{ "$schema": "https://thekingdom.dev/schemas/aesthetic-plurality-making-atlas/0.1.json", "artifact": { "asOf": "2026-08-29", "authorship": { "assistanceDisclosure": "Human-directed request; model-assisted research synthesis, original synthetic fixture authorship, implementation, and prefreeze verification. Independent review and release authorization remain separate recorded events.", "humanDirected": true, "modelAssisted": true }, "id": "kingdom-aesthetic-plurality-making-atlas-phase-0-2026-08-29", "kind": "STATIC_SYNTHETIC_RELATION_ATLAS", "lifecycle": { "externalPublicationPerformed": false, "frozen": true, "humanReviewCompleted": false, "independentReviewGreen": true, "phase": "FROZEN_STATIC_FIXTURE", "publicationAuthorized": true, "releaseGateSatisfied": true, "reviewState": "INDEPENDENT_REVIEW_GREEN_EXACT_BYTE_HANDOFF" }, "title": "KINGDOM Aesthetic Plurality & Making Relations Atlas — Phase 0" }, "buildReceipt": { "arithmetic": "EXACT_BOUNDED_SAFE_INTEGER_RATIONAL_FINITE_SET_AND_FINITE_GRAPH", "clockRead": false, "externalInputUsed": false, "generatorInputReceipts": [ { "byteSha256": "sha256:5a9de5fa37ebe5d64577a14017f2a089423b750675f95b2dc621ff400768fe6e", "bytes": 779, "path": "PUBLICATION-AUTHORIZATION.md" }, { "byteSha256": "sha256:b2603d78cf599391ab9504402c9ca5ba6e638eb67694bc09edf6ba0ed67023c3", "bytes": 4947, "path": "DESIGN-CONTRACT.md" }, { "byteSha256": "sha256:b9f811a6466b66bf282d59ff9535ad6f965b26a0c91ef3224b3e7843e94100ed", "bytes": 4859, "path": "SOURCE-INVENTORY.md" }, { "byteSha256": "sha256:aeb6d2e8ce1d692b03ff36be34050fcf59aa03d03671b5ec08e5ef800d6a6b38", "bytes": 3077, "path": "data/config.json" }, { "byteSha256": "sha256:b99e9b7d806c3a36f263eaccfa7271b053fb987240001d7fe6315fc2d487b9c0", "bytes": 27788, "path": "data/content.json" }, { "byteSha256": "sha256:2977b27db4169d5670c7f4a9aaa1c170e67b7663c025d793d4958e2f8b4750e5", "bytes": 20703, "path": "data/fixtures.json" }, { "byteSha256": "sha256:8f09e20817432b4f3b3d5725fa069c9aa3a24e99b56e01dfead3a7397e48cf10", "bytes": 14497, "path": "guide/public-guide.md" }, { "byteSha256": "sha256:97cb3483f5b4b533d9f4603ca1e47ca31d784c8077070a27a3a04347e86b55b1", "bytes": 30899, "path": "src/atlas.mjs" }, { "byteSha256": "sha256:2a61912bc885d03d0512520ac2bb060be110588c8952e7adda13fa925d731da3", "bytes": 4425, "path": "src/cli.mjs" }, { "byteSha256": "sha256:48c92300b0e8d0e5be424bf19524bf444a48b86633ac229606f239a7e9df5a43", "bytes": 12971, "path": "src/io.mjs" }, { "byteSha256": "sha256:e0460dfae7fa43aca58f2a604325be2c14b3df8af6904a3a4b33467a875101e3", "bytes": 5895, "path": "src/schema.mjs" }, { "byteSha256": "sha256:5cd9486338f848ce79f4909f7a783f7e9c67efc0598f1561c0c67319ffb0fb74", "bytes": 22587, "path": "src/verifier.mjs" } ], "networkUsed": false, "randomnessUsed": false, "semanticPayloadSha256": "sha256:31910cdeca51dbd7a14bc9cb468cf4e9fbd62933a09b62bd47645bc3626162b4", "verifiedFixtureCount": 18, "verifierState": "ALL_STATIC_SYNTHETIC_FIXTURES_RECOMPUTED" }, "constitutionalBoundaries": { "fixtureSafety": [ "original-synthetic-only", "abstract-labels-and-finite-structures-only", "no-real-person", "no-participant-record", "no-private-data", "no-personal-appearance-assessment", "no-living-tradition-representation", "no-protected-cultural-expression", "no-recognizable-third-party-work" ], "forbiddenConversions": [ "measurement-to-aesthetic-authority", "response-to-universal-taste", "judgment-to-truth", "judgment-to-goodness", "judgment-to-justice", "judgment-to-completion", "selection-to-winner", "publication-to-permission", "publication-to-adoption", "lineage-to-authorship", "generation-to-ownership", "aftermath-to-reward-or-punishment" ], "forbiddenFieldNames": [ "beautyScore", "tasteScore", "personScore", "cultureScore", "artifactScore", "rank", "ranking", "winner", "recommendation", "moderation", "gate", "truthVerdict", "goodnessVerdict", "justiceVerdict", "completionVerdict", "attractivenessScore" ], "noAutomaticConversion": true, "notBeautyFramework": true, "opening": "A form can be measured without being beautiful. A synthetic attributed response can be recorded without becoming universal. A work can be made without settling who authored, owns, may publish, or should adopt it. This atlas keeps those seams open so creation remains plural.", "separatelyOwnedBeautyDoctrineImported": false }, "counts": { "equationCards": 9, "kingdomOrientations": 0, "lanes": 10, "mathematicalFixtures": 9, "mathematicalRegisters": 2, "nonEquivalences": 21, "relationTypes": 15, "relationalFixtures": 9, "sourceBindings": 14, "syntheticFixtures": 18, "terms": 12 }, "equationCards": [ { "assumptions": [ "A finite representation x and a finite declared transformation set G are supplied." ], "fixtureIds": [ "FIXTURE_SYMMETRY_STABILIZER" ], "id": "CARD_SYMMETRY_STABILIZER", "nonclaims": [ "The stabilizer size is not an aesthetic scalar and does not imply preference." ], "notation": "Stab_G(x) = { g in G | g·x = x }", "title": "Symmetry is invariance under declared transformations" }, { "assumptions": [ "The fixture uses dyadic rational probabilities so verification remains exact." ], "fixtureIds": [ "FIXTURE_DYADIC_ENTROPY" ], "id": "CARD_SHANNON_ENTROPY", "nonclaims": [ "Entropy is not meaning, quality, beauty, or cultural significance." ], "notation": "H(P) = -Σ p_i log2(p_i)", "title": "Entropy depends on a declared distribution" }, { "assumptions": [ "Every code and specimen is explicitly finite." ], "fixtureIds": [ "FIXTURE_CODE_ORDER_REVERSAL" ], "id": "CARD_DESCRIPTION_LENGTH", "nonclaims": [ "A shorter declared encoding is not a better work or a universal simplicity fact." ], "notation": "L_C(x) = Σ count_x(s) · length_C(s)", "title": "Description length depends on code and model" }, { "assumptions": [ "The representation and finite reference set are named." ], "fixtureIds": [ "FIXTURE_REFERENCE_RELATIVE_NOVELTY" ], "id": "CARD_RELATIVE_NOVELTY", "nonclaims": [ "Reference-relative absence is not global originality, priority, authorship, or value." ], "notation": "N_R(x) = 1 when repr(x) is