenance", "publication-and-access" ], "non_implications": [ "Attribution, availability, or cultural importance does not grant authority to publish, represent, or act." ] }, "causal_influence": { "status": "not-assessed-by-static-atlas", "candidate_mediators": [ "Which carriers, transformations, exposures, interpretations, institutions, and material conditions could mediate any later change?" ], "alternative_causes": [ "Which prior events, shared environments, institutions, incentives, or selection processes could explain the same later observation?" ], "estimand_required_before_promotion": true, "comparator_required_before_promotion": true, "assumptions_required_before_promotion": true, "causal_effect_claimed": false, "non_implications": [ "Recording or repeating an expression establishes no causal influence, persuasion, or social effect." ] }, "evidence_profile": { "claim_register": "DESIGN_COMMITMENT", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "causal_status": "formal-mechanism-not-instantiated", "evidence_refs": [], "evidence_ref_status": "no-direct-predecessor-evidence-design-only", "expected_traces": { "source": "card-nuance-observables", "prompt_refs": [] }, "negative_cases": { "source": "card-nuance-alternative-paths", "prompt_refs": [] }, "counterevidence": [ "evidence-counterevidence" ], "falsifiers": [ "evidence-falsifier" ], "transport_bounds": [ "evidence-transport-bound" ], "promotion_requirement": "promotion-requires-source-bound-successor", "external_empirical_support_claimed": false, "mechanism_promoted": false }, "automatic_advance": false }, { "id": "shared-story-artifact", "label": "Shared story artifact", "definition": "A versioned narrative artifact, teaching, performance, or interpretive frame is available to more than one participant without implying common belief, agreement, comprehension, consent, or uniform reception.", "analytical_status": "typed-predecessor-stage-design-lens", "predecessor_domain_ids": [ "semantic-symbolic", "informational-record", "normative-public" ], "predecessor_dimension_ids": [ "interpretive-framing", "provenance-traceability", "path-dependence" ], "predecessor_node_type_ids": [ "EXPRESSION", "ARTIFACT", "CLAIM_ASSESSMENT" ], "predecessor_ladder_ids": [ "expression-recorded", "artifact-versioned" ], "nuance": { "carriers": [ "Text, oral performance, image, ritual, curriculum, archive, platform object, place, or embodied practice with a bounded version." ], "transformations": [ "Selection, composition, translation, adaptation, canonization, performance, interface formatting, and audience framing." ], "gates": [ "Provenance, version identity, rights, source-community context, access, and alternative or dissenting versions." ], "temporal_profile": { "onset": "Artifact formation may be gradual, episodic, reconstructed, or contested.", "duration": "Carrier persistence and active use have separate durations.", "latency": "Formation, preservation, rediscovery, and circulation may be separated by unknown intervals.", "overlap": "Versions, genres, communities, and interpretations may coexist.", "decay": "Media, language competence, practice, and contextual memory may decay at different rates.", "recurrence": "Retelling, ritual, teaching, adaptation, and revival can recur with changed conditions.", "censoring": "Destroyed, private, excluded, or non-canonical variants may be missing.", "resolution": "Resolve version, performance, audience, and observation window separately where evidence permits.", "timing_claim_status": "qualitative-audit-lens-only", "prediction": false }, "accumulation_profile": { "quantity_kind": "Versioned story artifact and contextual lineage", "unit": "non-additive", "additivity": "non-additive", "inflows": [ "Expressions, performances, translations, annotations, adaptations, and preserved variants." ], "outflows": [ "Loss, withdrawal, exclusion, obsolescence, destruction, or separation from context." ], "decay_or_reset": [ "Language change, archive loss, reinterpretation, correction, or explicit new edition." ], "scope": "One declared story lineage across named carriers, versions, communities, and dates.", "stock_flow_status": "analytical-lens-only", "summable_social_constructs": [], "effect_size_claimed": false }, "observables": [ "Artifact bytes or witnessed performance, digest or version, provenance chain, translations, access surface, contextual notes, variants, and challenges." ], "affected_party_ids": [ "expression-originators", "translators-curators-and-stewards", "source-communities-and-traditions", "audiences-and-non-audiences", "future-parties" ], "distribution": { "benefits": [ "Continuity, recognition, teaching, public vocabulary, or plural interpretation may be unevenly available." ], "burdens": [ "Stewardship, translation, exposure, assimilation pressure, and interpretive labor may be displaced." ], "risks": [ "Canon closure, appropriation, flattening, sacred or private exposure, and false community representation." ], "voice_and_options": [ "Keep version plurality, dissent, access conditions, contextual reply, refusal, and correction routes visible." ], "horizons": [ "Formation, current use, archival afterlife, revival, and future reinterpretation are separate horizons." ], "aggregate_score": null }, "affected_party_aftermath": [ { "affected_party_id": "expression-originators", "status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [ "party-benefit-question" ], "burdens": [], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false, "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason" }, { "affected_party_id": "translators-curators-and-stewards", "status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [], "burdens": [ "party-burden-question" ], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false, "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason" }, { "affected_party_id": "source-communities-and-traditions", "status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [ "party-benefit-question" ], "burdens": [], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false, "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason" }, { "affected_party_id": "audiences-and-non-audiences", "status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [ "party-benefit-question" ], "burdens": [], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false, "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason" }, { "affected_party_id": "future-parties", "status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [], "burdens": [], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false, "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason" } ], "emotion_observation": { "status": "unassessed", "reason_ref": "dimension-emotion-observation", "boundary_ref": "dimension-emotion-observation" }, "affect_context": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "grief-or-loss", "hope-or-efficacy", "love-care-or-solidarity", "belonging-or-identity-security" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-affect-context", "boundary_ref": "dimension-affect-context", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "social_position": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "status", "office", "discursive-power" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-social-position", "boundary_ref": "dimension-social-position", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "power_asymmetry": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "naming-and-interpretive", "canon-and-curriculum", "status-and-hierarchy" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-power-asymmetry", "boundary_ref": "dimension-power-asymmetry", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "material_conditions": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "labor-and-time", "land-and-geography", "data-and-technology" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-material-conditions", "boundary_ref": "dimension-material-conditions", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "flow_dynamics": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "accumulation-or-memory", "path-dependence-or-hysteresis", "branching-or-convergence" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-flow-dynamics", "boundary_ref": "dimension-flow-dynamics", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "topology": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "fork", "join", "parallel-path", "recurrence" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-topology", "boundary_ref": "dimension-topology", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "negative_flow": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "destroyed-or-lost", "inaccessible", "private-or-refused", "excluded", "unknown" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-negative-flow", "boundary_ref": "dimension-negative-flow", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "negative_flow_profiles": [ { "status_ref": "destroyed-or-lost", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "adverse_inference": false, "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses" }, { "status_ref": "inaccessible", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "adverse_inference": false, "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses" }, { "status_ref": "private-or-refused", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "adverse_inference": false, "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses" }, { "status_ref": "excluded", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "adverse_inference": false, "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses" }, { "status_ref": "unknown", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "unknown", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "adverse_inference": false, "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses" } ], "translation_profile": { "status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "source_language": "Declared source language or sign system; unknown until source-bound evidence is added.", "target_language": "Declared target language or sign system; unknown until source-bound evidence is added.", "source_register": "Declared source register and institutional setting; unknown until evidenced.", "target_register": "Declared target register and institutional setting; unknown until evidenced.", "source_genre": "Declared source genre; unknown until evidenced.", "target_genre": "Declared target genre; unknown until evidenced.", "source_version": "Stable source version or witnessed performance reference; none is added by this atlas.", "translator_position_refs": [ "discursive-power" ], "patron_position_refs": [ "agenda-control" ], "audience_party_refs": [ "audiences-and-non-audiences" ], "preserved": [ "translation-preserved-question" ], "changed": [ "translation-changed-question" ], "introduced": [ "translation-introduced-question" ], "omitted": [ "translation-omitted-question" ], "untranslatable": [ "translation-untranslatable-question" ], "counterreadings": [ "translation-counterreadings-question" ], "rights_and_access": [ "translation-rights-and-access-question" ], "fidelity_claimed": false, "representational_authority_granted": false, "reason_ref": "translation-rights-and-access-question" }, "threshold_profile": { "status": "unassessed", "reason_ref": "threshold-inactive-boundary", "boundary_ref": "threshold-inactive-boundary" }, "path_dependence_profile": { "status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-established", "reinforcement_mechanism": [ "path-reinforcement-question" ], "switching_cost": [ "path-switching-cost-question" ], "sunk_resource": [ "path-sunk-resource-question" ], "option_loss": [ "path-option-loss-question" ], "alternative_timing": [ "path-alternative-timing-question" ], "reversal_evidence": [ "path-reversal-evidence-question" ], "evidence": [ "path-evidence-requirement" ], "path_dependence_established": false, "reason_ref": "path-evidence-requirement" }, "distortions": [ "Genre compression, canonical selection, translation, editorial framing, platform format, and survivor bias can obscure plurality." ], "counterflows": [ "Counterstory, alternate canon, oral continuity, retranslation, contextual annotation, parody, refusal, and withdrawal." ], "failure_modes": [ "Availability is treated as shared belief, a version as an essence, or institutional preservation as neutral memory." ], "repair_routes": [ "Restore provenance and variant access, add community-authored context, correct framing, preserve the prior record, and reopen selection." ], "repair_residuals": [ "Extraction, exclusion, lost language, prior canon effects, and unequal archive survival may remain." ], "repair_recurrence_checks": [ "Review whether excluded variants, harmful framing, or unauthorized reuse recur in later editions, curricula, and interfaces." ], "repair_fresh_gate_required": true, "repair_profile": { "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "repair-review-or-retirement-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-run", "proposal_source": "card-repair-routes", "fresh_gate_refs": [ "attribution-and-provenance", "publication-and-access", "affected-party-register" ], "attempt": [ "repair-attempt-question" ], "execution_or_outcome_observation": [ "repair-outcome-question" ], "party_indexed_residuals": [ { "affected_party_id": "expression-originators", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "translators-curators-and-stewards", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "source-communities-and-traditions", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "audiences-and-non-audiences", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "future-parties", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] } ], "dissent": [ "repair-dissent-question" ], "recurrence": [ "repair-recurrence-question" ], "review_or_retirement": [ "repair-review-or-retirement-question" ], "repair_completed": false, "causal_effect_claimed": false, "erasure_or_absolution_claimed": false, "restored_consent_claimed": false }, "evidence_requirements": [ "Versioned carrier or witnessed performance, lineage, translation notes, selection context, access conditions, variants, and affected-party disagreement." ], "evidence_uncertainty": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "source", "selection-and-missingness", "temporal", "transport", "affected-party-incompleteness", "normative-disagreement" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-evidence-uncertainty", "boundary_ref": "dimension-evidence-uncertainty", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "uncertainty_aggregation": null, "alternative_paths": [ "A story may remain local, fragment, merge, fork, revive, coexist with rivals, be refused, or never enter an institution." ], "stop_conditions": [ "Stop reuse when rights, sacred or private access, provenance, attribution, or representation cannot be responsibly resolved." ], "stall_or_block_conditions": [ "Archive loss, language loss, censorship, inaccessible media, gatekeeping, unsafe participation, or resource limits." ], "reversibility": { "status": "irreversible-elements-present", "recoverable_elements": [ "Current metadata, access, translation, contextualization, and selection can be revised." ], "residual_or_irreversible_elements": [ "Lost versions, erased practices, prior exposure, assimilation, and historical exclusions may not be restored." ], "prerequisites": [ "Preserved versions, plural stewardship, affected-party participation, resources, and fresh authority." ] }, "explicit_non_implications": [ "A shared story artifact is not shared belief, collective mind, truth, legitimacy, authority, causal influence, or destiny." ] }, "authority_dependency": { "status": "no-authority-created-by-static-description", "required_for": [ "Publishing, teaching, translating, stewarding, restricting, or effectfully using a story artifact." ], "gate_input_ids": [ "attribution-and-provenance", "publication-and-access", "affected-party-register" ], "non_implications": [ "Stewardship, survival, sacred status, popularity, or institutional selection does not itself grant authority over the artifact or community." ] }, "causal_influence": { "status": "not-assessed-by-static-atlas", "candidate_mediators": [ "Which exposures, interpretations, relationships, institutions, incentives, and material practices could connect the artifact to a later observation?" ], "alternative_causes": [ "Which shared conditions, earlier practices, selection processes, or later reinterpretations could account for apparent continuity or change?" ], "estimand_required_before_promotion": true, "comparator_required_before_promotion": true, "assumptions_required_before_promotion": true, "causal_effect_claimed": false, "non_implications": [ "Artifact survival, recurrence, or institutional use establishes no belief, persuasion, behavior, or civilisational effect." ] }, "evidence_profile": { "claim_register": "DESIGN_COMMITMENT", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "causal_status": "formal-mechanism-not-instantiated", "evidence_refs": [], "evidence_ref_status": "no-direct-predecessor-evidence-design-only", "expected_traces": { "source": "card-nuance-observables", "prompt_refs": [] }, "negative_cases": { "source": "card-nuance-alternative-paths", "prompt_refs": [] }, "counterevidence": [ "evidence-counterevidence" ], "falsifiers": [ "evidence-falsifier" ], "transport_bounds": [ "evidence-transport-bound" ], "promotion_requirement": "promotion-requires-source-bound-successor", "external_empirical_support_claimed": false, "mechanism_promoted": false }, "automatic_advance": false }, { "id": "circulation-exposure-response", "label": "Circulation, exposure, and response", "definition": "Distribution, availability, measured exposure or attention proxy, and attributed public response remain separately evidenced events rather than a single uptake step.", "analytical_status": "typed-predecessor-stage-design-lens", "predecessor_domain_ids": [ "attention-exposure", "social-relational", "informational-record", "normative-public" ], "predecessor_dimension_ids": [ "discoverability", "attention-allocation", "coordination", "feedback-sensitivity" ], "predecessor_node_type_ids": [ "ARTIFACT", "DISTRIBUTION_OBSERVATION", "ATTENTION_OBSERVATION", "PUBLIC_RESPONSE_RECORD" ], "predecessor_ladder_ids": [ "distribution-witnessed", "exposure-measured", "public-response-attributed" ], "nuance": { "carriers": [ "Publishers, platforms, broadcasters, gatherings, schools, libraries, networks, search indexes, recommendations, and interpersonal relays." ], "transformations": [ "Selection, ranking, repetition, moderation, segmentation, translation, summarization, commentary, and measurement operationalization." ], "gates": [ "Publication rights, audience and privacy boundaries, channel access, measurement validity, non-targeting, and response attribution." ], "temporal_profile": { "onset": "Availability, delivery, exposure proxy, attention proxy, and response each have distinct possible onset times.", "duration": "Channel availability does not specify exposure or response duration.", "latency": "Delay among distribution, possible exposure, public response, and record creation is unknown unless measured.", "overlap": "Channels, campaigns, organic sharing, counterstory, and external events may overlap.", "decay": "Visibility, recall proxies, access, and response traces may decay at different rates.", "recurrence": "Redistribution, resurfacing, repetition, and renewed response may recur.", "censoring": "Private exposure, avoidance, deletion, moderation, nonresponse, and inaccessible channels censor observation.", "resolution": "Declare channel, population, construct, window, sampling, and timestamp resolution separately.", "timing_claim_status": "qualitative-audit-lens-only", "prediction": false }, "accumulation_profile": { "quantity_kind": "Bounded distribution and observation events", "unit": "declared event or instrument unit", "additivity": "bounded-declared-units-only", "inflows": [ "Published instances, delivery witnesses, scoped exposure measurements, and attributed public responses." ], "outflows": [ "Deletion, expiration, channel loss, access withdrawal, measurement invalidation, or deduplication." ], "decay_or_reset": [ "Window expiry, construct change, instrument drift, platform change, or declared cohort reset." ], "scope": "One declared artifact-channel-population-window-instrument combination; incompatible measures are not combined.", "stock_flow_status": "analytical-lens-only", "summable_social_constructs": [], "effect_size_claimed": false }, "observables": [ "Channel and surface, availability or delivery witness, sampling and instrument, privacy boundary, response artifact, attribution, timestamp, deletion, and counterevidence." ], "affected_party_ids": [ "audiences-and-non-audiences", "expression-originators", "translators-curators-and-stewards", "directly-affected-parties", "indirect-non-user-and-bystander-parties" ], "distribution": { "benefits": [ "Access, discoverability, public reply, and coordination opportunity may be unevenly distributed." ], "burdens": [ "Exposure, moderation, attention labor, surveillance, bandwidth, and response costs may fall on different parties." ], "risks": [ "Unwanted exposure, harassment, exclusion, surveillance, manipulation, chilling, and displacement beyond measured channels." ], "voice_and_options": [ "Keep avoidance, anonymity, refusal, correction, appeal, opt-out, alternative channel, and nonresponse visible." ], "horizons": [ "Immediate visibility, delayed resurfacing, archival discoverability, and cumulative platform change require distinct windows." ], "aggregate_score": null }, "affected_party_aftermath": [ { "affected_party_id": "audiences-and-non-audiences", "status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [ "party-benefit-question" ], "burdens": [], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false, "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason" }, { "affected_party_id": "expression-originators", "status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [ "party-benefit-question" ], "burdens": [], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false, "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason" }, { "affected_party_id": "translators-curators-and-stewards", "status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [], "burdens": [ "party-burden-question" ], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false, "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason" }, { "affected_party_id": "directly-affected-parties", "status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [ "party-benefit-question" ], "burdens": [ "party-burden-question" ], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false, "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason" }, { "affected_party_id": "indirect-non-user-and-bystander-parties", "status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [], "burdens": [ "party-burden-question" ], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false, "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason" } ], "emotion_observation": { "status": "unassessed", "reason_ref": "dimension-emotion-observation", "boundary_ref": "dimension-emotion-observation" }, "affect_context": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "fear-or-threat", "anger-or-outrage", "hope-or-efficacy", "hate-or-moral-exclusion" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-affect-context", "boundary_ref": "dimension-affect-context", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "social_position": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "network-position", "agenda-control", "discursive-power" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-social-position", "boundary_ref": "dimension-social-position", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "power_asymmetry": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "attention-and-distribution", "technical-and-infrastructure", "epistemic-and-measurement" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-power-asymmetry", "boundary_ref": "dimension-power-asymmetry", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "material_conditions": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "labor-and-time", "infrastructure-and-logistics", "data-and-technology", "energy-and-resources" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-material-conditions", "boundary_ref": "dimension-material-conditions", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "flow_dynamics": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "continuous-or-episodic", "delay-or-latency", "leakage-substitution-or-displacement", "coupling-or-decoupling" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-flow-dynamics", "boundary_ref": "dimension-flow-dynamics", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "topology": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "parallel-path", "bottleneck", "leakage", "substitution", "interruption" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-topology", "boundary_ref": "dimension-topology", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "negative_flow": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "not-observed", "detection-bounded-absence", "no-opportunity", "censored", "excluded", "measurement-failure", "unknown" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-negative-flow", "boundary_ref": "dimension-negative-flow", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "negative_flow_profiles": [ { "status_ref": "not-observed", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "adverse_inference": false, "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses" }, { "status_ref": "detection-bounded-absence", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "adverse_inference": false, "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses" }, { "status_ref": "no-opportunity", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "adverse_inference": false, "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses" }, { "status_ref": "censored", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "adverse_inference": false, "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses" }, { "status_ref": "excluded", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "adverse_inference": false, "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses" }, { "status_ref": "measurement-failure", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "adverse_inference": false, "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses" }, { "status_ref": "unknown", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "unknown", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "adverse_inference": false, "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses" } ], "translation_profile": { "status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "source_language": "Declared source language or sign system; unknown until source-bound evidence is added.", "target_language": "Declared target language or sign system; unknown until source-bound evidence is added.", "source_register": "Declared source register and institutional setting; unknown until evidenced.", "target_register": "Declared target register and institutional setting; unknown until evidenced.", "source_genre": "Declared source genre; unknown until evidenced.", "target_genre": "Declared target genre; unknown until evidenced.", "source_version": "Stable source version or witnessed performance reference; none is added by this atlas.", "translator_position_refs": [ "discursive-power" ], "patron_position_refs": [ "agenda-control" ], "audience_party_refs": [ "audiences-and-non-audiences" ], "preserved": [ "translation-preserved-question" ], "changed": [ "translation-changed-question" ], "introduced": [ "translation-introduced-question" ], "omitted": [ "translation-omitted-question" ], "untranslatable": [ "translation-untranslatable-question" ], "counterreadings": [ "translation-counterreadings-question" ], "rights_and_access": [ "translation-rights-and-access-question" ], "fidelity_claimed": false, "representational_authority_granted": false, "reason_ref": "translation-rights-and-access-question" }, "threshold_profile": { "status": "unassessed", "reason_ref": "threshold-inactive-boundary", "boundary_ref": "threshold-inactive-boundary" }, "path_dependence_profile": { "status": "unassessed", "reason_ref": "path-inactive-boundary", "boundary_ref": "path-inactive-boundary" }, "distortions": [ "Ranking, moderation, bot activity, repeated delivery, proxy drift, survivorship, selection, and platform incentives can distort exposure and response records." ], "counterflows": [ "Avoidance, refusal, blocking, counterstory, correction, alternative channel, contextual reply, moderation appeal, and privacy-preserving nonresponse." ], "failure_modes": [ "Availability becomes exposure, exposure proxy becomes attention, attention becomes belief, response becomes population opinion, or silence becomes consent." ], "repair_routes": [ "Correct attribution and measurement, disclose coverage, stop harmful distribution, preserve evidence, restore reply or appeal, and assess displaced effects." ], "repair_residuals": [ "Copied artifacts, remembered exposure, harassment, chilling, data retention, and off-platform displacement may remain." ], "repair_recurrence_checks": [ "Review resurfacing, substitute channels, ranking drift, repeated exposure, retaliation, and measurement exclusion under a fresh window." ], "repair_fresh_gate_required": true, "repair_profile": { "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "repair-review-or-retirement-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-run", "proposal_source": "card-repair-routes", "fresh_gate_refs": [ "publication-and-access", "affected-party-register", "rights-assessment", "consent-or-lawful-basis", "safety-and-stop-route" ], "attempt": [ "repair-attempt-question" ], "execution_or_outcome_observation": [ "repair-outcome-question" ], "party_indexed_residuals": [ { "affected_party_id": "audiences-and-non-audiences", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "expression-originators", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "translators-curators-and-stewards", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "directly-affected-parties", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "indirect-non-user-and-bystander-parties", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] } ], "dissent": [ "repair-dissent-question" ], "recurrence": [ "repair-recurrence-question" ], "review_or_retirement": [ "repair-review-or-retirement-question" ], "repair_completed": false, "causal_effect_claimed": false, "erasure_or_absolution_claimed": false, "restored_consent_claimed": false }, "evidence_requirements": [ "Artifact version, channel, surface, opportunity set, instrument, population, selection process, timestamps, privacy controls, response attribution, negative cases, and missingness." ], "evidence_uncertainty": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "measurement", "selection-and-missingness", "temporal", "identification-and-model", "transport", "affected-party-incompleteness" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-evidence-uncertainty", "boundary_ref": "dimension-evidence-uncertainty", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "uncertainty_aggregation": null, "alternative_paths": [ "Independent discovery, interpersonal relay, common external event, prior belief, institutional cue, avoidance, or substitute channel may explain later traces." ], "stop_conditions": [ "Stop distribution or measurement when rights, privacy, safety, lawful basis, construct validity, or anti-targeting boundaries fail." ], "stall_or_block_conditions": [ "Channel denial, censorship, access cost, language barrier, device or infrastructure failure, avoidance, exclusion, moderation, or inadequate sampling." ], "reversibility": { "status": "irreversible-elements-present", "recoverable_elements": [ "Current availability, ranking, access, measurement, attribution, and reply routes may be changed." ], "residual_or_irreversible_elements": [ "Prior exposure, copying, data capture, harassment, chilling, and displaced circulation may persist." ], "prerequisites": [ "Channel control, evidence preservation, affected-party review, privacy protection, and fresh authorization." ] }, "explicit_non_implications": [ "Distribution is not exposure; exposure is not attention; attention is not belief; response is not representativeness, consent, persuasion, or effect." ] }, "authority_dependency": { "status": "external-gate-required-before-effectful-use", "required_for": [ "Publishing, distributing, ranking, measuring, moderating, or contacting any audience." ], "gate_input_ids": [ "publication-and-access", "affected-party-register", "rights-assessment", "consent-or-lawful-basis", "safety-and-stop-route" ], "non_implications": [ "Channel access, a public artifact, or an analytics record grants no authority to expose, target, infer, or act on anyone." ] }, "causal_influence": { "status": "not-assessed-by-static-atlas", "candidate_mediators": [ "Which actual exposures, interpretations, social relays, incentives, or institutional responses could mediate a declared outcome?" ], "alternative_causes": [ "Which prior preferences, shared events, platform changes, selection processes, or measurement artifacts could produce the observed pattern?" ], "estimand_required_before_promotion": true, "comparator_required_before_promotion": true, "assumptions_required_before_promotion": true, "causal_effect_claimed": false, "non_implications": [ "Temporal ordering, reach, engagement, co-variation, or public response establishes no causal media effect." ] }, "evidence_profile": { "claim_register": "DESIGN_COMMITMENT", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "causal_status": "formal-mechanism-not-instantiated", "evidence_refs": [], "evidence_ref_status": "no-direct-predecessor-evidence-design-only", "expected_traces": { "source": "card-nuance-observables", "prompt_refs": [] }, "negative_cases": { "source": "card-nuance-alternative-paths", "prompt_refs": [] }, "counterevidence": [ "evidence-counterevidence" ], "falsifiers": [ "evidence-falsifier" ], "transport_bounds": [ "evidence-transport-bound" ], "promotion_requirement": "promotion-requires-source-bound-successor", "external_empirical_support_claimed": false, "mechanism_promoted": false }, "automatic_advance": false }, { "id": "institutional-selection-context", "label": "Institutional selection context", "definition": "A bounded context of roles, rules, offices, routines, archives, curricula, agendas, non-decisions, exclusions, resources, and inherited constraints through which artifacts or issues may become selectable.", "analytical_status": "analytical-context-no-dedicated-reality-node", "predecessor_domain_ids": [ "institutional-status", "normative-public", "social-relational" ], "predecessor_dimension_ids": [ "institutional-selection", "coordination", "path-dependence" ], "predecessor_node_type_ids": [], "predecessor_ladder_ids": [], "nuance": { "carriers": [ "Organizations, offices, procedures, archives, curricula, budgets, professional roles, infrastructures, customs, and informal networks." ], "transformations": [ "Admission, credentialing, canon selection, agenda setting, procedural framing, classification, delay, exclusion, routinization, and resource allocation." ], "gates": [ "Jurisdiction, membership, standing, agenda access, conflict rules, procedural review, public reason, records access, and appeal." ], "temporal_profile": { "onset": "Institutional forms may have multiple founding, legal, customary, and operational dates.", "duration": "Rules, offices, practices, and resource dependencies persist on different horizons.", "latency": "Selection effects and non-decisions may become visible only after queues, reviews, or delayed records.", "overlap": "Formal and informal institutions, jurisdictions, factions, and inherited practices may overlap.", "decay": "Capacity, legitimacy claims, memory, expertise, and compliance may decay differently.", "recurrence": "Agenda cycles, ceremonies, elections, reviews, appointments, and crises may recur.", "censoring": "Informal vetoes, private deliberations, destroyed records, and excluded parties may be inaccessible.", "resolution": "Declare institution, office, rule, population, jurisdiction, practice, and observation window separately.", "timing_claim_status": "qualitative-audit-lens-only", "prediction": false }, "accumulation_profile": { "quantity_kind": "Institutional memory, rule, resource, and constraint configuration", "unit": "non-additive", "additivity": "non-additive", "inflows": [ "Rules, precedents, staff practice, archives, resources, standards, obligations, and learned routines." ], "outflows": [ "Retirement, repeal, staff loss, budget loss, declassification, decay, exit, and institutional replacement." ], "decay_or_reset": [ "Review, reform, sunset, jurisdiction change, turnover, crisis, or explicit institutional reset." ], "scope": "One named institutional context and jurisdiction over a declared period; forms are not combined into a power total.", "stock_flow_status": "analytical-lens-only", "summable_social_constructs": [], "effect_size_claimed": false }, "observables": [ "Charters, rules, roles, minutes, agendas, queues, budgets, curricula, archives, non-decisions, exclusions, dissent, appeals, and operational practice." ], "affected_party_ids": [ "institutional-participants", "decision-subjects", "operators-and-labor", "resource-providers", "audiences-and-non-audiences", "future-parties" ], "distribution": { "benefits": [ "Standing, access, predictability, resources, recognition, and remedy may be unevenly allocated." ], "burdens": [ "Compliance, waiting, labor, documentation, exclusion, and adaptation costs may fall elsewhere." ], "risks": [ "Agenda closure, capture, path lock-in, hierarchy, arbitrary exclusion, coercion, and off-record displacement." ], "voice_and_options": [ "Track proposal access, dissent, refusal, appeal, exit, representation, alternative institutions, and safe challenge." ], "horizons": [ "Founding, routine operation, crisis, reform, succession, sunset, and intergenerational obligations require separate review." ], "aggregate_score": null }, "affected_party_aftermath": [ { "affected_party_id": "institutional-participants", "status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [], "burdens": [ "party-burden-question" ], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false, "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason" }, { "affected_party_id": "decision-subjects", "status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [], "burdens": [], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false, "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason" }, { "affected_party_id": "operators-and-labor", "status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [], "burdens": [ "party-burden-question" ], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false, "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason" }, { "affected_party_id": "resource-providers", "status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [ "party-benefit-question" ], "burdens": [ "party-burden-question" ], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false, "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason" }, { "affected_party_id": "audiences-and-non-audiences", "status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [ "party-benefit-question" ], "burdens": [], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false, "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason" }, { "affected_party_id": "future-parties", "status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [], "burdens": [], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false, "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason" } ], "emotion_observation": { "status": "unassessed", "reason_ref": "dimension-emotion-observation", "boundary_ref": "dimension-emotion-observation" }, "affect_context": { "status": "unassessed", "reason_ref": "dimension-affect-context", "boundary_ref": "dimension-affect-context" }, "social_position": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "economic-resources-ownership-labor-and-debt", "status", "office", "network-position", "agenda-control", "coercive-capacity", "discursive-power" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-social-position", "boundary_ref": "dimension-social-position", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "power_asymmetry": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "canon-and-curriculum", "agenda-and-procedure", "legal-jurisdiction-and-coercion", "resources-and-class", "status-and-hierarchy", "temporal-path-and-exit" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-power-asymmetry", "boundary_ref": "dimension-power-asymmetry", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "material_conditions": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "labor-and-time", "money-credit-and-property", "infrastructure-and-logistics", "data-and-technology", "land-and-geography" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-material-conditions", "boundary_ref": "dimension-material-conditions", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "flow_dynamics": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "accumulation-or-memory", "path-dependence-or-hysteresis", "threshold-or-tipping", "balancing-feedback" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-flow-dynamics", "boundary_ref": "dimension-flow-dynamics", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "topology": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "bottleneck", "parallel-path", "interruption", "recurrence", "balancing-loop" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-topology", "boundary_ref": "dimension-topology", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "negative_flow": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "no-opportunity", "blocked", "censored", "inaccessible", "excluded", "unknown" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-negative-flow", "boundary_ref": "dimension-negative-flow", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "negative_flow_profiles": [ { "status_ref": "no-opportunity", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "adverse_inference": false, "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses" }, { "status_ref": "blocked", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "adverse_inference": false, "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses" }, { "status_ref": "censored", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "adverse_inference": false, "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses" }, { "status_ref": "inaccessible", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "adverse_inference": false, "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses" }, { "status_ref": "excluded", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "adverse_inference": false, "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses" }, { "status_ref": "unknown", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "unknown", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "adverse_inference": false, "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses" } ], "translation_profile": { "status": "unassessed", "reason_ref": "translation-inactive-boundary", "boundary_ref": "translation-inactive-boundary" }, "threshold_profile": { "status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-estimated", "trigger": [ "threshold-trigger-question" ], "unit": [ "threshold-unit-question" ], "population": [ "threshold-population-question" ], "opportunity_set": [ "threshold-opportunity-question" ], "heterogeneous_distribution": [ "threshold-heterogeneity-question" ], "observation_horizon": [ "threshold-horizon-question" ], "reset_or_hysteresis": [ "threshold-reset-question" ], "evidence": [ "threshold-evidence-requirement" ], "person_estimate": false, "effect_size_estimated": false, "prediction": false, "reason_ref": "threshold-evidence-requirement" }, "path_dependence_profile": { "status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-established", "reinforcement_mechanism": [ "path-reinforcement-question" ], "switching_cost": [ "path-switching-cost-question" ], "sunk_resource": [ "path-sunk-resource-question" ], "option_loss": [ "path-option-loss-question" ], "alternative_timing": [ "path-alternative-timing-question" ], "reversal_evidence": [ "path-reversal-evidence-question" ], "evidence": [ "path-evidence-requirement" ], "path_dependence_established": false, "reason_ref": "path-evidence-requirement" }, "distortions": [ "Formal records can hide informal agenda power, non-decisions, unpaid labor, patronage, censorship, coercion, and jurisdictional spillovers." ], "counterflows": [ "Dissent, opposition, whistleblowing, refusal, appeal, exit, alternate institution, counterarchive, reform, sunset, and external review." ], "failure_modes": [ "Institutional form is treated as stasis, procedure as legitimacy, office as authority, persistence as effectiveness, or formal equality as equal power." ], "repair_routes": [ "Open records and agenda review, restore standing and appeal, correct exclusions, resource independent oversight, preserve history, and examine alternatives." ], "repair_residuals": [ "Lost opportunity, accumulated advantage, stigma, debt, weakened capacity, distrust, and path-dependent obligations may remain." ], "repair_recurrence_checks": [ "Test whether informal veto, exclusion, capture, retaliation, unequal waiting, or displaced burden returns after formal reform." ], "repair_fresh_gate_required": true, "repair_profile": { "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "repair-review-or-retirement-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-run", "proposal_source": "card-repair-routes", "fresh_gate_refs": [ "decision-procedure", "current-authority-and-jurisdiction", "affected-party-register", "rights-assessment", "consent-or-lawful-basis" ], "attempt": [ "repair-attempt-question" ], "execution_or_outcome_observation": [ "repair-outcome-question" ], "party_indexed_residuals": [ { "affected_party_id": "institutional-participants", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "decision-subjects", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "operators-and-labor", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "resource-providers", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "audiences-and-non-audiences", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "future-parties", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] } ], "dissent": [ "repair-dissent-question" ], "recurrence": [ "repair-recurrence-question" ], "review_or_retirement": [ "repair-review-or-retirement-question" ], "repair_completed": false, "causal_effect_claimed": false, "erasure_or_absolution_claimed": false, "restored_consent_claimed": false }, "evidence_requirements": [ "Institution-specific rules, roles, jurisdictions, budgets, agendas, non-decisions, practice, dissent, affected parties, exclusions, and comparative alternatives." ], "evidence_uncertainty": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "source", "selection-and-missingness", "temporal", "transport", "affected-party-incompleteness", "normative-disagreement", "authority-and-jurisdiction" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-evidence-uncertainty", "boundary_ref": "dimension-evidence-uncertainty", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "uncertainty_aggregation": null, "alternative_paths": [ "Informal networks, markets, households, movements, rival jurisdictions, professional norms, or non-action may bypass or reshape formal selection." ], "stop_conditions": [ "Stop an effectful institutional use when jurisdiction, rights, standing, conflict, affected-party review, appeal, or safe challenge is unresolved." ], "stall_or_block_conditions": [ "Agenda denial, resource scarcity, status barrier, veto, censorship, queue, jurisdiction conflict, fear of retaliation, or absent capability." ], "reversibility": { "status": "irreversible-elements-present", "recoverable_elements": [ "Rules, offices, access, budgets, records, procedures, and current allocations may be revised." ], "residual_or_irreversible_elements": [ "Lost time, entrenched advantage, damaged trust, dispossession, ecological harm, and foreclosed options may persist." ], "prerequisites": [ "Current authority, rights review, affected-party participation, resources, record preservation, and non-retaliation safeguards." ] }, "explicit_non_implications": [ "An institution is not static, unitary, legitimate, sovereign, effective, consensual, or causally produced by a story." ] }, "authority_dependency": { "status": "context-dependent-and-unresolved", "required_for": [ "Any institutional decision, rule, allocation, exclusion, coercion, publication, or execution." ], "gate_input_ids": [ "decision-procedure", "current-authority-and-jurisdiction", "affected-party-register", "rights-assessment", "consent-or-lawful-basis" ], "non_implications": [ "Institutional existence, office, tradition, procedure, capacity, or public recognition does not establish authentic authority or legitimacy." ] }, "causal_influence": { "status": "not-assessed-by-static-atlas", "candidate_mediators": [ "Which rules, incentives, resources, roles, information channels, sanctions, expectations, or material dependencies could mediate a declared change?" ], "alternative_causes": [ "Which external shocks, coalitions, fiscal conditions, technologies, coercive capacities, or shared histories could explain institutional selection or persistence?" ], "estimand_required_before_promotion": true, "comparator_required_before_promotion": true, "assumptions_required_before_promotion": true, "causal_effect_claimed": false, "non_implications": [ "Institutional sequence, survival, reform, or co-variation establishes no effect of a prior story or expression." ] }, "evidence_profile": { "claim_register": "DESIGN_COMMITMENT", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "causal_status": "formal-mechanism-not-instantiated", "evidence_refs": [], "evidence_ref_status": "no-direct-predecessor-evidence-design-only", "expected_traces": { "source": "card-nuance-observables", "prompt_refs": [] }, "negative_cases": { "source": "card-nuance-alternative-paths", "prompt_refs": [] }, "counterevidence": [ "evidence-counterevidence" ], "falsifiers": [ "evidence-falsifier" ], "transport_bounds": [ "evidence-transport-bound" ], "promotion_requirement": "promotion-requires-source-bound-successor", "external_empirical_support_claimed": false, "mechanism_promoted": false }, "automatic_advance": false }, { "id": "action-proposal", "label": "Action proposal", "definition": "A bounded possible action states purpose, target or subject, scope, alternatives, affected parties, resources, risks, stop path, and repair preview without becoming a decision, authorization, capability, attempt, or execution.", "analytical_status": "typed-predecessor-stage-design-lens", "predecessor_domain_ids": [ "institutional-status", "legal-jurisdictional", "normative-public", "economic-resource" ], "predecessor_dimension_ids": [ "institutional-selection", "distributional-aftermath", "repair-capacity" ], "predecessor_node_type_ids": [ "ACTION_PROPOSAL", "CLAIM_ASSESSMENT", "AFFECTED_PARTY_REGISTER", "RIGHTS_ASSESSMENT" ], "predecessor_ladder_ids": [ "proposal-recorded", "affected-party-basis-reviewed" ], "nuance": { "carriers": [ "Proposal document, agenda item, design, petition, bill, budget request, implementation plan, dissent, alternative, or non-action option." ], "transformations": [ "Problem framing, target definition, option generation, bundling, scoping, cost estimation, risk allocation, and revision." ], "gates": [ "Attribution, reviewed proposal, affected-party register, rights assessment, alternatives, budget horizon, stop route, and repair readiness." ], "temporal_profile": { "onset": "Proposal formation, submission, publication, and eligibility may occur at different times.", "duration": "Validity, review window, expiry, and implementation horizon must be declared.", "latency": "Submission-to-review and review-to-decision delay may be material and unequal.", "overlap": "Competing proposals, linked decisions, external shocks, and prior commitments may overlap.", "decay": "Evidence, costs, authority assumptions, capability, and affected-party conditions may become stale.", "recurrence": "Rejected, deferred, revised, or recurring proposals require new context and gates.", "censoring": "Unsubmitted, excluded, confidential, unsafe, or off-agenda alternatives may be missing.", "resolution": "Version proposals, amendments, alternatives, affected-party registers, and review dates separately.", "timing_claim_status": "qualitative-audit-lens-only", "prediction": false }, "accumulation_profile": { "quantity_kind": "Proposal versions, commitments, and declared resource requirements", "unit": "declared version or resource unit", "additivity": "bounded-declared-units-only", "inflows": [ "New options, evidence, amendments, resources, affected-party input, and risk findings." ], "outflows": [ "Withdrawal, rejection, expiry, supersession, removed scope, or invalidated evidence." ], "decay_or_reset": [ "Material change, horizon expiry, changed jurisdiction, fresh review, or proposal retirement." ], "scope": "One proposal version and named alternatives