not in R; otherwise 0", "title": "Novelty is relative to a reference and representation" }, { "assumptions": [ "All fixture coordinates belong only to an invented decision-vector register and are declared as maximize directions." ], "fixtureIds": [ "FIXTURE_PARETO_NON_DOMINATION" ], "id": "CARD_PARETO_FRONTIER", "nonclaims": [ "The frontier supplies no artifact evaluation, aesthetic judgment, winner, scalar order, or recommendation." ], "notation": "x is dominated when some y is >= on all declared objectives and > on at least one", "title": "Non-domination preserves plural abstract coordinates" }, { "assumptions": [ "Each synthetic ballot is a strict order over the same three labels." ], "fixtureIds": [ "FIXTURE_CONDORCET_CYCLE" ], "id": "CARD_PAIRWISE_CYCLE", "nonclaims": [ "Majority relations do not become a coherent collective taste or aesthetic authority." ], "notation": "A ≻ B, B ≻ C, C ≻ A", "title": "Pairwise aggregation can cycle" }, { "assumptions": [ "The declared version graph is finite." ], "fixtureIds": [ "FIXTURE_VERSION_DAG" ], "id": "CARD_VERSION_LINEAGE", "nonclaims": [ "Lineage does not settle intention, authorship, ownership, permission, or endorsement." ], "notation": "ancestor(u,v) iff a directed path u -> ... -> v exists", "title": "Derivation is a graph relation" }, { "assumptions": [ "The finite distribution is exact and totals one." ], "fixtureIds": [ "FIXTURE_STOCHASTIC_SUPPORT" ], "id": "CARD_STOCHASTIC_OCCURRENCE", "nonclaims": [ "Probability and occurrence do not establish intention, authorship, ownership, or permission." ], "notation": "P(X=x) > 0 implies x is supported; nothing more", "title": "Occurrence under a distribution is not intention" }, { "assumptions": [ "A finite feasible set, directed transition set, and start state are declared." ], "fixtureIds": [ "FIXTURE_FEASIBLE_NOT_REACHABLE" ], "id": "CARD_FEASIBILITY_REACHABILITY", "nonclaims": [ "Neither set establishes publication, adoption, permission, or real-world capability." ], "notation": "Reach(s0,E) may be a proper subset of F", "title": "Feasibility and reachability are different sets" } ], "kingdomOrientations": [], "nonEquivalences": [ { "fixtureIds": [ "FIXTURE_SYMMETRY_STABILIZER", "FIXTURE_ATTRIBUTED_DISAGREEMENT" ], "id": "NEQ_SYMMETRY_AESTHETIC_JUDGMENT", "left": "SYMMETRY_UNDER_TRANSFORM_SET", "reason": "Invariance is computed from a declared representation and transformations; an aesthetic judgment is an attributed evaluative act.", "right": "AESTHETIC_JUDGMENT" }, { "fixtureIds": [ "FIXTURE_DYADIC_ENTROPY" ], "id": "NEQ_ENTROPY_MEANING", "left": "SHANNON_ENTROPY", "reason": "Distributional uncertainty does not encode semantic, historical, cultural, or evaluative significance.", "right": "MEANING_OR_AESTHETIC_WORTH" }, { "fixtureIds": [ "FIXTURE_CODE_ORDER_REVERSAL" ], "id": "NEQ_CODE_LENGTH_GLOBAL_COMPLEXITY", "left": "DESCRIPTION_LENGTH_UNDER_CODE_C1", "reason": "The fixture reverses the ordering under a second declared code.", "right": "GLOBAL_COMPLEXITY_OR_QUALITY" }, { "fixtureIds": [ "FIXTURE_REFERENCE_RELATIVE_NOVELTY" ], "id": "NEQ_RELATIVE_GLOBAL_NOVELTY", "left": "REFERENCE_RELATIVE_NOVELTY", "reason": "The same representation is absent from one reference and present in another.", "right": "GLOBAL_ORIGINALITY" }, { "fixtureIds": [ "FIXTURE_PARETO_NON_DOMINATION" ], "id": "NEQ_PARETO_WINNER", "left": "PARETO_NON_DOMINATION", "reason": "Multiple invented coordinate vectors can remain on a frontier without any artifact relation, scalarization, or choice rule.", "right": "WINNER_OR_RECOMMENDATION" }, { "fixtureIds": [ "FIXTURE_CONDORCET_CYCLE" ], "id": "NEQ_AGGREGATION_COLLECTIVE_TASTE", "left": "PAIRWISE_MAJORITY_RELATION", "reason": "Pairwise majorities can be cyclic even when each synthetic ballot is transitive.", "right": "COHERENT_COLLECTIVE_TASTE" }, { "fixtureIds": [ "FIXTURE_VERSION_DAG" ], "id": "NEQ_LINEAGE_AUTHORSHIP", "left": "VERSION_DAG", "reason": "A derivation edge records ancestry only.", "right": "AUTHORSHIP_OWNERSHIP_OR_PERMISSION" }, { "fixtureIds": [ "FIXTURE_STOCHASTIC_SUPPORT" ], "id": "NEQ_PROBABILITY_INTENTION", "left": "STOCHASTIC_SUPPORT_OR_PROBABILITY", "reason": "A supported observed outcome supplies no maker statement or legal conclusion.", "right": "INTENTION_OR_AUTHORSHIP" }, { "fixtureIds": [ "FIXTURE_FEASIBLE_NOT_REACHABLE" ], "id": "NEQ_FEASIBLE_REACHABLE", "left": "FEASIBLE_SET", "reason": "A feasible state can be disconnected from the declared start under the declared transitions.", "right": "GRAPH_REACHABILITY" }, { "fixtureIds": [ "FIXTURE_FEASIBLE_NOT_REACHABLE", "FIXTURE_PUBLICATION_WITHOUT_ADOPTION" ], "id": "NEQ_REACHABLE_ADOPTED", "left": "GRAPH_REACHABILITY", "reason": "A path in a model does not record a voluntary adoption event.", "right": "ADOPTION" }, { "fixtureIds": [ "FIXTURE_RESPONSE_JUDGMENT_SEPARATION" ], "id": "NEQ_RESPONSE_JUDGMENT", "left": "ATTRIBUTED_RESPONSE", "reason": "A reported encounter and an explicit evaluation are separate attributed acts.", "right": "AESTHETIC_JUDGMENT" }, { "fixtureIds": [ "FIXTURE_ATTRIBUTED_DISAGREEMENT" ], "id": "NEQ_JUDGMENT_TRUTH_GOODNESS_JUSTICE", "left": "AESTHETIC_JUDGMENT", "reason": "The atlas records who judged what under which terms; it grants no metaphysical or moral conversion.", "right": "TRUTH_GOODNESS_OR_JUSTICE" }, { "fixtureIds": [ "FIXTURE_MAKER_STATEMENT_BOUNDARY" ], "id": "NEQ_MAKER_STATEMENT_SETTLED_MEANING", "left": "MAKER_STATEMENT", "reason": "Attribution establishes that a statement is in the fixture, not that it exhausts interpretation or proves an inner state.", "right": "EXCLUSIVE_MEANING_OR_PROVEN_INNER_STATE" }, { "fixtureIds": [ "FIXTURE_SYNTHETIC_CONTEXT_VARIATION" ], "id": "NEQ_CONTEXT_CULTURE_ESSENCE", "left": "DECLARED_CONTEXT_OR_TRADITION", "reason": "Context records are partial and attributed; they do not define a people or settle rights.", "right": "CULTURAL_ESSENCE_PERMISSION_OR_OWNERSHIP" }, { "fixtureIds": [ "FIXTURE_INSTITUTIONAL_SELECTION_BOUNDARY" ], "id": "NEQ_SELECTION_AESTHETIC_AUTHORITY", "left": "INSTITUTIONAL_SELECTION", "reason": "A selection event is scoped to one institution and procedure.", "right": "AESTHETIC_AUTHORITY_OR_UNIVERSAL_WINNER" }, { "fixtureIds": [ "FIXTURE_PUBLICATION_WITHOUT_ADOPTION" ], "id": "NEQ_PUBLICATION_PERMISSION_ADOPTION", "left": "PUBLICATION", "reason": "Availability, rights terms, and voluntary reuse are separately recorded relations.", "right": "PERMISSION_LICENCE_OR_ADOPTION" }, { "fixtureIds": [ "FIXTURE_ADOPTION_WITHOUT_ENDORSEMENT" ], "id": "NEQ_ADOPTION_ENDORSEMENT", "left": "ADOPTION", "reason": "One scoped reuse event need not affirm every statement, interpretation, or future use.", "right": "ENDORSEMENT_OR_UNIVERSAL_ACCEPTANCE" }, { "fixtureIds": [ "FIXTURE_AFTERMATH_REPAIR_BOUNDARY" ], "id": "NEQ_AFTERMATH_RETROACTIVE_VERDICT", "left": "AFTERMATH", "reason": "Consequences can inform repair without becoming a retroactive universal verdict.", "right": "RETROACTIVE_AESTHETIC_TRUTH_REWARD_OR_PUNISHMENT" }, { "fixtureIds": [ "FIXTURE_ACCESS_NOT_AESTHETIC_VERDICT" ], "id": "NEQ_ACCESS_AESTHETIC_QUALITY", "left": "ACCESS_RELATION", "reason": "A scoped technical access condition is important but does not settle aesthetic judgment or every user need.", "right": "AESTHETIC_QUALITY_OR_UNIVERSAL_INCLUSION" }, { "fixtureIds": [ "FIXTURE_VERSION_DAG" ], "id": "NEQ_TRANSLATION_IDENTITY_MEANING", "left": "TRANSLATES_WITH_DECLARED_LOSS", "reason": "A typed translation edge can name unresolved or lost distinctions and therefore is not an identity edge.", "right": "IDENTITY_OR_COMPLETE_MEANING_PRESERVATION" }, { "fixtureIds": [ "FIXTURE_VERSION_DAG" ], "id": "NEQ_TRANSLATION_RIGHTS", "left": "TRANSLATION_OR_VERSION_DERIVATION", "reason": "A translation or derivation record does not settle authorization or rights.", "right": "PERMISSION_LICENCE_OR_OWNERSHIP" } ], "protocol": "kingdom.aesthetic-plurality-making/0.1", "publicHandoff": { "currentState": "FROZEN_FOR_IMMUTABLE_HANDOFF", "htmlPage": false, "mutableAlias": false, "publicationAuthorized": true, "reviewGate": "INDEPENDENT_REVIEW_GREEN_THEN_RELEASE_OWNER_EXACT_BYTE_AUTHORIZATION", "routes": [ { "absoluteUrl": "https://thekingdom.dev/atlases/aesthetic-plurality-making-atlas-2026-08-29.json", "immutable": true, "mimeType": "application/json; charset=utf-8", "role": "CANONICAL_RECORD", "route": "/atlases/aesthetic-plurality-making-atlas-2026-08-29.json" }, { "absoluteUrl": "https://thekingdom.dev/schemas/aesthetic-plurality-making-atlas/0.1.json", "immutable": true, "mimeType": "application/json; charset=utf-8", "role": "CLOSED_SCHEMA", "route": "/schemas/aesthetic-plurality-making-atlas/0.1.json" }, { "absoluteUrl": "https://thekingdom.dev/AESTHETIC-PLURALITY-MAKING-ATLAS-v0.1.md", "immutable": true, "mimeType": "text/markdown; charset=utf-8", "role": "ACCESSIBLE_LINEAR_GUIDE", "route": "/AESTHETIC-PLURALITY-MAKING-ATLAS-v0.1.md" } ], "runtime": false }, "scope": { "accessDecision": false, "account": false, "api": false, "artifactEvaluation": false, "authorityConversion": false, "automatedRanking": false, "automatedRecommendation": false, "automaticAction": false, "completionConversion": false, "cultureEvaluation": false, "enforcementDecision": false, "formInput": false, "goodnessConversion": false, "governanceDecision": false, "justiceConversion": false, "legalConclusion": false, "liveInput": false, "livingTraditionFixture": false, "mcp": false, "moderationDecision": false, "network": false, "ownershipConversion": false, "participantData": false, "permissionConversion": false, "personEvaluation": false, "personalAppearanceAssessment": false, "privateData": false, "protectedExpressionFixture": false, "publicationDecision": false, "realPeople": false, "recognizableThirdPartyWork": false, "runtime": false, "scalarAestheticEvaluation": false, "staticArtifact": true, "syntheticOnly": true, "truthConversion": false, "wcagConformanceClaim": false }, "sourceBindingInvariants": { "authorityImported": false, "complianceImported": false, "currentnessImported": false, "downloadedAtBuild": false, "endorsementImported": false, "licenceImported": false, "linkOnly": true, "permissionImported": false, "reuseRightImported": false, "sourceTextImported": false, "truthImported": false }, "sourceBindings": [ { "bindingRole": "Information entropy orientation for one exact dyadic fixture.", "citation": "Claude E. Shannon, A Mathematical Theory of Communication, Bell System Technical Journal 27(3), 379–423 (1948).", "class": "PRIMARY_TECHNICAL_SOURCE", "id": "SOURCE_SHANNON_1948", "url": "https://doi.org/10.1002/j.1538-7305.1948.tb01338.x" }, { "bindingRole": "Description-length orientation; the atlas emphasizes declared-code dependence.", "citation": "Jorma Rissanen, Modeling by shortest data description, Automatica 14(5), 465–471 (1978).", "class": "PRIMARY_TECHNICAL_SOURCE", "id": "SOURCE_RISSANEN_1978", "url": "https://doi.org/10.1016/0005-1098(78)90005-5" }, { "bindingRole": "Algorithmic-description orientation with explicit reference-model dependence.", "citation": "A. N. Kolmogorov, Three approaches to the quantitative definition of information, Problems of Information Transmission 1(1), 3–11 (1965); English edition 1968.", "class": "PRIMARY_TECHNICAL_SOURCE", "id": "SOURCE_KOLMOGOROV_1965", "url": "https://doi.org/10.1080/00207166808803030" }, { "bindingRole": "Historical orientation for cyclic pairwise aggregation.", "citation": "Nicolas de Condorcet, Essai sur l’application de l’analyse à la probabilité des décisions rendues à la pluralité des voix, Imprimerie Royale (1785).", "class": "PRIMARY_TECHNICAL_SOURCE", "id": "SOURCE_CONDORCET_1785", "url": "https://gallica.bnf.fr/ark:/12148/bpt6k1057808s" }, { "bindingRole": "Social-choice orientation for limits of preference aggregation; no governance procedure is imported.", "citation": "Kenneth J. Arrow, Social Choice and Individual Values, Cowles Commission Monograph 12 (1951).", "class": "PRIMARY_TECHNICAL_SOURCE", "id": "SOURCE_ARROW_1951", "url": "https://cowles.