under a declared procedure and horizon.", "stock_flow_status": "analytical-lens-only", "summable_social_constructs": [], "effect_size_claimed": false }, "observables": [ "Version, purpose, scope, target or subject, alternatives, reasons, sponsors, costs, risks, affected parties, rights review, stop path, expiry, and dissent." ], "affected_party_ids": [ "institutional-participants", "decision-subjects", "operators-and-labor", "resource-providers", "directly-affected-parties", "indirect-non-user-and-bystander-parties", "future-parties", "ecological-systems" ], "distribution": { "benefits": [ "Expected benefits must remain party- and horizon-specific rather than netted." ], "burdens": [ "Cost, labor, compliance, surveillance, opportunity loss, maintenance, and repair obligations must be separately allocated." ], "risks": [ "Rights intrusion, exclusion, coercion, ecological impact, lock-in, data harm, failure, and burden displacement." ], "voice_and_options": [ "Record standing, representation limits, dissent, refusal, appeal, alternatives, non-action, and safe exit." ], "horizons": [ "Pre-decision, implementation, operation, maintenance, exit, repair, and future-party horizons remain distinct." ], "aggregate_score": null }, "affected_party_aftermath": [ { "affected_party_id": "institutional-participants", "status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [], "burdens": [ "party-burden-question" ], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false, "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason" }, { "affected_party_id": "decision-subjects", "status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [], "burdens": [], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false, "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason" }, { "affected_party_id": "operators-and-labor", "status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [], "burdens": [ "party-burden-question" ], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false, "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason" }, { "affected_party_id": "resource-providers", "status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [ "party-benefit-question" ], "burdens": [ "party-burden-question" ], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false, "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason" }, { "affected_party_id": "directly-affected-parties", "status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [ "party-benefit-question" ], "burdens": [ "party-burden-question" ], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false, "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason" }, { "affected_party_id": "indirect-non-user-and-bystander-parties", "status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [], "burdens": [ "party-burden-question" ], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false, "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason" }, { "affected_party_id": "future-parties", "status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [], "burdens": [], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false, "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason" }, { "affected_party_id": "ecological-systems", "status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [], "burdens": [ "party-burden-question" ], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false, "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason" } ], "emotion_observation": { "status": "unassessed", "reason_ref": "dimension-emotion-observation", "boundary_ref": "dimension-emotion-observation" }, "affect_context": { "status": "unassessed", "reason_ref": "dimension-affect-context", "boundary_ref": "dimension-affect-context" }, "social_position": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "economic-resources-ownership-labor-and-debt", "office", "agenda-control", "coercive-capacity" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-social-position", "boundary_ref": "dimension-social-position", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "power_asymmetry": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "agenda-and-procedure", "legal-jurisdiction-and-coercion", "resources-and-class", "epistemic-and-measurement", "temporal-path-and-exit" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-power-asymmetry", "boundary_ref": "dimension-power-asymmetry", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "material_conditions": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "body-and-care", "labor-and-time", "land-and-geography", "energy-and-resources", "climate-and-ecology", "money-credit-and-property", "infrastructure-and-logistics", "data-and-technology" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-material-conditions", "boundary_ref": "dimension-material-conditions", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "flow_dynamics": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "delay-or-latency", "branching-or-convergence", "leakage-substitution-or-displacement", "path-dependence-or-hysteresis" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-flow-dynamics", "boundary_ref": "dimension-flow-dynamics", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "topology": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "fork", "parallel-path", "bottleneck", "substitution", "interruption", "reversal" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-topology", "boundary_ref": "dimension-topology", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "negative_flow": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "no-opportunity", "blocked", "censored", "private-or-refused", "excluded", "unknown" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-negative-flow", "boundary_ref": "dimension-negative-flow", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "negative_flow_profiles": [ { "status_ref": "no-opportunity", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "adverse_inference": false, "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses" }, { "status_ref": "blocked", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "adverse_inference": false, "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses" }, { "status_ref": "censored", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "adverse_inference": false, "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses" }, { "status_ref": "private-or-refused", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "adverse_inference": false, "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses" }, { "status_ref": "excluded", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "adverse_inference": false, "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses" }, { "status_ref": "unknown", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "unknown", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "adverse_inference": false, "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses" } ], "translation_profile": { "status": "unassessed", "reason_ref": "translation-inactive-boundary", "boundary_ref": "translation-inactive-boundary" }, "threshold_profile": { "status": "unassessed", "reason_ref": "threshold-inactive-boundary", "boundary_ref": "threshold-inactive-boundary" }, "path_dependence_profile": { "status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-established", "reinforcement_mechanism": [ "path-reinforcement-question" ], "switching_cost": [ "path-switching-cost-question" ], "sunk_resource": [ "path-sunk-resource-question" ], "option_loss": [ "path-option-loss-question" ], "alternative_timing": [ "path-alternative-timing-question" ], "reversal_evidence": [ "path-reversal-evidence-question" ], "evidence": [ "path-evidence-requirement" ], "path_dependence_established": false, "reason_ref": "path-evidence-requirement" }, "distortions": [ "Problem framing, urgency, cost omission, strategic bundling, proxy metrics, selective evidence, hidden dependencies, and narrow boundaries can bias review." ], "counterflows": [ "Counterproposal, amendment, objection, refusal, rights challenge, unbundling, delay, withdrawal, non-action, and alternate institution." ], "failure_modes": [ "A proposal is treated as a decision, urgency as necessity, predicted benefit as evidence, feasibility as permission, or non-objection as consent." ], "repair_routes": [ "Withdraw or revise the proposal, broaden affected-party review, restore alternatives, update evidence and costs, preserve dissent, and reopen gates." ], "repair_residuals": [ "Agenda displacement, participation cost, disclosure, chilling, sunk effort, and early commitment effects may remain." ], "repair_recurrence_checks": [ "Check repeated framing, omitted parties, stale evidence, scope creep, hidden cost, and reintroduced rejected provisions." ], "repair_fresh_gate_required": true, "repair_profile": { "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "repair-review-or-retirement-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-run", "proposal_source": "card-repair-routes", "fresh_gate_refs": [ "reviewed-proposal", "decision-procedure", "current-authority-and-jurisdiction", "affected-party-register", "rights-assessment", "consent-or-lawful-basis", "budget-and-horizon", "repair-readiness" ], "attempt": [ "repair-attempt-question" ], "execution_or_outcome_observation": [ "repair-outcome-question" ], "party_indexed_residuals": [ { "affected_party_id": "institutional-participants", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "decision-subjects", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "operators-and-labor", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "resource-providers", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "directly-affected-parties", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "indirect-non-user-and-bystander-parties", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "future-parties", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "ecological-systems", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] } ], "dissent": [ "repair-dissent-question" ], "recurrence": [ "repair-recurrence-question" ], "review_or_retirement": [ "repair-review-or-retirement-question" ], "repair_completed": false, "causal_effect_claimed": false, "erasure_or_absolution_claimed": false, "restored_consent_claimed": false }, "evidence_requirements": [ "Versioned proposal, procedure, purpose, scope, alternatives including non-action, affected-party register, rights and distribution review, resources, uncertainty, stop conditions, and repair plan." ], "evidence_uncertainty": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "source", "measurement", "selection-and-missingness", "temporal", "identification-and-model", "transport", "affected-party-incompleteness", "normative-disagreement", "authority-and-jurisdiction" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-evidence-uncertainty", "boundary_ref": "dimension-evidence-uncertainty", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "uncertainty_aggregation": null, "alternative_paths": [ "Revise, split, pilot only under separate authority, use a less intrusive institution, delay for evidence, preserve status quo, or take documented non-action." ], "stop_conditions": [ "Stop advancement when purpose, rights, affected parties, alternatives, jurisdiction, material feasibility, safety, or repair cannot be responsibly bounded." ], "stall_or_block_conditions": [ "Agenda exclusion, resource gap, conflict, rights objection, missing evidence, unsafe participation, jurisdiction dispute, or expired conditions." ], "reversibility": { "status": "reversible-in-part", "recoverable_elements": [ "Scope, text, alternatives, budget, schedule, and current review status may be revised or withdrawn." ], "residual_or_irreversible_elements": [ "Disclosure, agenda displacement, participation burdens, sunk costs, and expectation effects may persist." ], "prerequisites": [ "Version history, withdrawal path, affected-party review, fresh evidence, and renewed procedure." ] }, "explicit_non_implications": [ "A proposal is not a decision, authority, consent, capability, attempt, execution, causal finding, or mandate." ] }, "authority_dependency": { "status": "external-gate-required-before-effectful-use", "required_for": [ "Advancing, approving, funding, piloting, implementing, or communicating a proposal as institutional policy." ], "gate_input_ids": [ "reviewed-proposal", "decision-procedure", "current-authority-and-jurisdiction", "affected-party-register", "rights-assessment", "consent-or-lawful-basis", "budget-and-horizon", "repair-readiness" ], "non_implications": [ "Authorship, sponsorship, expertise, public support, a decision, or technical merit does not itself grant authority to act." ] }, "causal_influence": { "status": "not-assessed-by-static-atlas", "candidate_mediators": [ "Which implementation, uptake, resource, behavioral, institutional, or environmental processes would connect the proposed action to a declared outcome?" ], "alternative_causes": [ "Which external trends, selection effects, concurrent policies, prior commitments, or measurement changes could produce that outcome?" ], "estimand_required_before_promotion": true, "comparator_required_before_promotion": true, "assumptions_required_before_promotion": true, "causal_effect_claimed": false, "non_implications": [ "A theory, rationale, model, forecast, or proposal sequence establishes no causal effect." ] }, "evidence_profile": { "claim_register": "DESIGN_COMMITMENT", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "causal_status": "formal-mechanism-not-instantiated", "evidence_refs": [], "evidence_ref_status": "no-direct-predecessor-evidence-design-only", "expected_traces": { "source": "card-nuance-observables", "prompt_refs": [] }, "negative_cases": { "source": "card-nuance-alternative-paths", "prompt_refs": [] }, "counterevidence": [ "evidence-counterevidence" ], "falsifiers": [ "evidence-falsifier" ], "transport_bounds": [ "evidence-transport-bound" ], "promotion_requirement": "promotion-requires-source-bound-successor", "external_empirical_support_claimed": false, "mechanism_promoted": false }, "automatic_advance": false }, { "id": "decision-record", "label": "Decision record", "definition": "A named process records selection, rejection, deferral, conditioning, or retirement of a proposal with reasons, dissent, scope, date, expiry, and appeal, without itself establishing authority, legitimacy, consent, capability, or execution.", "analytical_status": "typed-predecessor-stage-design-lens", "predecessor_domain_ids": [ "institutional-status", "legal-jurisdictional", "normative-public" ], "predecessor_dimension_ids": [ "institutional-selection", "authorized-reach", "path-dependence" ], "predecessor_node_type_ids": [ "DECISION_RECORD", "ACTION_PROPOSAL" ], "predecessor_ladder_ids": [ "decision-recorded" ], "nuance": { "carriers": [ "Vote, order, minute, judgment, resolution, administrative record, delegated choice, veto, deferral, condition, or retirement notice." ], "transformations": [ "Agenda selection, amendment, bundling, reason-giving, voting, delegation, veto, conditioning, deferral, publication, and appeal." ], "gates": [ "Decision procedure, current membership and conflicts, proposal identity, quorum or equivalent rule, reasons, dissent, expiry, notice, and appeal." ], "temporal_profile": { "onset": "Deliberation, formal choice, recording, notice, and effective date may differ.", "duration": "Decision validity, conditions, sunset, appeal, and review horizons must be declared.", "latency": "Queue, deliberation, publication, appeal, and downstream gate delay may be unequal.", "overlap": "Concurrent decisions, jurisdictions, amendments, stays, and external events may overlap.", "decay": "Facts, authority claims, membership, capability, and reasons may become stale.", "recurrence": "Renewal, reconsideration, appeal, review, and supersession may recur.", "censoring": "Private deliberation, informal veto, absent minutes, dissent suppression, and non-decision may be missing.", "resolution": "Version proposal, agenda, deliberation, decision, notice, appeal, and effective state separately.", "timing_claim_status": "qualitative-audit-lens-only", "prediction": false }, "accumulation_profile": { "quantity_kind": "Decision records and conditional commitments", "unit": "declared record or obligation unit", "additivity": "bounded-declared-units-only", "inflows": [ "Selections, conditions, reasons, amendments, dissents, delegated tasks, and review obligations." ], "outflows": [ "Rejection, expiry, revocation, supersession, fulfillment, stay, or retirement." ], "decay_or_reset": [ "Sunset, appeal outcome, jurisdiction change, material fact change, or formal reconsideration." ], "scope": "One named decision procedure, proposal version, jurisdiction, and validity period.", "stock_flow_status": "analytical-lens-only", "summable_social_constructs": [], "effect_size_claimed": false }, "observables": [ "Proposal version, agenda, decision maker, procedure, participation, conflicts, choice state, reasons, dissent, conditions, date, notice, expiry, appeal, and supersession." ], "affected_party_ids": [ "institutional-participants", "decision-subjects", "operators-and-labor", "directly-affected-parties", "indirect-non-user-and-bystander-parties", "future-parties" ], "distribution": { "benefits": [ "Recognition, resource priority, procedural clarity, and option creation may favor different parties." ], "burdens": [ "Delay, compliance, exclusion, lost alternatives, future obligation, and appeal cost may be unequally imposed." ], "risks": [ "Agenda capture, formalism, conflict, authority laundering, path lock-in, retaliation, and decision-subject erasure." ], "voice_and_options": [ "Record standing, attendance, representation, dissent, veto, recusal, appeal, exit, review, and non-action distinctly." ], "horizons": [ "Agenda, choice, notice, effective period, appeal, renewal, sunset, and aftermath need separate horizons." ], "aggregate_score": null }, "affected_party_aftermath": [ { "affected_party_id": "institutional-participants", "status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [], "burdens": [ "party-burden-question" ], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false, "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason" }, { "affected_party_id": "decision-subjects", "status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [], "burdens": [], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false, "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason" }, { "affected_party_id": "operators-and-labor", "status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [], "burdens": [ "party-burden-question" ], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false, "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason" }, { "affected_party_id": "directly-affected-parties", "status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [ "party-benefit-question" ], "burdens": [ "party-burden-question" ], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false, "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason" }, { "affected_party_id": "indirect-non-user-and-bystander-parties", "status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [], "burdens": [ "party-burden-question" ], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false, "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason" }, { "affected_party_id": "future-parties", "status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [], "burdens": [], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false, "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason" } ], "emotion_observation": { "status": "unassessed", "reason_ref": "dimension-emotion-observation", "boundary_ref": "dimension-emotion-observation" }, "affect_context": { "status": "unassessed", "reason_ref": "dimension-affect-context", "boundary_ref": "dimension-affect-context" }, "social_position": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "status", "office", "network-position", "agenda-control", "coercive-capacity" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-social-position", "boundary_ref": "dimension-social-position", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "power_asymmetry": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "agenda-and-procedure", "legal-jurisdiction-and-coercion", "status-and-hierarchy", "temporal-path-and-exit" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-power-asymmetry", "boundary_ref": "dimension-power-asymmetry", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "material_conditions": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "labor-and-time", "money-credit-and-property", "infrastructure-and-logistics", "data-and-technology" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-material-conditions", "boundary_ref": "dimension-material-conditions", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "flow_dynamics": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "delay-or-latency", "path-dependence-or-hysteresis", "branching-or-convergence", "balancing-feedback" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-flow-dynamics", "boundary_ref": "dimension-flow-dynamics", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "topology": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "fork", "bottleneck", "interruption", "reversal", "recurrence", "balancing-loop" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-topology", "boundary_ref": "dimension-topology", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "negative_flow": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "no-opportunity", "blocked", "censored", "inaccessible", "excluded", "unknown" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-negative-flow", "boundary_ref": "dimension-negative-flow", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "negative_flow_profiles": [ { "status_ref": "no-opportunity", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "adverse_inference": false, "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses" }, { "status_ref": "blocked", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "adverse_inference": false, "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses" }, { "status_ref": "censored", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "adverse_inference": false, "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses" }, { "status_ref": "inaccessible", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "adverse_inference": false, "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses" }, { "status_ref": "excluded", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "adverse_inference": false, "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses" }, { "status_ref": "unknown", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "unknown", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "adverse_inference": false, "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses" } ], "translation_profile": { "status": "unassessed", "reason_ref": "translation-inactive-boundary", "boundary_ref": "translation-inactive-boundary" }, "threshold_profile": { "status": "unassessed", "reason_ref": "threshold-inactive-boundary", "boundary_ref": "threshold-inactive-boundary" }, "path_dependence_profile": { "status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-established", "reinforcement_mechanism": [ "path-reinforcement-question" ], "switching_cost": [ "path-switching-cost-question" ], "sunk_resource": [ "path-sunk-resource-question" ], "option_loss": [ "path-option-loss-question" ], "alternative_timing": [ "path-alternative-timing-question" ], "reversal_evidence": [ "path-reversal-evidence-question" ], "evidence": [ "path-evidence-requirement" ], "path_dependence_established": false, "reason_ref": "path-evidence-requirement" }, "distortions": [ "Agenda control, bundling, procedural opacity, strategic delay, incomplete records, vote aggregation, conflict, and performative reason-giving can distort the visible choice." ], "counterflows": [ "Dissent, recusal, veto, amendment, deferral, appeal, stay, judicial or external review, withdrawal, supersession, and non-action." ], "failure_modes": [ "Decision becomes authority, majority becomes legitimacy, silence becomes consent, procedure becomes justice, or selection becomes implementation." ], "repair_routes": [ "Stay or revoke the decision, correct the record, restore standing and appeal, separate bundled questions, disclose conflict, and conduct fresh review." ], "repair_residuals": [ "Lost time, disclosure, exclusion, commitment, distrust, sunk cost, and option foreclosure may remain." ], "repair_recurrence_checks": [ "Review repeated agenda exclusion, conflict, rubber-stamping, retaliation, stale reasons, scope creep, and bypass of appeal." ], "repair_fresh_gate_required": true, "repair_profile": { "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "repair-review-or-retirement-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-run", "proposal_source": "card-repair-routes", "fresh_gate_refs": [ "decision-procedure", "current-authority-and-jurisdiction", "affected-party-register", "rights-assessment", "consent-or-lawful-basis" ], "attempt": [ "repair-attempt-question" ], "execution_or_outcome_observation": [ "repair-outcome-question" ], "party_indexed_residuals": [ { "affected_party_id": "institutional-participants", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "decision-subjects", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "operators-and-labor", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "directly-affected-parties", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "indirect-non-user-and-bystander-parties", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "future-parties", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] } ], "dissent": [ "repair-dissent-question" ], "recurrence": [ "repair-recurrence-question" ], "review_or_retirement": [ "repair-review-or-retirement-question" ], "repair_completed": false, "causal_effect_claimed": false, "erasure_or_absolution_claimed": false, "restored_consent_claimed": false }, "evidence_requirements": [ "Exact proposal, named procedure and decision maker, jurisdiction claim, agenda, participants, conflicts, reasons, dissent, conditions, date, notice, expiry, appeal, and current status." ], "evidence_uncertainty": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "source", "selection-and-missingness", "temporal", "affected-party-incompleteness", "normative-disagreement", "authority-and-jurisdiction" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-evidence-uncertainty", "boundary_ref": "dimension-evidence-uncertainty", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "uncertainty_aggregation": null, "alternative_paths": [ "Reject, defer, condition, split, return for evidence, choose an alternative, preserve non-action, escalate to a different authorized forum, or retire." ], "stop_conditions": [ "Stop downstream use when procedure, conflict, notice, dissent, current status, appeal, jurisdiction, or affected-party review is unresolved." ], "stall_or_block_conditions": [ "No quorum or equivalent standing, veto, recusal, missing record, jurisdiction dispute, appeal, stay, resource gap, or unsafe participation." ], "reversibility": { "status": "partially-reversible", "recoverable_elements": [ "A current decision may be stayed, corrected, revoked, superseded, appealed, or retired." ], "residual_or_irreversible_elements": [ "Disclosure, lost opportunity, reliance, commitment, status effects, and actions already taken may persist." ], "prerequisites": [ "Current procedure and authority, notice, preserved record, affected-party participation, and a viable appeal or revocation route." ] }, "explicit_non_implications": [ "A decision is not authority, consent, lawful basis, capability, execution, legitimacy, goodness, justice, or causal effect." ] }, "authority_dependency": { "status": "context-dependent-and-unresolved", "required_for": [ "Giving a decision external force, allocating resources, binding a subject, invoking capability, or executing an action." ], "gate_input_ids": [ "decision-procedure", "current-authority-and-jurisdiction", "affected-party-register", "rights-assessment", "consent-or-lawful-basis" ], "non_implications": [ "A procedurally valid-looking decision record does not authenticate the principal, jurisdiction, scope, lawful basis, consent, legitimacy, or authority to act." ] }, "causal_influence": { "status": "not-assessed-by-static-atlas", "candidate_mediators": [ "Which notices, incentives, sanctions, resource allocations, operator choices, implementation steps, or expectations could connect a decision to later behavior or outcomes?" ], "alternative_causes": [ "Which concurrent events, preexisting trends, informal practices, independent actors, or anticipated decisions could explain later changes?" ], "estimand_required_before_promotion": true, "comparator_required_before_promotion": true, "assumptions_required_before_promotion": true, "causal_effect_claimed": false, "non_implications": [ "Selection, publication, or temporal precedence establishes no implementation or causal decision effect." ] }, "evidence_profile": { "claim_register": "DESIGN_COMMITMENT", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "causal_status": "formal-mechanism-not-instantiated", "evidence_refs": [], "evidence_ref_status": "no-direct-predecessor-evidence-design-only", "expected_traces": { "source": "card-nuance-observables", "prompt_refs": [] }, "negative_cases": { "source": "card-nuance-alternative-paths", "prompt_refs": [] }, "counterevidence": [ "evidence-counterevidence" ], "falsifiers": [ "evidence-falsifier" ], "transport_bounds": [ "evidence-transport-bound" ], "promotion_requirement": "promotion-requires-source-bound-successor", "external_empirical_support_claimed": false, "mechanism_promoted": false }, "automatic_advance": false }, { "id": "authorization-rights-and-affected-party-gate", "label": "Authorization, rights, and affected-party gate", "definition": "Current authority and jurisdiction claims, affected-party scope, rights assessment, and each required consent or distinct lawful basis are externally verified for the exact proposed act, purpose, party, and horizon.", "analytical_status": "typed-predecessor-stage-design-lens", "predecessor_domain_ids": [ "legal-jurisdictional", "institutional-status", "normative-public" ], "predecessor_dimension_ids": [ "authorized-reach", "distributional-aftermath", "repair-capacity" ], "predecessor_node_type_ids": [ "AUTHORITY_GRANT_CLAIM", "AFFECTED_PARTY_REGISTER", "CONSENT_RECORD", "LAWFUL_BASIS_CLAIM", "RIGHTS_ASSESSMENT", "ACTION_PROPOSAL" ], "predecessor_ladder_ids": [ "authority-claim-verified", "affected-party-basis-reviewed" ], "nuance": { "carriers": [ "Authority source, delegation, jurisdiction record, affected-party register, rights assessment, consent record, lawful-basis claim, expiry, revocation, and dissent." ], "transformations": [ "Authentication, scope interpretation, delegation, conflict review, party registration, rights balancing, consent validation, condition setting, expiry, and revocation." ], "gates": [ "Current principal and issuer, grantee, exact act, target or subject, purpose, jurisdiction, expiry, revocation, rights, affected parties, consent or lawful basis, and appeal." ], "temporal_profile": { "onset": "Grant, consent, lawful basis, notice, and proposed act may begin at different times.", "duration": "Each authorization element has its own validity, purpose, jurisdiction, and retention horizon.", "latency": "Verification, notice, withdrawal, revocation, appeal, and propagation delays must be visible.", "overlap": "Multiple principals, jurisdictions, rights, consents, lawful bases, and conflicts may overlap.", "decay": "Authority, consent, factual predicates, representation, and affected-party scope may expire or change.", "recurrence": "Renewal, re-consent, reauthorization, review, challenge, withdrawal, and revocation may recur.", "censoring": "Private authority sources, unregistered parties, inaccessible remedies, and unsafe refusal may be missing.", "resolution": "Resolve each principal-act-party-purpose-jurisdiction-horizon tuple separately.", "timing_claim_status": "qualitative-audit-lens-only", "prediction": false }, "accumulation_profile": { "quantity_kind": "Distinct scoped authorization, rights, consent, and lawful-basis records", "unit": "declared principal-act-party-purpose-horizon record", "additivity": "bounded-declared-units-only", "inflows": [ "Verified grants, registrations, assessments, consents, lawful-basis claims, conditions, and notices." ], "outflows": [ "Expiry, withdrawal, revocation, invalidation, supersession, purpose change, or jurisdiction loss." ], "decay_or_reset": [ "Material change, changed party scope, changed purpose, new rights finding, revocation, or fresh verification." ], "scope": "Exact proposed act and affected-party relation; separate grants and bases are never collapsed into a legitimacy score.", "stock_flow_status": "analytical-lens-only", "summable_social_constructs": [], "effect_size_claimed": false }, "observables": [ "Authentic source, principal, issuer, grantee, act, subject, purpose, jurisdiction, scope, conditions, expiry, revocation, affected parties, rights analysis, consent or lawful basis, notice, and appeal." ], "affected_party_ids": [ "decision-subjects", "directly-affected-parties", "indirect-non-user-and-bystander-parties", "operators-and-labor", "future-parties", "ecological-systems" ], "distribution": { "benefits": [ "Protection, representation, remedy, service, and decisional agency may be unevenly available." ], "burdens": [ "Consent labor, documentation, exclusion, compliance, surveillance, appeal, and proof burdens may be shifted." ], "risks": [ "Authority laundering, coerced or invalid consent, jurisdiction overreach, omitted parties, rights tradeoff concealment, and inaccessible remedy." ], "voice_and_options": [ "Keep refusal, withdrawal, representation limits, dissent, appeal, accommodation, alternative basis, and non-action visible." ], "horizons": [ "Grant, notice, consent, act, retention, downstream use, review, expiry, revocation, repair, and future-party horizons differ." ], "aggregate_score": null }, "affected_party_aftermath": [ { "affected_party_id": "decision-subjects", "status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [], "burdens": [], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false, "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason" }, { "affected_party_id": "directly-affected-parties", "status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [ "party-benefit-question" ], "burdens": [ "party-burden-question" ], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false, "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason" }, { "affected_party_id": "indirect-non-user-and-bystander-parties", "status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [], "burdens": [ "party-burden-question" ], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false, "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason" }, { "affected_party_id": "operators-and-labor", "status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [], "burdens": [ "party-burden-question" ], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false, "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason" }, { "affected_party_id": "future-parties", "status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [], "burdens": [], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false, "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason" }, { "affected_party_id": "ecological-systems", "status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [], "burdens": [ "party-burden-question" ], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false, "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason" } ], "emotion_observation": { "status": "unassessed", "reason_ref": "dimension-emotion-observation", "boundary_ref": "dimension-emotion-observation" }, "affect_context": { "status": "unassessed", "reason_ref": "dimension-affect-context", "boundary_ref": "dimension-affect-context" }, "social_position": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "economic-resources-ownership-labor-and-debt", "status", "office", "agenda-control", "coercive-capacity" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-social-position", "boundary_ref": "dimension-social-position", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "power_asymmetry": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "legal-jurisdiction-and-coercion", "resources-and-class", "status-and-hierarchy", "agenda-and-procedure", "temporal-path-and-exit" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-power-asymmetry", "boundary_ref": "dimension-power-asymmetry", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "material_conditions": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "body-and-care", "labor-and-time", "land-and-geography", "money-credit-and-property", "infrastructure-and-logistics", "data-and-technology" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-material-conditions", "boundary_ref": "dimension-material-conditions", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "flow_dynamics": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "delay-or-latency", "path-dependence-or-hysteresis", "coupling-or-decoupling", "balancing-feedback" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-flow-dynamics", "boundary_ref": "dimension-flow-dynamics", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "topology": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "join", "bottleneck", "interruption", "reversal", "recurrence", "balancing-loop" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-topology", "boundary_ref": "dimension-topology", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "negative_flow": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "no-opportunity", "blocked", "censored", "private-or-refused", "excluded", "inaccessible", "unknown" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-negative-flow", "boundary_ref": "dimension-negative-flow", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "negative_flow_profiles": [ { "status_ref": "no-opportunity", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "adverse_inference": false, "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses" }, { "status_ref": "blocked", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "adverse_inference": false, "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses" }, { "status_ref": "censored", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "adverse_inference": false, "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses" }, { "status_ref": "private-or-refused", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "adverse_inference": false, "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses" }, { "status_ref": "excluded", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "adverse_inference": false, "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses" }, { "status_ref": "inaccessible", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "adverse_inference": false, "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses" }, { "status_ref": "unknown", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "unknown", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "adverse_inference": false, "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses" } ], "translation_profile": { "status": "unassessed", "reason_ref": "translation-inactive-boundary", "boundary_ref": "translation-inactive-boundary" }, "threshold_profile": { "status": "unassessed", "reason_ref": "threshold-inactive-boundary", "boundary_ref": "threshold-inactive-boundary" }, "path_dependence_profile": { "status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-established", "reinforcement_mechanism": [ "path-reinforcement-question" ], "switching_cost": [ "path-switching-cost-question" ], "sunk_resource": [ "path-sunk-resource-question" ], "option_loss": [ "path-option-loss-question" ], "alternative_timing": [ "path-alternative-timing-question" ], "reversal_evidence": [ "path-reversal-evidence-question" ], "evidence": [ "path-evidence-requirement" ], "path_dependence_established": false, "reason_ref": "path-evidence-requirement" }, "distortions": [ "Boilerplate, bundled consent, inaccessible procedure, power dependence, proxy representation, stale authority, jurisdiction ambiguity, and omitted non-users can create false clearance." ], "counterflows": [ "Refusal, withdrawal, revocation, rights challenge, jurisdiction objection, appeal, accommodation, narrower scope, alternative lawful basis, and non-action." ], "failure_modes": [ "Decision becomes authority, authority claim becomes authentic authority, signature becomes valid consent, lawful basis becomes legitimacy, or capability becomes permission." ], "repair_routes": [ "Pause the act, preserve records, notify parties, restore withdrawal and appeal, narrow scope, reverify authority, reassess rights, and make remedy accessible." ], "repair_residuals": [ "Prior disclosure, coercive pressure, retaliation, lost opportunity, dignity harm, data persistence, and distrust may remain." ], "repair_recurrence_checks": [ "Review stale grants, scope creep, repeated coercion, invalid consent patterns, omitted parties, retaliation, and inaccessible remedy." ], "repair_fresh_gate_required": true, "repair_profile": { "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "repair-review-or-retirement-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-run", "proposal_source": "card-repair-routes", "fresh_gate_refs": [ "current-authority-and-jurisdiction", "affected-party-register", "rights-assessment", "consent-or-lawful-basis", "safety-and-stop-route" ], "attempt": [ "repair-attempt-question" ], "execution_or_outcome_observation": [ "repair-outcome-question" ], "party_indexed_residuals": [ { "affected_party_id": "decision-subjects", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "directly-affected-parties", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "indirect-non-user-and-bystander-parties", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "operators-and-labor", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "future-parties", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "ecological-systems", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] } ], "dissent": [ "repair-dissent-question" ], "recurrence": [ "repair-recurrence-question" ], "review_or_retirement": [ "repair-review-or-retirement-question" ], "repair_completed": false, "causal_effect_claimed": false, "erasure_or_absolution_claimed": false, "restored_consent_claimed": false }, "evidence_requirements": [ "Authentic current authority source, exact scope and jurisdiction, conflicts, expiry and revocation, affected-party register, rights assessment, each consent or lawful basis, notice, alternatives, and appeal." ], "evidence_uncertainty": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "source", "measurement", "selection-and-missingness", "temporal", "affected-party-incompleteness", "normative-disagreement", "authority-and-jurisdiction" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-evidence-uncertainty", "boundary_ref": "dimension-evidence-uncertainty", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "uncertainty_aggregation": null, "alternative_paths": [ "Narrow or redesign the act, change forum, seek fresh consent, use a separately justified less intrusive basis, provide accommodation, defer, or take non-action." ], "stop_conditions": [ "Stop before capability or attempt when authority, jurisdiction, rights, party scope, consent or lawful basis, notice, expiry, revocation, or remedy is unresolved." ], "stall_or_block_conditions": [ "Invalid or expired grant, jurisdiction conflict, refusal, withdrawal, rights conflict, omitted party, unsafe consent, inaccessible process, or stayed decision." ], "reversibility": { "status": "irreversible-elements-present", "recoverable_elements": [ "A future act can be stopped, scope narrowed, grant revoked, consent withdrawn, record corrected, and remedy opened." ], "residual_or_irreversible_elements": [ "Prior coercion, disclosure, exclusion, dignity injury, lost time, and third-party propagation may persist." ], "prerequisites": [ "Immediate stop route, authentic current authority, affected-party notice, preserved evidence, independent review, and resourced remedy." ] }, "explicit_non_implications": [ "A verified authority claim is not consent, lawful basis, capability, legitimacy, goodness, proportionality, execution, or causal effect." ] }, "authority_dependency": { "status": "external-gate-required-before-effectful-use", "required_for": [ "Every effectful invocation or action and every use of protected resources, data, bodies, property, jurisdiction, or coercive capacity." ], "gate_input_ids": [ "current-authority-and-jurisdiction", "affected-party-register", "rights-assessment", "consent-or-lawful-basis", "safety-and-stop-route" ], "non_implications": [ "This atlas neither verifies nor grants authority, jurisdiction, rights clearance, consent, lawful basis, legitimacy, or permission." ] }, "causal_influence": { "status": "not-assessed-by-static-atlas", "candidate_mediators": [ "Which sanctions, incentives, trust relations, information, resource controls, operator choices, or material constraints could connect an authorization state to later events?" ], "alternative_causes": [ "Which independent legal duties, social norms, coercion, resource dependence, prior commitments, or external events could explain compliance or noncompliance?" ], "estimand_required_before_promotion": true, "comparator_required_before_promotion": true, "assumptions_required_before_promotion": true, "causal_effect_claimed": false, "non_implications": [ "Authorization status, consent, lawful basis, or refusal establishes no causal effect, effectiveness, legitimacy, or value." ] }, "evidence_profile": { "claim_register": "DESIGN_COMMITMENT", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "causal_status": "formal-mechanism-not-instantiated", "evidence_refs": [], "evidence_ref_status": "no-direct-predecessor-evidence-design-only", "expected_traces": { "source": "card-nuance-observables", "prompt_refs": [] }, "negative_cases": { "source": "card-nuance-alternative-paths", "prompt_refs": [] }, "counterevidence": [ "evidence-counterevidence" ], "falsifiers": [ "evidence-falsifier" ], "transport_bounds": [ "evidence-transport-bound" ], "promotion_requirement": "promotion-requires-source-bound-successor", "external_empirical_support_claimed": false, "mechanism_promoted": false }, "automatic_advance": false }, { "id": "capability-and-resources", "label": "Capability and resources", "definition": "Technical, human, financial, material, informational, maintenance, safety, and repair capability is evidenced for a bounded action without importing permission, authority, desirability, or predicted success.", "analytical_status": "typed-predecessor-stage-design-lens", "predecessor_domain_ids": [ "economic-resource", "digital-computational", "material-cyberphysical", "embodied-health", "ecological", "legal-jurisdictional" ], "predecessor_dimension_ids": [ "operational-capability", "authorized-reach", "digital-or-material-state-change", "repair-capacity" ], "predecessor_node_type_ids": [ "CAPABILITY_EVIDENCE", "ACTION_PROPOSAL" ], "predecessor_ladder_ids": [ "capability-verified" ], "nuance": { "carriers": [ "People, skills, care, funds, credit, land, energy, materials, data, software, equipment, facilities, networks, logistics, suppliers, and maintenance systems." ], "transformations": [ "Procurement, training, hiring, allocation, credentialing, configuration, integration, testing, scheduling, maintenance, and contingency planning." ], "gates": [ "Current authorization, capability evidence, budget and horizon, safety, labor conditions, supply chain, ecological limits, stop route, and repair readiness." ], "temporal_profile": { "onset": "Procurement, staffing, access, readiness, and authorization may start at different times.", "duration": "Capacity, credentials, funding, supplies, maintenance, and authority expire on separate horizons.", "latency": "Acquisition, training, delivery, integration, testing, and repair latency may be substantial.", "overlap": "Shared infrastructure, competing demands, outages, seasonal constraints, and supplier dependencies may overlap.", "decay": "Skills, software, equipment, funding, materials, data quality, and institutional knowledge may degrade.", "recurrence": "Maintenance, replenishment, retraining, recertification, inspection, and contingency exercises recur.", "censoring": "Hidden labor, supplier risk, unsafe conditions, proprietary systems, and off-balance-sheet obligations may be missing.", "resolution": "Resolve capability by exact action, resource, location, operator, dependency, time, and failure condition.", "timing_claim_status": "qualitative-audit-lens-only", "prediction": false }, "accumulation_profile": { "quantity_kind": "Declared physical, financial, labor, time, data, and technical resource quantities", "unit": "resource-specific declared unit", "additivity": "bounded-declared-units-only", "inflows": [ "Funding, staffing, training, inventory, energy, access, data, equipment, maintenance, and redundancy." ], "outflows": [ "Consumption, depreciation, turnover, outage, debt service, waste, access loss, depletion, and competing allocation." ], "decay_or_reset": [ "Maintenance, replacement, retraining, replenishment, revalidation, decommissioning, or declared inventory reset." ], "scope": "One bounded action envelope; only commensurable declared units may be summed, never capability, power, legitimacy, or readiness as a scalar.", "stock_flow_status": "analytical-lens-only", "summable_social_constructs": [], "effect_size_claimed": false }, "observables": [ "Resource quantities and units, ownership, conditions, operators, skills, dependencies, availability windows, tests, failures, maintenance, safety, lifecycle, exit, and repair capacity." ], "affected_party_ids": [ "operators-and-labor", "resource-providers", "decision-subjects", "directly-affected-parties", "indirect-non-user-and-bystander-parties", "future-parties", "ecological-systems" ], "distribution": { "benefits": [ "Pay, access, service, resilience, skill, and option value may accrue to different parties." ], "burdens": [ "Labor, care, debt, extraction, energy use, maintenance, waste, surveillance, and risk may be externalized." ], "risks": [ "Unsafe work, dependency, monopoly, depletion, ecological damage, technical lock-in, hidden fragility, and capability misuse." ], "voice_and_options": [ "Record labor refusal, supplier alternatives, community objection, safety stop, accessibility, exit, decommissioning, and repair claims." ], "horizons": [ "Acquisition, readiness, operation, maintenance, depletion, decommissioning, waste, debt, and ecological recovery differ." ], "aggregate_score": null }, "affected_party_aftermath": [ { "affected_party_id": "operators-and-labor", "status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [], "burdens": [ "party-burden-question" ], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false, "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason" }, { "affected_party_id": "resource-providers", "status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [ "party-benefit-question" ], "burdens": [ "party-burden-question" ], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false, "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason" }, { "affected_party_id": "decision-subjects", "status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [], "burdens": [], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false, "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason" }, { "affected_party_id": "directly-affected-parties", "status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [ "party-benefit-question" ], "burdens": [ "party-burden-question" ], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false, "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason" }, { "affected_party_id": "indirect-non-user-and-bystander-parties", "status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [], "burdens": [ "party-burden-question" ], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false, "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason" }, { "affected_party_id": "future-parties", "status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [], "burdens": [], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false, "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason" }, { "affected_party_id": "ecological-systems", "status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [], "burdens": [ "party-burden-question" ], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false, "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason" } ], "emotion_observation": { "status": "unassessed", "reason_ref": "dimension-emotion-observation", "boundary_ref": "dimension-emotion-observation" }, "affect_context": { "status": "unassessed", "reason_ref": "dimension-affect-context", "boundary_ref": "dimension-affect-context" }, "social_position": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "economic-resources-ownership-labor-and-debt", "office", "network-position", "coercive-capacity" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-social-position", "boundary_ref": "dimension-social-position", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "power_asymmetry": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "resources-and-class", "technical-and-infrastructure", "legal-jurisdiction-and-coercion", "temporal-path-and-exit" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-power-asymmetry", "boundary_ref": "dimension-power-asymmetry", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "material_conditions": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "body-and-care", "labor-and-time", "land-and-geography", "energy-and-resources", "climate-and-ecology", "money-credit-and-property", "infrastructure-and-logistics", "data-and-technology" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-material-conditions", "boundary_ref": "dimension-material-conditions", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "flow_dynamics": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "accumulation-or-memory", "delay-or-latency", "coupling-or-decoupling", "leakage-substitution-or-displacement" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-flow-dynamics", "boundary_ref": "dimension-flow-dynamics", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "topology": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "join", "parallel-path", "bottleneck", "leakage", "substitution", "interruption" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-topology", "boundary_ref": "dimension-topology", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "negative_flow": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "not-observed", "no-opportunity", "blocked", "inaccessible", "excluded", "measurement-failure", "unknown" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-negative-flow", "boundary_ref": "dimension-negative-flow", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "negative_flow_profiles": [ { "status_ref": "not-observed", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "adverse_inference": false, "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses" }, { "status_ref": "no-opportunity", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "adverse_inference": false, "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses" }, { "status_ref": "blocked", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "adverse_inference": false, "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses" }, { "status_ref": "inaccessible", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "adverse_inference": false, "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses" }, { "status_ref": "excluded", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "adverse_inference": false, "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses" }, { "status_ref": "measurement-failure", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "adverse_inference": false, "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses" }, { "status_ref": "unknown", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "unknown", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "adverse_inference": false, "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses" } ], "translation_profile": { "status": "unassessed", "reason_ref": "translation-inactive-boundary", "boundary_ref": "translation-inactive-boundary" }, "threshold_profile": { "status": "unassessed", "reason_ref": "threshold-inactive-boundary", "boundary_ref": "threshold-inactive-boundary" }, "path_dependence_profile": { "status": "unassessed", "reason_ref": "path-inactive-boundary", "boundary_ref": "path-inactive-boundary" }, "distortions": [ "Nominal budgets, vendor claims, inventory counts, technical demos, unpaid labor, hidden maintenance, supply risk, and narrow lifecycle boundaries can overstate capability." ], "counterflows": [ "Resource refusal, reallocation, safe shutdown, redundancy, substitution, decommissioning, labor action, access revocation, and repair reserve." ], "failure_modes": [ "Resources become capability, capability becomes authority, technical feasibility becomes safety, nominal capacity becomes available capacity, or capacity becomes predicted success." ], "repair_routes": [ "Pause use, inspect dependencies, protect labor and affected parties, replenish or decommission safely, correct claims, resource repair, and reopen authorization." ], "repair_residuals": [ "Debt, extraction, waste, injury, lock-in, lost skill, environmental damage, and dependency may remain." ], "repair_recurrence_checks": [ "Review recurring shortage, hidden labor, maintenance deferral, vendor dependence, safety bypass, waste displacement, and unauthorized capability use." ], "repair_fresh_gate_required": true, "repair_profile": { "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "repair-review-or-retirement-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-run", "proposal_source": "card-repair-routes", "fresh_gate_refs": [ "current-authority-and-jurisdiction", "rights-assessment", "consent-or-lawful-basis", "capability-and-resources", "budget-and-horizon", "safety-and-stop-route", "repair-readiness" ], "attempt": [ "repair-attempt-question" ], "execution_or_outcome_observation": [ "repair-outcome-question" ], "party_indexed_residuals": [ { "affected_party_id": "operators-and-labor", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "resource-providers", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "decision-subjects", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "directly-affected-parties", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "indirect-non-user-and-bystander-parties", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "future-parties", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "ecological-systems", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] } ], "dissent": [ "repair-dissent-question" ], "recurrence": [ "repair-recurrence-question" ], "review_or_retirement": [ "repair-review-or-retirement-question" ], "repair_completed": false, "causal_effect_claimed": false, "erasure_or_absolution_claimed": false, "restored_consent_claimed": false }, "evidence_requirements": [ "Action-specific resources and units, owners, operators, access, dependencies, tests, limitations, time windows, safety, labor, lifecycle, failure, stop, and repair evidence." ], "evidence_uncertainty": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "source", "measurement", "selection-and-missingness", "temporal", "transport", "affected-party-incompleteness", "authority-and-jurisdiction" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-evidence-uncertainty", "boundary_ref": "dimension-evidence-uncertainty", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "uncertainty_aggregation": null, "alternative_paths": [ "Use a less resource-intensive action, build redundancy, substitute a safer carrier, delay, narrow scope, use human review, decommission, or take non-action." ], "stop_conditions": [ "Stop before attempt when authorization, operator safety, resources, maintenance, ecological limits, dependency, monitoring, stop route, or repair capacity is unresolved." ], "stall_or_block_conditions": [ "Funding gap, labor refusal, outage, supply disruption, missing data, unsafe condition, expired credential, access loss, ecological constraint, or inadequate repair reserve." ], "reversibility": { "status": "irreversible-elements-present", "recoverable_elements": [ "Allocation, configuration, access, scheduling, inventory, and future operation may be changed or stopped." ], "residual_or_irreversible_elements": [ "Extraction, emissions, waste, injury, debt, disclosure, sunk infrastructure, and lost options may persist." ], "prerequisites": [ "Safe stop, decommissioning plan, labor and affected-party participation, resource ownership clarity, evidence preservation, and repair funding." ] }, "explicit_non_implications": [ "Capability is not permission, authority, safety, action, effectiveness, resilience, legitimacy, or causal effect." ] }, "authority_dependency": { "status": "external-gate-required-before-effectful-use", "required_for": [ "Acquiring, configuring, allocating, accessing, or invoking capability and protected resources for the proposed action." ], "gate_input_ids": [ "current-authority-and-jurisdiction", "rights-assessment", "consent-or-lawful-basis", "capability-and-resources", "budget-and-horizon", "safety-and-stop-route", "repair-readiness" ], "non_implications": [ "Possession, ownership, technical access, funding, or operator readiness does not grant authority or permission to use capability." ] }, "causal_influence": { "status": "not-assessed-by-static-atlas", "candidate_mediators": [ "Which operator choices, configurations, dependencies, reliability conditions, implementation steps, and affected-party responses could connect capacity to action or outcome?" ], "alternative_causes": [ "Which independent resources, informal workarounds, external actors, shared infrastructure, or measurement conventions could explain apparent readiness or later events?" ], "estimand_required_before_promotion": true, "comparator_required_before_promotion": true, "assumptions_required_before_promotion": true, "causal_effect_claimed": false, "non_implications": [ "Available resources or a successful test establishes no execution or causal effect." ] }, "evidence_profile": { "claim_register": "DESIGN_COMMITMENT", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "causal_status": "formal-mechanism-not-instantiated", "evidence_refs": [], "evidence_ref_status": "no-direct-predecessor-evidence-design-only", "expected_traces": { "source": "card-nuance-observables", "prompt_refs": [] }, "negative_cases": { "source": "card-nuance-alternative-paths", "prompt_refs": [] }, "counterevidence": [ "evidence-counterevidence" ], "falsifiers": [ "evidence-falsifier" ], "transport_bounds": [ "evidence-transport-bound" ], "promotion_requirement": "promotion-requires-source-bound-successor", "external_empirical_support_claimed": false, "mechanism_promoted": false }, "automatic_advance": false }, { "id": "attempt", "label": "Attempt", "definition": "A bounded invocation or repair attempt is witnessed with preflight, actor, proposal, authority reference, parameters, time, target or subject, capability context, and stop state without assuming execution or success.", "analytical_status": "typed-predecessor-stage-design-lens", "predecessor_domain_ids": [ "digital-computational", "material-cyberphysical", "institutional-status", "legal-jurisdictional" ], "predecessor_dimension_ids": [ "operational-capability", "authorized-reach", "digital-or-material-state-change" ], "predecessor_node_type_ids": [ "INVOCATION_ATTEMPT", "ACTION_PROPOSAL" ], "predecessor_ladder_ids": [ "invocation-attempt-witnessed" ], "nuance": { "carriers": [ "Authenticated invocation, operator command, submission, transaction, physical initiation, dispatch, service request, or repair attempt record." ], "transformations": [ "Parameter binding, authentication, scheduling, routing, preflight, validation, queueing, cancellation, retry, and failure handling." ], "gates": [ "Current authorization, exact proposal and parameters, affected parties, rights and lawful basis, capability, preflight, safety, stop route, monitoring accountability, and repair readiness." ], "temporal_profile": { "onset": "Authorization check, submission, queue entry, dispatch, and execution start may differ.", "duration": "Attempt, queue, retry, timeout, cancellation, and observation windows are separate.", "latency": "Network, administrative, physical, human, and dependency latency may obscure state.", "overlap": "Retries, duplicate attempts, concurrent operators, prior actions, and external events may overlap.", "decay": "Credentials, parameters, authorization, context, and target state may become stale before execution.", "recurrence": "Retries and repeated attempts require idempotency, fresh gate checks, and separate records.", "censoring": "Lost logs, private operators, disconnected systems, and destroyed records may hide attempts.", "resolution": "Use unique attempt identity and event timestamps for preflight, dispatch, acknowledgement, cancellation, failure, and execution linkage.", "timing_claim_status": "qualitative-audit-lens-only", "prediction": false }, "accumulation_profile": { "quantity_kind": "Uniquely identified invocation attempts", "unit": "attempt record", "additivity": "bounded-declared-units-only", "inflows": [ "Authenticated submissions, retries, repair attempts, and externally witnessed physical initiations." ], "outflows": [ "Cancellation, timeout, rejection, failure, deduplication, expiry, or linked execution." ], "decay_or_reset": [ "Idempotency reset, queue expiry, revoked authorization, changed target state, or new attempt identity." ], "scope": "One action proposal, principal, target, parameter set, system boundary, and observation window; counts do not measure intent or effect.", "stock_flow_status": "analytical-lens-only", "summable_social_constructs": [], "effect_size_claimed": false }, "observables": [ "Attempt ID, actor, proposal, authority reference, subject or target, purpose, parameters, preflight, capability state, timestamp, acknowledgement, retry lineage, cancellation, failure, and execution link." ], "affected_party_ids": [ "operators-and-labor", "decision-subjects", "directly-affected-parties", "indirect-non-user-and-bystander-parties", "resource-providers" ], "distribution": { "benefits": [ "Service access, operator clarity, timely response, or remedy opportunity may be uneven." ], "burdens": [ "Queueing, labor, monitoring, risk exposure, transaction cost, and repeated requests may be displaced." ], "risks": [ "Duplicate invocation, unauthorized attempt, wrong target, stale parameters, unsafe retry, denial of service, and coercive pressure." ], "voice_and_options": [ "Keep operator refusal, subject notice where required, cancellation, withdrawal, appeal, retry limits, and non-action visible." ], "horizons": [ "Preflight, queue, dispatch, timeout, execution linkage, incident, retention, and repair horizons differ." ], "aggregate_score": null }, "affected_party_aftermath": [ { "affected_party_id": "operators-and-labor", "status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [], "burdens": [ "party-burden-question" ], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false, "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason" }, { "affected_party_id": "decision-subjects", "status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [], "burdens": [], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false, "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason" }, { "affected_party_id": "directly-affected-parties", "status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [ "party-benefit-question" ], "burdens": [ "party-burden-question" ], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false, "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason" }, { "affected_party_id": "indirect-non-user-and-bystander-parties", "status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [], "burdens": [ "party-burden-question" ], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false, "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason" }, { "affected_party_id": "resource-providers", "status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [ "party-benefit-question" ], "burdens": [ "party-burden-question" ], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false, "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason" } ], "emotion_observation": { "status": "unassessed", "reason_ref": "dimension-emotion-observation", "boundary_ref": "dimension-emotion-observation" }, "affect_context": { "status": "unassessed", "reason_ref": "dimension-affect-context", "boundary_ref": "dimension-affect-context" }, "social_position": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "office", "network-position", "coercive-capacity" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-social-position", "boundary_ref": "dimension-social-position", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "power_asymmetry": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "legal-jurisdiction-and-coercion", "technical-and-infrastructure", "temporal-path-and-exit" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-power-asymmetry", "boundary_ref": "dimension-power-asymmetry", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "material_conditions": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "body-and-care", "labor-and-time", "energy-and-resources", "infrastructure-and-logistics", "data-and-technology" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-material-conditions", "boundary_ref": "dimension-material-conditions", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "flow_dynamics": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "delay-or-latency", "continuous-or-episodic", "coupling-or-decoupling", "threshold-or-tipping" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-flow-dynamics", "boundary_ref": "dimension-flow-dynamics", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "topology": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "parallel-path", "bottleneck", "interruption", "recurrence" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-topology", "boundary_ref": "dimension-topology", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "negative_flow": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "not-observed", "blocked", "censored", "destroyed-or-lost", "measurement-failure", "unknown" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-negative-flow", "boundary_ref": "dimension-negative-flow", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "negative_flow_profiles": [ { "status_ref": "not-observed", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "adverse_inference": false, "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses" }, { "status_ref": "blocked", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "adverse_inference": false, "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses" }, { "status_ref": "censored", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "adverse_inference": false, "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses" }, { "status_ref": "destroyed-or-lost", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "adverse_inference": false, "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses" }, { "status_ref": "measurement-failure", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "adverse_inference": false, "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses" }, { "status_ref": "unknown", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "unknown", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "adverse_inference": false, "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses" } ], "translation_profile": { "status": "unassessed", "reason_ref": "translation-inactive-boundary", "boundary_ref": "translation-inactive-boundary" }, "threshold_profile": { "status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-estimated", "trigger": [ "threshold-trigger-question" ], "unit": [ "threshold-unit-question" ], "population": [ "threshold-population-question" ], "opportunity_set": [ "threshold-opportunity-question" ], "heterogeneous_distribution": [ "threshold-heterogeneity-question" ], "observation_horizon": [ "threshold-horizon-question" ], "reset_or_hysteresis": [ "threshold-reset-question" ], "evidence": [ "threshold-evidence-requirement" ], "person_estimate": false, "effect_size_estimated": false, "prediction": false, "reason_ref": "threshold-evidence-requirement" }, "path_dependence_profile": { "status": "unassessed", "reason_ref": "path-inactive-boundary", "boundary_ref": "path-inactive-boundary" }, "distortions": [ "Duplicate IDs, missing clocks, retry collapse, optimistic acknowledgement, partial logs, actor ambiguity, stale authority, and wrong system boundary can misstate attempts." ], "counterflows": [ "Cancellation, refusal, withdrawal, revocation, rate limit, queue removal, safe stop, rollback preparation, and documented non-action." ], "failure_modes": [ "Attempt becomes execution, acknowledgement becomes completion, retry becomes persistence of authority, or failure becomes absence of impact." ], "repair_routes": [ "Stop retries, revoke access, preserve logs, notify affected parties, correct target and parameters, contain partial effects, and reopen gates." ], "repair_residuals": [ "Partial state changes, disclosure, resource consumption, queue displacement, fear, or external side effects may remain even without confirmed execution." ], "repair_recurrence_checks": [ "Review duplicate attempts, stale authorization, unsafe retry, partial effects, operator override, missing logs, and repeated wrong-target invocation." ], "repair_fresh_gate_required": true, "repair_profile": { "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "repair-review-or-retirement-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-run", "proposal_source": "card-repair-routes", "fresh_gate_refs": [ "current-authority-and-jurisdiction", "affected-party-register", "rights-assessment", "consent-or-lawful-basis", "capability-and-resources", "safety-and-stop-route", "repair-readiness" ], "attempt": [ "repair-attempt-question" ], "execution_or_outcome_observation": [ "repair-outcome-question" ], "party_indexed_residuals": [ { "affected_party_id": "operators-and-labor", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "decision-subjects", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "directly-affected-parties", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "indirect-non-user-and-bystander-parties", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "resource-providers", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] } ], "dissent": [ "repair-dissent-question" ], "recurrence": [ "repair-recurrence-question" ], "review_or_retirement": [ "repair-review-or-retirement-question" ], "repair_completed": false, "causal_effect_claimed": false, "erasure_or_absolution_claimed": false, "restored_consent_claimed": false }, "evidence_requirements": [ "Unique attempt and proposal IDs, current gate references, actor, target, parameters, preflight, timestamps, acknowledgement semantics, retry lineage, failure, cancellation, and execution linkage." ], "evidence_uncertainty": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "source", "measurement", "selection-and-missingness", "temporal", "affected-party-incompleteness", "authority-and-jurisdiction" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-evidence-uncertainty", "boundary_ref": "dimension-evidence-uncertainty", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "uncertainty_aggregation": null, "alternative_paths": [ "Cancel, defer, simulate without external effect, use manual review, route to a safer system, narrow scope, or take documented non-action." ], "stop_conditions": [ "Stop or cancel when any current authority, target, rights, parameter, safety, capability, monitoring, or repair gate fails or becomes stale." ], "stall_or_block_conditions": [ "Queue, rate limit, outage, refusal, invalid credentials, revoked authority, failed preflight, dependency loss, target mismatch, or unsafe condition." ], "reversibility": { "status": "irreversible-elements-present", "recoverable_elements": [ "Queued or not-yet-executed attempts may be cancelled and credentials or parameters changed." ], "residual_or_irreversible_elements": [ "Disclosure, partial effects, resource use, queue displacement, external notification, and fear may persist." ], "prerequisites": [ "Reliable attempt identity, cancellation path, evidence preservation, containment, affected-party notice, and fresh gates." ] }, "explicit_non_implications": [ "An attempt is not execution, completion, success, effect, intent, persistence of authority, or permission to retry." ] }, "authority_dependency": { "status": "external-gate-required-before-effectful-use", "required_for": [ "Submitting, retrying, routing, cancelling, or escalating an invocation against any external target or protected resource." ], "gate_input_ids": [ "current-authority-and-jurisdiction", "affected-party-register", "rights-assessment", "consent-or-lawful-basis", "capability-and-resources", "safety-and-stop-route", "repair-readiness" ], "non_implications": [ "Technical access, an accepted request, a prior grant, or a failed attempt does not authorize invocation or retry." ] }, "causal_influence": { "status": "not-assessed-by-static-atlas", "candidate_mediators": [ "Which partial execution, notification, queue effect, resource use, operator response, or target-state change could connect an attempt to an outcome?" ], "alternative_causes": [ "Which concurrent invocations, external actors, system state, measurement loss, or background changes could explain the same outcome?" ], "estimand_required_before_promotion": true, "comparator_required_before_promotion": true, "assumptions_required_before_promotion": true, "causal_effect_claimed": false, "non_implications": [ "Attempt timing, retries, acknowledgement, or failure status establishes no causal effect." ] }, "evidence_profile": { "claim_register": "DESIGN_COMMITMENT", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "causal_status": "formal-mechanism-not-instantiated", "evidence_refs": [], "evidence_ref_status": "no-direct-predecessor-evidence-design-only", "expected_traces": { "source": "card-nuance-observables", "prompt_refs": [] }, "negative_cases": { "source": "card-nuance-alternative-paths", "prompt_refs": [] }, "counterevidence": [ "evidence-counterevidence" ], "falsifiers": [ "evidence-falsifier" ], "transport_bounds": [ "evidence-transport-bound" ], "promotion_requirement": "promotion-requires-source-bound-successor", "external_empirical_support_claimed": false, "mechanism_promoted": false }, "automatic_advance": false }, { "id": "execution-or-action", "label": "Execution or action", "definition": "A separately witnessed digital, administrative, embodied, material, or ecological action is linked to an authorized attempt and bounded target or subject without assuming success, intended outcome, legitimacy, or causal effect.", "analytical_status": "typed-predecessor-stage-design-lens", "predecessor_domain_ids": [ "digital-computational", "material-cyberphysical", "embodied-health", "ecological", "legal-jurisdictional" ], "predecessor_dimension_ids": [ "digital-or-material-state-change", "operational-capability", "distributional-aftermath" ], "predecessor_node_type_ids": [ "ACTION_EXECUTION", "INVOCATION_ATTEMPT" ], "predecessor_ladder_ids": [ "execution-status-witnessed" ], "nuance": { "carriers": [ "Operator act, service process, software execution, transaction, administrative change, communication, physical movement, material intervention, or witnessed non-action." ], "transformations": [ "Input validation, actuation, transfer, modification, enforcement, communication, resource consumption, logging, containment, rollback, and termination." ], "gates": [ "Live authorization, exact attempt linkage, target verification, preflight, monitoring, safety envelope, stop route, incident response, and repair readiness." ], "temporal_profile": { "onset": "Start, first external effect, acknowledgement, and recorded execution time may differ.", "duration": "Execution, exposure, persistence, containment, rollback, and observation windows are separate.", "latency": "Actuation and downstream material or social response may be delayed.", "overlap": "Concurrent actions, non-actions, dependencies, environmental events, and feedback may overlap.", "decay": "Execution traces, target state, effects, credentials, and monitoring quality may decay or change.", "recurrence": "Repeated, scheduled, iterative, or automated-seeming actions still require separate current authorization and records.", "censoring": "Partial execution, silent failure, off-system effects, private operators, and missing logs may be hidden.", "resolution": "Resolve start, partial state, completion status, termination, target change, and rollback as distinct events.", "timing_claim_status": "qualitative-audit-lens-only", "prediction": false }, "accumulation_profile": { "quantity_kind": "Witnessed action events and declared material or digital changes", "unit": "action-specific declared unit", "additivity": "bounded-declared-units-only", "inflows": [ "Separately witnessed executions, partial executions, resource transfers, state changes, and authorized repeats." ], "outflows": [ "Rollback, reversal, decommissioning, expiration, recovery, or bounded state restoration." ], "decay_or_reset": [ "Target reset, rollback, restoration, data expiry, physical decay, or declared observation reset." ], "scope": "One action-attempt-target-purpose-system-time tuple; heterogeneous actions and social effects are not combined.", "stock_flow_status": "analytical-lens-only", "summable_social_constructs": [], "effect_size_claimed": false }, "observables": [ "Execution ID, linked attempt and proposal, actor, target or subject, start and end, status, state changes, resources, logs, monitor, stop events, failures, rollback, and external witnesses." ], "affected_party_ids": [ "operators-and-labor", "decision-subjects", "directly-affected-parties", "indirect-non-user-and-bystander-parties", "resource-providers", "future-parties", "ecological-systems" ], "distribution": { "benefits": [ "Service, transfer, protection, access, or material improvement must be observed by party and horizon." ], "burdens": [ "Labor, compliance, extraction, surveillance, disruption, exclusion, risk, maintenance, and waste may be shifted." ], "risks": [ "Wrong target, unauthorized scope, partial failure, coercion, safety incident, cascading dependency, irreversible change, and displaced harm." ], "voice_and_options": [ "Maintain refusal, safe stop, withdrawal where meaningful, appeal, incident report, alternative service, exit, and remedy." ], "horizons": [ "Execution, immediate effect, delayed effect, persistence, maintenance, reversal, repair, and future impact differ." ], "aggregate_score": null }, "affected_party_aftermath": [ { "affected_party_id": "operators-and-labor", "status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [], "burdens": [ "party-burden-question" ], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false, "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason" }, { "affected_party_id": "decision-subjects", "status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [], "burdens": [], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false, "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason" }, { "affected_party_id": "directly-affected-parties", "status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [ "party-benefit-question" ], "burdens": [ "party-burden-question" ], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false, "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason" }, { "affected_party_id": "indirect-non-user-and-bystander-parties", "status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [], "burdens": [ "party-burden-question" ], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false, "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason" }, { "affected_party_id": "resource-providers", "status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [ "party-benefit-question" ], "burdens": [ "party-burden-question" ], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false, "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason" }, { "affected_party_id": "future-parties", "status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [], "burdens": [], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false, "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason" }, { "affected_party_id": "ecological-systems", "status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [], "burdens": [ "party-burden-question" ], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false, "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason" } ], "emotion_observation": { "status": "unassessed", "reason_ref": "dimension-emotion-observation", "boundary_ref": "dimension-emotion-observation" }, "affect_context": { "status": "unassessed", "reason_ref": "dimension-affect-context", "boundary_ref": "dimension-affect-context" }, "social_position": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "economic-resources-ownership-labor-and-debt", "office", "coercive-capacity", "network-position" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-social-position", "boundary_ref": "dimension-social-position", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "power_asymmetry": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "legal-jurisdiction-and-coercion", "resources-and-class", "technical-and-infrastructure", "temporal-path-and-exit" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-power-asymmetry", "boundary_ref": "dimension-power-asymmetry", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "material_conditions": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "body-and-care", "labor-and-time", "land-and-geography", "energy-and-resources", "climate-and-ecology", "money-credit-and-property", "infrastructure-and-logistics", "data-and-technology" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-material-conditions", "boundary_ref": "dimension-material-conditions", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "flow_dynamics": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "continuous-or-episodic", "delay-or-latency", "coupling-or-decoupling", "leakage-substitution-or-displacement" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-flow-dynamics", "boundary_ref": "dimension-flow-dynamics", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "topology": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "parallel-path", "bottleneck", "leakage", "interruption", "reversal", "recurrence" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-topology", "boundary_ref": "dimension-topology", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "negative_flow": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "not-observed", "detection-bounded-absence", "blocked", "censored", "destroyed-or-lost", "measurement-failure", "unknown" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-negative-flow", "boundary_ref": "dimension-negative-flow", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "negative_flow_profiles": [ { "status_ref": "not-observed", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "adverse_inference": false, "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses" }, { "status_ref": "detection-bounded-absence", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "adverse_inference": false, "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses" }, { "status_ref": "blocked", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "adverse_inference": false, "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses" }, { "status_ref": "censored", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "adverse_inference": false, "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses" }, { "status_ref": "destroyed-or-lost", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "adverse_inference": false, "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses" }, { "status_ref": "measurement-failure", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "adverse_inference": false, "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses" }, { "status_ref": "unknown", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "unknown", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "adverse_inference": false, "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses" } ], "translation_profile": { "status": "unassessed", "reason_ref": "translation-inactive-boundary", "boundary_ref": "translation-inactive-boundary" }, "threshold_profile": { "status": "unassessed", "reason_ref": "threshold-inactive-boundary", "boundary_ref": "threshold-inactive-boundary" }, "path_dependence_profile": { "status": "unassessed", "reason_ref": "path-inactive-boundary", "boundary_ref": "path-inactive-boundary" }, "distortions": [ "Success-coded status, partial logs, actor ambiguity, target mismatch, narrow boundary, missing non-users, hidden labor, and rollback claims can obscure actual action." ], "counterflows": [ "Safe stop, refusal, withdrawal, containment, rollback, reversal, decommissioning, appeal, external intervention, and repair action." ], "failure_modes": [ "Attempt becomes execution, execution becomes completion, completion becomes success, intended state becomes observed outcome, or actor log becomes causal proof." ], "repair_routes": [ "Stop and contain, preserve evidence, notify and protect affected parties, reverse where possible, restore service, compensate, correct records, and reassess recurrence." ], "repair_residuals": [ "Injury, exposure, dispossession, emissions, waste, distrust, fear, option loss, and third-party propagation may remain." ], "repair_recurrence_checks": [ "Review repeated wrong-target action, authorization drift, monitoring gaps, partial failures, rollback failure, operator pressure, and displaced effects." ], "repair_fresh_gate_required": true, "repair_profile": { "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "repair-review-or-retirement-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-run", "proposal_source": "card-repair-routes", "fresh_gate_refs": [ "current-authority-and-jurisdiction", "affected-party-register", "rights-assessment", "consent-or-lawful-basis", "capability-and-resources", "budget-and-horizon", "safety-and-stop-route", "repair-readiness" ], "attempt": [ "repair-attempt-question" ], "execution_or_outcome_observation": [ "repair-outcome-question" ], "party_indexed_residuals": [ { "affected_party_id": "operators-and-labor", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "decision-subjects", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "directly-affected-parties", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "indirect-non-user-and-bystander-parties", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "resource-providers", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "future-parties", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "ecological-systems", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] } ], "dissent": [ "repair-dissent-question" ], "recurrence": [ "repair-recurrence-question" ], "review_or_retirement": [ "repair-review-or-retirement-question" ], "repair_completed": false, "causal_effect_claimed": false, "erasure_or_absolution_claimed": false, "restored_consent_claimed": false }, "evidence_requirements": [ "Unique execution and attempt links, current gate evidence, actor and target, timestamps, state witnesses, resources, status semantics, monitoring, stop events, failures, rollback, affected parties, and boundary limits." ], "evidence_uncertainty": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "source", "measurement", "selection-and-missingness", "temporal", "identification-and-model", "affected-party-incompleteness", "authority-and-jurisdiction" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-evidence-uncertainty", "boundary_ref": "dimension-evidence-uncertainty", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "uncertainty_aggregation": null, "alternative_paths": [ "Stop, narrow, substitute a safer method, use staged human review, provide alternative service, restore prior state, decommission, or take documented non-action." ], "stop_conditions": [ "Stop immediately when authority, target, rights, safety, monitoring, scope, capability, containment, or repair conditions fail or become unknown." ], "stall_or_block_conditions": [ "Failed preflight, operator refusal, dependency outage, safety interlock, revoked authority, target change, resource loss, containment, or external stay." ], "reversibility": { "status": "irreversible-elements-present", "recoverable_elements": [ "Some digital state, transfers, access, configuration, service, or material conditions may be rolled back or restored." ], "residual_or_irreversible_elements": [ "Bodily harm, disclosure, copying, emissions, ecological change, coercion, lost time, and social consequences may persist." ], "prerequisites": [ "Immediate stop, reliable state history, backups or restitution resources, affected-party participation, fresh authority, and independent review." ] }, "explicit_non_implications": [ "Execution is not success, intended outcome, causal effect, legitimacy, justice, consent, proportionality, or harmlessness." ] }, "authority_dependency": { "status": "external-gate-required-before-effectful-use", "required_for": [ "Every external act, material change, communication, enforcement, transfer, data use, and repeat execution." ], "gate_input_ids": [ "current-authority-and-jurisdiction", "affected-party-register", "rights-assessment", "consent-or-lawful-basis", "capability-and-resources", "budget-and-horizon", "safety-and-stop-route", "repair-readiness" ], "non_implications": [ "A live system, operator instruction, prior attempt, decision, or capability record does not grant authority to execute." ] }, "causal_influence": { "status": "not-assessed-by-static-atlas", "candidate_mediators": [ "Which delivered treatment, exposure, material pathway, institutional response, behavioral adaptation, or environmental process could connect execution to a declared outcome?" ], "alternative_causes": [ "Which concurrent actions, background trends, selection, anticipation, spillovers, shared shocks, or measurement changes could produce the observed outcome?" ], "estimand_required_before_promotion": true, "comparator_required_before_promotion": true, "assumptions_required_before_promotion": true, "causal_effect_claimed": false, "non_implications": [ "Witnessed execution and temporal precedence establish no causal effect or attribution of an outcome." ] }, "evidence_profile": { "claim_register": "DESIGN_COMMITMENT", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "causal_status": "formal-mechanism-not-instantiated", "evidence_refs": [], "evidence_ref_status": "no-direct-predecessor-evidence-design-only", "expected_traces": { "source": "card-nuance-observables", "prompt_refs": [] }, "negative_cases": { "source": "card-nuance-alternative-paths", "prompt_refs": [] }, "counterevidence": [ "evidence-counterevidence" ], "falsifiers": [ "evidence-falsifier" ], "transport_bounds": [ "evidence-transport-bound" ], "promotion_requirement": "promotion-requires-source-bound-successor", "external_empirical_support_claimed": false, "mechanism_promoted": false }, "automatic_advance": false }, { "id": "outcome-observation", "label": "Outcome observation", "definition": "A bounded digital, material, embodied, ecological, institutional, or public state is observed after or around an action under a declared construct, population, method, horizon, and missingness boundary without being called an effect.", "analytical_status": "typed-predecessor-stage-design-lens", "predecessor_domain_ids": [ "informational-record", "material-cyberphysical", "embodied-health", "ecological", "social-relational", "institutional-status", "normative-public" ], "predecessor_dimension_ids": [ "digital-or-material-state-change", "distributional-aftermath", "feedback-sensitivity" ], "predecessor_node_type_ids": [ "OUTCOME_OBSERVATION", "ASSOCIATION_OBSERVATION" ], "predecessor_ladder_ids": [ "outcome-observed" ], "nuance": { "carriers": [ "Sensor, administrative record, survey, self-report, interview, audit, ledger, observation, ecological sample, complaint, service record, or affected-party account." ], "transformations": [ "Construct definition, sampling, instrumentation, aggregation within valid units, linkage, coding, normalization, redaction, publication, and revision." ], "gates": [ "Outcome definition, measurement validity, population and affected-party scope, privacy and rights, time window, missingness, baseline or comparator distinction, and review." ], "temporal_profile": { "onset": "Action, possible effect, observation, measurement, and record time may differ.", "duration": "State duration, observation window, instrument exposure, and record retention are separate.", "latency": "Biological, material, institutional, ecological, reporting, and detection latency may be long or unknown.", "overlap": "Concurrent actions, prior trends, adaptation, spillovers, seasonality, and external shocks may overlap.", "decay": "Effects, states, biomarkers, memory, records, and instrument validity may decay differently.", "recurrence": "Events, symptoms, complaints, service states, incidents, and measurements may recur.", "censoring": "Loss to follow-up, privacy, refusal, death, migration, destruction, platform exit, and delayed reporting may censor outcomes.", "resolution": "Declare construct, unit, population, place, horizon, event time, observation time, and record time separately.", "timing_claim_status": "qualitative-audit-lens-only", "prediction": false }, "accumulation_profile": { "quantity_kind": "Declared outcome construct in valid physical, administrative, event, or instrument units", "unit": "construct-specific declared unit", "additivity": "bounded-declared-units-only", "inflows": [ "New measurements, events, affected-party accounts, corrections, linked records, and independently replicated observations." ], "outflows": [ "Invalidation, deduplication, correction, reclassification, expiry, loss to follow-up, or deletion under lawful policy." ], "decay_or_reset": [ "Instrument change, cohort reset, construct revision, baseline change, recovery, or declared observation-window closure." ], "scope": "One construct-population-place-window-method definition; meaning, welfare, legitimacy, emotion, and heterogeneous units are not summed.", "stock_flow_status": "analytical-lens-only", "summable_social_constructs": [], "effect_size_claimed": false }, "observables": [ "Construct, unit, method, instrument, population, selection, baseline distinction, timestamps, missingness, privacy, affected parties, raw or referenced evidence, corrections, and negative cases." ], "affected_party_ids": [ "directly-affected-parties", "indirect-non-user-and-bystander-parties", "decision-subjects", "operators-and-labor", "future-parties", "ecological-systems" ], "distribution": { "benefits": [ "Observed service, health, resource, access, safety, environmental, or option changes remain party- and horizon-specific." ], "burdens": [ "Observed harm, exclusion, cost, labor, exposure, displacement, and maintenance remain disaggregated." ], "risks": [ "Proxy error, missing non-users, surveillance, retraumatization, publication harm, aggregation bias, and boundary displacement." ], "voice_and_options": [ "Preserve self-description, contestation, refusal, data correction, appeal, alternative measure, privacy, and nonparticipation." ], "horizons": [ "Immediate, delayed, cumulative, recovery, recurrence, lifecycle, intergenerational, and ecological horizons remain separate." ], "aggregate_score": null }, "affected_party_aftermath": [ { "affected_party_id": "directly-affected-parties", "status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [ "party-benefit-question" ], "burdens": [ "party-burden-question" ], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false, "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason" }, { "affected_party_id": "indirect-non-user-and-bystander-parties", "status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [], "burdens": [ "party-burden-question" ], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false, "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason" }, { "affected_party_id": "decision-subjects", "status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [], "burdens": [], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false, "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason" }, { "affected_party_id": "operators-and-labor", "status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [], "burdens": [ "party-burden-question" ], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false, "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason" }, { "affected_party_id": "future-parties", "status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [], "burdens": [], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false, "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason" }, { "affected_party_id": "ecological-systems", "status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [], "burdens": [ "party-burden-question" ], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false, "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason" } ], "emotion_observation": { "status": "unassessed", "reason_ref": "dimension-emotion-observation", "boundary_ref": "dimension-emotion-observation" }, "affect_context": { "status": "unassessed", "reason_ref": "dimension-affect-context", "boundary_ref": "dimension-affect-context" }, "social_position": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "economic-resources-ownership-labor-and-debt", "status", "office", "network-position", "coercive-capacity", "discursive-power" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-social-position", "boundary_ref": "dimension-social-position", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "power_asymmetry": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "epistemic-and-measurement", "resources-and-class", "status-and-hierarchy", "technical-and-infrastructure", "temporal-path-and-exit" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-power-asymmetry", "boundary_ref": "dimension-power-asymmetry", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "material_conditions": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "body-and-care", "labor-and-time", "land-and-geography", "energy-and-resources", "climate-and-ecology", "money-credit-and-property", "infrastructure-and-logistics", "data-and-technology" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-material-conditions", "boundary_ref": "dimension-material-conditions", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "flow_dynamics": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "delay-or-latency", "continuous-or-episodic", "accumulation-or-memory", "leakage-substitution-or-displacement", "coupling-or-decoupling" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-flow-dynamics", "boundary_ref": "dimension-flow-dynamics", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "topology": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "parallel-path", "leakage", "substitution", "interruption", "recurrence" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-topology", "boundary_ref": "dimension-topology", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "negative_flow": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "not-observed", "detection-bounded-absence", "no-opportunity", "censored", "destroyed-or-lost", "inaccessible", "private-or-refused", "excluded", "measurement-failure", "unknown" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-negative-flow", "boundary_ref": "dimension-negative-flow", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "negative_flow_profiles": [ { "status_ref": "not-observed", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "adverse_inference": false, "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses" }, { "status_ref": "detection-bounded-absence", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "adverse_inference": false, "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses" }, { "status_ref": "no-opportunity", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "adverse_inference": false, "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses" }, { "status_ref": "censored", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "adverse_inference": false, "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses" }, { "status_ref": "destroyed-or-lost", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "adverse_inference": false, "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses" }, { "status_ref": "inaccessible", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "adverse_inference": false, "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses" }, { "status_ref": "private-or-refused", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "adverse_inference": false, "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses" }, { "status_ref": "excluded", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "adverse_inference": false, "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses" }, { "status_ref": "measurement-failure", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "adverse_inference": false, "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses" }, { "status_ref": "unknown", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "unknown", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "adverse_inference": false, "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses" } ], "translation_profile": { "status": "unassessed", "reason_ref": "translation-inactive-boundary", "boundary_ref": "translation-inactive-boundary" }, "threshold_profile": { "status": "unassessed", "reason_ref": "threshold-inactive-boundary", "boundary_ref": "threshold-inactive-boundary" }, "path_dependence_profile": { "status": "unassessed", "reason_ref": "path-inactive-boundary", "boundary_ref": "path-inactive-boundary" }, "distortions": [ "Construct choice, proxy drift, attrition, survivor bias, underreporting, observer effect, selective publication, data linkage, and narrow boundary can alter the visible aftermath." ], "counterflows": [ "Affected-party testimony, complaint, correction, independent audit, alternative measure, refusal, privacy protection, negative case, and boundary