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2022-09/m12-all.pdf" }, { "bindingRole": "One attributed processing-fluency model, preserved as a proposal rather than a universal law.", "citation": "Rolf Reber, Norbert Schwarz, and Piotr Winkielman, Processing Fluency and Aesthetic Pleasure: Is Beauty in the Perceiver’s Processing Experience?, Personality and Social Psychology Review 8(4), 364–382 (2004).", "class": "PRIMARY_TECHNICAL_SOURCE", "id": "SOURCE_REBER_SCHWARZ_WINKIELMAN_2004", "url": "https://doi.org/10.1207/S15327957PSPR0804_3" }, { "bindingRole": "Empirical counterweight to universal conversion from symmetry to aesthetic judgment.", "citation": "Helmut Leder, Pablo P. L. Tinio, David Brieber, Tonio Kröner, Thomas Jacobsen, and Raphael Rosenberg, Symmetry Is Not a Universal Law of Beauty, Empirical Studies of the Arts 37(1), 104–114 (2019).", "class": "PRIMARY_TECHNICAL_SOURCE", "id": "SOURCE_LEDER_ET_AL_2019", "url": "https://doi.org/10.1177/0276237418777941" }, { "bindingRole": "Individual disagreement orientation limited to abstract randomized patterns.", "citation": "Jay Friedenberg, Beauty in the Eye of the Beholder: Individual Differences in Preference for Randomized Visual Patterns, Experimental Psychology 66(2), 123–136 (2019).", "class": "PRIMARY_TECHNICAL_SOURCE", "id": "SOURCE_FRIEDENBERG_2019", "url": "https://doi.org/10.1027/1618-3169/a000432" }, { "bindingRole": "Cross-cultural empirical orientation preserving both commonality and difference without culture scores.", "citation": "Eline Van Geert, Rong Ding, and Johan Wagemans, A Cross-Cultural Comparison of Aesthetic Preferences for Neatly Organized Compositions: Native Chinese- Versus Native Dutch-Speaking Samples, Empirical Studies of the Arts 43(1), 250–275 (2025; online 2024).", "class": "PRIMARY_TECHNICAL_SOURCE", "id": "SOURCE_VAN_GEERT_DING_WAGEMANS_2025", "url": "https://doi.org/10.1177/02762374241245917" }, { "bindingRole": "Official cultural-expression diversity context; no compliance or legal conclusion.", "citation": "UNESCO, Convention on the Protection and Promotion of the Diversity of Cultural Expressions, adopted 20 October 2005.", "class": "OFFICIAL_NORMATIVE_CONTEXT", "id": "SOURCE_UNESCO_2005_CONVENTION", "url": "https://www.unesco.org/en/legal-affairs/convention-protection-and-promotion-diversity-cultural-expressions" }, { "bindingRole": "Boundary context against treating cultural expressions as ownerless fixture material.", "citation": "World Intellectual Property Organization, Traditional Cultural Expressions, official topic page.", "class": "OFFICIAL_NORMATIVE_CONTEXT", "id": "SOURCE_WIPO_TCE", "url": "https://www.wipo.int/en/web/traditional-knowledge/traditional-cultural-expressions/index" }, { "bindingRole": "Official Indigenous-rights context; no culture is represented by a synthetic fixture.", "citation": "United Nations General Assembly, United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples, A/RES/61/295 (2007), especially Article 31.", "class": "OFFICIAL_NORMATIVE_CONTEXT", "id": "SOURCE_UNDRIP_2007", "url": "https://www.un.org/development/desa/Indigenouspeoples/wp-content/uploads/sites/19/2018/11/UNDRIP_E_web.pdf" }, { "bindingRole": "Technical access orientation kept distinct from aesthetic judgment; no conformance claim.", "citation": "W3C Accessibility Guidelines Working Group, Web Content Accessibility Guidelines (WCAG) 2.2, W3C Recommendation 12 December 2024.", "class": "OFFICIAL_NORMATIVE_CONTEXT", "id": "SOURCE_WCAG_2_2_2024", "url": "https://www.w3.org/TR/2024/REC-WCAG22-20241212/" }, { "bindingRole": "Jurisdiction-specific legal context for keeping stochastic generation, human contribution, and authorship questions distinct; no legal advice or conclusion.", "citation": "U.S. Copyright Office, Copyright and Artificial Intelligence, Part 2: Copyrightability (January 2025).", "class": "OFFICIAL_NORMATIVE_CONTEXT", "id": "SOURCE_USCO_AI_PART_2_2025", "url": "https://www.copyright.gov/ai/Copyright-and-Artificial-Intelligence-Part-2-Copyrightability-Report.pdf" } ], "syntheticFixtures": [ { "expected": { "preservingTransformCount": 4, "preservingTransformIds": [ "IDENTITY", "ROTATE_180", "REFLECT_MAIN_DIAGONAL", "REFLECT_ANTI_DIAGONAL" ] }, "id": "FIXTURE_SYMMETRY_STABILIZER", "input": { "sequence": [ "R", "B", "B", "R" ], "transforms": [ { "id": "IDENTITY", "permutation": [ 0, 1, 2, 3 ] }, { "id": "ROTATE_90", "permutation": [ 2, 0, 3, 1 ] }, { "id": "ROTATE_180", "permutation": [ 3, 2, 1, 0 ] }, { "id": "ROTATE_270", "permutation": [ 1, 3, 0, 2 ] }, { "id": "REFLECT_VERTICAL", "permutation": [ 1, 0, 3, 2 ] }, { "id": "REFLECT_HORIZONTAL", "permutation": [ 2, 3, 0, 1 ] }, { "id": "REFLECT_MAIN_DIAGONAL", "permutation": [ 0, 2, 1, 3 ] }, { "id": "REFLECT_ANTI_DIAGONAL", "permutation": [ 3, 1, 2, 0 ] } ] }, "kind": "MATHEMATICAL", "lane": "FORM", "nonclaims": [ "Four preserving transforms do not make the pattern beautiful, good, important, finished, or preferred." ], "operation": "SYMMETRY_STABILIZER", "premises": [ "The four positions are a declared 2-by-2 representation.", "A transform acts by the listed permutation and no unlisted transform is inferred." ], "synthetic": true, "title": "One finite pattern has four preserving transformations in the declared set", "witnessesNonEquivalence": [ "NEQ_SYMMETRY_AESTHETIC_JUDGMENT" ] }, { "expected": { "entropyBits": { "denominator": 2, "numerator": 3 } }, "id": "FIXTURE_DYADIC_ENTROPY", "input": { "logarithmBase": 2, "symbols": [ { "count": 2, "id": "A" }, { "count": 1, "id": "B" }, { "count": 1, "id": "C" } ], "total": 4 }, "kind": "MATHEMATICAL", "lane": "FORM", "nonclaims": [ "Three halves of a bit says nothing about meaning, response, aesthetic judgment, culture, or worth." ], "operation": "DYADIC_ENTROPY", "premises": [ "Counts are positive integers and total four.", "Logarithms use base two." ], "synthetic": true, "title": "Exact entropy for a declared three-symbol distribution", "witnessesNonEquivalence": [ "NEQ_ENTROPY_MEANING" ] }, { "expected": { "orderingReverses": true, "shorterByCodebook": [ { "codebookId": "CODE_A_SHORT", "specimenId": "X" }, { "codebookId": "CODE_B_SHORT", "specimenId": "Y" } ], "totals": [ { "bits": 4, "codebookId": "CODE_A_SHORT", "specimenId": "X" }, { "bits": 8, "codebookId": "CODE_A_SHORT", "specimenId": "Y" }, { "bits": 8, "codebookId": "CODE_B_SHORT", "specimenId": "X" }, { "bits": 4, "codebookId": "CODE_B_SHORT", "specimenId": "Y" } ] }, "id": "FIXTURE_CODE_ORDER_REVERSAL", "input": { "codebooks": [ { "id": "CODE_A_SHORT", "lengths": [ { "bits": 1, "symbol": "A" }, { "bits": 2, "symbol": "B" } ] }, { "id": "CODE_B_SHORT", "lengths": [ { "bits": 2, "symbol": "A" }, { "bits": 1, "symbol": "B" } ] } ], "specimens": [ { "id": "X", "symbols": [ "A", "A", "A", "A" ] }, { "id": "Y", "symbols": [ "B", "B", "B", "B" ] } ] }, "kind": "MATHEMATICAL", "lane": "FORM", "nonclaims": [ "Neither encoding is an aesthetic judgment, quality metric, or universal complexity measure." ], "operation": "CODE_LENGTH_REVERSAL", "premises": [ "Only literal symbol lengths are summed.", "Each declared code is a fixture convention, not a claim of optimal compression." ], "synthetic": true, "title": "Two declared codes reverse the description-length ordering", "witnessesNonEquivalence": [ "NEQ_CODE_LENGTH_GLOBAL_COMPLEXITY" ] }, { "expected": { "notNovelRelativeTo": [ "REFERENCE_BETA" ], "novelRelativeTo": [ "REFERENCE_ALPHA" ] }, "id": "FIXTURE_REFERENCE_RELATIVE_NOVELTY", "input": { "candidateRepresentation": "spiral|blue", "references": [ { "id": "REFERENCE_ALPHA", "representations": [ "line|red", "arc|blue" ] }, { "id": "REFERENCE_BETA", "representations": [ "line|red", "spiral|blue" ] } ] }, "kind": "MATHEMATICAL", "lane": "FORM", "nonclaims": [ "Absence from REFERENCE_ALPHA does not establish global originality, priority, authorship, ownership, or aesthetic worth." ], "operation": "REFERENCE_MEMBERSHIP", "premises": [ "Representation is exact string identity in this fixture.", "Reference sets are finite and explicitly named." ], "synthetic": true, "title": "The same representation is absent from one reference and present in another", "witnessesNonEquivalence": [ "NEQ_RELATIVE_GLOBAL_NOVELTY" ] }, { "expected": { "paretoFrontierVectorIds": [ "VECTOR_A", "VECTOR_B", "VECTOR_C" ], "strictlyDominatedVectorIds": [ "VECTOR_D" ] }, "id": "FIXTURE_PARETO_NON_DOMINATION", "input": { "coordinateIds": [ "DECLARED_COORDINATE_P", "DECLARED_COORDINATE_Q" ], "vectors": [ { "coordinates": [ 3, 1 ], "id": "VECTOR_A" }, { "coordinates": [ 2, 2 ], "id": "VECTOR_B" }, { "coordinates": [ 1, 3 ], "id": "VECTOR_C" }, { "coordinates": [ 1, 1 ], "id": "VECTOR_D" } ] }, "kind": "MATHEMATICAL", "lane": "ABSTRACT_DECISION_VECTOR_REGISTER", "nonclaims": [ "The vectors are not artifacts or judgments; the frontier ranks, selects, and recommends nothing." ], "operation": "PARETO_MAXIMIZE", "premises": [ "Both integer coordinates are declared as maximize directions.", "No weights, scalarization, or choice rule exists." ], "synthetic": true, "title": "Three invented vectors remain on a Pareto frontier under two declared coordinates", "witnessesNonEquivalence": [ "NEQ_PARETO_WINNER" ] }, { "expected": { "collectiveWinnerEstablished": false, "cycle": true }, "id": "FIXTURE_CONDORCET_CYCLE", "input": { "ballots": [ { "id": "SYNTHETIC_BALLOT_1", "order": [ "A", "B", "C" ] }, { "id": "SYNTHETIC_BALLOT_2", "order": [ "B", "C", "A" ] }, { "id": "SYNTHETIC_BALLOT_3", "order": [ "C", "A", "B" ] } ] }, "kind": "MATHEMATICAL", "lane": "ABSTRACT_PREFERENCE_AGGREGATION_REGISTER", "nonclaims": [ "The fixture produces no ranking; the cycle authorizes no tie-breaker, institution, winner, consensus, recommendation, or collective aesthetic voice." ], "operation": "PAIRWISE_MAJORITY_CYCLE", "premises": [ "A, B, and C are opaque synthetic symbols, not artifacts, people, cultures, or aesthetic judgments.", "Each fixed ballot is a strict order over the same symbols and every ballot has equal count one." ], "synthetic": true, "title": "Three fixed orders over opaque synthetic symbols yield a cyclic pairwise relation", "witnessesNonEquivalence": [ "NEQ_AGGREGATION_COLLECTIVE_TASTE" ] }, { "expected": { "acyclic": true, "ancestorRelations": [ "SKETCH_1>ASSEMBLY_2", "SKETCH_1>PRINT_3", "SKETCH_1>TRANSLATION_3B", "ASSEMBLY_2>PRINT_3", "ASSEMBLY_2>TRANSLATION_3B" ], "declaredMeaningLossPreserved": true, "rightsSettled": false, "typedTranslationEdges": [ "ASSEMBLY_2>TRANSLATION_3B" ] }, "id": "FIXTURE_VERSION_DAG", "input": { "edges": [ { "from": "SKETCH_1", "relationType": "DERIVES_FROM", "to": "ASSEMBLY_2" }, { "from": "ASSEMBLY_2", "relationType": "DERIVES_FROM", "to": "PRINT_3" }, { "from": "ASSEMBLY_2", "relationType": "TRANSLATES_WITH_DECLARED_LOSS", "to": "TRANSLATION_3B" } ], "nodes": [ "SKETCH_1", "ASSEMBLY_2", "PRINT_3", "TRANSLATION_3B" ], "translationDeclaration": { "declaredMeaningLoss": [ "TOKEN_P_HAS_NO_DECLARED_EQUIVALENT" ], "edge": "ASSEMBLY_2>TRANSLATION_3B", "rightsState": "UNRESOLVED", "sourceLanguage": "SYNTHETIC_LANGUAGE_ALPHA", "targetLanguage": "SYNTHETIC_LANGUAGE_BETA" } }, "kind": "MATHEMATICAL", "lane": "MAKING_EVENT", "nonclaims": [ "The graph records no intention, authorship, ownership, permission, licence, endorsement, or creative-credit allocation; translation is not identity or guaranteed meaning preservation." ], "operation": "VERSION_DAG", "premises": [ "Nodes and derivation edges are complete for this fixture only.", "Edges point from predecessor to derived version." ], "synthetic": true, "title": "A finite derivation graph records lineage and nothing more", "witnessesNonEquivalence": [ "NEQ_LINEAGE_AUTHORSHIP", "NEQ_TRANSLATION_IDENTITY_MEANING", "NEQ_TRANSLATION_RIGHTS" ] }, { "expected": { "authorshipEstablished": false, "inSupport": true, "intentionEstablished": false, "observedProbability": { "denominator": 4, "numerator": 1 } }, "id": "FIXTURE_STOCHASTIC_SUPPORT", "input": { "distribution": [ { "outcome": "FORM_X", "probability": { "denominator": 4, "numerator": 2 } }, { "outcome": "FORM_Y", "probability": { "denominator": 4, "numerator": 1 } }, { "outcome": "FORM_Z", "probability": { "denominator": 4, "numerator": 1 } } ], "observedOutcome": "FORM_Y" }, "kind": "MATHEMATICAL", "lane": "MAKING_EVENT", "nonclaims": [ "The distribution and occurrence settle no intention, authorship, ownership, copyrightability, permission, or adoption question." ], "operation": "FINITE_DISTRIBUTION_SUPPORT", "premises": [ "The three rational probabilities sum exactly to one.", "The fixture performs no sampling and uses no randomness." ], "synthetic": true, "title": "A supported observed outcome does not establish intention or authorship", "witnessesNonEquivalence": [ "NEQ_PROBABILITY_INTENTION" ] }, { "expected": { "feasibleButUnreachableStateIds": [ "STATE_D" ], "reachableStateIds": [ "STATE_A", "STATE_B", "STATE_C" ] }, "id": "FIXTURE_FEASIBLE_NOT_REACHABLE", "input": { "feasibleStateIds": [ "STATE_A", "STATE_B", "STATE_C", "STATE_D" ], "startStateId": "STATE_A", "transitions": [ { "from": "STATE_A", "to": "STATE_B" }, { "from": "STATE_B", "to": "STATE_C" } ] }, "kind": "MATHEMATICAL", "lane": "MAKING_EVENT", "nonclaims": [ "Model reachability is not real-world capability, permission, publication, adoption, or aesthetic merit." ], "operation": "FEASIBILITY_REACHABILITY", "premises": [ "All four states are feasible by declaration.", "Only listed directed transitions are available." ], "synthetic": true, "title": "One feasible state is unreachable from the declared start", "witnessesNonEquivalence": [ "NEQ_FEASIBLE_REACHABLE", "NEQ_REACHABLE_ADOPTED" ] }, { "expected": { "collapsedConsensus": false, "distinctLabels": true, "universalJudgment": false }, "id": "FIXTURE_ATTRIBUTED_DISAGREEMENT", "input": { "formId": "ABSTRACT_FORM_ALPHA", "judgments": [ { "asOf": "2026-08-29", "attributionId": "SYNTHETIC_ROLE_ALPHA", "contextId": "CONTEXT_ALPHA", "label": "INVITING", "methodId": "SYNTHETIC_DIRECT_LABEL_METHOD", "vocabularyId": "DECLARED_AESTHETIC_VOCABULARY_ALPHA" }, { "asOf": "2026-08-29", "attributionId": "SYNTHETIC_ROLE_BETA", "contextId": "CONTEXT_BETA", "label": "UNSETTLING", "methodId": "SYNTHETIC_DIRECT_LABEL_METHOD", "vocabularyId": "DECLARED_AESTHETIC_VOCABULARY_ALPHA" } ] }, "kind": "RELATIONAL", "lane": "AESTHETIC_JUDGMENT", "nonclaims": [ "Neither synthetic label is a truth verdict, person trait, culture trait, winner, or recommendation." ], "operation": "PRESERVE_ATTRIBUTED_DISAGREEMENT", "premises": [ "Both roles and the encountered form are synthetic.", "No participant or population inference is permitted." ], "synthetic": true, "title": "Two synthetic attributed judgments disagree without collapse", "witnessesNonEquivalence": [ "NEQ_SYMMETRY_AESTHETIC_JUDGMENT", "NEQ_JUDGMENT_TRUTH_GOODNESS_JUSTICE" ] }, { "expected": { "aestheticJudgmentRecorded": false, "responseRecorded": true, "universalResponseEstablished": false }, "id": "FIXTURE_RESPONSE_JUDGMENT_SEPARATION", "input": { "aestheticJudgments": [], "formId": "ABSTRACT_FORM_RESPONSE_ALPHA", "response": { "asOf": "2026-08-29", "attributionId": "SYNTHETIC_RESPONSE_ROLE", "contextId": "SYNTHETIC_RESPONSE_CONTEXT", "report": "ATTENTION_RETURNED" } }, "kind": "RELATIONAL", "lane": "ATTRIBUTED_RESPONSE", "nonclaims": [ "The response token is not an aesthetic judgment, population estimate, person trait, or universal response." ], "operation": "RESPONSE_JUDGMENT_BOUNDARY", "premises": [ "The role, form, context, and response token are synthetic.", "A response report is not silently retyped as an evaluative judgment." ], "synthetic": true, "title": "A synthetic attributed response is recorded without an aesthetic judgment", "witnessesNonEquivalence": [ "NEQ_RESPONSE_JUDGMENT" ] }, { "expected": { "exclusiveMeaningEstablished": false, "innerStateProven": false, "statementAttributed": true }, "id": "FIXTURE_MAKER_STATEMENT_BOUNDARY", "input": { "formId": "ABSTRACT_FORM_BETA", "makingEventId": "SYNTHETIC_MAKING_EVENT_BETA", "statement": { "attributionId": "SYNTHETIC_MAKER_ROLE", "text": "I explored repetition." } }, "kind": "RELATIONAL", "lane": "MAKER_STATEMENT", "nonclaims": [ "Recording the sentence does not prove an inner state, exhaust interpretation, assign authorship, or establish ownership." ], "operation": "MAKER_STATEMENT_BOUNDARY", "premises": [ "The form, event, role, and statement are synthetic.", "The statement is recorded exactly as fixture data." ], "synthetic": true, "title": "A maker statement remains attributed without settling meaning", "witnessesNonEquivalence": [ "NEQ_MAKER_STATEMENT_SETTLED_MEANING" ] }, { "expected": { "contextCount": 2, "ownershipEstablished": false, "permissionEstablished": false, "realCommunityRepresented": false }, "id": "FIXTURE_SYNTHETIC_CONTEXT_VARIATION", "input": { "contexts": [ { "description": "Encountered as a repeated workshop exercise.", "id": "INVENTED_CONTEXT_ONE" }, { "description": "Encountered as an isolated archive fragment.", "id": "INVENTED_CONTEXT_TWO" } ], "formId": "ABSTRACT_FORM_GAMMA" }, "kind": "RELATIONAL", "lane": "CONTEXT_TRADITION", "nonclaims": [ "The invented contexts do not model, score, summarize, or stand in for any culture or living tradition." ], "operation": "CONTEXT_VARIATION", "premises": [ "Both contexts are invented analytic placeholders and represent no real community or tradition.", "No contextual description implies permission or ownership." ], "synthetic": true, "title": "The same abstract form is situated in two invented fixture contexts", "witnessesNonEquivalence": [ "NEQ_CONTEXT_CULTURE_ESSENCE" ] }, { "expected": { "publicAdoptionEstablished": false, "selectionRecorded": true, "universalAestheticAuthority": false, "winnerEstablished": false }, "id": "FIXTURE_INSTITUTIONAL_SELECTION_BOUNDARY", "input": { "institutionId": "SYNTHETIC_INSTITUTION_ALPHA", "procedureId": "DECLARED_PROCEDURE_ALPHA", "selectedFormId": "ABSTRACT_FORM_DELTA" }, "kind": "RELATIONAL", "lane": "INSTITUTIONAL_SELECTION", "nonclaims": [ "Selection supplies no global rank, universal judgment, recommendation, adoption, or truth status." ], "operation": "INSTITUTIONAL_SELECTION_BOUNDARY", "premises": [ "The institution, procedure, form, and event are synthetic.", "The fixture records selection, not why every selector acted." ], "synthetic": true, "title": "One synthetic selection event stays scoped to its declared procedure", "witnessesNonEquivalence": [ "NEQ_SELECTION_AESTHETIC_AUTHORITY" ] }, { "expected": { "adoptionRecorded": false, "licenceInferred": false, "permissionInferred": false, "publicationRecorded": true }, "id": "FIXTURE_PUBLICATION_WITHOUT_ADOPTION", "input": { "adoptionEvents": [], "artifactId": "SYNTHETIC_ARTIFACT_EPSILON", "publicationEvent": { "declaredRightsLabel": "RIGHTS_UNSPECIFIED", "publisherId": "SYNTHETIC_PUBLISHER", "route": "/synthetic/epsilon" } }, "kind": "RELATIONAL", "lane": "PUBLICATION", "nonclaims": [ "Availability does not create permission, licence, reuse, endorsement, or adoption." ], "operation": "PUBLICATION_ADOPTION_BOUNDARY", "premises": [ "The route, publisher, artifact, and rights label are synthetic placeholders.", "No actual publication or rights grant occurs." ], "synthetic": true, "title": "A synthetic publication event occurs without an adoption event", "witnessesNonEquivalence": [ "NEQ_PUBLICATION_PERMISSION_ADOPTION", "NEQ_REACHABLE_ADOPTED" ] }, { "expected": { "adoptionRecorded": true, "endorsementRecorded": false, "universalAcceptanceEstablished": false }, "id": "FIXTURE_ADOPTION_WITHOUT_ENDORSEMENT", "input": { "adoptionEvent": { "adopterId": "SYNTHETIC_ADOPTER", "contextId": "SYNTHETIC_USE_CONTEXT", "use": "TEMPORARY_DISPLAY" }, "artifactId": "SYNTHETIC_ARTIFACT_ZETA", "endorsementStatements": [] }, "kind": "RELATIONAL", "lane": "ADOPTION", "nonclaims": [ "One use does not endorse every interpretation, future use, publisher, maker statement, or institution." ], "operation": "ADOPTION_ENDORSEMENT_BOUNDARY", "premises": [ "The adopter, artifact, and use context are synthetic.", "The adoption record contains no endorsement statement." ], "synthetic": true, "title": "A scoped synthetic adoption does not imply endorsement", "witnessesNonEquivalence": [ "NEQ_ADOPTION_ENDORSEMENT" ] }, { "expected": { "eventCount": 2, "repairRecorded": true, "retroactiveAestheticTruth": false, "rewardOrPunishmentAuthorized": false }, "id": "FIXTURE_AFTERMATH_REPAIR_BOUNDARY", "input": { "aftermathEvents": [ { "id": "OBSERVATION_1", "kind": "MATERIAL_WEAR_RECORDED" }, { "id": "REPAIR_1", "kind": "REVERSIBLE_REPAIR_RECORDED" } ], "artifactId": "SYNTHETIC_ARTIFACT_ETA" }, "kind": "RELATIONAL", "lane": "AFTERMATH", "nonclaims": [ "Wear and repair do not prove success, failure, aesthetic truth, deserved reward, or deserved punishment." ], "operation": "AFTERMATH_BOUNDARY", "premises": [ "The artifact and maintenance events are synthetic.", "A repair can be recorded without assigning reward or punishment." ], "synthetic": true, "title": "A synthetic repair event records aftermath without retroactive verdict", "witnessesNonEquivalence": [ "NEQ_AFTERMATH_RETROACTIVE_VERDICT" ] }, { "expected": { "aestheticJudgmentEstablished": false, "satisfiedTechnicalCheckCount": 2, "universalInclusionEstablished": false, "wcagConformanceEstablished": false }, "id": "FIXTURE_ACCESS_NOT_AESTHETIC_VERDICT", "input": { "contentId": "SYNTHETIC_CONTENT_THETA", "declaredTechnicalChecks": [ { "id": "TEXT_ALTERNATIVE_PRESENT", "satisfied": true }, { "id": "KEYBOARD_PATH_PRESENT", "satisfied": true } ] }, "kind": "RELATIONAL", "lane": "FORM", "nonclaims": [ "Two synthetic checks establish neither aesthetic quality nor conformance, universal access, completion, or recommendation." ], "operation": "ACCESS_AESTHETIC_BOUNDARY", "premises": [ "The content and checklist are synthetic.", "The checklist is not a WCAG conformance evaluation." ], "synthetic": true, "title": "A scoped technical access check remains separate from aesthetic judgment", "witnessesNonEquivalence": [ "NEQ_ACCESS_AESTHETIC_QUALITY" ] } ], "vocabularies": { "lanes": [ { "definition": "A declared arrangement, pattern, specification, or material configuration described without an aesthetic verdict.", "id": "FORM", "keepsDistinctFrom": [ "MAKING_EVENT", "ATTRIBUTED_RESPONSE", "AESTHETIC_JUDGMENT", "INSTITUTIONAL_SELECTION" ], "label": "Form" }, { "definition": "A bounded transformation, assembly, selection, or revision event with declared inputs and outputs.", "id": "MAKING_EVENT", "keepsDistinctFrom": [ "FORM", "MAKER_STATEMENT", "PUBLICATION", "ADOPTION" ], "label": "Making event" }, { "definition": "An attributed statement about a making event, purpose, process, or form; it records the statement rather than proving an inner state or exclusive meaning.", "id": "MAKER_STATEMENT", "keepsDistinctFrom": [ "MAKING_EVENT", "AESTHETIC_JUDGMENT", "CONTEXT_TRADITION", "AUTHORSHIP_OR_OWNERSHIP" ], "label": "Maker statement" }, { "definition": "A situated report of an encounter, attributed in Phase 0 only to an explicitly synthetic role and never generalized to a person or population.", "id": "ATTRIBUTED_RESPONSE", "keepsDistinctFrom": [ "FORM", "AESTHETIC_JUDGMENT", "COLLECTIVE_PREFERENCE", "UNIVERSAL_RESPONSE" ], "label": "Attributed response" }, { "definition": "An attributed evaluation under a declared vocabulary, method, date, and context, preserved alongside possible disagreement.", "id": "AESTHETIC_JUDGMENT", "keepsDistinctFrom": [ "TRUTH", "GOODNESS", "JUSTICE", "COMPLETION", "AUTHORITY" ], "label": "Aesthetic judgment" }, { "definition": "A declared historical, social, material, ritual, or interpretive context represented without reducing a culture or community to an essence.", "id": "CONTEXT_TRADITION", "keepsDistinctFrom": [ "CULTURAL_ESSENCE", "PERMISSION", "OWNERSHIP", "UNIVERSAL_MEANING" ], "label": "Context and tradition" }, { "definition": "A documented acceptance, exhibition, acquisition, commissioning, curriculum, or award event under a stated institutional procedure.", "id": "INSTITUTIONAL_SELECTION", "keepsDistinctFrom": [ "AESTHETIC_AUTHORITY", "WINNER", "TRUTH", "PUBLIC_ADOPTION" ], "label": "Institutional selection" }, { "definition": "A documented act of