expansion." ], "failure_modes": [ "Post-action state becomes causal effect, measured average becomes every party, absence becomes zero, intended target becomes complete boundary, or metric becomes value." ], "repair_routes": [ "Protect parties, correct and version measurements, broaden boundary, restore missing voices, stop harmful data collection, preserve evidence, and open causal and normative review separately." ], "repair_residuals": [ "Unmeasured harm, surveillance, retraumatization, stigma, missing records, ecological change, and delayed or irreversible effects may remain." ], "repair_recurrence_checks": [ "Repeat measurement under declared horizons, inspect displaced and non-user effects, monitor recurrence, and audit whether prior missingness or proxy bias returns." ], "repair_fresh_gate_required": true, "repair_profile": { "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "repair-review-or-retirement-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-run", "proposal_source": "card-repair-routes", "fresh_gate_refs": [ "current-authority-and-jurisdiction", "affected-party-register", "rights-assessment", "consent-or-lawful-basis", "publication-and-access", "safety-and-stop-route" ], "attempt": [ "repair-attempt-question" ], "execution_or_outcome_observation": [ "repair-outcome-question" ], "party_indexed_residuals": [ { "affected_party_id": "directly-affected-parties", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "indirect-non-user-and-bystander-parties", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "decision-subjects", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "operators-and-labor", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "future-parties", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "ecological-systems", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] } ], "dissent": [ "repair-dissent-question" ], "recurrence": [ "repair-recurrence-question" ], "review_or_retirement": [ "repair-review-or-retirement-question" ], "repair_completed": false, "causal_effect_claimed": false, "erasure_or_absolution_claimed": false, "restored_consent_claimed": false }, "evidence_requirements": [ "Declared outcome construct and unit, method, population, selection, instrument, timing, privacy, missingness, affected-party scope, corrections, negative cases, and system boundary." ], "evidence_uncertainty": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "source", "measurement", "selection-and-missingness", "temporal", "identification-and-model", "transport", "affected-party-incompleteness", "normative-disagreement" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-evidence-uncertainty", "boundary_ref": "dimension-evidence-uncertainty", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "uncertainty_aggregation": null, "alternative_paths": [ "Background trend, common shock, selection, anticipation, substitution, displacement, concurrent action, measurement change, or natural recovery may produce the observation." ], "stop_conditions": [ "Stop collection, linkage, publication, or downstream use when rights, privacy, safety, construct validity, missingness, boundary, or affected-party protection is inadequate." ], "stall_or_block_conditions": [ "No opportunity, loss to follow-up, refusal, privacy restriction, inaccessible system, destroyed evidence, instrument failure, delayed detection, or unsafe reporting." ], "reversibility": { "status": "irreversible-elements-present", "recoverable_elements": [ "Current measurement, access, linkage, publication, construct, and corrective record may be changed." ], "residual_or_irreversible_elements": [ "Underlying harm, lost evidence, prior surveillance, disclosure, stigma, bodily or ecological change, and delayed effects may persist." ], "prerequisites": [ "Evidence preservation, privacy and safety safeguards, affected-party participation, independent review, and resources for longitudinal observation and repair." ] }, "explicit_non_implications": [ "An outcome observation is not an effect, attribution, success, benefit, harm total, legitimacy, justice, emotion, or prediction." ] }, "authority_dependency": { "status": "external-gate-required-before-effectful-use", "required_for": [ "Collecting, linking, retaining, publishing, interpreting for decisions, or acting on outcome data." ], "gate_input_ids": [ "current-authority-and-jurisdiction", "affected-party-register", "rights-assessment", "consent-or-lawful-basis", "publication-and-access", "safety-and-stop-route" ], "non_implications": [ "A public event, operational log, research interest, or prior consent does not authorize every measurement, linkage, inference, publication, or reuse." ] }, "causal_influence": { "status": "not-assessed-by-static-atlas", "candidate_mediators": [ "Which delivered intervention, uptake, exposure, material process, institutional response, or behavioral adaptation could connect action to this exact outcome construct?" ], "alternative_causes": [ "Which background trend, common cause, selection, anticipation, spillover, concurrent action, measurement change, or regression could explain it?" ], "estimand_required_before_promotion": true, "comparator_required_before_promotion": true, "assumptions_required_before_promotion": true, "causal_effect_claimed": false, "non_implications": [ "Post-action timing, association, narrative fit, or observed change establishes no causal effect." ] }, "evidence_profile": { "claim_register": "DESIGN_COMMITMENT", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "causal_status": "formal-mechanism-not-instantiated", "evidence_refs": [], "evidence_ref_status": "no-direct-predecessor-evidence-design-only", "expected_traces": { "source": "card-nuance-observables", "prompt_refs": [] }, "negative_cases": { "source": "card-nuance-alternative-paths", "prompt_refs": [] }, "counterevidence": [ "evidence-counterevidence" ], "falsifiers": [ "evidence-falsifier" ], "transport_bounds": [ "evidence-transport-bound" ], "promotion_requirement": "promotion-requires-source-bound-successor", "external_empirical_support_claimed": false, "mechanism_promoted": false }, "automatic_advance": false }, { "id": "aftermath-causal-and-normative-assessment", "label": "Aftermath causal and normative assessment", "definition": "Outcome observations, associations, a declared causal estimand and assessment, and separate rights or normative assessments are evaluated under explicit methods and frameworks without merging effect, legitimacy, goodness, or justice.", "analytical_status": "typed-predecessor-stage-design-lens", "predecessor_domain_ids": [ "normative-public", "informational-record", "social-relational", "legal-jurisdictional", "embodied-health", "ecological" ], "predecessor_dimension_ids": [ "distributional-aftermath", "feedback-sensitivity", "repair-capacity" ], "predecessor_node_type_ids": [ "OUTCOME_OBSERVATION", "ASSOCIATION_OBSERVATION", "CAUSAL_ESTIMAND", "CAUSAL_ASSESSMENT", "NORMATIVE_ASSESSMENT", "RIGHTS_ASSESSMENT" ], "predecessor_ladder_ids": [ "outcome-observed", "causal-effect-assessed", "normative-assessment-separated" ], "nuance": { "carriers": [ "Outcome records, affected-party accounts, estimand specification, study design, causal assessment, rights analysis, ethical framework, distribution review, dissent, and uncertainty vector." ], "transformations": [ "Construct definition, comparison, identification, modeling, sensitivity analysis, interpretation, rights reasoning, value articulation, distribution review, and publication." ], "gates": [ "Outcome quality, estimand and comparator, assumptions, alternative causes, transport limits, affected-party completeness, named normative framework, jurisdiction, dissent, and review." ], "temporal_profile": { "onset": "Outcome, detection, causal question, analysis, normative review, and publication may start at different times.", "duration": "Effect windows, follow-up, assessment validity, rights impact, and repair horizons are distinct.", "latency": "Delayed outcomes, reporting, identification, affected-party recognition, and institutional response may create long latency.", "overlap": "Concurrent actions, feedback, adaptation, repair, shocks, and changing norms may overlap assessment.", "decay": "Data quality, model fit, transportability, authority, and normative relevance may change over time.", "recurrence": "Reanalysis, replication, rights review, appeal, reinterpretation, and updated aftermath assessment may recur.", "censoring": "Missing outcomes, unpublished nulls, inaccessible data, unsafe testimony, lost parties, and truncated follow-up may censor assessment.", "resolution": "Resolve outcome horizon, estimand, comparator, population, method, framework, affected party, and assessment date separately.", "timing_claim_status": "qualitative-audit-lens-only", "prediction": false }, "accumulation_profile": { "quantity_kind": "Heterogeneous evidence, assessments, disagreement, and residual records", "unit": "non-additive", "additivity": "non-additive", "inflows": [ "New outcome evidence, replications, counterevidence, affected-party accounts, causal analyses, rights findings, and normative arguments." ], "outflows": [ "Retraction, invalidation, supersession, scope narrowing, data expiry, or explicit retirement of an assessment." ], "decay_or_reset": [ "New evidence, method correction, changed conditions, framework revision, jurisdiction change, or declared fresh assessment." ], "scope": "One estimand-population-horizon-method question and separately named normative frameworks; uncertainty and disagreement are not averaged.", "stock_flow_status": "analytical-lens-only", "summable_social_constructs": [], "effect_size_claimed": false }, "observables": [ "Outcome data, estimand, comparator, assumptions, identification strategy, sensitivity, uncertainty vector, alternative causes, transport limits, affected parties, rights analysis, framework, reasons, and dissent." ], "affected_party_ids": [ "directly-affected-parties", "indirect-non-user-and-bystander-parties", "decision-subjects", "operators-and-labor", "future-parties", "ecological-systems" ], "distribution": { "benefits": [ "Effects and valued outcomes remain indexed by affected party, baseline, framework, and horizon." ], "burdens": [ "Harms, costs, risk, uncertainty, lost options, and repair labor remain separate and cannot be netted away." ], "risks": [ "Model overclaim, omitted parties, value laundering, average-effect dominance, transport failure, retrospective justification, and framework capture." ], "voice_and_options": [ "Preserve affected-party interpretation, refusal, dissent, alternative estimand, rival model, competing framework, appeal, and unresolved disagreement." ], "horizons": [ "Immediate, delayed, cumulative, recovery, recurrence, lifecycle, intergenerational, and ecological aftermath must remain separate." ], "aggregate_score": null }, "affected_party_aftermath": [ { "affected_party_id": "directly-affected-parties", "status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [ "party-benefit-question" ], "burdens": [ "party-burden-question" ], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false, "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason" }, { "affected_party_id": "indirect-non-user-and-bystander-parties", "status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [], "burdens": [ "party-burden-question" ], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false, "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason" }, { "affected_party_id": "decision-subjects", "status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [], "burdens": [], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false, "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason" }, { "affected_party_id": "operators-and-labor", "status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [], "burdens": [ "party-burden-question" ], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false, "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason" }, { "affected_party_id": "future-parties", "status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [], "burdens": [], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false, "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason" }, { "affected_party_id": "ecological-systems", "status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [], "burdens": [ "party-burden-question" ], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false, "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason" } ], "emotion_observation": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "self-report", "attributed-expression", "behavioral-observation", "physiology", "cultural-vocabulary", "institutional-framing" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-emotion-observation", "boundary_ref": "dimension-emotion-observation", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "affect_context": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "fear-or-threat", "anger-or-outrage", "humiliation-or-status-injury", "grief-or-loss", "hope-or-efficacy", "shame-or-guilt" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-affect-context", "boundary_ref": "dimension-affect-context", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "social_position": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "economic-resources-ownership-labor-and-debt", "status", "office", "network-position", "agenda-control", "coercive-capacity", "discursive-power" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-social-position", "boundary_ref": "dimension-social-position", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "power_asymmetry": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "epistemic-and-measurement", "agenda-and-procedure", "legal-jurisdiction-and-coercion", "resources-and-class", "status-and-hierarchy", "temporal-path-and-exit" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-power-asymmetry", "boundary_ref": "dimension-power-asymmetry", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "material_conditions": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "body-and-care", "labor-and-time", "land-and-geography", "energy-and-resources", "climate-and-ecology", "money-credit-and-property", "infrastructure-and-logistics", "data-and-technology" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-material-conditions", "boundary_ref": "dimension-material-conditions", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "flow_dynamics": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "delay-or-latency", "accumulation-or-memory", "path-dependence-or-hysteresis", "leakage-substitution-or-displacement", "reinforcing-feedback", "balancing-feedback" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-flow-dynamics", "boundary_ref": "dimension-flow-dynamics", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "topology": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "fork", "join", "parallel-path", "leakage", "substitution", "recurrence", "reinforcing-loop", "balancing-loop" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-topology", "boundary_ref": "dimension-topology", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "negative_flow": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "not-observed", "detection-bounded-absence", "censored", "destroyed-or-lost", "inaccessible", "private-or-refused", "excluded", "measurement-failure", "unknown" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-negative-flow", "boundary_ref": "dimension-negative-flow", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "negative_flow_profiles": [ { "status_ref": "not-observed", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "adverse_inference": false, "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses" }, { "status_ref": "detection-bounded-absence", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "adverse_inference": false, "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses" }, { "status_ref": "censored", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "adverse_inference": false, "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses" }, { "status_ref": "destroyed-or-lost", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "adverse_inference": false, "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses" }, { "status_ref": "inaccessible", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "adverse_inference": false, "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses" }, { "status_ref": "private-or-refused", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "adverse_inference": false, "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses" }, { "status_ref": "excluded", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "adverse_inference": false, "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses" }, { "status_ref": "measurement-failure", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "adverse_inference": false, "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses" }, { "status_ref": "unknown", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "unknown", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "adverse_inference": false, "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses" } ], "translation_profile": { "status": "unassessed", "reason_ref": "translation-inactive-boundary", "boundary_ref": "translation-inactive-boundary" }, "threshold_profile": { "status": "unassessed", "reason_ref": "threshold-inactive-boundary", "boundary_ref": "threshold-inactive-boundary" }, "path_dependence_profile": { "status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-established", "reinforcement_mechanism": [ "path-reinforcement-question" ], "switching_cost": [ "path-switching-cost-question" ], "sunk_resource": [ "path-sunk-resource-question" ], "option_loss": [ "path-option-loss-question" ], "alternative_timing": [ "path-alternative-timing-question" ], "reversal_evidence": [ "path-reversal-evidence-question" ], "evidence": [ "path-evidence-requirement" ], "path_dependence_established": false, "reason_ref": "path-evidence-requirement" }, "distortions": [ "P-hacking, model selection, construct drift, publication bias, framework laundering, aggregation, retrospective storytelling, stakeholder exclusion, and narrow boundaries can overstate closure." ], "counterflows": [ "Replication, falsification, counterevidence, alternative estimand, rival model, affected-party testimony, rights challenge, dissenting framework, appeal, and non-action." ], "failure_modes": [ "Association becomes effect, effect becomes success, average becomes everyone, effect becomes legitimacy, framework becomes universal truth, or absence becomes no harm." ], "repair_routes": [ "Correct or retract claims, expand observation and party scope, preserve dissent, stop harmful use, provide remedy, reassess residuals, and require fresh authorization for any new action." ], "repair_residuals": [ "Underlying harm, epistemic exclusion, stigma, prior decisions, lost trust, missing evidence, ecological change, and unresolved normative disagreement may remain." ], "repair_recurrence_checks": [ "Repeat outcome review, test alternative causes, inspect transport and subgroup limits, track residuals, reopen rights analysis, and watch recurrence under fresh gates." ], "repair_fresh_gate_required": true, "repair_profile": { "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "repair-review-or-retirement-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-run", "proposal_source": "card-repair-routes", "fresh_gate_refs": [ "attribution-and-provenance", "publication-and-access", "current-authority-and-jurisdiction", "affected-party-register", "rights-assessment", "consent-or-lawful-basis", "safety-and-stop-route" ], "attempt": [ "repair-attempt-question" ], "execution_or_outcome_observation": [ "repair-outcome-question" ], "party_indexed_residuals": [ { "affected_party_id": "directly-affected-parties", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "indirect-non-user-and-bystander-parties", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "decision-subjects", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "operators-and-labor", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "future-parties", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "ecological-systems", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] } ], "dissent": [ "repair-dissent-question" ], "recurrence": [ "repair-recurrence-question" ], "review_or_retirement": [ "repair-review-or-retirement-question" ], "repair_completed": false, "causal_effect_claimed": false, "erasure_or_absolution_claimed": false, "restored_consent_claimed": false }, "evidence_requirements": [ "Quality-controlled outcomes, explicit estimand and comparator, identification assumptions, sensitivity and falsifiers, alternative causes, transport scope, uncertainty vector, affected parties, named frameworks, reasons, and dissent." ], "evidence_uncertainty": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "source", "measurement", "selection-and-missingness", "temporal", "identification-and-model", "transport", "affected-party-incompleteness", "normative-disagreement", "authority-and-jurisdiction" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-evidence-uncertainty", "boundary_ref": "dimension-evidence-uncertainty", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "uncertainty_aggregation": null, "alternative_paths": [ "No effect, heterogeneous effect, delayed effect, common cause, substitution, displacement, adaptation, measurement artifact, concurrent action, rival framework, or unresolved judgment must remain possible." ], "stop_conditions": [ "Stop claim promotion or action when identification, measurement, affected-party scope, rights, framework, authority, transport, uncertainty, or falsifier requirements are inadequate." ], "stall_or_block_conditions": [ "Missing comparator, confounding, weak measurement, censoring, unsafe testimony, inaccessible data, unresolved jurisdiction, affected-party omission, normative conflict, or inadequate follow-up." ], "reversibility": { "status": "irreversible-elements-present", "recoverable_elements": [ "Current claims, models, publications, decisions, frameworks, and data access may be corrected, narrowed, or retired." ], "residual_or_irreversible_elements": [ "Underlying harms, prior reliance, stigma, exclusion, data exposure, lost opportunity, and ecological effects may persist." ], "prerequisites": [ "Preserved evidence and history, independent review, affected-party participation, correction channels, fresh authority, and resourced remedy." ] }, "explicit_non_implications": [ "Causal assessment is not legitimacy, goodness, justice, authority, prediction, or mandate; normative assessment is not causal effect or metaphysical verdict." ] }, "authority_dependency": { "status": "external-gate-required-before-effectful-use", "required_for": [ "Collecting or linking evidence, publishing sensitive findings, making institutional decisions, or initiating any response or repair." ], "gate_input_ids": [ "attribution-and-provenance", "publication-and-access", "current-authority-and-jurisdiction", "affected-party-register", "rights-assessment", "consent-or-lawful-basis", "safety-and-stop-route" ], "non_implications": [ "Evidence quality, causal identification, affected-party support, moral argument, or urgent harm does not by itself grant jurisdiction or authority to act." ] }, "causal_influence": { "status": "not-assessed-by-static-atlas", "candidate_mediators": [ "Which explicitly measured mechanisms connect the exact action contrast to the exact outcome under the declared population and horizon?" ], "alternative_causes": [ "Which confounders, selection processes, anticipation, interference, spillovers, concurrent actions, model choices, or measurement changes remain plausible?" ], "estimand_required_before_promotion": true, "comparator_required_before_promotion": true, "assumptions_required_before_promotion": true, "causal_effect_claimed": false, "non_implications": [ "The atlas records requirements for causal assessment but performs no identification and asserts no effect." ] }, "evidence_profile": { "claim_register": "DESIGN_COMMITMENT", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "causal_status": "formal-mechanism-not-instantiated", "evidence_refs": [], "evidence_ref_status": "no-direct-predecessor-evidence-design-only", "expected_traces": { "source": "card-nuance-observables", "prompt_refs": [] }, "negative_cases": { "source": "card-nuance-alternative-paths", "prompt_refs": [] }, "counterevidence": [ "evidence-counterevidence" ], "falsifiers": [ "evidence-falsifier" ], "transport_bounds": [ "evidence-transport-bound" ], "promotion_requirement": "promotion-requires-source-bound-successor", "external_empirical_support_claimed": false, "mechanism_promoted": false }, "automatic_advance": false }, { "id": "feedback-challenge-and-counterflow", "label": "Feedback, challenge, and counterflow", "definition": "Affected-party response, challenge, correction, counterstory, audit, refusal, withdrawal, appeal, and changed measurements may reopen any earlier stage without automatically commanding a new action.", "analytical_status": "typed-predecessor-stage-design-lens", "predecessor_domain_ids": [ "normative-public", "social-relational", "informational-record", "institutional-status", "attention-exposure" ], "predecessor_dimension_ids": [ "feedback-sensitivity", "repair-capacity", "provenance-traceability", "path-dependence" ], "predecessor_node_type_ids": [ "FEEDBACK_ITEM", "CLAIM_ASSESSMENT", "PUBLIC_RESPONSE_RECORD", "OUTCOME_OBSERVATION", "NORMATIVE_ASSESSMENT" ], "predecessor_ladder_ids": [ "public-response-attributed", "outcome-observed", "normative-assessment-separated" ], "nuance": { "carriers": [ "Complaint, appeal, counterstory, correction, audit, whistleblowing, protest, refusal, withdrawal, incident report, affected-party account, replication, or changed measurement." ], "transformations": [ "Attribution, triage, translation, aggregation within valid scope, verification, routing, protection, response, correction, escalation, and reopening." ], "gates": [ "Safe access, non-retaliation, privacy, attribution, standing, response duty, independent review, preservation, urgency route, authority, and repair readiness." ], "temporal_profile": { "onset": "Harm, awareness, expression, receipt, attribution, review, and institutional response may begin at different times.", "duration": "Feedback availability, investigation, appeal, protection, response, and recurrence windows are separate.", "latency": "Fear, power, access, detection, translation, queueing, and delayed effects may postpone feedback.", "overlap": "Multiple complaints, counterstories, investigations, repairs, external events, and retaliation may overlap.", "decay": "Evidence, memory, access, institutional attention, and protection may degrade while residuals persist.", "recurrence": "Challenges, incidents, appeals, counterflows, and feedback loops may recur or reopen closed records.", "censoring": "Retaliation, privacy, fear, inaccessibility, destruction, moderation, exclusion, and settlement may censor feedback.", "resolution": "Resolve event, affected party, claim, recipient, response, protection, route, and outcome timestamps separately.", "timing_claim_status": "qualitative-audit-lens-only", "prediction": false }, "accumulation_profile": { "quantity_kind": "Distinct feedback items, linked evidence, responses, residuals, and recurrence observations", "unit": "declared item or event unit", "additivity": "bounded-declared-units-only", "inflows": [ "Complaints, appeals, counterstories, corrections, audits, refusals, withdrawals, incidents, replications, and affected-party accounts." ], "outflows": [ "Verified resolution state, withdrawal without adverse inference, correction, routing, deduplication, invalidation, or protected closure." ], "decay_or_reset": [ "Fresh incident, new evidence, recurrence, changed affected-party scope, failed repair, or declared review reset." ], "scope": "One issue taxonomy and review surface; item counts do not measure severity, legitimacy, trust, emotion, or consensus.", "stock_flow_status": "analytical-lens-only", "summable_social_constructs": [], "effect_size_claimed": false }, "observables": [ "Feedback artifact, attribution or protected anonymity, issue, linked stage or claim, evidence, affected parties, timestamps, route, protection, response, disagreement, correction, withdrawal, residual, and recurrence." ], "affected_party_ids": [ "directly-affected-parties", "indirect-non-user-and-bystander-parties", "decision-subjects", "institutional-participants", "operators-and-labor", "audiences-and-non-audiences", "future-parties", "ecological-systems" ], "distribution": { "benefits": [ "Voice, correction, protection, explanation, remedy access, institutional learning, and option restoration may be unequally available." ], "burdens": [ "Proof, retelling, delay, translation, exposure, retaliation risk, appeal labor, and repair monitoring may fall on harmed parties." ], "risks": [ "Retaliation, retraumatization, token consultation, surveillance, complaint laundering, capture, suppression, and premature closure." ], "voice_and_options": [ "Preserve anonymity, refusal, representation limits, plural and conflicting accounts, appeal, escalation, exit, withdrawal, and non-action without adverse inference." ], "horizons": [ "Immediate safety, response, investigation, correction, remedy, recurrence, institutional memory, and intergenerational aftermath differ." ], "aggregate_score": null }, "affected_party_aftermath": [ { "affected_party_id": "directly-affected-parties", "status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [ "party-benefit-question" ], "burdens": [ "party-burden-question" ], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false, "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason" }, { "affected_party_id": "indirect-non-user-and-bystander-parties", "status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [], "burdens": [ "party-burden-question" ], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false, "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason" }, { "affected_party_id": "decision-subjects", "status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [], "burdens": [], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false, "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason" }, { "affected_party_id": "institutional-participants", "status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [], "burdens": [ "party-burden-question" ], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false, "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason" }, { "affected_party_id": "operators-and-labor", "status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [], "burdens": [ "party-burden-question" ], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false, "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason" }, { "affected_party_id": "audiences-and-non-audiences", "status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [ "party-benefit-question" ], "burdens": [], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false, "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason" }, { "affected_party_id": "future-parties", "status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [], "burdens": [], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false, "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason" }, { "affected_party_id": "ecological-systems", "status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [], "burdens": [ "party-burden-question" ], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false, "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason" } ], "emotion_observation": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "self-report", "attributed-expression", "behavioral-observation", "physiology", "cultural-vocabulary", "institutional-framing" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-emotion-observation", "boundary_ref": "dimension-emotion-observation", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "affect_context": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "fear-or-threat", "anger-or-outrage", "humiliation-or-status-injury", "grief-or-loss", "hope-or-efficacy", "love-care-or-solidarity", "hate-or-moral-exclusion", "shame-or-guilt" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-affect-context", "boundary_ref": "dimension-affect-context", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "social_position": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "economic-resources-ownership-labor-and-debt", "status", "office", "network-position", "agenda-control", "coercive-capacity", "discursive-power" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-social-position", "boundary_ref": "dimension-social-position", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "power_asymmetry": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "naming-and-interpretive", "attention-and-distribution", "agenda-and-procedure", "legal-jurisdiction-and-coercion", "resources-and-class", "status-and-hierarchy", "epistemic-and-measurement", "temporal-path-and-exit" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-power-asymmetry", "boundary_ref": "dimension-power-asymmetry", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "material_conditions": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "body-and-care", "labor-and-time", "land-and-geography", "energy-and-resources", "climate-and-ecology", "money-credit-and-property", "infrastructure-and-logistics", "data-and-technology" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-material-conditions", "boundary_ref": "dimension-material-conditions", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "flow_dynamics": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "delay-or-latency", "branching-or-convergence", "leakage-substitution-or-displacement", "reinforcing-feedback", "balancing-feedback", "path-dependence-or-hysteresis" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-flow-dynamics", "boundary_ref": "dimension-flow-dynamics", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "topology": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "fork", "join", "parallel-path", "bottleneck", "leakage", "substitution", "interruption", "reversal", "recurrence", "reinforcing-loop", "balancing-loop" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-topology", "boundary_ref": "dimension-topology", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "negative_flow": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "not-observed", "detection-bounded-absence", "no-opportunity", "blocked", "censored", "destroyed-or-lost", "inaccessible", "private-or-refused", "excluded", "measurement-failure", "unknown" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-negative-flow", "boundary_ref": "dimension-negative-flow", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "negative_flow_profiles": [ { "status_ref": "not-observed", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "adverse_inference": false, "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses" }, { "status_ref": "detection-bounded-absence", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "adverse_inference": false, "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses" }, { "status_ref": "no-opportunity", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "adverse_inference": false, "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses" }, { "status_ref": "blocked", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "adverse_inference": false, "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses" }, { "status_ref": "censored", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "adverse_inference": false, "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses" }, { "status_ref": "destroyed-or-lost", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "adverse_inference": false, "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses" }, { "status_ref": "inaccessible", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "adverse_inference": false, "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses" }, { "status_ref": "private-or-refused", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "adverse_inference": false, "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses" }, { "status_ref": "excluded", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "adverse_inference": false, "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses" }, { "status_ref": "measurement-failure", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "adverse_inference": false, "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses" }, { "status_ref": "unknown", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "unknown", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "adverse_inference": false, "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses" } ], "translation_profile": { "status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "source_language": "Declared source language or sign system; unknown until source-bound evidence is added.", "target_language": "Declared target language or sign system; unknown until source-bound evidence is added.", "source_register": "Declared source register and institutional setting; unknown until evidenced.", "target_register": "Declared target register and institutional setting; unknown until evidenced.", "source_genre": "Declared source genre; unknown until evidenced.", "target_genre": "Declared target genre; unknown until evidenced.", "source_version": "Stable source version or witnessed performance reference; none is added by this atlas.", "translator_position_refs": [ "discursive-power" ], "patron_position_refs": [ "agenda-control" ], "audience_party_refs": [ "audiences-and-non-audiences" ], "preserved": [ "translation-preserved-question" ], "changed": [ "translation-changed-question" ], "introduced": [ "translation-introduced-question" ], "omitted": [ "translation-omitted-question" ], "untranslatable": [ "translation-untranslatable-question" ], "counterreadings": [ "translation-counterreadings-question" ], "rights_and_access": [ "translation-rights-and-access-question" ], "fidelity_claimed": false, "representational_authority_granted": false, "reason_ref": "translation-rights-and-access-question" }, "threshold_profile": { "status": "unassessed", "reason_ref": "threshold-inactive-boundary", "boundary_ref": "threshold-inactive-boundary" }, "path_dependence_profile": { "status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-established", "reinforcement_mechanism": [ "path-reinforcement-question" ], "switching_cost": [ "path-switching-cost-question" ], "sunk_resource": [ "path-sunk-resource-question" ], "option_loss": [ "path-option-loss-question" ], "alternative_timing": [ "path-alternative-timing-question" ], "reversal_evidence": [ "path-reversal-evidence-question" ], "evidence": [ "path-evidence-requirement" ], "path_dependence_established": false, "reason_ref": "path-evidence-requirement" }, "distortions": [ "Complaint counting, selective amplification, moderation, retaliation, institutional framing, forced taxonomy, unsafe attribution, strategic delay, and closure metrics can erase substance and parties." ], "counterflows": [ "Counterstory, challenge, correction, withdrawal, refusal, appeal, protest, audit, replication, alternate institution, privacy, exit, non-action, and repair demand." ], "failure_modes": [ "Feedback becomes command, volume becomes truth, silence becomes satisfaction, response becomes repair, closure becomes justice, or counterstory becomes a targeting input." ], "repair_routes": [ "Protect and hear affected parties, preserve and investigate evidence, correct records, stop harm, provide remedy, reopen decisions, track residuals, and review recurrence." ], "repair_residuals": [ "Retaliation, distrust, injury, stigma, lost opportunity, suppressed accounts, unresolved disagreement, and prior circulation or action may remain." ], "repair_recurrence_checks": [ "Track repeated incidents, retaliation, complaint suppression, reopened harms, failed corrections, substitute channels, and fresh affected-party accounts." ], "repair_fresh_gate_required": true, "repair_profile": { "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "repair-review-or-retirement-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-run", "proposal_source": "card-repair-routes", "fresh_gate_refs": [ "publication-and-access", "current-authority-and-jurisdiction", "affected-party-register", "rights-assessment", "consent-or-lawful-basis", "safety-and-stop-route", "repair-readiness" ], "attempt": [ "repair-attempt-question" ], "execution_or_outcome_observation": [ "repair-outcome-question" ], "party_indexed_residuals": [ { "affected_party_id": "directly-affected-parties", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "indirect-non-user-and-bystander-parties", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "decision-subjects", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "institutional-participants", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "operators-and-labor", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "audiences-and-non-audiences", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "future-parties", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "ecological-systems", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] } ], "dissent": [ "repair-dissent-question" ], "recurrence": [ "repair-recurrence-question" ], "review_or_retirement": [ "repair-review-or-retirement-question" ], "repair_completed": false, "causal_effect_claimed": false, "erasure_or_absolution_claimed": false, "restored_consent_claimed": false }, "evidence_requirements": [ "Exact feedback artifact or protected record, attribution limits, affected parties, issue and linked stage, evidence, safe opportunity, missingness, protection, response, disagreement, residual, and recurrence." ], "evidence_uncertainty": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "source", "measurement", "selection-and-missingness", "temporal", "identification-and-model", "transport", "affected-party-incompleteness", "normative-disagreement", "authority-and-jurisdiction" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-evidence-uncertainty", "boundary_ref": "dimension-evidence-uncertainty", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "uncertainty_aggregation": null, "alternative_paths": [ "Private remedy, public challenge, correction, appeal, independent review, alternate institution, collective action, refusal, exit, withdrawal, restorative process, or documented non-action may coexist." ], "stop_conditions": [ "Stop collection, publication, triage, or downstream action when safety, retaliation, privacy, standing, authority, representation, rights, evidence preservation, or remedy access fails." ], "stall_or_block_conditions": [ "Fear, retaliation, censorship, language or disability barrier, cost, queue, status, jurisdiction, missing records, inaccessible forum, capture, or unsafe disclosure." ], "reversibility": { "status": "irreversible-elements-present", "recoverable_elements": [ "Records, access, routes, protection, current decisions, publication, and response practices may be corrected or reopened." ], "residual_or_irreversible_elements": [ "Harm, retaliation, disclosure, lost time, stigma, distrust, silenced accounts, and foreclosed opportunities may persist." ], "prerequisites": [ "Non-retaliation, independent review, affected-party control and participation, evidence preservation, fresh authority, and resourced remedy." ] }, "explicit_non_implications": [ "Feedback is not truth, representativeness, command, consent, authority, causal effect, predicted escalation, or completed repair." ] }, "authority_dependency": { "status": "external-gate-required-before-effectful-use", "required_for": [ "Collecting or publishing protected feedback, changing a decision, disciplining anyone, stopping an action, or initiating repair." ], "gate_input_ids": [ "publication-and-access", "current-authority-and-jurisdiction", "affected-party-register", "rights-assessment", "consent-or-lawful-basis", "safety-and-stop-route", "repair-readiness" ], "non_implications": [ "Feedback content, public pressure, institutional receipt, urgency, or apparent consensus does not itself authorize publication, sanction, action, or repair." ] }, "causal_influence": { "status": "not-assessed-by-static-atlas", "candidate_mediators": [ "Which correction, incentive, changed belief, resource, procedure, enforcement, adaptation, or institutional learning could connect feedback to a later state?" ], "alternative_causes": [ "Which external event, prior review, concurrent reform, leadership change, resource shift, or measurement change could explain the later state?" ], "estimand_required_before_promotion": true, "comparator_required_before_promotion": true, "assumptions_required_before_promotion": true, "causal_effect_claimed": false, "non_implications": [ "Feedback followed by change establishes neither a feedback effect nor successful correction." ] }, "evidence_profile": { "claim_register": "DESIGN_COMMITMENT", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "causal_status": "formal-mechanism-not-instantiated", "evidence_refs": [], "evidence_ref_status": "no-direct-predecessor-evidence-design-only", "expected_traces": { "source": "card-nuance-observables", "prompt_refs": [] }, "negative_cases": { "source": "card-nuance-alternative-paths", "prompt_refs": [] }, "counterevidence": [ "evidence-counterevidence" ], "falsifiers": [ "evidence-falsifier" ], "transport_bounds": [ "evidence-transport-bound" ], "promotion_requirement": "promotion-requires-source-bound-successor", "external_empirical_support_claimed": false, "mechanism_promoted": false }, "automatic_advance": false }, { "id": "repair-review-and-retirement", "label": "Repair, review, and retirement", "definition": "A separately proposed, freshly authorized, attempted, observed, and reviewed repair may stop, correct, restore, restitute, compensate, rehabilitate, satisfy, prevent recurrence, or retire a path while preserving history, residuals, disagreement, and future review.", "analytical_status": "typed-predecessor-stage-design-lens", "predecessor_domain_ids": [ "normative-public", "legal-jurisdictional", "institutional-status", "economic-resource", "material-cyberphysical", "embodied-health", "ecological" ], "predecessor_dimension_ids": [ "repair-capacity", "distributional-aftermath", "feedback-sensitivity", "path-dependence" ], "predecessor_node_type_ids": [ "REPAIR_PROPOSAL", "REPAIR_ATTEMPT", "NON_ACTION", "FEEDBACK_ITEM", "OUTCOME_OBSERVATION", "RIGHTS_ASSESSMENT" ], "predecessor_ladder_ids": [ "repair-proposed", "repair-outcome-reviewed" ], "nuance": { "carriers": [ "Stop order, correction, preserved history, apology or acknowledgment, restitution, compensation, rehabilitation, satisfaction, institutional reform, non-repetition measure, retirement, residual register, and recurrence review." ], "transformations": [ "Harm containment, evidence preservation, affected-party review, proposal, fresh authorization, resource allocation, attempt, observation, residual assessment, recurrence check, revision, and retirement." ], "gates": [ "Immediate safety, affected-party register and voice, rights, fresh authority, exact repair proposal, capability and budget, non-retaliation, evidence preservation, alternatives, stop route, residual, recurrence, and appeal." ], "temporal_profile": { "onset": "Harm, recognition, stop, proposal, authorization, attempt, benefit, residual, and review may begin at different times.", "duration": "Containment, restitution, care, rehabilitation, institutional change, monitoring, and ecological recovery have distinct horizons.", "latency": "Delayed harm, recognition, payment, recovery, trust, institutional learning, and recurrence may have long or unknown latency.", "overlap": "Ongoing harm, multiple repairs, litigation, public discourse, institutional reform, and new incidents may overlap.", "decay": "Resources, attention, protection, institutional memory, and some restored conditions may decay while residuals remain.", "recurrence": "Harm, failure mode, complaint, repair attempt, review, and non-repetition work may recur.", "censoring": "Private settlement, unsafe testimony, missing parties, lost evidence, future effects, and institutional closure may censor residuals.", "resolution": "Resolve stop, proposal, authority, attempt, outcome, residual, recurrence, party, and horizon states separately.", "timing_claim_status": "qualitative-audit-lens-only", "prediction": false }, "accumulation_profile": { "quantity_kind": "Declared repair resources, obligations, events, outcome observations, residuals, and recurrence records", "unit": "repair-specific declared unit", "additivity": "bounded-declared-units-only", "inflows": [ "Protected evidence, repair proposals, funds, care, labor, corrections, restitution, compensation, rehabilitation, reforms, residual findings, and recurrence observations." ], "outflows": [ "Fulfilled bounded obligation, disbursement, resource depletion, retirement, invalidation, or supersession under preserved history." ], "decay_or_reset": [ "Fresh harm, recurrence, failed repair, changed party scope, new evidence, obligation expiry only where legitimate, or fresh review." ], "scope": "One harm and affected-party set under named repair forms and horizons; pain, trust, justice, absolution, legitimacy, and residuals are not summed.", "stock_flow_status": "analytical-lens-only", "summable_social_constructs": [], "effect_size_claimed": false }, "observables": [ "Harm and evidence, affected parties, desired and disputed repair, proposal, authority, resources, attempt, delivery, outcome, residual, recurrence, non-repetition, dissent, appeal, and current status." ], "affected_party_ids": [ "directly-affected-parties", "indirect-non-user-and-bystander-parties", "decision-subjects", "operators-and-labor", "institutional-participants", "resource-providers", "future-parties", "ecological-systems" ], "distribution": { "benefits": [ "Safety, acknowledgment, correction, restitution, compensation, care, rehabilitation, option restoration, and non-repetition may matter differently by party." ], "burdens": [ "Proof, retelling, waiting, care, monitoring, administration, funding, maintenance, and compromise burdens must be visible." ], "risks": [ "Retraumatization, retaliation, coerced settlement, symbolic substitution, unequal remedy, premature closure, repeated harm, and displaced residual." ], "voice_and_options": [ "Affected parties retain plural goals, refusal, privacy, representation limits, dissent, appeal, alternative repair, exit, and unresolved judgment." ], "horizons": [ "Immediate safety, material restitution, care, recovery, institutional change, recurrence, intergenerational, and ecological repair remain separate." ], "aggregate_score": null }, "affected_party_aftermath": [ { "affected_party_id": "directly-affected-parties", "status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [ "party-benefit-question" ], "burdens": [ "party-burden-question" ], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false, "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason" }, { "affected_party_id": "indirect-non-user-and-bystander-parties", "status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [], "burdens": [ "party-burden-question" ], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false, "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason" }, { "affected_party_id": "decision-subjects", "status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [], "burdens": [], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false, "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason" }, { "affected_party_id": "operators-and-labor", "status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [], "burdens": [ "party-burden-question" ], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false, "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason" }, { "affected_party_id": "institutional-participants", "status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [], "burdens": [ "party-burden-question" ], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false, "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason" }, { "affected_party_id": "resource-providers", "status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [ "party-benefit-question" ], "burdens": [ "party-burden-question" ], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false, "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason" }, { "affected_party_id": "future-parties", "status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [], "burdens": [], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false, "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason" }, { "affected_party_id": "ecological-systems", "status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [], "burdens": [ "party-burden-question" ], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false, "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason" } ], "emotion_observation": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "self-report", "attributed-expression", "behavioral-observation", "physiology", "cultural-vocabulary", "institutional-framing" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-emotion-observation", "boundary_ref": "dimension-emotion-observation", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "affect_context": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "fear-or-threat", "anger-or-outrage", "humiliation-or-status-injury", "grief-or-loss", "hope-or-efficacy", "love-care-or-solidarity", "shame-or-guilt", "belonging-or-identity-security" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-affect-context", "boundary_ref": "dimension-affect-context", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "social_position": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "economic-resources-ownership-labor-and-debt", "status", "office", "network-position", "agenda-control", "coercive-capacity", "discursive-power" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-social-position", "boundary_ref": "dimension-social-position", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "power_asymmetry": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "naming-and-interpretive", "attention-and-distribution", "agenda-and-procedure", "legal-jurisdiction-and-coercion", "resources-and-class", "status-and-hierarchy", "technical-and-infrastructure", "epistemic-and-measurement", "temporal-path-and-exit" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-power-asymmetry", "boundary_ref": "dimension-power-asymmetry", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "material_conditions": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "body-and-care", "labor-and-time", "land-and-geography", "energy-and-resources", "climate-and-ecology", "money-credit-and-property", "infrastructure-and-logistics", "data-and-technology" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-material-conditions", "boundary_ref": "dimension-material-conditions", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "flow_dynamics": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "delay-or-latency", "accumulation-or-memory", "path-dependence-or-hysteresis", "leakage-substitution-or-displacement", "reinforcing-feedback", "balancing-feedback" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-flow-dynamics", "boundary_ref": "dimension-flow-dynamics", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "topology": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "fork", "join", "parallel-path", "bottleneck", "leakage", "substitution", "interruption", "reversal", "recurrence", "reinforcing-loop", "balancing-loop" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-topology", "boundary_ref": "dimension-topology", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "negative_flow": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "not-observed", "detection-bounded-absence", "no-opportunity", "blocked", "censored", "destroyed-or-lost", "inaccessible", "private-or-refused", "excluded", "measurement-failure", "unknown" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-negative-flow", "boundary_ref": "dimension-negative-flow", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "negative_flow_profiles": [ { "status_ref": "not-observed", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "adverse_inference": false, "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses" }, { "status_ref": "detection-bounded-absence", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "adverse_inference": false, "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses" }, { "status_ref": "no-opportunity", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "adverse_inference": false, "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses" }, { "status_ref": "blocked", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "adverse_inference": false, "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses" }, { "status_ref": "censored", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "adverse_inference": false, "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses" }, { "status_ref": "destroyed-or-lost", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "adverse_inference": false, "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses" }, { "status_ref": "inaccessible", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "adverse_inference": false, "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses" }, { "status_ref": "private-or-refused", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "adverse_inference": false, "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses" }, { "status_ref": "excluded", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "adverse_inference": false, "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses" }, { "status_ref": "measurement-failure", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "adverse_inference": false, "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses" }, { "status_ref": "unknown", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "unknown", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "adverse_inference": false, "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses" } ], "translation_profile": { "status": "unassessed", "reason_ref": "translation-inactive-boundary", "boundary_ref": "translation-inactive-boundary" }, "threshold_profile": { "status": "unassessed", "reason_ref": "threshold-inactive-boundary", "boundary_ref": "threshold-inactive-boundary" }, "path_dependence_profile": { "status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-established", "reinforcement_mechanism": [ "path-reinforcement-question" ], "switching_cost": [ "path-switching-cost-question" ], "sunk_resource": [ "path-sunk-resource-question" ], "option_loss": [ "path-option-loss-question" ], "alternative_timing": [ "path-alternative-timing-question" ], "reversal_evidence": [ "path-reversal-evidence-question" ], "evidence": [ "path-evidence-requirement" ], "path_dependence_established": false, "reason_ref": "path-evidence-requirement" }, "distortions": [ "Closure metrics, settlement secrecy, apology substitution, compensation averages, institutional self-review, erased history, resource control, and short horizons can overstate repair." ], "counterflows": [ "Affected-party refusal, alternative repair, appeal, renewed complaint, independent review, counterhistory, recurrence finding, retirement, and documented non-action." ], "failure_modes": [ "Attempt becomes repair, payment becomes absolution, apology becomes consent, outcome becomes restoration, closure becomes justice, or reform becomes non-repetition." ], "repair_routes": [ "Maintain safety and evidence, correct and restitute, compensate and care, rehabilitate where possible, acknowledge, reform, monitor recurrence, preserve residuals, reopen review, and retire unsafe paths." ], "repair_residuals": [ "Irreversible injury, death, lost time, exposure, dispossession, ecological loss, stigma, distrust, grief, option loss, and unresolved disagreement may remain." ], "repair_recurrence_checks": [ "Track the original failure mode, retaliation, unmet obligations, displaced harm, repeated affected parties, degraded safeguards, fresh incidents, and long-horizon residuals." ], "repair_fresh_gate_required": true, "repair_profile": { "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "repair-review-or-retirement-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-run", "proposal_source": "card-repair-routes", "fresh_gate_refs": [ "reviewed-proposal", "decision-procedure", "current-authority-and-jurisdiction", "affected-party-register", "rights-assessment", "consent-or-lawful-basis", "capability-and-resources", "budget-and-horizon", "safety-and-stop-route", "repair-readiness" ], "attempt": [ "repair-attempt-question" ], "execution_or_outcome_observation": [ "repair-outcome-question" ], "party_indexed_residuals": [ { "affected_party_id": "directly-affected-parties", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "indirect-non-user-and-bystander-parties", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "decision-subjects", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "operators-and-labor", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "institutional-participants", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "resource-providers", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "future-parties", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "ecological-systems", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] } ], "dissent": [ "repair-dissent-question" ], "recurrence": [ "repair-recurrence-question" ], "review_or_retirement": [ "repair-review-or-retirement-question" ], "repair_completed": false, "causal_effect_claimed": false, "erasure_or_absolution_claimed": false, "restored_consent_claimed": false }, "evidence_requirements": [ "Preserved harm and action history, affected-party register and plural positions, rights, repair alternatives, fresh authority, resources, attempt, delivery, outcome, residual, recurrence, non-repetition, appeal, and independent review." ], "evidence_uncertainty": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "source", "measurement", "selection-and-missingness", "temporal", "identification-and-model", "transport", "affected-party-incompleteness", "normative-disagreement", "authority-and-jurisdiction" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-evidence-uncertainty", "boundary_ref": "dimension-evidence-uncertainty", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "uncertainty_aggregation": null, "alternative_paths": [ "Immediate stop, correction, restitution, compensation, care, rehabilitation, satisfaction, public or private acknowledgment, institutional reform, non-repetition, retirement, or no further action may be separately considered." ], "stop_conditions": [ "Stop or redesign repair when it creates fresh harm, lacks current authority, coerces participation, erases history, hides residuals, shifts burden, blocks appeal, or lacks recurrence review." ], "stall_or_block_conditions": [ "Unsafe participation, retaliation, disputed authority, missing evidence, unavailable resources, inaccessible remedy, conflicting party needs, delayed effects, failed delivery, or institutional resistance." ], "reversibility": { "status": "irreversible-elements-present", "recoverable_elements": [ "Current repair design, resources, access, protection, records, institutional rules, and future action may be corrected or reopened." ], "residual_or_irreversible_elements": [ "Death, injury, disclosure, lost years, dispossession, ecological loss, cultural loss, grief, stigma, distrust, and foreclosed options may persist." ], "prerequisites": [ "Immediate safety, preserved history, affected-party control and participation, fresh authority, independent review, adequate resources, long-horizon monitoring, and appeal." ] }, "explicit_non_implications": [ "Repair is not erasure, absolution, restored consent, forgiveness, reconciliation, legitimacy, completed justice, causal proof, or permission for renewed action." ] }, "authority_dependency": { "status": "external-gate-required-before-effectful-use", "required_for": [ "Every stop, disclosure, correction, restitution, compensation, care intervention, institutional change, monitoring act, or retirement decision." ], "gate_input_ids": [ "reviewed-proposal", "decision-procedure", "current-authority-and-jurisdiction", "affected-party-register", "rights-assessment", "consent-or-lawful-basis", "capability-and-resources", "budget-and-horizon", "safety-and-stop-route", "repair-readiness" ], "non_implications": [ "Harm, urgency, apology, affected-party request, prior authority, funding, or apparent benefit does not by itself authorize a particular repair or declare closure." ] }, "causal_influence": { "status": "not-assessed-by-static-atlas", "candidate_mediators": [ "Which delivered repair component, access, resource, care, institutional change, behavior, or material restoration could connect the repair attempt to a declared outcome?" ], "alternative_causes": [ "Which natural recovery, external support, concurrent reform, selection, attrition, changed measurement, or unrelated event could explain the outcome or non-recurrence?" ], "estimand_required_before_promotion": true, "comparator_required_before_promotion": true, "assumptions_required_before_promotion": true, "causal_effect_claimed": false, "non_implications": [ "Repair attempt, observed improvement, non-recurrence, gratitude, silence, or closure record establishes no repair effect or completed justice." ] }, "evidence_profile": { "claim_register": "DESIGN_COMMITMENT", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "causal_status": "formal-mechanism-not-instantiated", "evidence_refs": [], "evidence_ref_status": "no-direct-predecessor-evidence-design-only", "expected_traces": { "source": "card-nuance-observables", "prompt_refs": [] }, "negative_cases": { "source": "card-nuance-alternative-paths", "prompt_refs": [] }, "counterevidence": [ "evidence-counterevidence" ], "falsifiers": [ "evidence-falsifier" ], "transport_bounds": [ "evidence-transport-bound" ], "promotion_requirement": "promotion-requires-source-bound-successor", "external_empirical_support_claimed": false, "mechanism_promoted": false }, "automatic_advance": false } ], "transitions": [ { "id": "expression-to-shared-story", "from_stage_ids": [ "word-or-expression" ], "to_stage_ids": [ "shared-story-artifact" ], "predecessor_relation_ids": [ "EMBODIES_EXPRESSION" ], "relation_gap_status": "typed-predecessor-relations-listed", "relation_direction_note": "Listed Reality relation directions type compatible claim endpoints; they do not assert this temporal transition or reverse immutable predecessor edges.", "transition_status": "design-question-not-observed-or-causal-transition", "nuance": { "template_ref": "transition-default", "carriers": [ "Separately versioned records, roles, media, infrastructures, resources, bodies, or institutions bound to Word or expression and Shared story artifact." ], "transformations": [ "Audit composition, inscription, performance, translation, and versioning without presumed fidelity or shared reception; do not collapse it into an automatic bridge." ], "gates": [ "Source, target, opportunity, current authority, rights, affected parties, material conditions, safety, stop, and repair gates remain separately evidenced." ], "observables": [ "Source-bound Word or expression and Shared story artifact records that distinguish composition, inscription, performance, translation, and versioning without presumed fidelity or shared reception, with opportunity, timing, gates, missingness, counterevidence, and rival paths." ], "affected_party_ids": [ "expression-originators", "translators-curators-and-stewards", "source-communities-and-traditions", "audiences-and-non-audiences" ], "affected_party_aftermath": [ { "affected_party_id": "expression-originators", "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [ "party-benefit-question" ], "burdens": [], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false }, { "affected_party_id": "translators-curators-and-stewards", "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [], "burdens": [ "party-burden-question" ], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false }, { "affected_party_id": "source-communities-and-traditions", "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [ "party-benefit-question" ], "burdens": [], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false }, { "affected_party_id": "audiences-and-non-audiences", "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [ "party-benefit-question" ], "burdens": [], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false } ], "emotion_observation": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "self-report", "attributed-expression", "cultural-vocabulary", "institutional-framing" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-emotion-observation", "boundary_ref": "dimension-emotion-observation", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "affect_context": { "status": "unassessed", "reason_ref": "dimension-affect-context", "boundary_ref": "dimension-affect-context" }, "social_position": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "status", "discursive-power", "office" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-social-position", "boundary_ref": "dimension-social-position", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "power_asymmetry": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "naming-and-interpretive", "epistemic-and-measurement", "canon-and-curriculum", "status-and-hierarchy" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-power-asymmetry", "boundary_ref": "dimension-power-asymmetry", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "material_conditions": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "body-and-care", "labor-and-time", "data-and-technology", "land-and-geography" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-material-conditions", "boundary_ref": "dimension-material-conditions", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "flow_dynamics": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "delay-or-latency", "accumulation-or-memory", "branching-or-convergence", "path-dependence-or-hysteresis" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-flow-dynamics", "boundary_ref": "dimension-flow-dynamics", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "topology": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "fork", "join", "recurrence" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-topology", "boundary_ref": "dimension-topology", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "negative_flow": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "not-observed", "no-opportunity", "blocked", "unknown" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-negative-flow", "boundary_ref": "dimension-negative-flow", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "negative_flow_profiles": [ { "status_ref": "not-observed", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses", "adverse_inference": false }, { "status_ref": "no-opportunity", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses", "adverse_inference": false }, { "status_ref": "blocked", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses", "adverse_inference": false }, { "status_ref": "unknown", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "unknown", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses", "adverse_inference": false } ], "translation_profile": { "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "translation-rights-and-access-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "source_language": "Declared source language or sign system; unknown until source-bound evidence is added.", "target_language": "Declared target language or sign system; unknown until source-bound evidence is added.", "source_register": "Declared source register and institutional setting; unknown until evidenced.", "target_register": "Declared target register and institutional setting; unknown until evidenced.", "source_genre": "Declared source genre; unknown until evidenced.", "target_genre": "Declared target genre; unknown until evidenced.", "source_version": "Stable source version or witnessed performance reference; none is added by this atlas.", "translator_position_refs": [ "discursive-power" ], "patron_position_refs": [ "agenda-control" ], "audience_party_refs": [ "audiences-and-non-audiences" ], "preserved": [ "translation-preserved-question" ], "changed": [ "translation-changed-question" ], "introduced": [ "translation-introduced-question" ], "omitted": [ "translation-omitted-question" ], "untranslatable": [ "translation-untranslatable-question" ], "counterreadings": [ "translation-counterreadings-question" ], "rights_and_access": [ "translation-rights-and-access-question" ], "fidelity_claimed": false, "representational_authority_granted": false }, "threshold_profile": { "status": "unassessed", "reason_ref": "threshold-inactive-boundary", "boundary_ref": "threshold-inactive-boundary" }, "path_dependence_profile": { "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "path-evidence-requirement", "claim_status": "design-question-not-established", "reinforcement_mechanism": [ "path-reinforcement-question" ], "switching_cost": [ "path-switching-cost-question" ], "sunk_resource": [ "path-sunk-resource-question" ], "option_loss": [ "path-option-loss-question" ], "alternative_timing": [ "path-alternative-timing-question" ], "reversal_evidence": [ "path-reversal-evidence-question" ], "evidence": [ "path-evidence-requirement" ], "path_dependence_established": false }, "repair_profile": { "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "repair-review-or-retirement-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-run", "proposal_source": "card-repair-routes", "fresh_gate_refs": [ "attribution-and-provenance", "publication-and-access", "affected-party-register" ], "attempt": [ "repair-attempt-question" ], "execution_or_outcome_observation": [ "repair-outcome-question" ], "party_indexed_residuals": [ { "affected_party_id": "expression-originators", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "translators-curators-and-stewards", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "source-communities-and-traditions", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "audiences-and-non-audiences", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] } ], "dissent": [ "repair-dissent-question" ], "recurrence": [ "repair-recurrence-question" ], "review_or_retirement": [ "repair-review-or-retirement-question" ], "repair_completed": false, "causal_effect_claimed": false, "erasure_or_absolution_claimed": false, "restored_consent_claimed": false }, "evidence_uncertainty": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "source", "measurement", "selection-and-missingness", "temporal", "affected-party-incompleteness", "transport", "normative-disagreement" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-evidence-uncertainty", "boundary_ref": "dimension-evidence-uncertainty", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "alternative_paths": [ "The Shared story artifact trace may arise independently, through a rival carrier or institution, after an external event, through selection or measurement, or not arise at all." ] }, "evidence_profile": { "claim_register": "DESIGN_COMMITMENT", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "causal_status": "formal-mechanism-not-instantiated", "evidence_refs": [], "evidence_ref_status": "no-direct-predecessor-evidence-design-only", "expected_traces": { "source": "card-nuance-observables", "prompt_refs": [] }, "negative_cases": { "source": "card-nuance-alternative-paths", "prompt_refs": [] }, "counterevidence": [ "evidence-counterevidence" ], "falsifiers": [ "evidence-falsifier" ], "transport_bounds": [ "evidence-transport-bound" ], "promotion_requirement": "promotion-requires-source-bound-successor", "external_empirical_support_claimed": false, "mechanism_promoted": false }, "authority_dependency": { "status": "external-gate-required-before-effectful-use", "template_ref": "transition-authority", "gate_input_ids": [ "attribution-and-provenance", "publication-and-access", "affected-party-register" ] }, "causal_influence": { "status": "not-assessed-by-static-atlas", "template_ref": "transition-causal", "estimand_required_before_promotion": true, "comparator_required_before_promotion": true, "assumptions_required_before_promotion": true, "causal_effect_claimed": false }, "automatic": false, "transitive": false }, { "id": "story-to-circulation", "from_stage_ids": [ "shared-story-artifact" ], "to_stage_ids": [ "circulation-exposure-response" ], "predecessor_relation_ids": [ "DISTRIBUTES_ARTIFACT", "MEASURES_EXPOSURE_TO", "REPORTS_PUBLIC_RESPONSE_TO" ], "relation_gap_status": "typed-predecessor-relations-listed", "relation_direction_note": "Listed Reality relation directions type compatible claim endpoints; they do not assert this temporal transition or reverse immutable predecessor edges.", "transition_status": "design-question-not-observed-or-causal-transition", "nuance": { "template_ref": "transition-default", "carriers": [ "Separately versioned records, roles, media, infrastructures, resources, bodies, or institutions bound to Shared story artifact and Circulation, exposure, and response." ], "transformations": [ "Audit separating availability, delivery, exposure proxy, attention proxy, attributed response, and missingness; do not collapse it into an automatic bridge." ], "gates": [ "Source, target, opportunity, current authority, rights, affected parties, material conditions, safety, stop, and repair gates remain separately evidenced." ], "observables": [ "Source-bound Shared story artifact and Circulation, exposure, and response records that distinguish separating availability, delivery, exposure proxy, attention proxy, attributed response, and missingness, with opportunity, timing, gates, missingness, counterevidence, and rival paths." ], "affected_party_ids": [ "audiences-and-non-audiences", "expression-originators", "translators-curators-and-stewards", "indirect-non-user-and-bystander-parties" ], "affected_party_aftermath": [ { "affected_party_id": "audiences-and-non-audiences", "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [ "party-benefit-question" ], "burdens": [], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false }, { "affected_party_id": "expression-originators", "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [ "party-benefit-question" ], "burdens": [], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false }, { "affected_party_id": "translators-curators-and-stewards", "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [], "burdens": [ "party-burden-question" ], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false }, { "affected_party_id": "indirect-non-user-and-bystander-parties", "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [], "burdens": [ "party-burden-question" ], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false } ], "emotion_observation": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "self-report", "attributed-expression", "cultural-vocabulary", "institutional-framing", "behavioral-observation" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-emotion-observation", "boundary_ref": "dimension-emotion-observation", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "affect_context": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "grief-or-loss", "hope-or-efficacy", "love-care-or-solidarity", "belonging-or-identity-security", "fear-or-threat" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-affect-context", "boundary_ref": "dimension-affect-context", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "social_position": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "status", "office", "discursive-power", "network-position", "agenda-control" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-social-position", "boundary_ref": "dimension-social-position", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "power_asymmetry": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "naming-and-interpretive", "canon-and-curriculum", "status-and-hierarchy", "attention-and-distribution", "technical-and-infrastructure" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-power-asymmetry", "boundary_ref": "dimension-power-asymmetry", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "material_conditions": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "labor-and-time", "land-and-geography", "data-and-technology", "infrastructure-and-logistics", "energy-and-resources" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-material-conditions", "boundary_ref": "dimension-material-conditions", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "flow_dynamics": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "delay-or-latency", "leakage-substitution-or-displacement", "coupling-or-decoupling", "branching-or-convergence" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-flow-dynamics", "boundary_ref": "dimension-flow-dynamics", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "topology": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "parallel-path", "bottleneck", "leakage", "substitution" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-topology", "boundary_ref": "dimension-topology", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "negative_flow": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "not-observed", "no-opportunity", "blocked", "unknown" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-negative-flow", "boundary_ref": "dimension-negative-flow", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "negative_flow_profiles": [ { "status_ref": "not-observed", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses", "adverse_inference": false }, { "status_ref": "no-opportunity", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses", "adverse_inference": false }, { "status_ref": "blocked", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses", "adverse_inference": false }, { "status_ref": "unknown", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "unknown", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses", "adverse_inference": false } ], "translation_profile": { "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "translation-rights-and-access-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "source_language": "Declared source language or sign system; unknown until source-bound evidence is added.", "target_language": "Declared target language or sign system; unknown until source-bound evidence is added.", "source_register": "Declared source register and institutional setting; unknown until evidenced.", "target_register": "Declared target register and institutional setting; unknown until evidenced.", "source_genre": "Declared source genre; unknown until evidenced.", "target_genre": "Declared target genre; unknown until evidenced.", "source_version": "Stable source version or witnessed performance reference; none is added by this atlas.", "translator_position_refs": [ "discursive-power" ], "patron_position_refs": [ "agenda-control" ], "audience_party_refs": [ "audiences-and-non-audiences" ], "preserved": [ "translation-preserved-question" ], "changed": [ "translation-changed-question" ], "introduced": [ "translation-introduced-question" ], "omitted": [ "translation-omitted-question" ], "untranslatable": [ "translation-untranslatable-question" ], "counterreadings": [ "translation-counterreadings-question" ], "rights_and_access": [ "translation-rights-and-access-question" ], "fidelity_claimed": false, "representational_authority_granted": false }, "threshold_profile": { "status": "unassessed", "reason_ref": "threshold-inactive-boundary", "boundary_ref": "threshold-inactive-boundary" }, "path_dependence_profile": { "status": "unassessed", "reason_ref": "path-inactive-boundary", "boundary_ref": "path-inactive-boundary" }, "repair_profile": { "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "repair-review-or-retirement-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-run", "proposal_source": "card-repair-routes", "fresh_gate_refs": [ "attribution-and-provenance", "publication-and-access", "affected-party-register", "rights-assessment", "consent-or-lawful-basis", "safety-and-stop-route" ], "attempt": [ "repair-attempt-question" ], "execution_or_outcome_observation": [ "repair-outcome-question" ], "party_indexed_residuals": [ { "affected_party_id": "audiences-and-non-audiences", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "expression-originators", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "translators-curators-and-stewards", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "indirect-non-user-and-bystander-parties", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] } ], "dissent": [ "repair-dissent-question" ], "recurrence": [ "repair-recurrence-question" ], "review_or_retirement": [ "repair-review-or-retirement-question" ], "repair_completed": false, "causal_effect_claimed": false, "erasure_or_absolution_claimed": false, "restored_consent_claimed": false }, "evidence_uncertainty": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "source", "selection-and-missingness", "temporal", "transport", "affected-party-incompleteness", "normative-disagreement", "measurement", "identification-and-model" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-evidence-uncertainty", "boundary_ref": "dimension-evidence-uncertainty", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "alternative_paths": [ "The Circulation, exposure, and response trace may arise independently, through a rival carrier or institution, after an external event, through selection or measurement, or not arise at all." ] }, "evidence_profile": { "claim_register": "DESIGN_COMMITMENT", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "causal_status": "formal-mechanism-not-instantiated", "evidence_refs": [], "evidence_ref_status": "no-direct-predecessor-evidence-design-only", "expected_traces": { "source": "card-nuance-observables", "prompt_refs": [] }, "negative_cases": { "source": "card-nuance-alternative-paths", "prompt_refs": [] }, "counterevidence": [ "evidence-counterevidence" ], "falsifiers": [ "evidence-falsifier" ], "transport_bounds": [ "evidence-transport-bound" ], "promotion_requirement": "promotion-requires-source-bound-successor", "external_empirical_support_claimed": false, "mechanism_promoted": false }, "authority_dependency": { "status": "external-gate-required-before-effectful-use", "template_ref": "transition-authority", "gate_input_ids": [ "attribution-and-provenance", "publication-and-access", "affected-party-register", "rights-assessment", "consent-or-lawful-basis", "safety-and-stop-route" ] }, "causal_influence": { "status": "not-assessed-by-static-atlas", "template_ref": "transition-causal", "estimand_required_before_promotion": true, "comparator_required_before_promotion": true, "assumptions_required_before_promotion": true, "causal_effect_claimed": false }, "automatic": false, "transitive": false }, { "id": "circulation-to-institutional-context", "from_stage_ids": [ "circulation-exposure-response" ], "to_stage_ids": [ "institutional-selection-context" ], "predecessor_relation_ids": [], "relation_gap_status": "no-direct-predecessor-relation", "relation_direction_note": "No direct predecessor relation is invented; the transition remains an open design question between separately typed stages.", "transition_status": "design-question-not-observed-or-causal-transition", "nuance": { "template_ref": "transition-default", "carriers": [ "Separately versioned records, roles, media, infrastructures, resources, bodies, or institutions bound to Circulation, exposure, and response and Institutional selection context." ], "transformations": [ "Audit agenda entry, archive or curriculum selection, non-decision, exclusion, informal routing, and rival institutions; do not collapse it into an automatic bridge." ], "gates": [ "Source, target, opportunity, current authority, rights, affected parties, material conditions, safety, stop, and repair gates remain separately evidenced." ], "observables": [ "Source-bound Circulation, exposure, and response and Institutional selection context records that distinguish agenda entry, archive or curriculum selection, non-decision, exclusion, informal routing, and rival institutions, with opportunity, timing, gates, missingness, counterevidence, and rival paths." ], "affected_party_ids": [ "audiences-and-non-audiences", "institutional-participants", "source-communities-and-traditions", "decision-subjects" ], "affected_party_aftermath": [ { "affected_party_id": "audiences-and-non-audiences", "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [ "party-benefit-question" ], "burdens": [], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false }, { "affected_party_id": "institutional-participants", "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [], "burdens": [ "party-burden-question" ], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false }, { "affected_party_id": "source-communities-and-traditions", "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [ "party-benefit-question" ], "burdens": [], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false }, { "affected_party_id": "decision-subjects", "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [], "burdens": [], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false } ], "emotion_observation": { "status": "unassessed", "reason_ref": "dimension-emotion-observation", "boundary_ref": "dimension-emotion-observation" }, "affect_context": { "status": "unassessed", "reason_ref": "dimension-affect-context", "boundary_ref": "dimension-affect-context" }, "social_position": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "network-position", "agenda-control", "discursive-power", "economic-resources-ownership-labor-and-debt", "status" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-social-position", "boundary_ref": "dimension-social-position", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "power_asymmetry": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "attention-and-distribution", "technical-and-infrastructure", "epistemic-and-measurement", "canon-and-curriculum", "agenda-and-procedure" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-power-asymmetry", "boundary_ref": "dimension-power-asymmetry", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "material_conditions": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "labor-and-time", "infrastructure-and-logistics", "data-and-technology", "energy-and-resources", "money-credit-and-property" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-material-conditions", "boundary_ref": "dimension-material-conditions", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "flow_dynamics": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "delay-or-latency", "path-dependence-or-hysteresis", "branching-or-convergence", "leakage-substitution-or-displacement" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-flow-dynamics", "boundary_ref": "dimension-flow-dynamics", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "topology": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "bottleneck", "parallel-path", "substitution", "interruption" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-topology", "boundary_ref": "dimension-topology", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "negative_flow": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "not-observed", "no-opportunity", "blocked", "unknown" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-negative-flow", "boundary_ref": "dimension-negative-flow", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "negative_flow_profiles": [ { "status_ref": "not-observed", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses", "adverse_inference": false }, { "status_ref": "no-opportunity", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses", "adverse_inference": false }, { "status_ref": "blocked", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses", "adverse_inference": false }, { "status_ref": "unknown", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "unknown", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses", "adverse_inference": false } ], "translation_profile": { "status": "unassessed", "reason_ref": "translation-inactive-boundary", "boundary_ref": "translation-inactive-boundary" }, "threshold_profile": { "status": "unassessed", "reason_ref": "threshold-inactive-boundary", "boundary_ref": "threshold-inactive-boundary" }, "path_dependence_profile": { "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "path-evidence-requirement", "claim_status": "design-question-not-established", "reinforcement_mechanism": [ "path-reinforcement-question" ], "switching_cost": [ "path-switching-cost-question" ], "sunk_resource": [ "path-sunk-resource-question" ], "option_loss": [ "path-option-loss-question" ], "alternative_timing": [ "path-alternative-timing-question" ], "reversal_evidence": [ "path-reversal-evidence-question" ], "evidence": [ "path-evidence-requirement" ], "path_dependence_established": false }, "repair_profile": { "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "repair-review-or-retirement-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-run", "proposal_source": "card-repair-routes", "fresh_gate_refs": [ "publication-and-access", "affected-party-register", "rights-assessment", "consent-or-lawful-basis", "safety-and-stop-route", "decision-procedure", "current-authority-and-jurisdiction" ], "attempt": [ "repair-attempt-question" ], "execution_or_outcome_observation": [ "repair-outcome-question" ], "party_indexed_residuals": [ { "affected_party_id": "audiences-and-non-audiences", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "institutional-participants", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "source-communities-and-traditions", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "decision-subjects", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] } ], "dissent": [ "repair-dissent-question" ], "recurrence": [ "repair-recurrence-question" ], "review_or_retirement": [ "repair-review-or-retirement-question" ], "repair_completed": false, "causal_effect_claimed": false, "erasure_or_absolution_claimed": false, "restored_consent_claimed": false }, "evidence_uncertainty": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "measurement", "selection-and-missingness", "temporal", "identification-and-model", "transport", "affected-party-incompleteness", "source", "normative-disagreement", "authority-and-jurisdiction" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-evidence-uncertainty", "boundary_ref": "dimension-evidence-uncertainty", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "alternative_paths": [ "The Institutional selection context trace may arise independently, through a rival carrier or institution, after an external event, through selection or measurement, or not arise at all." ] }, "evidence_profile": { "claim_register": "DESIGN_COMMITMENT", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "causal_status": "formal-mechanism-not-instantiated", "evidence_refs": [], "evidence_ref_status": "no-direct-predecessor-evidence-design-only", "expected_traces": { "source": "card-nuance-observables", "prompt_refs": [] }, "negative_cases": { "source": "card-nuance-alternative-paths", "prompt_refs": [] }, "counterevidence": [ "evidence-counterevidence" ], "falsifiers": [ "evidence-falsifier" ], "transport_bounds": [ "evidence-transport-bound" ], "promotion_requirement": "promotion-requires-source-bound-successor", "external_empirical_support_claimed": false, "mechanism_promoted": false }, "authority_dependency": { "status": "external-gate-required-before-effectful-use", "template_ref": "transition-authority", "gate_input_ids": [ "publication-and-access", "affected-party-register", "rights-assessment", "consent-or-lawful-basis", "safety-and-stop-route", "decision-procedure", "current-authority-and-jurisdiction" ] }, "causal_influence": { "status": "not-assessed-by-static-atlas", "template_ref": "transition-causal", "estimand_required_before_promotion": true, "comparator_required_before_promotion": true, "assumptions_required_before_promotion": true, "causal_effect_claimed": false }, "automatic": false, "transitive": false }, { "id": "institution-to-proposal", "from_stage_ids": [ "institutional-selection-context" ], "to_stage_ids": [ "action-proposal" ], "predecessor_relation_ids": [], "relation_gap_status": "no-direct-predecessor-relation", "relation_direction_note": "No direct predecessor relation is invented; the transition remains an open design question between separately typed stages.", "transition_status": "design-question-not-observed-or-causal-transition", "nuance": { "template_ref": "transition-default", "carriers": [ "Separately versioned records, roles, media, infrastructures, resources, bodies, or institutions bound to Institutional selection context and Action proposal." ], "transformations": [ "Audit problem framing, option generation, affected-party scope, counterproposal, agenda power, and non-action; do not collapse it into an automatic bridge." ], "gates": [ "Source, target, opportunity, current authority, rights, affected parties, material conditions, safety, stop, and repair gates remain separately evidenced." ], "observables": [ "Source-bound Institutional selection context and Action proposal records that distinguish problem framing, option generation, affected-party scope, counterproposal, agenda power, and non-action, with opportunity, timing, gates, missingness, counterevidence, and rival paths." ], "affected_party_ids": [ "institutional-participants", "decision-subjects", "operators-and-labor", "future-parties" ], "affected_party_aftermath": [ { "affected_party_id": "institutional-participants", "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [], "burdens": [ "party-burden-question" ], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false }, { "affected_party_id": "decision-subjects", "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [], "burdens": [], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false }, { "affected_party_id": "operators-and-labor", "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [], "burdens": [ "party-burden-question" ], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false }, { "affected_party_id": "future-parties", "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [], "burdens": [], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false } ], "emotion_observation": { "status": "unassessed", "reason_ref": "dimension-emotion-observation", "boundary_ref": "dimension-emotion-observation" }, "affect_context": { "status": "unassessed", "reason_ref": "dimension-affect-context", "boundary_ref": "dimension-affect-context" }, "social_position": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "economic-resources-ownership-labor-and-debt", "status", "office", "network-position", "agenda-control" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-social-position", "boundary_ref": "dimension-social-position", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "power_asymmetry": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "canon-and-curriculum", "agenda-and-procedure", "legal-jurisdiction-and-coercion", "resources-and-class", "status-and-hierarchy" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-power-asymmetry", "boundary_ref": "dimension-power-asymmetry", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "material_conditions": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "labor-and-time", "money-credit-and-property", "infrastructure-and-logistics", "data-and-technology", "land-and-geography" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-material-conditions", "boundary_ref": "dimension-material-conditions", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "flow_dynamics": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "delay-or-latency", "path-dependence-or-hysteresis", "branching-or-convergence" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-flow-dynamics", "boundary_ref": "dimension-flow-dynamics", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "topology": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "fork", "bottleneck", "parallel-path" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-topology", "boundary_ref": "dimension-topology", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "negative_flow": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "not-observed", "no-opportunity", "blocked", "unknown" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-negative-flow", "boundary_ref": "dimension-negative-flow", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "negative_flow_profiles": [ { "status_ref": "not-observed", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses", "adverse_inference": false }, { "status_ref": "no-opportunity", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses", "adverse_inference": false }, { "status_ref": "blocked", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses", "adverse_inference": false }, { "status_ref": "unknown", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "unknown", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses", "adverse_inference": false } ], "translation_profile": { "status": "unassessed", "reason_ref": "translation-inactive-boundary", "boundary_ref": "translation-inactive-boundary" }, "threshold_profile": { "status": "unassessed", "reason_ref": "threshold-inactive-boundary", "boundary_ref": "threshold-inactive-boundary" }, "path_dependence_profile": { "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "path-evidence-requirement", "claim_status": "design-question-not-established", "reinforcement_mechanism": [ "path-reinforcement-question" ], "switching_cost": [ "path-switching-cost-question" ], "sunk_resource": [ "path-sunk-resource-question" ], "option_loss": [ "path-option-loss-question" ], "alternative_timing": [ "path-alternative-timing-question" ], "reversal_evidence": [ "path-reversal-evidence-question" ], "evidence": [ "path-evidence-requirement" ], "path_dependence_established": false }, "repair_profile": { "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "repair-review-or-retirement-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-run", "proposal_source": "card-repair-routes", "fresh_gate_refs": [ "decision-procedure", "current-authority-and-jurisdiction", "affected-party-register", "rights-assessment", "consent-or-lawful-basis", "reviewed-proposal", "budget-and-horizon", "repair-readiness" ], "attempt": [ "repair-attempt-question" ], "execution_or_outcome_observation": [ "repair-outcome-question" ], "party_indexed_residuals": [ { "affected_party_id": "institutional-participants", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "decision-subjects", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "operators-and-labor", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "future-parties", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] } ], "dissent": [ "repair-dissent-question" ], "recurrence": [ "repair-recurrence-question" ], "review_or_retirement": [ "repair-review-or-retirement-question" ], "repair_completed": false, "causal_effect_claimed": false, "erasure_or_absolution_claimed": false, "restored_consent_claimed": false }, "evidence_uncertainty": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "source", "selection-and-missingness", "temporal", "transport", "affected-party-incompleteness", "normative-disagreement", "authority-and-jurisdiction", "measurement", "identification-and-model" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-evidence-uncertainty", "boundary_ref": "dimension-evidence-uncertainty", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "alternative_paths": [ "The Action proposal trace may arise independently, through a rival carrier or institution, after an external event, through selection or measurement, or not arise at all." ] }, "evidence_profile": { "claim_register": "DESIGN_COMMITMENT", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "causal_status": "formal-mechanism-not-instantiated", "evidence_refs": [], "evidence_ref_status": "no-direct-predecessor-evidence-design-only", "expected_traces": { "source": "card-nuance-observables", "prompt_refs": [] }, "negative_cases": { "source": "card-nuance-alternative-paths", "prompt_refs": [] }, "counterevidence": [ "evidence-counterevidence" ], "falsifiers": [ "evidence-falsifier" ], "transport_bounds": [ "evidence-transport-bound" ], "promotion_requirement": "promotion-requires-source-bound-successor", "external_empirical_support_claimed": false, "mechanism_promoted": false }, "authority_dependency": { "status": "external-gate-required-before-effectful-use", "template_ref": "transition-authority", "gate_input_ids": [ "decision-procedure", "current-authority-and-jurisdiction", "affected-party-register", "rights-assessment", "consent-or-lawful-basis", "reviewed-proposal", "budget-and-horizon", "repair-readiness" ] }, "causal_influence": { "status": "not-assessed-by-static-atlas", "template_ref": "transition-causal", "estimand_required_before_promotion": true, "comparator_required_before_promotion": true, "assumptions_required_before_promotion": true, "causal_effect_claimed": false }, "automatic": false, "transitive": false }, { "id": "proposal-to-decision", "from_stage_ids": [ "action-proposal" ], "to_stage_ids": [ "decision-record" ], "predecessor_relation_ids": [ "SELECTS_PROPOSAL" ], "relation_gap_status": "typed-predecessor-relations-listed", "relation_direction_note": "Listed Reality relation directions type compatible claim endpoints; they do not assert this temporal transition or reverse immutable predecessor edges.", "transition_status": "design-question-not-observed-or-causal-transition", "nuance": { "template_ref": "transition-default", "carriers": [ "Separately versioned records, roles, media, infrastructures, resources, bodies, or institutions bound to Action proposal and Decision record." ], "transformations": [ "Audit selection, rejection, deferral, conditioning, amendment, dissent, appeal, supersession, and retirement; do not collapse it into an automatic bridge." ], "gates": [ "Source, target, opportunity, current authority, rights, affected parties, material conditions, safety, stop, and repair gates remain separately evidenced." ], "observables": [ "Source-bound Action proposal and Decision record records that distinguish selection, rejection, deferral, conditioning, amendment, dissent, appeal, supersession, and retirement, with opportunity, timing, gates, missingness, counterevidence, and rival paths." ], "affected_party_ids": [ "institutional-participants", "decision-subjects", "directly-affected-parties", "operators-and-labor" ], "affected_party_aftermath": [ { "affected_party_id": "institutional-participants", "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [], "burdens": [ "party-burden-question" ], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false }, { "affected_party_id": "decision-subjects", "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [], "burdens": [], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false }, { "affected_party_id": "directly-affected-parties", "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [ "party-benefit-question" ], "burdens": [ "party-burden-question" ], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false }, { "affected_party_id": "operators-and-labor", "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [], "burdens": [ "party-burden-question" ], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false } ], "emotion_observation": { "status": "unassessed", "reason_ref": "dimension-emotion-observation", "boundary_ref": "dimension-emotion-observation" }, "affect_context": { "status": "unassessed", "reason_ref": "dimension-affect-context", "boundary_ref": "dimension-affect-context" }, "social_position": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "economic-resources-ownership-labor-and-debt", "office", "agenda-control", "coercive-capacity", "status" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-social-position", "boundary_ref": "dimension-social-position", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "power_asymmetry": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "agenda-and-procedure", "legal-jurisdiction-and-coercion", "resources-and-class", "epistemic-and-measurement", "temporal-path-and-exit" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-power-asymmetry", "boundary_ref": "dimension-power-asymmetry", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "material_conditions": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "body-and-care", "labor-and-time", "land-and-geography", "energy-and-resources", "climate-and-ecology" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-material-conditions", "boundary_ref": "dimension-material-conditions", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "flow_dynamics": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "delay-or-latency", "path-dependence-or-hysteresis", "branching-or-convergence", "balancing-feedback" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-flow-dynamics", "boundary_ref": "dimension-flow-dynamics", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "topology": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "fork", "bottleneck", "interruption", "reversal" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-topology", "boundary_ref": "dimension-topology", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "negative_flow": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "not-observed", "no-opportunity", "blocked", "unknown" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-negative-flow", "boundary_ref": "dimension-negative-flow", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "negative_flow_profiles": [ { "status_ref": "not-observed", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses", "adverse_inference": false }, { "status_ref": "no-opportunity", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses", "adverse_inference": false }, { "status_ref": "blocked", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses", "adverse_inference": false }, { "status_ref": "unknown", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "unknown", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses", "adverse_inference": false } ], "translation_profile": { "status": "unassessed", "reason_ref": "translation-inactive-boundary", "boundary_ref": "translation-inactive-boundary" }, "threshold_profile": { "status": "unassessed", "reason_ref": "threshold-inactive-boundary", "boundary_ref": "threshold-inactive-boundary" }, "path_dependence_profile": { "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "path-evidence-requirement", "claim_status": "design-question-not-established", "reinforcement_mechanism": [ "path-reinforcement-question" ], "switching_cost": [ "path-switching-cost-question" ], "sunk_resource": [ "path-sunk-resource-question" ], "option_loss": [ "path-option-loss-question" ], "alternative_timing": [ "path-alternative-timing-question" ], "reversal_evidence": [ "path-reversal-evidence-question" ], "evidence": [ "path-evidence-requirement" ], "path_dependence_established": false }, "repair_profile": { "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "repair-review-or-retirement-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-run", "proposal_source": "card-repair-routes", "fresh_gate_refs": [ "reviewed-proposal", "decision-procedure", "current-authority-and-jurisdiction", "affected-party-register", "rights-assessment", "consent-or-lawful-basis", "budget-and-horizon", "repair-readiness" ], "attempt": [ "repair-attempt-question" ], "execution_or_outcome_observation": [ "repair-outcome-question" ], "party_indexed_residuals": [ { "affected_party_id": "institutional-participants", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "decision-subjects", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "directly-affected-parties", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "operators-and-labor", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] } ], "dissent": [ "repair-dissent-question" ], "recurrence": [ "repair-recurrence-question" ], "review_or_retirement": [ "repair-review-or-retirement-question" ], "repair_completed": false, "causal_effect_claimed": false, "erasure_or_absolution_claimed": false, "restored_consent_claimed": false }, "evidence_uncertainty": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "source", "measurement", "selection-and-missingness", "temporal", "identification-and-model", "transport", "affected-party-incompleteness", "normative-disagreement", "authority-and-jurisdiction" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-evidence-uncertainty", "boundary_ref": "dimension-evidence-uncertainty", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "alternative_paths": [ "The Decision record trace may arise independently, through a rival carrier or institution, after an external event, through selection or measurement, or not arise at all." ] }, "evidence_profile": { "claim_register": "DESIGN_COMMITMENT", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "causal_status": "formal-mechanism-not-instantiated", "evidence_refs": [], "evidence_ref_status": "no-direct-predecessor-evidence-design-only", "expected_traces": { "source": "card-nuance-observables", "prompt_refs": [] }, "negative_cases": { "source": "card-nuance-alternative-paths", "prompt_refs": [] }, "counterevidence": [ "evidence-counterevidence" ], "falsifiers": [ "evidence-falsifier" ], "transport_bounds": [ "evidence-transport-bound" ], "promotion_requirement": "promotion-requires-source-bound-successor", "external_empirical_support_claimed": false, "mechanism_promoted": false }, "authority_dependency": { "status": "external-gate-required-before-effectful-use", "template_ref": "transition-authority", "gate_input_ids": [ "reviewed-proposal", "decision-procedure", "current-authority-and-jurisdiction", "affected-party-register", "rights-assessment", "consent-or-lawful-basis", "budget-and-horizon", "repair-readiness" ] }, "causal_influence": { "status": "not-assessed-by-static-atlas", "template_ref": "transition-causal", "estimand_required_before_promotion": true, "comparator_required_before_promotion": true, "assumptions_required_before_promotion": true, "causal_effect_claimed": false }, "automatic": false, "transitive": false }, { "id": "decision-to-authorization-gate", "from_stage_ids": [ "decision-record" ], "to_stage_ids": [ "authorization-rights-and-affected-party-gate" ], "predecessor_relation_ids": [], "relation_gap_status": "no-direct-predecessor-relation", "relation_direction_note": "No direct predecessor relation is invented; the transition remains an open design question between separately typed stages.", "transition_status": "design-question-not-observed-or-causal-transition", "nuance": { "template_ref": "transition-default", "carriers": [ "Separately versioned records, roles, media, infrastructures, resources, bodies, or institutions bound to Decision record and Authorization, rights, and affected-party gate." ], "transformations": [ "Audit keeping decision separate from authentic authority, jurisdiction, rights, affected parties, consent, lawful basis, expiry, and revocation; do not collapse it into an automatic bridge." ], "gates": [ "Source, target, opportunity, current authority, rights, affected parties, material conditions, safety, stop, and repair gates remain separately evidenced." ], "observables": [ "Source-bound Decision record and Authorization, rights, and affected-party gate records that distinguish keeping decision separate from authentic authority, jurisdiction, rights, affected parties, consent, lawful basis, expiry, and revocation, with opportunity, timing, gates, missingness, counterevidence, and rival paths." ], "affected_party_ids": [ "decision-subjects", "directly-affected-parties", "indirect-non-user-and-bystander-parties", "institutional-participants" ], "affected_party_aftermath": [ { "affected_party_id": "decision-subjects", "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [], "burdens": [], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false }, { "affected_party_id": "directly-affected-parties", "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [ "party-benefit-question" ], "burdens": [ "party-burden-question" ], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false }, { "affected_party_id": "indirect-non-user-and-bystander-parties", "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [], "burdens": [ "party-burden-question" ], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false }, { "affected_party_id": "institutional-participants", "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [], "burdens": [ "party-burden-question" ], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false } ], "emotion_observation": { "status": "unassessed", "reason_ref": "dimension-emotion-observation", "boundary_ref": "dimension-emotion-observation" }, "affect_context": { "status": "unassessed", "reason_ref": "dimension-affect-context", "boundary_ref": "dimension-affect-context" }, "social_position": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "status", "office", "network-position", "agenda-control", "coercive-capacity" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-social-position", "boundary_ref": "dimension-social-position", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "power_asymmetry": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "agenda-and-procedure", "legal-jurisdiction-and-coercion", "status-and-hierarchy", "temporal-path-and-exit", "resources-and-class" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-power-asymmetry", "boundary_ref": "dimension-power-asymmetry", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "material_conditions": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "labor-and-time", "money-credit-and-property", "infrastructure-and-logistics", "data-and-technology", "body-and-care" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-material-conditions", "boundary_ref": "dimension-material-conditions", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "flow_dynamics": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "delay-or-latency", "coupling-or-decoupling", "balancing-feedback" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-flow-dynamics", "boundary_ref": "dimension-flow-dynamics", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "topology": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "join", "bottleneck", "interruption", "reversal" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-topology", "boundary_ref": "dimension-topology", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "negative_flow": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "not-observed", "no-opportunity", "blocked", "unknown" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-negative-flow", "boundary_ref": "dimension-negative-flow", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "negative_flow_profiles": [ { "status_ref": "not-observed", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses", "adverse_inference": false }, { "status_ref": "no-opportunity", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses", "adverse_inference": false }, { "status_ref": "blocked", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses", "adverse_inference": false }, { "status_ref": "unknown", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "unknown", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses", "adverse_inference": false } ], "translation_profile": { "status": "unassessed", "reason_ref": "translation-inactive-boundary", "boundary_ref": "translation-inactive-boundary" }, "threshold_profile": { "status": "unassessed", "reason_ref": "threshold-inactive-boundary", "boundary_ref": "threshold-inactive-boundary" }, "path_dependence_profile": { "status": "unassessed", "reason_ref": "path-inactive-boundary", "boundary_ref": "path-inactive-boundary" }, "repair_profile": { "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "repair-review-or-retirement-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-run", "proposal_source": "card-repair-routes", "fresh_gate_refs": [ "decision-procedure", "current-authority-and-jurisdiction", "affected-party-register", "rights-assessment", "consent-or-lawful-basis", "safety-and-stop-route" ], "attempt": [ "repair-attempt-question" ], "execution_or_outcome_observation": [ "repair-outcome-question" ], "party_indexed_residuals": [ { "affected_party_id": "decision-subjects", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "directly-affected-parties", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "indirect-non-user-and-bystander-parties", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "institutional-participants", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] } ], "dissent": [ "repair-dissent-question" ], "recurrence": [ "repair-recurrence-question" ], "review_or_retirement": [ "repair-review-or-retirement-question" ], "repair_completed": false, "causal_effect_claimed": false, "erasure_or_absolution_claimed": false, "restored_consent_claimed": false }, "evidence_uncertainty": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "source", "selection-and-missingness", "temporal", "affected-party-incompleteness", "normative-disagreement", "authority-and-jurisdiction", "measurement" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-evidence-uncertainty", "boundary_ref": "dimension-evidence-uncertainty", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "alternative_paths": [ "The Authorization, rights, and affected-party gate trace may arise independently, through a rival carrier or institution, after an external event, through selection or measurement, or not arise at all." ] }, "evidence_profile": { "claim_register": "DESIGN_COMMITMENT", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "causal_status": "formal-mechanism-not-instantiated", "evidence_refs": [], "evidence_ref_status": "no-direct-predecessor-evidence-design-only", "expected_traces": { "source": "card-nuance-observables", "prompt_refs": [] }, "negative_cases": { "source": "card-nuance-alternative-paths", "prompt_refs": [] }, "counterevidence": [ "evidence-counterevidence" ], "falsifiers": [ "evidence-falsifier" ], "transport_bounds": [ "evidence-transport-bound" ], "promotion_requirement": "promotion-requires-source-bound-successor", "external_empirical_support_claimed": false, "mechanism_promoted": false }, "authority_dependency": { "status": "external-gate-required-before-effectful-use", "template_ref": "transition-authority", "gate_input_ids": [ "decision-procedure", "current-authority-and-jurisdiction", "affected-party-register", "rights-assessment", "consent-or-lawful-basis", "safety-and-stop-route" ] }, "causal_influence": { "status": "not-assessed-by-static-atlas", "template_ref": "transition-causal", "estimand_required_before_promotion": true, "comparator_required_before_promotion": true, "assumptions_required_before_promotion": true, "causal_effect_claimed": false }, "automatic": false, "transitive": false }, { "id": "authorization-gate-to-capability", "from_stage_ids": [ "authorization-rights-and-affected-party-gate" ], "to_stage_ids": [ "capability-and-resources" ], "predecessor_relation_ids": [], "relation_gap_status": "no-direct-predecessor-relation", "relation_direction_note": "No direct predecessor relation is invented; the transition remains an open design question between separately typed stages.", "transition_status": "design-question-not-observed-or-causal-transition", "nuance": { "template_ref": "transition-default", "carriers": [ "Separately versioned records, roles, media, infrastructures, resources, bodies, or institutions bound to Authorization, rights, and affected-party gate and Capability and resources." ], "transformations": [ "Audit keeping permission questions separate from human, technical, fiscal, material, maintenance, safety, and repair capability; do not collapse it into an automatic bridge." ], "gates": [ "Source, target, opportunity, current authority, rights, affected parties, material conditions, safety, stop, and repair gates remain separately evidenced." ], "observables": [ "Source-bound Authorization, rights, and affected-party gate and Capability and resources records that distinguish keeping permission questions separate from human, technical, fiscal, material, maintenance, safety, and repair capability, with opportunity, timing, gates, missingness, counterevidence, and rival paths." ], "affected_party_ids": [ "operators-and-labor", "resource-providers", "directly-affected-parties", "future-parties", "ecological-systems" ], "affected_party_aftermath": [ { "affected_party_id": "operators-and-labor", "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [], "burdens": [ "party-burden-question" ], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false }, { "affected_party_id": "resource-providers", "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [ "party-benefit-question" ], "burdens": [ "party-burden-question" ], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false }, { "affected_party_id": "directly-affected-parties", "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [ "party-benefit-question" ], "burdens": [ "party-burden-question" ], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false }, { "affected_party_id": "future-parties", "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [], "burdens": [], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false }, { "affected_party_id": "ecological-systems", "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [], "burdens": [ "party-burden-question" ], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false } ], "emotion_observation": { "status": "unassessed", "reason_ref": "dimension-emotion-observation", "boundary_ref": "dimension-emotion-observation" }, "affect_context": { "status": "unassessed", "reason_ref": "dimension-affect-context", "boundary_ref": "dimension-affect-context" }, "social_position": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "economic-resources-ownership-labor-and-debt", "status", "office", "agenda-control", "coercive-capacity" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-social-position", "boundary_ref": "dimension-social-position", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "power_asymmetry": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "legal-jurisdiction-and-coercion", "resources-and-class", "status-and-hierarchy", "agenda-and-procedure", "temporal-path-and-exit" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-power-asymmetry", "boundary_ref": "dimension-power-asymmetry", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "material_conditions": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "body-and-care", "labor-and-time", "land-and-geography", "money-credit-and-property", "infrastructure-and-logistics" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-material-conditions", "boundary_ref": "dimension-material-conditions", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "flow_dynamics": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "delay-or-latency", "coupling-or-decoupling", "accumulation-or-memory" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-flow-dynamics", "boundary_ref": "dimension-flow-dynamics", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "topology": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "join", "bottleneck", "parallel-path", "interruption" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-topology", "boundary_ref": "dimension-topology", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "negative_flow": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "not-observed", "no-opportunity", "blocked", "unknown" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-negative-flow", "boundary_ref": "dimension-negative-flow", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "negative_flow_profiles": [ { "status_ref": "not-observed", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses", "adverse_inference": false }, { "status_ref": "no-opportunity", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses", "adverse_inference": false }, { "status_ref": "blocked", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses", "adverse_inference": false }, { "status_ref": "unknown", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "unknown", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses", "adverse_inference": false } ], "translation_profile": { "status": "unassessed", "reason_ref": "translation-inactive-boundary", "boundary_ref": "translation-inactive-boundary" }, "threshold_profile": { "status": "unassessed", "reason_ref": "threshold-inactive-boundary", "boundary_ref": "threshold-inactive-boundary" }, "path_dependence_profile": { "status": "unassessed", "reason_ref": "path-inactive-boundary", "boundary_ref": "path-inactive-boundary" }, "repair_profile": { "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "repair-review-or-retirement-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-run", "proposal_source": "card-repair-routes", "fresh_gate_refs": [ "current-authority-and-jurisdiction", "affected-party-register", "rights-assessment", "consent-or-lawful-basis", "safety-and-stop-route", "capability-and-resources", "budget-and-horizon", "repair-readiness" ], "attempt": [ "repair-attempt-question" ], "execution_or_outcome_observation": [ "repair-outcome-question" ], "party_indexed_residuals": [ { "affected_party_id": "operators-and-labor", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "resource-providers", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "directly-affected-parties", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "future-parties", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "ecological-systems", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] } ], "dissent": [ "repair-dissent-question" ], "recurrence": [ "repair-recurrence-question" ], "review_or_retirement": [ "repair-review-or-retirement-question" ], "repair_completed": false, "causal_effect_claimed": false, "erasure_or_absolution_claimed": false, "restored_consent_claimed": false }, "evidence_uncertainty": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "source", "measurement", "selection-and-missingness", "temporal", "affected-party-incompleteness", "normative-disagreement", "authority-and-jurisdiction", "transport" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-evidence-uncertainty", "boundary_ref": "dimension-evidence-uncertainty", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "alternative_paths": [ "The Capability and resources trace may arise independently, through a rival carrier or institution, after an external event, through selection or measurement, or not arise at all." ] }, "evidence_profile": { "claim_register": "DESIGN_COMMITMENT", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "causal_status": "formal-mechanism-not-instantiated", "evidence_refs": [], "evidence_ref_status": "no-direct-predecessor-evidence-design-only", "expected_traces": { "source": "card-nuance-observables", "prompt_refs": [] }, "negative_cases": { "source": "card-nuance-alternative-paths", "prompt_refs": [] }, "counterevidence": [ "evidence-counterevidence" ], "falsifiers": [ "evidence-falsifier" ], "transport_bounds": [ "evidence-transport-bound" ], "promotion_requirement": "promotion-requires-source-bound-successor", "external_empirical_support_claimed": false, "mechanism_promoted": false }, "authority_dependency": { "status": "external-gate-required-before-effectful-use", "template_ref": "transition-authority", "gate_input_ids": [ "current-authority-and-jurisdiction", "affected-party-register", "rights-assessment", "consent-or-lawful-basis", "safety-and-stop-route", "capability-and-resources", "budget-and-horizon", "repair-readiness" ] }, "causal_influence": { "status": "not-assessed-by-static-atlas", "template_ref": "transition-causal", "estimand_required_before_promotion": true, "comparator_required_before_promotion": true, "assumptions_required_before_promotion": true, "causal_effect_claimed": false }, "automatic": false, "transitive": false }, { "id": "capability-to-attempt", "from_stage_ids": [ "capability-and-resources" ], "to_stage_ids": [ "attempt" ], "predecessor_relation_ids": [ "TECHNICALLY_ENABLES" ], "relation_gap_status": "typed-predecessor-relations-listed", "relation_direction_note": "Listed Reality relation directions type compatible claim endpoints; they do not assert this temporal transition or reverse immutable predecessor edges.", "transition_status": "design-question-not-observed-or-causal-transition", "nuance": { "template_ref": "transition-default", "carriers": [ "Separately versioned records, roles, media, infrastructures, resources, bodies, or institutions bound to Capability and resources and Attempt." ], "transformations": [ "Audit fresh gates, parameter binding, target verification, preflight, unique invocation identity, cancellation, and documented non-action; do not collapse it into an automatic bridge." ], "gates": [ "Source, target, opportunity, current authority, rights, affected parties, material conditions, safety, stop, and repair gates remain separately evidenced." ], "observables": [ "Source-bound Capability and resources and Attempt records that distinguish fresh gates, parameter binding, target verification, preflight, unique invocation identity, cancellation, and documented non-action, with opportunity, timing, gates, missingness, counterevidence, and rival paths." ], "affected_party_ids": [ "operators-and-labor", "resource-providers", "directly-affected-parties", "decision-subjects" ], "affected_party_aftermath": [ { "affected_party_id": "operators-and-labor", "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [], "burdens": [ "party-burden-question" ], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false }, { "affected_party_id": "resource-providers", "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [ "party-benefit-question" ], "burdens": [ "party-burden-question" ], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false }, { "affected_party_id": "directly-affected-parties", "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [ "party-benefit-question" ], "burdens": [ "party-burden-question" ], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false }, { "affected_party_id": "decision-subjects", "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [], "burdens": [], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false } ], "emotion_observation": { "status": "unassessed", "reason_ref": "dimension-emotion-observation", "boundary_ref": "dimension-emotion-observation" }, "affect_context": { "status": "unassessed", "reason_ref": "dimension-affect-context", "boundary_ref": "dimension-affect-context" }, "social_position": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "economic-resources-ownership-labor-and-debt", "office", "network-position", "coercive-capacity" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-social-position", "boundary_ref": "dimension-social-position", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "power_asymmetry": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "resources-and-class", "technical-and-infrastructure", "legal-jurisdiction-and-coercion", "temporal-path-and-exit" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-power-asymmetry", "boundary_ref": "dimension-power-asymmetry", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "material_conditions": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "body-and-care", "labor-and-time", "land-and-geography", "energy-and-resources", "climate-and-ecology" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-material-conditions", "boundary_ref": "dimension-material-conditions", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "flow_dynamics": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "delay-or-latency", "coupling-or-decoupling", "continuous-or-episodic" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-flow-dynamics", "boundary_ref": "dimension-flow-dynamics", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "topology": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "bottleneck", "interruption", "parallel-path" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-topology", "boundary_ref": "dimension-topology", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "negative_flow": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "not-observed", "no-opportunity", "blocked", "unknown" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-negative-flow", "boundary_ref": "dimension-negative-flow", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "negative_flow_profiles": [ { "status_ref": "not-observed", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses", "adverse_inference": false }, { "status_ref": "no-opportunity", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses", "adverse_inference": false }, { "status_ref": "blocked", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses", "adverse_inference": false }, { "status_ref": "unknown", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "unknown", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses", "adverse_inference": false } ], "translation_profile": { "status": "unassessed", "reason_ref": "translation-inactive-boundary", "boundary_ref": "translation-inactive-boundary" }, "threshold_profile": { "status": "unassessed", "reason_ref": "threshold-inactive-boundary", "boundary_ref": "threshold-inactive-boundary" }, "path_dependence_profile": { "status": "unassessed", "reason_ref": "path-inactive-boundary", "boundary_ref": "path-inactive-boundary" }, "repair_profile": { "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "repair-review-or-retirement-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-run", "proposal_source": "card-repair-routes", "fresh_gate_refs": [ "current-authority-and-jurisdiction", "rights-assessment", "consent-or-lawful-basis", "capability-and-resources", "budget-and-horizon", "safety-and-stop-route", "repair-readiness", "affected-party-register" ], "attempt": [ "repair-attempt-question" ], "execution_or_outcome_observation": [ "repair-outcome-question" ], "party_indexed_residuals": [ { "affected_party_id": "operators-and-labor", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "resource-providers", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "directly-affected-parties", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "decision-subjects", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] } ], "dissent": [ "repair-dissent-question" ], "recurrence": [ "repair-recurrence-question" ], "review_or_retirement": [ "repair-review-or-retirement-question" ], "repair_completed": false, "causal_effect_claimed": false, "erasure_or_absolution_claimed": false, "restored_consent_claimed": false }, "evidence_uncertainty": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "source", "measurement", "selection-and-missingness", "temporal", "transport", "affected-party-incompleteness", "authority-and-jurisdiction" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-evidence-uncertainty", "boundary_ref": "dimension-evidence-uncertainty", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "alternative_paths": [ "The Attempt trace may arise independently, through a rival carrier or institution, after an external event, through selection or measurement, or not arise at all." ] }, "evidence_profile": { "claim_register": "DESIGN_COMMITMENT", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "causal_status": "formal-mechanism-not-instantiated", "evidence_refs": [], "evidence_ref_status": "no-direct-predecessor-evidence-design-only", "expected_traces": { "source": "card-nuance-observables", "prompt_refs": [] }, "negative_cases": { "source": "card-nuance-alternative-paths", "prompt_refs": [] }, "counterevidence": [ "evidence-counterevidence" ], "falsifiers": [ "evidence-falsifier" ], "transport_bounds": [ "evidence-transport-bound" ], "promotion_requirement": "promotion-requires-source-bound-successor", "external_empirical_support_claimed": false, "mechanism_promoted": false }, "authority_dependency": { "status": "external-gate-required-before-effectful-use", "template_ref": "transition-authority", "gate_input_ids": [ "current-authority-and-jurisdiction", "rights-assessment", "consent-or-lawful-basis", "capability-and-resources", "budget-and-horizon", "safety-and-stop-route", "repair-readiness", "affected-party-register" ] }, "causal_influence": { "status": "not-assessed-by-static-atlas", "template_ref": "transition-causal", "estimand_required_before_promotion": true, "comparator_required_before_promotion": true, "assumptions_required_before_promotion": true, "causal_effect_claimed": false }, "automatic": false, "transitive": false }, { "id": "attempt-to-execution", "from_stage_ids": [ "attempt" ], "to_stage_ids": [ "execution-or-action" ], "predecessor_relation_ids": [ "EXECUTES_ATTEMPT" ], "relation_gap_status": "typed-predecessor-relations-listed", "relation_direction_note": "Listed Reality relation directions type compatible claim endpoints; they do not assert this temporal transition or reverse immutable predecessor edges.", "transition_status": "design-question-not-observed-or-causal-transition", "nuance": { "template_ref": "transition-default", "carriers": [ "Separately versioned records, roles, media, infrastructures, resources, bodies, or institutions bound to Attempt and Execution or action." ], "transformations": [ "Audit failure, cancellation, partial execution, duplicate execution, changed target state, containment, and rollback; do not collapse it into an automatic bridge." ], "gates": [ "Source, target, opportunity, current authority, rights, affected parties, material conditions, safety, stop, and repair gates remain separately evidenced." ], "observables": [ "Source-bound Attempt and Execution or action records that distinguish failure, cancellation, partial execution, duplicate execution, changed target state, containment, and rollback, with opportunity, timing, gates, missingness, counterevidence, and rival paths." ], "affected_party_ids": [ "operators-and-labor", "directly-affected-parties", "indirect-non-user-and-bystander-parties", "decision-subjects" ], "affected_party_aftermath": [ { "affected_party_id": "operators-and-labor", "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [], "burdens": [ "party-burden-question" ], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false }, { "affected_party_id": "directly-affected-parties", "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [ "party-benefit-question" ], "burdens": [ "party-burden-question" ], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false }, { "affected_party_id": "indirect-non-user-and-bystander-parties", "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [], "burdens": [ "party-burden-question" ], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false }, { "affected_party_id": "decision-subjects", "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [], "burdens": [], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false } ], "emotion_observation": { "status": "unassessed", "reason_ref": "dimension-emotion-observation", "boundary_ref": "dimension-emotion-observation" }, "affect_context": { "status": "unassessed", "reason_ref": "dimension-affect-context", "boundary_ref": "dimension-affect-context" }, "social_position": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "office", "network-position", "coercive-capacity", "economic-resources-ownership-labor-and-debt" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-social-position", "boundary_ref": "dimension-social-position", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "power_asymmetry": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "legal-jurisdiction-and-coercion", "technical-and-infrastructure", "temporal-path-and-exit", "resources-and-class" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-power-asymmetry", "boundary_ref": "dimension-power-asymmetry", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "material_conditions": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "body-and-care", "labor-and-time", "energy-and-resources", "infrastructure-and-logistics", "data-and-technology" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-material-conditions", "boundary_ref": "dimension-material-conditions", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "flow_dynamics": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "delay-or-latency", "coupling-or-decoupling", "continuous-or-episodic" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-flow-dynamics", "boundary_ref": "dimension-flow-dynamics", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "topology": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "interruption", "recurrence", "parallel-path", "reversal" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-topology", "boundary_ref": "dimension-topology", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "negative_flow": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "not-observed", "no-opportunity", "blocked", "unknown" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-negative-flow", "boundary_ref": "dimension-negative-flow", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "negative_flow_profiles": [ { "status_ref": "not-observed", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses", "adverse_inference": false }, { "status_ref": "no-opportunity", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses", "adverse_inference": false }, { "status_ref": "blocked", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses", "adverse_inference": false }, { "status_ref": "unknown", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "unknown", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses", "adverse_inference": false } ], "translation_profile": { "status": "unassessed", "reason_ref": "translation-inactive-boundary", "boundary_ref": "translation-inactive-boundary" }, "threshold_profile": { "status": "unassessed", "reason_ref": "threshold-inactive-boundary", "boundary_ref": "threshold-inactive-boundary" }, "path_dependence_profile": { "status": "unassessed", "reason_ref": "path-inactive-boundary", "boundary_ref": "path-inactive-boundary" }, "repair_profile": { "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "repair-review-or-retirement-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-run", "proposal_source": "card-repair-routes", "fresh_gate_refs": [ "current-authority-and-jurisdiction", "affected-party-register", "rights-assessment", "consent-or-lawful-basis", "capability-and-resources", "safety-and-stop-route", "repair-readiness", "budget-and-horizon" ], "attempt": [ "repair-attempt-question" ], "execution_or_outcome_observation": [ "repair-outcome-question" ], "party_indexed_residuals": [ { "affected_party_id": "operators-and-labor", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "directly-affected-parties", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "indirect-non-user-and-bystander-parties", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "decision-subjects", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] } ], "dissent": [ "repair-dissent-question" ], "recurrence": [ "repair-recurrence-question" ], "review_or_retirement": [ "repair-review-or-retirement-question" ], "repair_completed": false, "causal_effect_claimed": false, "erasure_or_absolution_claimed": false, "restored_consent_claimed": false }, "evidence_uncertainty": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "source", "measurement", "selection-and-missingness", "temporal", "affected-party-incompleteness", "authority-and-jurisdiction", "identification-and-model" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-evidence-uncertainty", "boundary_ref": "dimension-evidence-uncertainty", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "alternative_paths": [ "The Execution or action trace may arise independently, through a rival carrier or institution, after an external event, through selection or measurement, or not arise at all." ] }, "evidence_profile": { "claim_register": "DESIGN_COMMITMENT", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "causal_status": "formal-mechanism-not-instantiated", "evidence_refs": [], "evidence_ref_status": "no-direct-predecessor-evidence-design-only", "expected_traces": { "source": "card-nuance-observables", "prompt_refs": [] }, "negative_cases": { "source": "card-nuance-alternative-paths", "prompt_refs": [] }, "counterevidence": [ "evidence-counterevidence" ], "falsifiers": [ "evidence-falsifier" ], "transport_bounds": [ "evidence-transport-bound" ], "promotion_requirement": "promotion-requires-source-bound-successor", "external_empirical_support_claimed": false, "mechanism_promoted": false }, "authority_dependency": { "status": "external-gate-required-before-effectful-use", "template_ref": "transition-authority", "gate_input_ids": [ "current-authority-and-jurisdiction", "affected-party-register", "rights-assessment", "consent-or-lawful-basis", "capability-and-resources", "safety-and-stop-route", "repair-readiness", "budget-and-horizon" ] }, "causal_influence": { "status": "not-assessed-by-static-atlas", "template_ref": "transition-causal", "estimand_required_before_promotion": true, "comparator_required_before_promotion": true, "assumptions_required_before_promotion": true, "causal_effect_claimed": false }, "automatic": false, "transitive": false }, { "id": "execution-to-outcome", "from_stage_ids": [ "execution-or-action" ], "to_stage_ids": [ "outcome-observation" ], "predecessor_relation_ids": [ "PRECEDES_OUTCOME" ], "relation_gap_status": "typed-predecessor-relations-listed", "relation_direction_note": "Listed Reality relation directions type compatible claim endpoints; they do not assert this temporal transition or reverse immutable predecessor edges.", "transition_status": "design-question-not-observed-or-causal-transition", "nuance": { "template_ref": "transition-default", "carriers": [ "Separately versioned records, roles, media, infrastructures, resources, bodies, or institutions bound to Execution or action and Outcome observation." ], "transformations": [ "Audit separating witnessed action, temporal order, outcome construct, event time, observation time, missingness, spillover, and rival cause; do not collapse it into an automatic bridge." ], "gates": [ "Source, target, opportunity, current authority, rights, affected parties, material conditions, safety, stop, and repair gates remain separately evidenced." ], "observables": [ "Source-bound Execution or action and Outcome observation records that distinguish separating witnessed action, temporal order, outcome construct, event time, observation time, missingness, spillover, and rival cause, with opportunity, timing, gates, missingness, counterevidence, and rival paths." ], "affected_party_ids": [ "directly-affected-parties", "indirect-non-user-and-bystander-parties", "operators-and-labor", "future-parties", "ecological-systems" ], "affected_party_aftermath": [ { "affected_party_id": "directly-affected-parties", "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [ "party-benefit-question" ], "burdens": [ "party-burden-question" ], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false }, { "affected_party_id": "indirect-non-user-and-bystander-parties", "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [], "burdens": [ "party-burden-question" ], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false }, { "affected_party_id": "operators-and-labor", "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [], "burdens": [ "party-burden-question" ], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false }, { "affected_party_id": "future-parties", "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [], "burdens": [], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false }, { "affected_party_id": "ecological-systems", "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [], "burdens": [ "party-burden-question" ], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false } ], "emotion_observation": { "status": "unassessed", "reason_ref": "dimension-emotion-observation", "boundary_ref": "dimension-emotion-observation" }, "affect_context": { "status": "unassessed", "reason_ref": "dimension-affect-context", "boundary_ref": "dimension-affect-context" }, "social_position": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "economic-resources-ownership-labor-and-debt", "office", "coercive-capacity", "network-position", "status" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-social-position", "boundary_ref": "dimension-social-position", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "power_asymmetry": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "legal-jurisdiction-and-coercion", "resources-and-class", "technical-and-infrastructure", "temporal-path-and-exit", "epistemic-and-measurement" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-power-asymmetry", "boundary_ref": "dimension-power-asymmetry", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "material_conditions": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "body-and-care", "labor-and-time", "land-and-geography", "energy-and-resources", "climate-and-ecology" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-material-conditions", "boundary_ref": "dimension-material-conditions", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "flow_dynamics": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "delay-or-latency", "leakage-substitution-or-displacement", "coupling-or-decoupling", "continuous-or-episodic" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-flow-dynamics", "boundary_ref": "dimension-flow-dynamics", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "topology": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "parallel-path", "leakage", "substitution", "interruption", "recurrence" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-topology", "boundary_ref": "dimension-topology", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "negative_flow": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "not-observed", "no-opportunity", "blocked", "unknown" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-negative-flow", "boundary_ref": "dimension-negative-flow", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "negative_flow_profiles": [ { "status_ref": "not-observed", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses", "adverse_inference": false }, { "status_ref": "no-opportunity", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses", "adverse_inference": false }, { "status_ref": "blocked", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses", "adverse_inference": false }, { "status_ref": "unknown", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "unknown", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses", "adverse_inference": false } ], "translation_profile": { "status": "unassessed", "reason_ref": "translation-inactive-boundary", "boundary_ref": "translation-inactive-boundary" }, "threshold_profile": { "status": "unassessed", "reason_ref": "threshold-inactive-boundary", "boundary_ref": "threshold-inactive-boundary" }, "path_dependence_profile": { "status": "unassessed", "reason_ref": "path-inactive-boundary", "boundary_ref": "path-inactive-boundary" }, "repair_profile": { "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "repair-review-or-retirement-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-run", "proposal_source": "card-repair-routes", "fresh_gate_refs": [ "current-authority-and-jurisdiction", "affected-party-register", "rights-assessment", "consent-or-lawful-basis", "capability-and-resources", "budget-and-horizon", "safety-and-stop-route", "repair-readiness", "publication-and-access" ], "attempt": [ "repair-attempt-question" ], "execution_or_outcome_observation": [ "repair-outcome-question" ], "party_indexed_residuals": [ { "affected_party_id": "directly-affected-parties", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "indirect-non-user-and-bystander-parties", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "operators-and-labor", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "future-parties", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "ecological-systems", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] } ], "dissent": [ "repair-dissent-question" ], "recurrence": [ "repair-recurrence-question" ], "review_or_retirement": [ "repair-review-or-retirement-question" ], "repair_completed": false, "causal_effect_claimed": false, "erasure_or_absolution_claimed": false, "restored_consent_claimed": false }, "evidence_uncertainty": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "source", "measurement", "selection-and-missingness", "temporal", "identification-and-model", "affected-party-incompleteness", "authority-and-jurisdiction", "transport", "normative-disagreement" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-evidence-uncertainty", "boundary_ref": "dimension-evidence-uncertainty", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "alternative_paths": [ "The Outcome observation trace may arise independently, through a rival carrier or institution, after an external event, through selection or measurement, or not arise at all." ] }, "evidence_profile": { "claim_register": "DESIGN_COMMITMENT", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "causal_status": "formal-mechanism-not-instantiated", "evidence_refs": [], "evidence_ref_status": "no-direct-predecessor-evidence-design-only", "expected_traces": { "source": "card-nuance-observables", "prompt_refs": [] }, "negative_cases": { "source": "card-nuance-alternative-paths", "prompt_refs": [] }, "counterevidence": [ "evidence-counterevidence" ], "falsifiers": [ "evidence-falsifier" ], "transport_bounds": [ "evidence-transport-bound" ], "promotion_requirement": "promotion-requires-source-bound-successor", "external_empirical_support_claimed": false, "mechanism_promoted": false }, "authority_dependency": { "status": "external-gate-required-before-effectful-use", "template_ref": "transition-authority", "gate_input_ids": [ "current-authority-and-jurisdiction", "affected-party-register", "rights-assessment", "consent-or-lawful-basis", "capability-and-resources", "budget-and-horizon", "safety-and-stop-route", "repair-readiness", "publication-and-access" ] }, "causal_influence": { "status": "not-assessed-by-static-atlas", "template_ref": "transition-causal", "estimand_required_before_promotion": true, "comparator_required_before_promotion": true, "assumptions_required_before_promotion": true, "causal_effect_claimed": false }, "automatic": false, "transitive": false }, { "id": "outcome-to-aftermath-assessment", "from_stage_ids": [ "outcome-observation" ], "to_stage_ids": [ "aftermath-causal-and-normative-assessment" ], "predecessor_relation_ids": [ "ASSOCIATED_WITH", "DEFINES_ESTIMAND_FOR", "ASSESSES_CAUSAL_EFFECT", "ASSESSES_UNDER_FRAMEWORK" ], "relation_gap_status": "typed-predecessor-relations-listed", "relation_direction_note": "Listed Reality relation directions type compatible claim endpoints; they do not assert this temporal transition or reverse immutable predecessor edges.", "transition_status": "design-question-not-observed-or-causal-transition", "nuance": { "template_ref": "transition-default", "carriers": [ "Separately versioned records, roles, media, infrastructures, resources, bodies, or institutions bound to Outcome observation and Aftermath causal and normative assessment." ], "transformations": [ "Audit keeping observation, association, estimand, identification, causal assessment, rights, normative framework, disagreement, and transport separate; do not collapse it into an automatic bridge." ], "gates": [ "Source, target, opportunity, current authority, rights, affected parties, material conditions, safety, stop, and repair gates remain separately evidenced." ], "observables": [ "Source-bound Outcome observation and Aftermath causal and normative assessment records that distinguish keeping observation, association, estimand, identification, causal assessment, rights, normative framework, disagreement, and transport separate, with opportunity, timing, gates, missingness, counterevidence, and rival paths." ], "affected_party_ids": [ "directly-affected-parties", "indirect-non-user-and-bystander-parties", "decision-subjects", "future-parties", "ecological-systems" ], "affected_party_aftermath": [ { "affected_party_id": "directly-affected-parties", "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [ "party-benefit-question" ], "burdens": [ "party-burden-question" ], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false }, { "affected_party_id": "indirect-non-user-and-bystander-parties", "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [], "burdens": [ "party-burden-question" ], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false }, { "affected_party_id": "decision-subjects", "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [], "burdens": [], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false }, { "affected_party_id": "future-parties", "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [], "burdens": [], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false }, { "affected_party_id": "ecological-systems", "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [], "burdens": [ "party-burden-question" ], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false } ], "emotion_observation": { "status": "unassessed", "reason_ref": "dimension-emotion-observation", "boundary_ref": "dimension-emotion-observation" }, "affect_context": { "status": "unassessed", "reason_ref": "dimension-affect-context", "boundary_ref": "dimension-affect-context" }, "social_position": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "economic-resources-ownership-labor-and-debt", "status", "office", "network-position", "coercive-capacity" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-social-position", "boundary_ref": "dimension-social-position", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "power_asymmetry": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "epistemic-and-measurement", "resources-and-class", "status-and-hierarchy", "technical-and-infrastructure", "temporal-path-and-exit" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-power-asymmetry", "boundary_ref": "dimension-power-asymmetry", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "material_conditions": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "body-and-care", "labor-and-time", "land-and-geography", "energy-and-resources", "climate-and-ecology" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-material-conditions", "boundary_ref": "dimension-material-conditions", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "flow_dynamics": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "delay-or-latency", "path-dependence-or-hysteresis", "leakage-substitution-or-displacement", "reinforcing-feedback", "balancing-feedback" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-flow-dynamics", "boundary_ref": "dimension-flow-dynamics", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "topology": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "fork", "join", "parallel-path", "leakage", "recurrence", "reinforcing-loop", "balancing-loop" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-topology", "boundary_ref": "dimension-topology", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "negative_flow": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "not-observed", "no-opportunity", "blocked", "unknown" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-negative-flow", "boundary_ref": "dimension-negative-flow", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "negative_flow_profiles": [ { "status_ref": "not-observed", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses", "adverse_inference": false }, { "status_ref": "no-opportunity", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses", "adverse_inference": false }, { "status_ref": "blocked", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses", "adverse_inference": false }, { "status_ref": "unknown", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "unknown", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses", "adverse_inference": false } ], "translation_profile": { "status": "unassessed", "reason_ref": "translation-inactive-boundary", "boundary_ref": "translation-inactive-boundary" }, "threshold_profile": { "status": "unassessed", "reason_ref": "threshold-inactive-boundary", "boundary_ref": "threshold-inactive-boundary" }, "path_dependence_profile": { "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "path-evidence-requirement", "claim_status": "design-question-not-established", "reinforcement_mechanism": [ "path-reinforcement-question" ], "switching_cost": [ "path-switching-cost-question" ], "sunk_resource": [ "path-sunk-resource-question" ], "option_loss": [ "path-option-loss-question" ], "alternative_timing": [ "path-alternative-timing-question" ], "reversal_evidence": [ "path-reversal-evidence-question" ], "evidence": [ "path-evidence-requirement" ], "path_dependence_established": false }, "repair_profile": { "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "repair-review-or-retirement-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-run", "proposal_source": "card-repair-routes", "fresh_gate_refs": [ "current-authority-and-jurisdiction", "affected-party-register", "rights-assessment", "consent-or-lawful-basis", "publication-and-access", "safety-and-stop-route", "attribution-and-provenance" ], "attempt": [ "repair-attempt-question" ], "execution_or_outcome_observation": [ "repair-outcome-question" ], "party_indexed_residuals": [ { "affected_party_id": "directly-affected-parties", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "indirect-non-user-and-bystander-parties", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "decision-subjects", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "future-parties", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "ecological-systems", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] } ], "dissent": [ "repair-dissent-question" ], "recurrence": [ "repair-recurrence-question" ], "review_or_retirement": [ "repair-review-or-retirement-question" ], "repair_completed": false, "causal_effect_claimed": false, "erasure_or_absolution_claimed": false, "restored_consent_claimed": false }, "evidence_uncertainty": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "source", "measurement", "selection-and-missingness", "temporal", "identification-and-model", "transport", "affected-party-incompleteness", "normative-disagreement", "authority-and-jurisdiction" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-evidence-uncertainty", "boundary_ref": "dimension-evidence-uncertainty", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "alternative_paths": [ "The Aftermath causal and normative assessment trace may arise independently, through a rival carrier or institution, after an external event, through selection or measurement, or not arise at all." ] }, "evidence_profile": { "claim_register": "DESIGN_COMMITMENT", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "causal_status": "formal-mechanism-not-instantiated", "evidence_refs": [], "evidence_ref_status": "no-direct-predecessor-evidence-design-only", "expected_traces": { "source": "card-nuance-observables", "prompt_refs": [] }, "negative_cases": { "source": "card-nuance-alternative-paths", "prompt_refs": [] }, "counterevidence": [ "evidence-counterevidence" ], "falsifiers": [ "evidence-falsifier" ], "transport_bounds": [ "evidence-transport-bound" ], "promotion_requirement": "promotion-requires-source-bound-successor", "external_empirical_support_claimed": false, "mechanism_promoted": false }, "authority_dependency": { "status": "external-gate-required-before-effectful-use", "template_ref": "transition-authority", "gate_input_ids": [ "current-authority-and-jurisdiction", "affected-party-register", "rights-assessment", "consent-or-lawful-basis", "publication-and-access", "safety-and-stop-route", "attribution-and-provenance" ] }, "causal_influence": { "status": "not-assessed-by-static-atlas", "template_ref": "transition-causal", "estimand_required_before_promotion": true, "comparator_required_before_promotion": true, "assumptions_required_before_promotion": true, "causal_effect_claimed": false }, "automatic": false, "transitive": false }, { "id": "assessment-to-feedback", "from_stage_ids": [ "aftermath-causal-and-normative-assessment" ], "to_stage_ids": [ "feedback-challenge-and-counterflow" ], "predecessor_relation_ids": [ "CHALLENGES" ], "relation_gap_status": "typed-predecessor-relations-listed", "relation_direction_note": "Listed Reality relation directions type compatible claim endpoints; they do not assert this temporal transition or reverse immutable predecessor edges.", "transition_status": "design-question-not-observed-or-causal-transition", "nuance": { "template_ref": "transition-default", "carriers": [ "Separately versioned records, roles, media, infrastructures, resources, bodies, or institutions bound to Aftermath causal and normative assessment and Feedback, challenge, and counterflow." ], "transformations": [ "Audit complaint, counterevidence, counterstory, replication, refusal, withdrawal, appeal, protest, correction, privacy, and safe non-response; do not collapse it into an automatic bridge." ], "gates": [ "Source, target, opportunity, current authority, rights, affected parties, material conditions, safety, stop, and repair gates remain separately evidenced." ], "observables": [ "Source-bound Aftermath causal and normative assessment and Feedback, challenge, and counterflow records that distinguish complaint, counterevidence, counterstory, replication, refusal, withdrawal, appeal, protest, correction, privacy, and safe non-response, with opportunity, timing, gates, missingness, counterevidence, and rival paths." ], "affected_party_ids": [ "directly-affected-parties", "indirect-non-user-and-bystander-parties", "institutional-participants", "audiences-and-non-audiences", "operators-and-labor" ], "affected_party_aftermath": [ { "affected_party_id": "directly-affected-parties", "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [ "party-benefit-question" ], "burdens": [ "party-burden-question" ], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false }, { "affected_party_id": "indirect-non-user-and-bystander-parties", "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [], "burdens": [ "party-burden-question" ], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false }, { "affected_party_id": "institutional-participants", "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [], "burdens": [ "party-burden-question" ], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false }, { "affected_party_id": "audiences-and-non-audiences", "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [ "party-benefit-question" ], "burdens": [], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false }, { "affected_party_id": "operators-and-labor", "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [], "burdens": [ "party-burden-question" ], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false } ], "emotion_observation": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "self-report", "attributed-expression", "behavioral-observation", "physiology", "cultural-vocabulary" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-emotion-observation", "boundary_ref": "dimension-emotion-observation", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "affect_context": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "fear-or-threat", "anger-or-outrage", "humiliation-or-status-injury", "grief-or-loss", "hope-or-efficacy" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-affect-context", "boundary_ref": "dimension-affect-context", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "social_position": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "economic-resources-ownership-labor-and-debt", "status", "office", "network-position", "agenda-control" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-social-position", "boundary_ref": "dimension-social-position", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "power_asymmetry": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "epistemic-and-measurement", "agenda-and-procedure", "legal-jurisdiction-and-coercion", "resources-and-class", "status-and-hierarchy" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-power-asymmetry", "boundary_ref": "dimension-power-asymmetry", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "material_conditions": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "body-and-care", "labor-and-time", "land-and-geography", "energy-and-resources", "climate-and-ecology" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-material-conditions", "boundary_ref": "dimension-material-conditions", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "flow_dynamics": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "delay-or-latency", "branching-or-convergence", "reinforcing-feedback", "balancing-feedback", "leakage-substitution-or-displacement" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-flow-dynamics", "boundary_ref": "dimension-flow-dynamics", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "topology": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "fork", "join", "parallel-path", "bottleneck", "recurrence", "reinforcing-loop", "balancing-loop" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-topology", "boundary_ref": "dimension-topology", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "negative_flow": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "not-observed", "no-opportunity", "blocked", "unknown" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-negative-flow", "boundary_ref": "dimension-negative-flow", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "negative_flow_profiles": [ { "status_ref": "not-observed", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses", "adverse_inference": false }, { "status_ref": "no-opportunity", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses", "adverse_inference": false }, { "status_ref": "blocked", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses", "adverse_inference": false }, { "status_ref": "unknown", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "unknown", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses", "adverse_inference": false } ], "translation_profile": { "status": "unassessed", "reason_ref": "translation-inactive-boundary", "boundary_ref": "translation-inactive-boundary" }, "threshold_profile": { "status": "unassessed", "reason_ref": "threshold-inactive-boundary", "boundary_ref": "threshold-inactive-boundary" }, "path_dependence_profile": { "status": "unassessed", "reason_ref": "path-inactive-boundary", "boundary_ref": "path-inactive-boundary" }, "repair_profile": { "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "repair-review-or-retirement-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-run", "proposal_source": "card-repair-routes", "fresh_gate_refs": [ "attribution-and-provenance", "publication-and-access", "current-authority-and-jurisdiction", "affected-party-register", "rights-assessment", "consent-or-lawful-basis", "safety-and-stop-route", "repair-readiness" ], "attempt": [ "repair-attempt-question" ], "execution_or_outcome_observation": [ "repair-outcome-question" ], "party_indexed_residuals": [ { "affected_party_id": "directly-affected-parties", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "indirect-non-user-and-bystander-parties", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "institutional-participants", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "audiences-and-non-audiences", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "operators-and-labor", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] } ], "dissent": [ "repair-dissent-question" ], "recurrence": [ "repair-recurrence-question" ], "review_or_retirement": [ "repair-review-or-retirement-question" ], "repair_completed": false, "causal_effect_claimed": false, "erasure_or_absolution_claimed": false, "restored_consent_claimed": false }, "evidence_uncertainty": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "source", "measurement", "selection-and-missingness", "temporal", "identification-and-model", "transport", "affected-party-incompleteness", "normative-disagreement", "authority-and-jurisdiction" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-evidence-uncertainty", "boundary_ref": "dimension-evidence-uncertainty", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "alternative_paths": [ "The Feedback, challenge, and counterflow trace may arise independently, through a rival carrier or institution, after an external event, through selection or measurement, or not arise at all." ] }, "evidence_profile": { "claim_register": "DESIGN_COMMITMENT", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "causal_status": "formal-mechanism-not-instantiated", "evidence_refs": [], "evidence_ref_status": "no-direct-predecessor-evidence-design-only", "expected_traces": { "source": "card-nuance-observables", "prompt_refs": [] }, "negative_cases": { "source": "card-nuance-alternative-paths", "prompt_refs": [] }, "counterevidence": [ "evidence-counterevidence" ], "falsifiers": [ "evidence-falsifier" ], "transport_bounds": [ "evidence-transport-bound" ], "promotion_requirement": "promotion-requires-source-bound-successor", "external_empirical_support_claimed": false, "mechanism_promoted": false }, "authority_dependency": { "status": "external-gate-required-before-effectful-use", "template_ref": "transition-authority", "gate_input_ids": [ "attribution-and-provenance", "publication-and-access", "current-authority-and-jurisdiction", "affected-party-register", "rights-assessment", "consent-or-lawful-basis", "safety-and-stop-route", "repair-readiness" ] }, "causal_influence": { "status": "not-assessed-by-static-atlas", "template_ref": "transition-causal", "estimand_required_before_promotion": true, "comparator_required_before_promotion": true, "assumptions_required_before_promotion": true, "causal_effect_claimed": false }, "automatic": false, "transitive": false }, { "id": "feedback-to-repair-review", "from_stage_ids": [ "feedback-challenge-and-counterflow" ], "to_stage_ids": [ "repair-review-and-retirement" ], "predecessor_relation_ids": [ "RESPONDS_WITH_REPAIR", "ASSESSES_UNDER_FRAMEWORK" ], "relation_gap_status": "typed-predecessor-relations-listed", "relation_direction_note": "Listed Reality relation directions type compatible claim endpoints; they do not assert this temporal transition or reverse immutable predecessor edges.", "transition_status": "design-question-not-observed-or-causal-transition", "nuance": { "template_ref": "transition-default", "carriers": [ "Separately versioned records, roles, media, infrastructures, resources, bodies, or institutions bound to Feedback, challenge, and counterflow and Repair, review, and retirement." ], "transformations": [ "Audit separating feedback, repair proposal, fresh gates, attempt, execution or outcome, party residual, dissent, recurrence, review, and retirement; do not collapse it into an automatic bridge." ], "gates": [ "Source, target, opportunity, current authority, rights, affected parties, material conditions, safety, stop, and repair gates remain separately evidenced." ], "observables": [ "Source-bound Feedback, challenge, and counterflow and Repair, review, and retirement records that distinguish separating feedback, repair proposal, fresh gates, attempt, execution or outcome, party residual, dissent, recurrence, review, and retirement, with opportunity, timing, gates, missingness, counterevidence, and rival paths." ], "affected_party_ids": [ "directly-affected-parties", "indirect-non-user-and-bystander-parties", "operators-and-labor", "institutional-participants", "future-parties", "ecological-systems" ], "affected_party_aftermath": [ { "affected_party_id": "directly-affected-parties", "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [ "party-benefit-question" ], "burdens": [ "party-burden-question" ], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false }, { "affected_party_id": "indirect-non-user-and-bystander-parties", "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [], "burdens": [ "party-burden-question" ], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false }, { "affected_party_id": "operators-and-labor", "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [], "burdens": [ "party-burden-question" ], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false }, { "affected_party_id": "institutional-participants", "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [], "burdens": [ "party-burden-question" ], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false }, { "affected_party_id": "future-parties", "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [], "burdens": [], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false }, { "affected_party_id": "ecological-systems", "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [], "burdens": [ "party-burden-question" ], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false } ], "emotion_observation": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "self-report", "attributed-expression", "behavioral-observation", "physiology", "cultural-vocabulary" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-emotion-observation", "boundary_ref": "dimension-emotion-observation", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "affect_context": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "fear-or-threat", "anger-or-outrage", "humiliation-or-status-injury", "grief-or-loss", "hope-or-efficacy" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-affect-context", "boundary_ref": "dimension-affect-context", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "social_position": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "economic-resources-ownership-labor-and-debt", "status", "office", "network-position", "agenda-control" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-social-position", "boundary_ref": "dimension-social-position", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "power_asymmetry": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "naming-and-interpretive", "attention-and-distribution", "agenda-and-procedure", "legal-jurisdiction-and-coercion", "resources-and-class" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-power-asymmetry", "boundary_ref": "dimension-power-asymmetry", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "material_conditions": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "body-and-care", "labor-and-time", "land-and-geography", "energy-and-resources", "climate-and-ecology" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-material-conditions", "boundary_ref": "dimension-material-conditions", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "flow_dynamics": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "delay-or-latency", "path-dependence-or-hysteresis", "reinforcing-feedback", "balancing-feedback", "leakage-substitution-or-displacement" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-flow-dynamics", "boundary_ref": "dimension-flow-dynamics", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "topology": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "fork", "join", "parallel-path", "interruption", "reversal", "recurrence", "reinforcing-loop", "balancing-loop" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-topology", "boundary_ref": "dimension-topology", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "negative_flow": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "not-observed", "no-opportunity", "blocked", "unknown" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-negative-flow", "boundary_ref": "dimension-negative-flow", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "negative_flow_profiles": [ { "status_ref": "not-observed", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses", "adverse_inference": false }, { "status_ref": "no-opportunity", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses", "adverse_inference": false }, { "status_ref": "blocked", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses", "adverse_inference": false }, { "status_ref": "unknown", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "unknown", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses", "adverse_inference": false } ], "translation_profile": { "status": "unassessed", "reason_ref": "translation-inactive-boundary", "boundary_ref": "translation-inactive-boundary" }, "threshold_profile": { "status": "unassessed", "reason_ref": "threshold-inactive-boundary", "boundary_ref": "threshold-inactive-boundary" }, "path_dependence_profile": { "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "path-evidence-requirement", "claim_status": "design-question-not-established", "reinforcement_mechanism": [ "path-reinforcement-question" ], "switching_cost": [ "path-switching-cost-question" ], "sunk_resource": [ "path-sunk-resource-question" ], "option_loss": [ "path-option-loss-question" ], "alternative_timing": [ "path-alternative-timing-question" ], "reversal_evidence": [ "path-reversal-evidence-question" ], "evidence": [ "path-evidence-requirement" ], "path_dependence_established": false }, "repair_profile": { "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "repair-review-or-retirement-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-run", "proposal_source": "card-repair-routes", "fresh_gate_refs": [ "publication-and-access", "current-authority-and-jurisdiction", "affected-party-register", "rights-assessment", "consent-or-lawful-basis", "safety-and-stop-route", "repair-readiness", "reviewed-proposal", "decision-procedure", "capability-and-resources", "budget-and-horizon" ], "attempt": [ "repair-attempt-question" ], "execution_or_outcome_observation": [ "repair-outcome-question" ], "party_indexed_residuals": [ { "affected_party_id": "directly-affected-parties", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "indirect-non-user-and-bystander-parties", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "operators-and-labor", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "institutional-participants", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "future-parties", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "ecological-systems", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] } ], "dissent": [ "repair-dissent-question" ], "recurrence": [ "repair-recurrence-question" ], "review_or_retirement": [ "repair-review-or-retirement-question" ], "repair_completed": false, "causal_effect_claimed": false, "erasure_or_absolution_claimed": false, "restored_consent_claimed": false }, "evidence_uncertainty": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "source", "measurement", "selection-and-missingness", "temporal", "identification-and-model", "transport", "affected-party-incompleteness", "normative-disagreement", "authority-and-jurisdiction" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-evidence-uncertainty", "boundary_ref": "dimension-evidence-uncertainty", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "alternative_paths": [ "The Repair, review, and retirement trace may arise independently, through a rival carrier or institution, after an external event, through selection or measurement, or not arise at all." ] }, "evidence_profile": { "claim_register": "DESIGN_COMMITMENT", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "causal_status": "formal-mechanism-not-instantiated", "evidence_refs": [], "evidence_ref_status": "no-direct-predecessor-evidence-design-only", "expected_traces": { "source": "card-nuance-observables", "prompt_refs": [] }, "negative_cases": { "source": "card-nuance-alternative-paths", "prompt_refs": [] }, "counterevidence": [ "evidence-counterevidence" ], "falsifiers": [ "evidence-falsifier" ], "transport_bounds": [ "evidence-transport-bound" ], "promotion_requirement": "promotion-requires-source-bound-successor", "external_empirical_support_claimed": false, "mechanism_promoted": false }, "authority_dependency": { "status": "external-gate-required-before-effectful-use", "template_ref": "transition-authority", "gate_input_ids": [ "publication-and-access", "current-authority-and-jurisdiction", "affected-party-register", "rights-assessment", "consent-or-lawful-basis", "safety-and-stop-route", "repair-readiness", "reviewed-proposal", "decision-procedure", "capability-and-resources", "budget-and-horizon" ] }, "causal_influence": { "status": "not-assessed-by-static-atlas", "template_ref": "transition-causal", "estimand_required_before_promotion": true, "comparator_required_before_promotion": true, "assumptions_required_before_promotion": true, "causal_effect_claimed": false }, "automatic": false, "transitive": false } ], "crosswalk_flow_overlays": [ { "id": "naming-to-expression", "projection_binding_id": "civilisation-reality-projection", "projection_crosswalk_id": "naming-to-expression", "stage_ids": [ "word-or-expression", "shared-story-artifact" ], "transition_ids": [ "expression-to-shared-story" ], "nuance": { "template_ref": "overlay-default", "carriers": [ "Attributed word, name, invocation, sign, performance, inscription, or versioned artifact records." ], "transformations": [ "Ask how naming becomes a recorded expression or story artifact while referent, understanding, uptake, authority, and effect remain unresolved." ], "gates": [ "Require attribution, provenance, language and community context, rights, affected-party coverage, and a stop before referent or belief inference." ], "observables": [ "Source-bound expression and artifact versions, attribution seams, translation choices, counterreadings, and missing or refused records." ], "affected_party_ids": [ "expression-originators", "translators-curators-and-stewards", "source-communities-and-traditions", "audiences-and-non-audiences" ], "affected_party_aftermath": [ { "affected_party_id": "expression-originators", "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [ "party-benefit-question" ], "burdens": [], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false }, { "affected_party_id": "translators-curators-and-stewards", "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [], "burdens": [ "party-burden-question" ], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false }, { "affected_party_id": "source-communities-and-traditions", "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [ "party-benefit-question" ], "burdens": [], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false }, { "affected_party_id": "audiences-and-non-audiences", "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [ "party-benefit-question" ], "burdens": [], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false } ], "emotion_observation": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "self-report", "attributed-expression", "cultural-vocabulary", "institutional-framing" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-emotion-observation", "boundary_ref": "dimension-emotion-observation", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "affect_context": { "status": "unassessed", "reason_ref": "dimension-affect-context", "boundary_ref": "dimension-affect-context" }, "social_position": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "status", "discursive-power", "office" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-social-position", "boundary_ref": "dimension-social-position", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "power_asymmetry": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "naming-and-interpretive", "epistemic-and-measurement", "canon-and-curriculum", "status-and-hierarchy" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-power-asymmetry", "boundary_ref": "dimension-power-asymmetry", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "material_conditions": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "body-and-care", "labor-and-time", "data-and-technology", "land-and-geography" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-material-conditions", "boundary_ref": "dimension-material-conditions", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "flow_dynamics": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "delay-or-latency", "accumulation-or-memory", "branching-or-convergence", "path-dependence-or-hysteresis" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-flow-dynamics", "boundary_ref": "dimension-flow-dynamics", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "topology": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "fork", "join", "recurrence" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-topology", "boundary_ref": "dimension-topology", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "negative_flow": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "not-observed", "no-opportunity", "blocked", "unknown" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-negative-flow", "boundary_ref": "dimension-negative-flow", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "negative_flow_profiles": [ { "status_ref": "not-observed", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses", "adverse_inference": false }, { "status_ref": "no-opportunity", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses", "adverse_inference": false }, { "status_ref": "blocked", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses", "adverse_inference": false }, { "status_ref": "unknown", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "unknown", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses", "adverse_inference": false } ], "translation_profile": { "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "translation-rights-and-access-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "source_language": "Declared source language or sign system; unknown until source-bound evidence is added.", "target_language": "Declared target language or sign system; unknown until source-bound evidence is added.", "source_register": "Declared source register and institutional setting; unknown until evidenced.", "target_register": "Declared target register and institutional setting; unknown until evidenced.", "source_genre": "Declared source genre; unknown until evidenced.", "target_genre": "Declared target genre; unknown until evidenced.", "source_version": "Stable source version or witnessed performance reference; none is added by this atlas.", "translator_position_refs": [ "discursive-power" ], "patron_position_refs": [ "agenda-control" ], "audience_party_refs": [ "audiences-and-non-audiences" ], "preserved": [ "translation-preserved-question" ], "changed": [ "translation-changed-question" ], "introduced": [ "translation-introduced-question" ], "omitted": [ "translation-omitted-question" ], "untranslatable": [ "translation-untranslatable-question" ], "counterreadings": [ "translation-counterreadings-question" ], "rights_and_access": [ "translation-rights-and-access-question" ], "fidelity_claimed": false, "representational_authority_granted": false }, "threshold_profile": { "status": "unassessed", "reason_ref": "threshold-inactive-boundary", "boundary_ref": "threshold-inactive-boundary" }, "path_dependence_profile": { "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "path-evidence-requirement", "claim_status": "design-question-not-established", "reinforcement_mechanism": [ "path-reinforcement-question" ], "switching_cost": [ "path-switching-cost-question" ], "sunk_resource": [ "path-sunk-resource-question" ], "option_loss": [ "path-option-loss-question" ], "alternative_timing": [ "path-alternative-timing-question" ], "reversal_evidence": [ "path-reversal-evidence-question" ], "evidence": [ "path-evidence-requirement" ], "path_dependence_established": false }, "repair_profile": { "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "repair-review-or-retirement-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-run", "proposal_source": "card-repair-routes", "fresh_gate_refs": [ "attribution-and-provenance", "publication-and-access", "affected-party-register" ], "attempt": [ "repair-attempt-question" ], "execution_or_outcome_observation": [ "repair-outcome-question" ], "party_indexed_residuals": [ { "affected_party_id": "expression-originators", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "translators-curators-and-stewards", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "source-communities-and-traditions", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "audiences-and-non-audiences", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] } ], "dissent": [ "repair-dissent-question" ], "recurrence": [ "repair-recurrence-question" ], "review_or_retirement": [ "repair-review-or-retirement-question" ], "repair_completed": false, "causal_effect_claimed": false, "erasure_or_absolution_claimed": false, "restored_consent_claimed": false }, "evidence_uncertainty": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "source", "measurement", "selection-and-missingness", "temporal", "affected-party-incompleteness", "transport", "normative-disagreement" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-evidence-uncertainty", "boundary_ref": "dimension-evidence-uncertainty", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "alternative_paths": [ "The expression may remain private, untranslated, contested, refused, forgotten, independently recreated, or never materialized." ] }, "evidence_profile": { "claim_register": "DESIGN_COMMITMENT", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "causal_status": "formal-mechanism-not-instantiated", "evidence_refs": [], "evidence_ref_status": "no-direct-predecessor-evidence-design-only", "expected_traces": { "source": "card-nuance-observables", "prompt_refs": [] }, "negative_cases": { "source": "card-nuance-alternative-paths", "prompt_refs": [] }, "counterevidence": [ "evidence-counterevidence" ], "falsifiers": [ "evidence-falsifier" ], "transport_bounds": [ "evidence-transport-bound" ], "promotion_requirement": "promotion-requires-source-bound-successor", "external_empirical_support_claimed": false, "mechanism_promoted": false }, "authority_dependency": { "status": "external-gate-required-before-effectful-use", "template_ref": "overlay-authority", "gate_input_ids": [ "attribution-and-provenance", "publication-and-access", "affected-party-register" ] }, "causal_influence": { "status": "not-assessed-by-static-atlas", "template_ref": "overlay-causal", "estimand_required_before_promotion": true, "comparator_required_before_promotion": true, "assumptions_required_before_promotion": true, "causal_effect_claimed": false }, "new_claim_created": false, "authority_granted": false, "external_effect_claimed": false }, { "id": "story-to-public-deliberation", "projection_binding_id": "civilisation-reality-projection", "projection_crosswalk_id": "story-to-public-deliberation", "stage_ids": [ "word-or-expression", "shared-story-artifact", "circulation-exposure-response" ], "transition_ids": [ "expression-to-shared-story", "story-to-circulation" ], "nuance": { "template_ref": "overlay-default", "carriers": [ "Versioned story or teaching artifacts, distribution witnesses, exposure observations, and attributed public-response records." ], "transformations": [ "Keep expression, artifact, circulation, exposure, and response as separate evidenced stages rather than one persuasion or belief pathway." ], "gates": [ "Require separate provenance, distribution, exposure, response, rights, affected-party, and observation-coverage gates." ], "observables": [ "Versioned artifacts and separately scoped distribution, exposure, non-exposure, response, refusal, counterstory, and censoring traces." ], "affected_party_ids": [ "audiences-and-non-audiences", "expression-originators", "translators-curators-and-stewards", "indirect-non-user-and-bystander-parties" ], "affected_party_aftermath": [ { "affected_party_id": "audiences-and-non-audiences", "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [ "party-benefit-question" ], "burdens": [], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false }, { "affected_party_id": "expression-originators", "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [ "party-benefit-question" ], "burdens": [], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false }, { "affected_party_id": "translators-curators-and-stewards", "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [], "burdens": [ "party-burden-question" ], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false }, { "affected_party_id": "indirect-non-user-and-bystander-parties", "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [], "burdens": [ "party-burden-question" ], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false } ], "emotion_observation": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "self-report", "attributed-expression", "cultural-vocabulary", "institutional-framing", "behavioral-observation" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-emotion-observation", "boundary_ref": "dimension-emotion-observation", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "affect_context": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "grief-or-loss", "hope-or-efficacy", "love-care-or-solidarity", "belonging-or-identity-security", "fear-or-threat" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-affect-context", "boundary_ref": "dimension-affect-context", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "social_position": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "status", "office", "discursive-power", "network-position", "agenda-control" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-social-position", "boundary_ref": "dimension-social-position", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "power_asymmetry": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "naming-and-interpretive", "canon-and-curriculum", "status-and-hierarchy", "attention-and-distribution", "technical-and-infrastructure" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-power-asymmetry", "boundary_ref": "dimension-power-asymmetry", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "material_conditions": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "labor-and-time", "land-and-geography", "data-and-technology", "infrastructure-and-logistics", "energy-and-resources" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-material-conditions", "boundary_ref": "dimension-material-conditions", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "flow_dynamics": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "delay-or-latency", "leakage-substitution-or-displacement", "coupling-or-decoupling", "branching-or-convergence" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-flow-dynamics", "boundary_ref": "dimension-flow-dynamics", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "topology": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "parallel-path", "bottleneck", "leakage", "substitution" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-topology", "boundary_ref": "dimension-topology", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "negative_flow": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "not-observed", "no-opportunity", "blocked", "unknown" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-negative-flow", "boundary_ref": "dimension-negative-flow", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "negative_flow_profiles": [ { "status_ref": "not-observed", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses", "adverse_inference": false }, { "status_ref": "no-opportunity", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses", "adverse_inference": false }, { "status_ref": "blocked", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses", "adverse_inference": false }, { "status_ref": "unknown", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "unknown", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses", "adverse_inference": false } ], "translation_profile": { "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "translation-rights-and-access-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "source_language": "Declared source language or sign system; unknown until source-bound evidence is added.", "target_language": "Declared target language or sign system; unknown until source-bound evidence is added.", "source_register": "Declared source register and institutional setting; unknown until evidenced.", "target_register": "Declared target register and institutional setting; unknown until evidenced.", "source_genre": "Declared source genre; unknown until evidenced.", "target_genre": "Declared target genre; unknown until evidenced.", "source_version": "Stable source version or witnessed performance reference; none is added by this atlas.", "translator_position_refs": [ "discursive-power" ], "patron_position_refs": [ "agenda-control" ], "audience_party_refs": [ "audiences-and-non-audiences" ], "preserved": [ "translation-preserved-question" ], "changed": [ "translation-changed-question" ], "introduced": [ "translation-introduced-question" ], "omitted": [ "translation-omitted-question" ], "untranslatable": [ "translation-untranslatable-question" ], "counterreadings": [ "translation-counterreadings-question" ], "rights_and_access": [ "translation-rights-and-access-question" ], "fidelity_claimed": false, "representational_authority_granted": false }, "threshold_profile": { "status": "unassessed", "reason_ref": "threshold-inactive-boundary", "boundary_ref": "threshold-inactive-boundary" }, "path_dependence_profile": { "status": "unassessed", "reason_ref": "path-inactive-boundary", "boundary_ref": "path-inactive-boundary" }, "repair_profile": { "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "repair-review-or-retirement-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-run", "proposal_source": "card-repair-routes", "fresh_gate_refs": [ "attribution-and-provenance", "publication-and-access", "affected-party-register", "rights-assessment", "consent-or-lawful-basis", "safety-and-stop-route" ], "attempt": [ "repair-attempt-question" ], "execution_or_outcome_observation": [ "repair-outcome-question" ], "party_indexed_residuals": [ { "affected_party_id": "audiences-and-non-audiences", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "expression-originators", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "translators-curators-and-stewards", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "indirect-non-user-and-bystander-parties", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] } ], "dissent": [ "repair-dissent-question" ], "recurrence": [ "repair-recurrence-question" ], "review_or_retirement": [ "repair-review-or-retirement-question" ], "repair_completed": false, "causal_effect_claimed": false, "erasure_or_absolution_claimed": false, "restored_consent_claimed": false }, "evidence_uncertainty": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "source", "selection-and-missingness", "temporal", "transport", "affected-party-incompleteness", "normative-disagreement", "measurement", "identification-and-model" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-evidence-uncertainty", "boundary_ref": "dimension-evidence-uncertainty", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "alternative_paths": [ "A story may circulate without measurable exposure or response; similar responses may arise from institutions, material conditions, prior commitments, other stories, or unknown causes." ] }, "evidence_profile": { "claim_register": "DESIGN_COMMITMENT", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "causal_status": "formal-mechanism-not-instantiated", "evidence_refs": [], "evidence_ref_status": "no-direct-predecessor-evidence-design-only", "expected_traces": { "source": "card-nuance-observables", "prompt_refs": [] }, "negative_cases": { "source": "card-nuance-alternative-paths", "prompt_refs": [] }, "counterevidence": [ "evidence-counterevidence" ], "falsifiers": [ "evidence-falsifier" ], "transport_bounds": [ "evidence-transport-bound" ], "promotion_requirement": "promotion-requires-source-bound-successor", "external_empirical_support_claimed": false, "mechanism_promoted": false }, "authority_dependency": { "status": "external-gate-required-before-effectful-use", "template_ref": "overlay-authority", "gate_input_ids": [ "attribution-and-provenance", "publication-and-access", "affected-party-register", "rights-assessment", "consent-or-lawful-basis", "safety-and-stop-route" ] }, "causal_influence": { "status": "not-assessed-by-static-atlas", "template_ref": "overlay-causal", "estimand_required_before_promotion": true, "comparator_required_before_promotion": true, "assumptions_required_before_promotion": true, "causal_effect_claimed": false }, "new_claim_created": false, "authority_granted": false, "external_effect_claimed": false }, { "id": "canon-to-selection-feedback", "projection_binding_id": "civilisation-reality-projection", "projection_crosswalk_id": "canon-to-selection-feedback", "stage_ids": [ "shared-story-artifact", "circulation-exposure-response", "institutional-selection-context", "action-proposal", "decision-record", "feedback-challenge-and-counterflow", "repair-review-and-retirement" ], "transition_ids": [ "story-to-circulation", "circulation-to-institutional-context", "institution-to-proposal", "proposal-to-decision" ], "nuance": { "template_ref": "overlay-default", "carriers": [ "Versioned canon, curriculum, archive, ranking, omission, selection-criteria, distribution, attention, decision, and challenge records." ], "transformations": [ "Inspect selection, persistence, visibility, omission, correction, supersession, and withdrawal without converting them into truth, merit, consensus, or legitimacy." ], "gates": [ "Require selector provenance, criteria, alternatives, exclusions, affected communities, distribution context, feedback access, and fresh review." ], "observables": [ "Selection criteria and versions, included and omitted alternatives, selector positions, distribution and attention traces, challenges, corrections, withdrawals, and unresolved disagreement." ], "affected_party_ids": [ "audiences-and-non-audiences", "institutional-participants", "source-communities-and-traditions", "decision-subjects" ], "affected_party_aftermath": [ { "affected_party_id": "audiences-and-non-audiences", "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [ "party-benefit-question" ], "burdens": [], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false }, { "affected_party_id": "institutional-participants", "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [], "burdens": [ "party-burden-question" ], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false }, { "affected_party_id": "source-communities-and-traditions", "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [ "party-benefit-question" ], "burdens": [], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false }, { "affected_party_id": "decision-subjects", "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [], "burdens": [], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false } ], "emotion_observation": { "status": "unassessed", "reason_ref": "dimension-emotion-observation", "boundary_ref": "dimension-emotion-observation" }, "affect_context": { "status": "unassessed", "reason_ref": "dimension-affect-context", "boundary_ref": "dimension-affect-context" }, "social_position": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "network-position", "agenda-control", "discursive-power", "economic-resources-ownership-labor-and-debt", "status" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-social-position", "boundary_ref": "dimension-social-position", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "power_asymmetry": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "attention-and-distribution", "technical-and-infrastructure", "epistemic-and-measurement", "canon-and-curriculum", "agenda-and-procedure" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-power-asymmetry", "boundary_ref": "dimension-power-asymmetry", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "material_conditions": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "labor-and-time", "infrastructure-and-logistics", "data-and-technology", "energy-and-resources", "money-credit-and-property" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-material-conditions", "boundary_ref": "dimension-material-conditions", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "flow_dynamics": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "delay-or-latency", "path-dependence-or-hysteresis", "branching-or-convergence", "leakage-substitution-or-displacement" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-flow-dynamics", "boundary_ref": "dimension-flow-dynamics", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "topology": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "bottleneck", "parallel-path", "substitution", "interruption" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-topology", "boundary_ref": "dimension-topology", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "negative_flow": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "not-observed", "no-opportunity", "blocked", "unknown" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-negative-flow", "boundary_ref": "dimension-negative-flow", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "negative_flow_profiles": [ { "status_ref": "not-observed", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses", "adverse_inference": false }, { "status_ref": "no-opportunity", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses", "adverse_inference": false }, { "status_ref": "blocked", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses", "adverse_inference": false }, { "status_ref": "unknown", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "unknown", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses", "adverse_inference": false } ], "translation_profile": { "status": "unassessed", "reason_ref": "translation-inactive-boundary", "boundary_ref": "translation-inactive-boundary" }, "threshold_profile": { "status": "unassessed", "reason_ref": "threshold-inactive-boundary", "boundary_ref": "threshold-inactive-boundary" }, "path_dependence_profile": { "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "path-evidence-requirement", "claim_status": "design-question-not-established", "reinforcement_mechanism": [ "path-reinforcement-question" ], "switching_cost": [ "path-switching-cost-question" ], "sunk_resource": [ "path-sunk-resource-question" ], "option_loss": [ "path-option-loss-question" ], "alternative_timing": [ "path-alternative-timing-question" ], "reversal_evidence": [ "path-reversal-evidence-question" ], "evidence": [ "path-evidence-requirement" ], "path_dependence_established": false }, "repair_profile": { "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "repair-review-or-retirement-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-run", "proposal_source": "card-repair-routes", "fresh_gate_refs": [ "publication-and-access", "affected-party-register", "rights-assessment", "consent-or-lawful-basis", "safety-and-stop-route", "decision-procedure", "current-authority-and-jurisdiction" ], "attempt": [ "repair-attempt-question" ], "execution_or_outcome_observation": [ "repair-outcome-question" ], "party_indexed_residuals": [ { "affected_party_id": "audiences-and-non-audiences", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "institutional-participants", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "source-communities-and-traditions", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "decision-subjects", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] } ], "dissent": [ "repair-dissent-question" ], "recurrence": [ "repair-recurrence-question" ], "review_or_retirement": [ "repair-review-or-retirement-question" ], "repair_completed": false, "causal_effect_claimed": false, "erasure_or_absolution_claimed": false, "restored_consent_claimed": false }, "evidence_uncertainty": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "measurement", "selection-and-missingness", "temporal", "identification-and-model", "transport", "affected-party-incompleteness", "source", "normative-disagreement", "authority-and-jurisdiction" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-evidence-uncertainty", "boundary_ref": "dimension-evidence-uncertainty", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "alternative_paths": [ "Persistence may follow copying cost, patronage, infrastructure, censorship, curriculum design, community care, accident, or path dependence; attention may fragment or decouple." ] }, "evidence_profile": { "claim_register": "DESIGN_COMMITMENT", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "causal_status": "formal-mechanism-not-instantiated", "evidence_refs": [], "evidence_ref_status": "no-direct-predecessor-evidence-design-only", "expected_traces": { "source": "card-nuance-observables", "prompt_refs": [] }, "negative_cases": { "source": "card-nuance-alternative-paths", "prompt_refs": [] }, "counterevidence": [ "evidence-counterevidence" ], "falsifiers": [ "evidence-falsifier" ], "transport_bounds": [ "evidence-transport-bound" ], "promotion_requirement": "promotion-requires-source-bound-successor", "external_empirical_support_claimed": false, "mechanism_promoted": false }, "authority_dependency": { "status": "external-gate-required-before-effectful-use", "template_ref": "overlay-authority", "gate_input_ids": [ "publication-and-access", "affected-party-register", "rights-assessment", "consent-or-lawful-basis", "safety-and-stop-route", "decision-procedure", "current-authority-and-jurisdiction" ] }, "causal_influence": { "status": "not-assessed-by-static-atlas", "template_ref": "overlay-causal", "estimand_required_before_promotion": true, "comparator_required_before_promotion": true, "assumptions_required_before_promotion": true, "causal_effect_claimed": false }, "new_claim_created": false, "authority_granted": false, "external_effect_claimed": false }, { "id": "legitimation-to-decision-authority-separation", "projection_binding_id": "civilisation-reality-projection", "projection_crosswalk_id": "legitimation-to-decision-authority-separation", "stage_ids": [ "shared-story-artifact", "institutional-selection-context", "action-proposal", "decision-record", "authorization-rights-and-affected-party-gate", "capability-and-resources" ], "transition_ids": [ "institution-to-proposal", "proposal-to-decision", "decision-to-authorization-gate", "authorization-gate-to-capability" ], "nuance": { "template_ref": "overlay-default", "carriers": [ "Attributed legitimation, critique, proposal, decision, authority, jurisdiction, consent or lawful-basis, rights, affected-party, and capability records." ], "transformations": [ "Trace sacred-order legitimation or critique as an attributed claim while proposal, decision, authority, consent or lawful basis, rights, capability, legitimacy, and justice remain distinct." ], "gates": [ "Require a current independent authority, jurisdiction, rights, affected-party, consent or lawful-basis, capability, safety, stop, and repair gate before effectful use." ], "observables": [ "Separate claim, proposal, decision, authority, jurisdiction, rights, consent or lawful-basis, capability, dissent, refusal, revocation, and review records." ], "affected_party_ids": [ "decision-subjects", "directly-affected-parties", "indirect-non-user-and-bystander-parties", "institutional-participants" ], "affected_party_aftermath": [ { "affected_party_id": "decision-subjects", "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [], "burdens": [], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false }, { "affected_party_id": "directly-affected-parties", "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [ "party-benefit-question" ], "burdens": [ "party-burden-question" ], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false }, { "affected_party_id": "indirect-non-user-and-bystander-parties", "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [], "burdens": [ "party-burden-question" ], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false }, { "affected_party_id": "institutional-participants", "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [], "burdens": [ "party-burden-question" ], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false } ], "emotion_observation": { "status": "unassessed", "reason_ref": "dimension-emotion-observation", "boundary_ref": "dimension-emotion-observation" }, "affect_context": { "status": "unassessed", "reason_ref": "dimension-affect-context", "boundary_ref": "dimension-affect-context" }, "social_position": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "status", "office", "network-position", "agenda-control", "coercive-capacity" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-social-position", "boundary_ref": "dimension-social-position", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "power_asymmetry": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "agenda-and-procedure", "legal-jurisdiction-and-coercion", "status-and-hierarchy", "temporal-path-and-exit", "resources-and-class" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-power-asymmetry", "boundary_ref": "dimension-power-asymmetry", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "material_conditions": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "labor-and-time", "money-credit-and-property", "infrastructure-and-logistics", "data-and-technology", "body-and-care" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-material-conditions", "boundary_ref": "dimension-material-conditions", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "flow_dynamics": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "delay-or-latency", "coupling-or-decoupling", "balancing-feedback" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-flow-dynamics", "boundary_ref": "dimension-flow-dynamics", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "topology": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "join", "bottleneck", "interruption", "reversal" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-topology", "boundary_ref": "dimension-topology", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "negative_flow": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "not-observed", "no-opportunity", "blocked", "unknown" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-negative-flow", "boundary_ref": "dimension-negative-flow", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "negative_flow_profiles": [ { "status_ref": "not-observed", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses", "adverse_inference": false }, { "status_ref": "no-opportunity", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses", "adverse_inference": false }, { "status_ref": "blocked", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses", "adverse_inference": false }, { "status_ref": "unknown", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "unknown", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses", "adverse_inference": false } ], "translation_profile": { "status": "unassessed", "reason_ref": "translation-inactive-boundary", "boundary_ref": "translation-inactive-boundary" }, "threshold_profile": { "status": "unassessed", "reason_ref": "threshold-inactive-boundary", "boundary_ref": "threshold-inactive-boundary" }, "path_dependence_profile": { "status": "unassessed", "reason_ref": "path-inactive-boundary", "boundary_ref": "path-inactive-boundary" }, "repair_profile": { "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "repair-review-or-retirement-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-run", "proposal_source": "card-repair-routes", "fresh_gate_refs": [ "decision-procedure", "current-authority-and-jurisdiction", "affected-party-register", "rights-assessment", "consent-or-lawful-basis", "safety-and-stop-route" ], "attempt": [ "repair-attempt-question" ], "execution_or_outcome_observation": [ "repair-outcome-question" ], "party_indexed_residuals": [ { "affected_party_id": "decision-subjects", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "directly-affected-parties", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "indirect-non-user-and-bystander-parties", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "institutional-participants", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] } ], "dissent": [ "repair-dissent-question" ], "recurrence": [ "repair-recurrence-question" ], "review_or_retirement": [ "repair-review-or-retirement-question" ], "repair_completed": false, "causal_effect_claimed": false, "erasure_or_absolution_claimed": false, "restored_consent_claimed": false }, "evidence_uncertainty": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "source", "selection-and-missingness", "temporal", "affected-party-incompleteness", "normative-disagreement", "authority-and-jurisdiction", "measurement" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-evidence-uncertainty", "boundary_ref": "dimension-evidence-uncertainty", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "alternative_paths": [ "The same narrative may authorize, constrain, criticize, or remain irrelevant; a decision may be reversed, refused, blocked, unauthorized, unlawful, incapable, or contested." ] }, "evidence_profile": { "claim_register": "DESIGN_COMMITMENT", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "causal_status": "formal-mechanism-not-instantiated", "evidence_refs": [], "evidence_ref_status": "no-direct-predecessor-evidence-design-only", "expected_traces": { "source": "card-nuance-observables", "prompt_refs": [] }, "negative_cases": { "source": "card-nuance-alternative-paths", "prompt_refs": [] }, "counterevidence": [ "evidence-counterevidence" ], "falsifiers": [ "evidence-falsifier" ], "transport_bounds": [ "evidence-transport-bound" ], "promotion_requirement": "promotion-requires-source-bound-successor", "external_empirical_support_claimed": false, "mechanism_promoted": false }, "authority_dependency": { "status": "external-gate-required-before-effectful-use", "template_ref": "overlay-authority", "gate_input_ids": [ "decision-procedure", "current-authority-and-jurisdiction", "affected-party-register", "rights-assessment", "consent-or-lawful-basis", "safety-and-stop-route" ] }, "causal_influence": { "status": "not-assessed-by-static-atlas", "template_ref": "overlay-causal", "estimand_required_before_promotion": true, "comparator_required_before_promotion": true, "assumptions_required_before_promotion": true, "causal_effect_claimed": false }, "new_claim_created": false, "authority_granted": false, "external_effect_claimed": false }, { "id": "translation-to-claim-assessment", "projection_binding_id": "civilisation-reality-projection", "projection_crosswalk_id": "translation-to-claim-assessment", "stage_ids": [ "word-or-expression", "shared-story-artifact", "action-proposal", "aftermath-causal-and-normative-assessment", "feedback-challenge-and-counterflow" ], "transition_ids": [ "expression-to-shared-story", "assessment-to-feedback" ], "nuance": { "template_ref": "overlay-default", "carriers": [ "Versioned source and target artifacts, witnessed performances, translator and patron position records, declared frameworks, seams, counterreadings, rights, and access conditions." ], "transformations": [ "Inspect preservation, change, introduction, omission, untranslatability, and counterreading without granting fidelity, shared meaning, representational authority, or doctrinal identity." ], "gates": [ "Require stable source versions, declared language, register and genre, translator and patron position, affected audiences, rights, access, counterreadings, and correction routes." ], "observables": [ "Parallel versions, retained original wording, translation notes, contested referents, changed or omitted terms, counterreadings, refusals, access limits, and framework-specific assessments." ], "affected_party_ids": [ "expression-originators", "translators-curators-and-stewards", "source-communities-and-traditions", "audiences-and-non-audiences" ], "affected_party_aftermath": [ { "affected_party_id": "expression-originators", "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [ "party-benefit-question" ], "burdens": [], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false }, { "affected_party_id": "translators-curators-and-stewards", "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [], "burdens": [ "party-burden-question" ], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false }, { "affected_party_id": "source-communities-and-traditions", "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [ "party-benefit-question" ], "burdens": [], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false }, { "affected_party_id": "audiences-and-non-audiences", "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [ "party-benefit-question" ], "burdens": [], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false } ], "emotion_observation": { "status": "unassessed", "reason_ref": "dimension-emotion-observation", "boundary_ref": "dimension-emotion-observation" }, "affect_context": { "status": "unassessed", "reason_ref": "dimension-affect-context", "boundary_ref": "dimension-affect-context" }, "social_position": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "status", "discursive-power", "office" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-social-position", "boundary_ref": "dimension-social-position", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "power_asymmetry": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "naming-and-interpretive", "epistemic-and-measurement", "canon-and-curriculum", "status-and-hierarchy" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-power-asymmetry", "boundary_ref": "dimension-power-asymmetry", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "material_conditions": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "body-and-care", "labor-and-time", "data-and-technology", "land-and-geography" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-material-conditions", "boundary_ref": "dimension-material-conditions", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "flow_dynamics": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "delay-or-latency", "accumulation-or-memory", "branching-or-convergence", "path-dependence-or-hysteresis" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-flow-dynamics", "boundary_ref": "dimension-flow-dynamics", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "topology": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "fork", "join", "recurrence" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-topology", "boundary_ref": "dimension-topology", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "negative_flow": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "not-observed", "no-opportunity", "blocked", "unknown" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-negative-flow", "boundary_ref": "dimension-negative-flow", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "negative_flow_profiles": [ { "status_ref": "not-observed", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses", "adverse_inference": false }, { "status_ref": "no-opportunity", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses", "adverse_inference": false }, { "status_ref": "blocked", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses", "adverse_inference": false }, { "status_ref": "unknown", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "unknown", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses", "adverse_inference": false } ], "translation_profile": { "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "translation-rights-and-access-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "source_language": "Declared source language or sign system; unknown until source-bound evidence is added.", "target_language": "Declared target language or sign system; unknown until source-bound evidence is added.", "source_register": "Declared source register and institutional setting; unknown until evidenced.", "target_register": "Declared target register and institutional setting; unknown until evidenced.", "source_genre": "Declared source genre; unknown until evidenced.", "target_genre": "Declared target genre; unknown until evidenced.", "source_version": "Stable source version or witnessed performance reference; none is added by this atlas.", "translator_position_refs": [ "discursive-power" ], "patron_position_refs": [ "agenda-control" ], "audience_party_refs": [ "audiences-and-non-audiences" ], "preserved": [ "translation-preserved-question" ], "changed": [ "translation-changed-question" ], "introduced": [ "translation-introduced-question" ], "omitted": [ "translation-omitted-question" ], "untranslatable": [ "translation-untranslatable-question" ], "counterreadings": [ "translation-counterreadings-question" ], "rights_and_access": [ "translation-rights-and-access-question" ], "fidelity_claimed": false, "representational_authority_granted": false }, "threshold_profile": { "status": "unassessed", "reason_ref": "threshold-inactive-boundary", "boundary_ref": "threshold-inactive-boundary" }, "path_dependence_profile": { "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "path-evidence-requirement", "claim_status": "design-question-not-established", "reinforcement_mechanism": [ "path-reinforcement-question" ], "switching_cost": [ "path-switching-cost-question" ], "sunk_resource": [ "path-sunk-resource-question" ], "option_loss": [ "path-option-loss-question" ], "alternative_timing": [ "path-alternative-timing-question" ], "reversal_evidence": [ "path-reversal-evidence-question" ], "evidence": [ "path-evidence-requirement" ], "path_dependence_established": false }, "repair_profile": { "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "repair-review-or-retirement-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-run", "proposal_source": "card-repair-routes", "fresh_gate_refs": [ "attribution-and-provenance", "publication-and-access", "affected-party-register" ], "attempt": [ "repair-attempt-question" ], "execution_or_outcome_observation": [ "repair-outcome-question" ], "party_indexed_residuals": [ { "affected_party_id": "expression-originators", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "translators-curators-and-stewards", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "source-communities-and-traditions", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "audiences-and-non-audiences", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] } ], "dissent": [ "repair-dissent-question" ], "recurrence": [ "repair-recurrence-question" ], "review_or_retirement": [ "repair-review-or-retirement-question" ], "repair_completed": false, "causal_effect_claimed": false, "erasure_or_absolution_claimed": false, "restored_consent_claimed": false }, "evidence_uncertainty": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "source", "measurement", "selection-and-missingness", "temporal", "affected-party-incompleteness", "transport", "normative-disagreement" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-evidence-uncertainty", "boundary_ref": "dimension-evidence-uncertainty", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "alternative_paths": [ "A term may require parallel translations, retained original wording, refusal to translate, or an unresolved seam; communities may contest source, genre, referent, authority, or framework." ] }, "evidence_profile": { "claim_register": "DESIGN_COMMITMENT", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "causal_status": "formal-mechanism-not-instantiated", "evidence_refs": [], "evidence_ref_status": "no-direct-predecessor-evidence-design-only", "expected_traces": { "source": "card-nuance-observables", "prompt_refs": [] }, "negative_cases": { "source": "card-nuance-alternative-paths", "prompt_refs": [] }, "counterevidence": [ "evidence-counterevidence" ], "falsifiers": [ "evidence-falsifier" ], "transport_bounds": [ "evidence-transport-bound" ], "promotion_requirement": "promotion-requires-source-bound-successor", "external_empirical_support_claimed": false, "mechanism_promoted": false }, "authority_dependency": { "status": "external-gate-required-before-effectful-use", "template_ref": "overlay-authority", "gate_input_ids": [ "attribution-and-provenance", "publication-and-access", "affected-party-register" ] }, "causal_influence": { "status": "not-assessed-by-static-atlas", "template_ref": "overlay-causal", "estimand_required_before_promotion": true, "comparator_required_before_promotion": true, "assumptions_required_before_promotion": true, "causal_effect_claimed": false }, "new_claim_created": false, "authority_granted": false, "external_effect_claimed": false }, { "id": "counterstory-to-challenge-repair", "projection_binding_id": "civilisation-reality-projection", "projection_crosswalk_id": "counterstory-to-challenge-repair", "stage_ids": [ "shared-story-artifact", "circulation-exposure-response", "institutional-selection-context", "action-proposal", "outcome-observation", "aftermath-causal-and-normative-assessment", "feedback-challenge-and-counterflow", "repair-review-and-retirement" ], "transition_ids": [ "story-to-circulation", "circulation-to-institutional-context", "outcome-to-aftermath-assessment", "assessment-to-feedback", "feedback-to-repair-review" ], "nuance": { "template_ref": "overlay-default", "carriers": [ "Attributed suppressed record, counterstory, preservation and access history, challenge, correction, supersession, withdrawal, repair proposal, attempt, outcome, dissent, and residual records." ], "transformations": [ "Keep challenge, correction, supersession, withdrawal, repair proposal, attempt, outcome observation, residuals, recurrence, and renewed review as separate non-automatic records." ], "gates": [ "Require provenance, safe access, affected-party voice and refusal, authority, rights, capability, witnessed repair attempt and outcome, residual review, recurrence checks, and a fresh gate." ], "observables": [ "Suppressed and counterstory versions, access and preservation traces, institutional responses, unanswered challenges, corrections, repair attempts, outcomes, residuals, recurrence, dissent, and retirement decisions." ], "affected_party_ids": [ "directly-affected-parties", "indirect-non-user-and-bystander-parties", "operators-and-labor", "institutional-participants", "future-parties", "ecological-systems" ], "affected_party_aftermath": [ { "affected_party_id": "directly-affected-parties", "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [ "party-benefit-question" ], "burdens": [ "party-burden-question" ], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false }, { "affected_party_id": "indirect-non-user-and-bystander-parties", "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [], "burdens": [ "party-burden-question" ], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false }, { "affected_party_id": "operators-and-labor", "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [], "burdens": [ "party-burden-question" ], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false }, { "affected_party_id": "institutional-participants", "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [], "burdens": [ "party-burden-question" ], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false }, { "affected_party_id": "future-parties", "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [], "burdens": [], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [ "party-option-voice-exit-question" ], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false }, { "affected_party_id": "ecological-systems", "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "party-selected-question-reason", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "benefits": [], "burdens": [ "party-burden-question" ], "risks": [ "party-risk-question" ], "option_voice_and_exit_effects": [], "horizon": [ "party-horizon-question" ], "evidence": [], "unknowns": [ "party-aftermath-evidence-unknown" ], "residuals": [ "party-residual-question" ], "aggregate_score": null, "netted": false } ], "emotion_observation": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "self-report", "attributed-expression", "behavioral-observation", "cultural-vocabulary" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-emotion-observation", "boundary_ref": "dimension-emotion-observation", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "affect_context": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "fear-or-threat", "anger-or-outrage", "humiliation-or-status-injury", "grief-or-loss", "hope-or-efficacy" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-affect-context", "boundary_ref": "dimension-affect-context", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "social_position": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "economic-resources-ownership-labor-and-debt", "status", "office", "network-position", "agenda-control" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-social-position", "boundary_ref": "dimension-social-position", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "power_asymmetry": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "naming-and-interpretive", "attention-and-distribution", "agenda-and-procedure", "legal-jurisdiction-and-coercion", "resources-and-class" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-power-asymmetry", "boundary_ref": "dimension-power-asymmetry", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "material_conditions": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "body-and-care", "labor-and-time", "land-and-geography", "energy-and-resources", "climate-and-ecology" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-material-conditions", "boundary_ref": "dimension-material-conditions", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "flow_dynamics": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "delay-or-latency", "path-dependence-or-hysteresis", "reinforcing-feedback", "balancing-feedback", "leakage-substitution-or-displacement" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-flow-dynamics", "boundary_ref": "dimension-flow-dynamics", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "topology": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "fork", "join", "parallel-path", "interruption", "reversal", "recurrence", "reinforcing-loop", "balancing-loop" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-topology", "boundary_ref": "dimension-topology", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "negative_flow": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "not-observed", "no-opportunity", "blocked", "unknown" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-negative-flow", "boundary_ref": "dimension-negative-flow", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "negative_flow_profiles": [ { "status_ref": "not-observed", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses", "adverse_inference": false }, { "status_ref": "no-opportunity", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses", "adverse_inference": false }, { "status_ref": "blocked", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses", "adverse_inference": false }, { "status_ref": "unknown", "applicability_status": "applicable-question", "claim_status": "unknown", "expected_trace": "negative-expected-trace", "opportunity_or_at_risk_set": "negative-opportunity-set", "horizon": "negative-observation-horizon", "method": "negative-observation-method", "coverage_and_sensitivity": "negative-coverage-and-sensitivity", "access_limits": "negative-access-limits", "evidence": [], "alternatives": [ "negative-rival-statuses" ], "reason_ref": "negative-rival-statuses", "adverse_inference": false } ], "translation_profile": { "status": "unassessed", "reason_ref": "translation-inactive-boundary", "boundary_ref": "translation-inactive-boundary" }, "threshold_profile": { "status": "unassessed", "reason_ref": "threshold-inactive-boundary", "boundary_ref": "threshold-inactive-boundary" }, "path_dependence_profile": { "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "path-evidence-requirement", "claim_status": "design-question-not-established", "reinforcement_mechanism": [ "path-reinforcement-question" ], "switching_cost": [ "path-switching-cost-question" ], "sunk_resource": [ "path-sunk-resource-question" ], "option_loss": [ "path-option-loss-question" ], "alternative_timing": [ "path-alternative-timing-question" ], "reversal_evidence": [ "path-reversal-evidence-question" ], "evidence": [ "path-evidence-requirement" ], "path_dependence_established": false }, "repair_profile": { "status": "applicable-question", "reason_ref": "repair-review-or-retirement-question", "claim_status": "design-question-not-run", "proposal_source": "card-repair-routes", "fresh_gate_refs": [ "publication-and-access", "current-authority-and-jurisdiction", "affected-party-register", "rights-assessment", "consent-or-lawful-basis", "safety-and-stop-route", "repair-readiness", "reviewed-proposal", "decision-procedure", "capability-and-resources", "budget-and-horizon" ], "attempt": [ "repair-attempt-question" ], "execution_or_outcome_observation": [ "repair-outcome-question" ], "party_indexed_residuals": [ { "affected_party_id": "directly-affected-parties", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "indirect-non-user-and-bystander-parties", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "operators-and-labor", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "institutional-participants", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "future-parties", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] }, { "affected_party_id": "ecological-systems", "residual_source": "card-repair-residuals", "evidence_or_unknowns": [ "repair-residual-evidence-unknown" ] } ], "dissent": [ "repair-dissent-question" ], "recurrence": [ "repair-recurrence-question" ], "review_or_retirement": [ "repair-review-or-retirement-question" ], "repair_completed": false, "causal_effect_claimed": false, "erasure_or_absolution_claimed": false, "restored_consent_claimed": false }, "evidence_uncertainty": { "status": "applicable-question", "refs": [ "source", "measurement", "selection-and-missingness", "temporal", "identification-and-model", "transport", "affected-party-incompleteness", "normative-disagreement", "authority-and-jurisdiction" ], "reason_ref": "dimension-evidence-uncertainty", "boundary_ref": "dimension-evidence-uncertainty", "evidence_requirements": [ "dimension-evidence-boundary" ] }, "alternative_paths": [ "A challenge may remain unanswered, coexist with the challenged record, yield correction without material repair, or reveal disagreement that cannot be synthesized; revival need not restore an earlier world." ] }, "evidence_profile": { "claim_register": "DESIGN_COMMITMENT", "claim_status": "design-question-not-observed", "causal_status": "formal-mechanism-not-instantiated", "evidence_refs": [], "evidence_ref_status": "no-direct-predecessor-evidence-design-only", "expected_traces": { "source": "card-nuance-observables", "prompt_refs": [] }, "negative_cases": { "source": "card-nuance-alternative-paths", "prompt_refs": [] }, "counterevidence": [ "evidence-counterevidence" ], "falsifiers": [ "evidence-falsifier" ], "transport_bounds": [ "evidence-transport-bound" ], "promotion_requirement": "promotion-requires-source-bound-successor", "external_empirical_support_claimed": false, "mechanism_promoted": false }, "authority_dependency": { "status": "external-gate-required-before-effectful-use", "template_ref": "overlay-authority", "gate_input_ids": [ "publication-and-access", "current-authority-and-jurisdiction", "affected-party-register", "rights-assessment", "consent-or-lawful-basis", "safety-and-stop-route", "repair-readiness", "reviewed-proposal", "decision-procedure", "capability-and-resources", "budget-and-horizon" ] }, "causal_influence": { "status": "not-assessed-by-static-atlas", "template_ref": "overlay-causal", "estimand_required_before_promotion": true, "comparator_required_before_promotion": true, "assumptions_required_before_promotion": true, "causal_effect_claimed": false }, "new_claim_created": false, "authority_granted": false, "external_effect_claimed": false } ], "open_domain_bindings": [ { "id": "war-and-organised-violence", "projection_binding_id": "civilisation-reality-projection", "projection_open_domain_id": "war-and-organised-violence", "flow_touchpoint_ids": [ "institutional-selection-context", "decision-record", "authorization-rights-and-affected-party-gate", "capability-and-resources", "attempt", "execution-or-action", "outcome-observation", "aftermath-causal-and-normative-assessment", "feedback-challenge-and-counterflow", "repair-review-and-retirement", "decision-to-authorization-gate", "authorization-gate-to-capability", "capability-to-attempt", "attempt-to-execution", "execution-to-outcome" ], "status": "remains-open-no-mechanism-added", "needed_evidence": [ "Conflict-specific primary records and comparative historical research.", "Separate evidence for coercion, institutions, resources, affected parties, and aftermath." ], "nonclaim": "This atlas places war and organised violence questions near relevant flow touchpoints but adds no empirical mechanism, estimate, prediction, strategy, authority, or effect claim.", "stop_condition": "Do not infer a war mechanism, prediction, strategy, legitimacy, or authorization from story/religion relations or generic reality-domain labels." }, { "id": "coercion-and-security-capacity", "projection_binding_id": "civilisation-reality-projection", "projection_open_domain_id": "coercion-and-security-capacity", "flow_touchpoint_ids": [ "decision-record", "authorization-rights-and-affected-party-gate", "capability-and-resources", "attempt", "execution-or-action", "outcome-observation", "aftermath-causal-and-normative-assessment", "feedback-challenge-and-counterflow", "decision-to-authorization-gate", "authorization-gate-to-capability", "capability-to-attempt", "attempt-to-execution", "execution-to-outcome" ], "status": "remains-open-no-mechanism-added", "needed_evidence": [ "Institution-specific legal, administrative, fiscal, and operational records.", "Affected-party testimony and independent rights and aftermath assessment." ], "nonclaim": "This atlas places coercion and security capacity questions near relevant flow touchpoints but adds no empirical mechanism, estimate, prediction, strategy, authority, or effect claim.", "stop_condition": "Do not translate a legitimacy claim, institution label, or capability record into permission to coerce or evidence that coercion was lawful, necessary, proportionate, or effective." }, { "id": "class-and-resource-asymmetry", "projection_binding_id": "civilisation-reality-projection", "projection_open_domain_id": "class-and-resource-asymmetry", "flow_touchpoint_ids": [ "institutional-selection-context", "action-proposal", "decision-record", "capability-and-resources", "outcome-observation", "aftermath-causal-and-normative-assessment", "feedback-challenge-and-counterflow", "institution-to-proposal", "proposal-to-decision", "authorization-gate-to-capability", "execution-to-outcome", "outcome-to-aftermath-assessment" ], "status": "remains-open-no-mechanism-added", "needed_evidence": [ "Distributional, ownership, labour, fiscal, and material-flow evidence.", "Competing class concepts and explicit units of comparison." ], "nonclaim": "This atlas places class and resource asymmetry questions near relevant flow touchpoints but adds no empirical mechanism, estimate, prediction, strategy, authority, or effect claim.", "stop_condition": "Do not infer class position, interests, exploitation, benefit, burden, or resource incidence from cultural, religious, attention, or institutional labels alone." }, { "id": "status-hierarchy-and-elite-fracture", "projection_binding_id": "civilisation-reality-projection", "projection_open_domain_id": "status-hierarchy-and-elite-fracture", "flow_touchpoint_ids": [ "shared-story-artifact", "circulation-exposure-response", "institutional-selection-context", "action-proposal", "decision-record", "feedback-challenge-and-counterflow", "story-to-circulation", "circulation-to-institutional-context", "institution-to-proposal", "proposal-to-decision" ], "status": "remains-open-no-mechanism-added", "needed_evidence": [ "Context-specific status categories and institutional records.", "Evidence distinguishing hierarchy, prestige, class, office, faction, and coercive position." ], "nonclaim": "This atlas places status hierarchy and elite fracture questions near relevant flow touchpoints but adds no empirical mechanism, estimate, prediction, strategy, authority, or effect claim.", "stop_condition": "Do not rank people or groups, impute elite membership or motive, or infer coalition fracture from specialist roles, public claims, or status language." }, { "id": "collective-emotion-and-affect", "projection_binding_id": "civilisation-reality-projection", "projection_open_domain_id": "collective-emotion-and-affect", "flow_touchpoint_ids": [ "word-or-expression", "shared-story-artifact", "circulation-exposure-response", "aftermath-causal-and-normative-assessment", "feedback-challenge-and-counterflow", "expression-to-shared-story", "story-to-circulation", "outcome-to-aftermath-assessment", "assessment-to-feedback" ], "status": "remains-open-no-mechanism-added", "needed_evidence": [ "Ethically collected, context-specific affect evidence with privacy and inference limits.", "Separate treatment of expression, self-report, behaviour, physiology, institution, and cultural vocabulary." ], "nonclaim": "This atlas places collective emotion and affect questions near relevant flow touchpoints but adds no empirical mechanism, estimate, prediction, strategy, authority, or effect claim.", "stop_condition": "Do not infer an individual or collective emotion, diagnosis, intent, consent, hostility, or susceptibility from expressions, stories, exposure, response, silence, refusal, identity, or group membership." }, { "id": "revolution-and-regime-change", "projection_binding_id": "civilisation-reality-projection", "projection_open_domain_id": "revolution-and-regime-change", "flow_touchpoint_ids": [ "shared-story-artifact", "circulation-exposure-response", "institutional-selection-context", "action-proposal", "decision-record", "authorization-rights-and-affected-party-gate", "capability-and-resources", "execution-or-action", "outcome-observation", "aftermath-causal-and-normative-assessment", "feedback-challenge-and-counterflow", "repair-review-and-retirement", "circulation-to-institutional-context", "proposal-to-decision", "decision-to-authorization-gate", "attempt-to-execution", "execution-to-outcome", "assessment-to-feedback" ], "status": "remains-open-no-mechanism-added", "needed_evidence": [ "Comparative revolution and regime-transition research with negative cases.", "Event sequences separating structural conditions, organisation, framing, coercion, contingency, and aftermath." ], "nonclaim": "This atlas places revolution and regime change questions near relevant flow touchpoints but adds no empirical mechanism, estimate, prediction, strategy, authority, or effect claim.", "stop_condition": "Do not predict, incite, suppress, optimize, or authorize regime change from dissent, counterstory, legitimation, or public-response records." }, { "id": "fiscal-and-economic-shocks", "projection_binding_id": "civilisation-reality-projection", "projection_open_domain_id": "fiscal-and-economic-shocks", "flow_touchpoint_ids": [ "institutional-selection-context", "action-proposal", "decision-record", "capability-and-resources", "outcome-observation", "aftermath-causal-and-normative-assessment", "feedback-challenge-and-counterflow", "institution-to-proposal", "proposal-to-decision", "authorization-gate-to-capability", "execution-to-outcome", "outcome-to-aftermath-assessment" ], "status": "remains-open-no-mechanism-added", "needed_evidence": [ "Time-bounded fiscal, economic, ecological, institutional, and distributional records.", "Competing causal explanations, counterfactual assumptions, and lag structure." ], "nonclaim": "This atlas places fiscal and economic shocks questions near relevant flow touchpoints but adds no empirical mechanism, estimate, prediction, strategy, authority, or effect claim.", "stop_condition": "Do not infer shock, scarcity, fiscal capacity, distributional burden, social response, conflict, or policy effect from an indexed domain or temporal sequence." }, { "id": "propaganda-media-and-information-power", "projection_binding_id": "civilisation-reality-projection", "projection_open_domain_id": "propaganda-media-and-information-power", "flow_touchpoint_ids": [ "word-or-expression", "shared-story-artifact", "circulation-exposure-response", "institutional-selection-context", "outcome-observation", "aftermath-causal-and-normative-assessment", "feedback-challenge-and-counterflow", "expression-to-shared-story", "story-to-circulation", "circulation-to-institutional-context", "execution-to-outcome", "assessment-to-feedback" ], "status": "remains-open-no-mechanism-added", "needed_evidence": [ "Platform, ownership, distribution, content, exposure, audience, experimental or quasi-experimental, and institutional evidence kept separately typed.", "Rights, privacy, provenance, counterevidence, affected-party, and anti-targeting safeguards." ], "nonclaim": "This atlas places propaganda media and information power questions near relevant flow touchpoints but adds no empirical mechanism, estimate, prediction, strategy, authority, or effect claim.", "stop_condition": "Do not infer belief, persuasion, deception, susceptibility, intent, or behavioural effect, and do not create targeting, censorship, propaganda, counter-propaganda, or amplification instructions." }, { "id": "citizen-governance-dynamics", "projection_binding_id": "civilisation-reality-projection", "projection_open_domain_id": "citizen-governance-dynamics", "flow_touchpoint_ids": [ "action-proposal", "decision-record", "authorization-rights-and-affected-party-gate", "capability-and-resources", "execution-or-action", "outcome-observation", "aftermath-causal-and-normative-assessment", "feedback-challenge-and-counterflow", "repair-review-and-retirement", "proposal-to-decision", "decision-to-authorization-gate", "authorization-gate-to-capability", "attempt-to-execution", "execution-to-outcome", "outcome-to-aftermath-assessment", "assessment-to-feedback", "feedback-to-repair-review" ], "status": "remains-open-no-mechanism-added", "needed_evidence": [ "Jurisdiction-specific constitutional, legal, administrative, participatory, service, and affected-party evidence.", "Explicit legitimacy concepts, institutional alternatives, dissent channels, correction rights, and non-jurisdiction boundaries." ], "nonclaim": "This atlas places citizen governance dynamics questions near relevant flow touchpoints but adds no empirical mechanism, estimate, prediction, strategy, authority, or effect claim.", "stop_condition": "Do not treat participation as consent, decision as authority, performance as legitimacy, visibility as representation, governance vocabulary as jurisdiction, or KINGDOM as a sovereign government." } ], "unknowns": [ { "id": "observation-coverage-and-detection", "question": "What opportunity, trace, horizon, method, coverage, sensitivity, and access would make a missing transition interpretable?", "why_unknown": "The pinned predecessors provide no live observation frame or coverage estimate for this atlas.", "needed_evidence": [ "A declared opportunity or at-risk set, expected trace, horizon, method, coverage and sensitivity, access limits, and rival missing-flow statuses.", "Independent evidence for censoring, destruction, refusal, exclusion, or measurement failure where any is asserted." ], "stop_condition": "Treat absence as unknown unless adequate observation coverage is established; never infer zero, nonexistence, disbelief, consent, or adverse motive." }, { "id": "carrier-and-version-provenance", "question": "Which versioned carriers and transformations connect a source stage to a target stage?", "why_unknown": "The atlas defines audit questions but adds no case-specific carrier, version, custody, translation, or transformation record.", "needed_evidence": [ "Stable source and target references, version and custody history, transformation records, access conditions, and counterversions." ], "stop_condition": "Stop before treating similarity, sequence, reuse, or shared vocabulary as provenance, fidelity, derivation, or causal transmission." }, { "id": "temporal-order-latency-and-censoring", "question": "What are the separate onset, duration, latency, overlap, decay, recurrence, censoring, and resolution times?", "why_unknown": "The canonical profiles are qualitative lenses and contain no case-specific timestamps or observation horizons.", "needed_evidence": [ "Source, opportunity, gate, transition, target, observation, feedback, and record times with uncertainty and censoring documented separately." ], "stop_condition": "Do not infer an event order, transition, delay distribution, recurrence pattern, or prediction from analytical stage order." }, { "id": "affected-party-completeness-and-distribution", "question": "Which parties are affected, missing, refusing, excluded, or differently exposed to benefits, burdens, risks, voice, options, exit, and residuals?", "why_unknown": "Registry categories are design prompts, not a complete case-specific affected-party register or distributional dataset.", "needed_evidence": [ "An updateable affected-party register, safe participation and refusal routes, party-indexed horizons, evidence and unknowns, and distributional alternatives." ], "stop_condition": "Do not aggregate, net, score, rank, or erase dissent; an unlisted party is not evidence of no effect." }, { "id": "authority-rights-and-jurisdiction", "question": "Which current authority, jurisdiction, consent or lawful basis, rights assessment, and revocation route apply?", "why_unknown": "Static predecessor claim types and this atlas confer no authority, jurisdiction, lawful basis, consent, or permission.", "needed_evidence": [ "Current independent records for authority, jurisdiction, rights, consent or lawful basis, affected parties, capability, safety, stop, appeal, and revocation." ], "stop_condition": "No proposal, decision, story, institution, capability, or atlas entry may substitute for a current independent action gate." }, { "id": "material-capability-and-constraint", "question": "Which body and care, labour and time, land, energy, ecological, financial, infrastructure, and data conditions enable, constrain, redirect, or displace a flow?", "why_unknown": "The material vocabulary is a non-deterministic audit lens and the atlas contains no case-specific resource or capability evidence.", "needed_evidence": [ "Bounded physical, labour, financial, ecological, infrastructure, logistics, and technical records with units, scopes, ownership, constraints, and alternatives." ], "stop_condition": "Do not infer capability, permission, necessity, effect, class position, or deterministic cause from a material-condition label." }, { "id": "affect-and-private-state", "question": "What affect context is self-reported or otherwise observed, and what remains private or unassessed?", "why_unknown": "Affect labels and observation types are design vocabularies; expression, behaviour, silence, participation, identity, and institutional framing do not reveal private state.", "needed_evidence": [ "Ethically collected self-report or clearly typed observation with cultural context, privacy protection, affected-party limits, counterreadings, and uncertainty." ], "stop_condition": "Do not infer belief, identity, intent, emotion, diagnosis, motive, hostility, consent, susceptibility, or worth." }, { "id": "power-position-and-boundary-displacement", "question": "Which economic, status, office, network, agenda, coercive, discursive, epistemic, platform, or exit asymmetries matter inside and beyond the chosen boundary?", "why_unknown": "The vocabularies name audit axes but add no person or group positions, motive, mechanism, or evidence of displaced effects.", "needed_evidence": [ "Context-specific roles, resources, ownership, offices, networks, agenda rights, coercive capacities, discursive access, exit conditions, and effects outside the declared boundary." ], "stop_condition": "Do not infer motive, worth, legitimacy, authority, susceptibility, effect, or a complete system boundary from a position or power label." }, { "id": "causal-identification-and-transport", "question": "What estimand, comparator, assumptions, negative cases, counterevidence, falsifiers, and transport bounds would support a causal claim?", "why_unknown": "The atlas adds formal design questions only; external empirical sources were not added and no mechanism is instantiated or identified.", "needed_evidence": [ "A source-bound successor with a declared estimand, comparator, identification strategy, assumptions, measurement model, negative cases, counterevidence, falsifiers, uncertainty vector, and transport limits." ], "stop_condition": "Do not promote sequence, association, taxonomy, topology, threshold, hysteresis, feedback, power, affect, or material vocabulary into a causal finding or prediction." }, { "id": "repair-residuals-recurrence-and-fresh-gate", "question": "What repair was proposed, freshly authorized, attempted, executed, observed, contested, left residual, repeated, reviewed, or retired?", "why_unknown": "Repair entries are static design questions; no proposal is run and no completion, effect, restored consent, absolution, or erasure is established.", "needed_evidence": [ "Separate proposal, fresh action gate, attempt, execution, outcome observation, party-indexed residual, dissent, recurrence, review, and retirement records." ], "stop_condition": "Do not call repair complete, effective, consent-restoring, absolving, history-erasing, or justice-completing; any further intervention requires a fresh gate." } ], "boundaries": { "read_only": true, "structure_only": true, "static_atlas": true, "public_static_publication_family": true, "network": false, "filesystem_write": false, "source_dereference": false, "live_intake": false, "person_profiles": false, "group_susceptibility_estimates": false, "score_or_rank": false, "causal_effect_identified": false, "deterministic_prediction": false, "effect_size_estimated": false, "targeting": false, "persuasion_optimization": false, "propaganda_or_counterpropaganda_instructions": false, "coercive_or_revolutionary_strategy": false, "metaphysical_verdict": false, "belief_identity_intent_emotion_or_motive_inferred": false, "authority_granted": false, "consent_or_lawful_basis_established": false, "capability_granted": false, "action_proposed": false, "action_attempted": false, "action_executed": false, "external_effect_claimed": false, "writes_wake": false, "writes_karma": false, "publication_trigger": false, "deployment_trigger": false, "automatic_action": false, "predecessor_mutation": false, "predecessor_republication": false, "unsupported_domains_filled": false, "feedback_opens_review_only": true, "repair_requires_fresh_gate": true, "repair_preserves_history_residuals_and_recurrence": true, "absence_requires_adequate_coverage": true, "non_action_has_no_adverse_inference": true }, "integrity": { "algorithm": "sha256-recursive-sorted-json-keys-v1", "digest": "sha256:3d304d7c20787bc3f8b3587b9efca64f61fc4578000570b38acec84d49b84a50", "digest_field_zeroed": true } }