making an artifact available at a declared location and under declared terms.", "id": "PUBLICATION", "keepsDistinctFrom": [ "PERMISSION", "LICENCE", "ADOPTION", "ENDORSEMENT" ], "label": "Publication" }, { "definition": "A distinct, voluntary, context-bound choice to reuse, perform, integrate, maintain, or carry a form.", "id": "ADOPTION", "keepsDistinctFrom": [ "PUBLICATION", "ENDORSEMENT", "UNIVERSAL_ACCEPTANCE", "OBLIGATION" ], "label": "Adoption" }, { "definition": "Observed consequences, maintenance, contestation, repair, withdrawal, succession, or retirement after a making, publication, or adoption event.", "id": "AFTERMATH", "keepsDistinctFrom": [ "RETROACTIVE_AESTHETIC_VERDICT", "PUNISHMENT", "REWARD", "AUTOMATIC_CONTINUATION" ], "label": "Aftermath" } ], "mathematicalRegisters": [ { "aestheticJudgmentRelation": false, "artifactRelation": false, "choiceRule": false, "definition": "A finite register of invented integer coordinate vectors used only to demonstrate multiobjective non-domination.", "id": "ABSTRACT_DECISION_VECTOR_REGISTER", "selectionRelation": false }, { "aestheticJudgmentRelation": false, "artifactRelation": false, "choiceRule": false, "definition": "A finite register of fixed strict orders over opaque invented symbols used only to demonstrate a pairwise aggregation cycle.", "id": "ABSTRACT_PREFERENCE_AGGREGATION_REGISTER", "selectionRelation": false } ], "relationTypes": [ { "definition": "A bounded description refers to a declared form or event.", "id": "DESCRIBES" }, { "definition": "A declared form is an output of a declared making event.", "id": "PRODUCED_BY" }, { "definition": "An attributed statement concerns a declared form or event.", "id": "STATEMENT_ABOUT" }, { "definition": "An attributed synthetic response concerns one declared encounter.", "id": "RESPONSE_TO" }, { "definition": "An attributed aesthetic judgment evaluates one declared object under named terms.", "id": "JUDGMENT_OF" }, { "definition": "A statement, response, judgment, or event is bounded to a declared context.", "id": "SITUATED_IN" }, { "definition": "An artifact was selected through a declared institutional procedure.", "id": "SELECTED_BY" }, { "definition": "An artifact was made available through a declared publication event.", "id": "PUBLISHED_AS" }, { "definition": "An artifact was voluntarily reused in one declared adoption context.", "id": "ADOPTED_IN" }, { "definition": "A declared event has a later recorded consequence or stewardship event.", "id": "HAS_AFTERMATH" }, { "definition": "A version has a declared lineage edge from another version.", "id": "DERIVES_FROM" }, { "definition": "A form or making event is bounded by a declared feasibility, access, material, or rights condition.", "id": "CONSTRAINED_BY" }, { "definition": "Two attributed judgments differ without forced resolution.", "id": "DISAGREES_WITH" }, { "definition": "A typed boundary says one relation must not be silently converted into another.", "id": "NOT_EQUIVALENT_TO" }, { "definition": "A version is declared as a translation with named source and target languages, explicit possible meaning loss, and separately unresolved rights.", "id": "TRANSLATES_WITH_DECLARED_LOSS" } ], "terms": [ { "definition": "The subset of declared transformations under which a declared finite representation remains invariant.", "id": "SYMMETRY_UNDER_TRANSFORM_SET", "nonclaims": [ "Not a universal property independent of representation or transform set.", "Not an aesthetic judgment." ] }, { "definition": "Expected information under a declared finite probability distribution and logarithm base.", "id": "SHANNON_ENTROPY", "nonclaims": [ "Not semantic meaning.", "Not aesthetic value." ] }, { "definition": "A bit length under a named code or model-description convention.", "id": "DESCRIPTION_LENGTH", "nonclaims": [ "Not code-independent complexity.", "Not quality or worth." ] }, { "definition": "Absence of a declared representation from a named finite reference set.", "id": "REFERENCE_RELATIVE_NOVELTY", "nonclaims": [ "Not global originality.", "Not priority, authorship, or ownership." ] }, { "definition": "No declared alternative is at least as strong on every declared objective and strictly stronger on at least one.", "id": "PARETO_NON_DOMINATION", "nonclaims": [ "Not a scalar ordering.", "Not a preferred choice or recommendation." ] }, { "definition": "A relation computed from declared finite preference orders by pairwise counts.", "id": "PAIRWISE_MAJORITY_RELATION", "nonclaims": [ "Need not be transitive.", "Not a coherent collective taste or authority." ] }, { "definition": "A finite directed acyclic graph whose edges declare version derivation.", "id": "VERSION_DAG", "nonclaims": [ "Not authorship, ownership, permission, endorsement, or creative credit." ] }, { "definition": "The outcomes assigned non-zero probability by a declared finite distribution.", "id": "STOCHASTIC_SUPPORT", "nonclaims": [ "An observed supported outcome does not establish intention or authorship." ] }, { "definition": "The states satisfying a declared finite set of constraints.", "id": "FEASIBLE_SET", "nonclaims": [ "Membership does not establish reachability, publication, adoption, or permission." ] }, { "definition": "Existence of a finite directed path from a declared start state under declared transitions.", "id": "GRAPH_REACHABILITY", "nonclaims": [ "Reachability does not establish feasibility outside the model, adoption, or authority." ] }, { "definition": "An attributed empirical proposal relating processing dynamics to some reported aesthetic responses under studied conditions.", "id": "PROCESSING_FLUENCY_MODEL", "nonclaims": [ "One model is not a universal law.", "It does not convert ease, repetition, symmetry, or familiarity into aesthetic truth." ] }, { "definition": "A declared relation between content, a mode of access, and an explicitly scoped technical criterion.", "id": "ACCESS_RELATION", "nonclaims": [ "Not an aesthetic verdict.", "Not a universal inclusion or standards-conformance claim." ] } ] } }